Chunky Vs Creamy And What Brand? / myLot

Toccoa, Georgia

November 24, 2015 5:18pm CST

I use to only like creamy peanut butter and I would buy any brand that was on sale. Now, I like both creamy and chunky and at the moment, I am going through a chunky phase. My husband really likes the Natural Peanut Butter that you have to stir. It is the kind where the peanut oil sits on top and to properly eat it, the oil must be stirred into the peanut butter. It is a little more expensive than the other brands but it is worth it. The brand is Smuckers. If you like and eat peanut butter, what is your favorite kind?

9 people like this

8 responses

koopharper

@koopharper (7523)

• Canada

24 Nov 15

For me it was always chunky although I will eat creamy if there is no chunky. I've had Peter Pan and Jiffy and liked them both. Been awhile because I don't know where I was living at the time. Here the choice is Kraft or the store brand and that's about it.

2 people like this

Cynthia Owens

@cindiowens (5120)

• North Myrtle Beach, South Carolina

24 Nov 15

Creamy definitely. I like Peter Pan, Jiffy, just not store brands usually. I remember as a child having to stir the oil into the peanut butter.

2 people like this

beintesays

@beintesays (19)

• Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia

25 Nov 15

For me, I prefer more the creamy one based on what I try from Jiffy. Though not really tried yet the chunky one, it looks like you may need some time to chew your bread with this kind of spread.

1 person likes this

Anna

@LadyDuck (460307)

• Switzerland

25 Nov 15

I am allergic to peanuts, so I keep nothing in the house containing peanuts, it's a serious allergy so it's better not to risk to use some by mistake.

1 person likes this