Greyfriars Bobby Of Edinburgh

@bookbar (1609)
Sudbury, England
January 15, 2016 1:58pm CST
You may have heard the story of a faithful Skye Terrier called Greyfriars Bobby, who supposedly lay at his dead master's grave for 14 years in Edinburgh. This story inspired many books and even a Disney film, and his statue sits atop of a water fountain, outside the churchyard, where his vigil was said to have taken place, and although this event happened in the 1850's, tourists still come to visit Bobby, and rub his Bronze nose...now becoming 'over rubbed' as Bronzes do. So is this just a 'shaggy dog' story? Dr. Jan Bondeson from Cardiff University, thinks so, after researching it,possibly concocted by 2 local businessman, who saw an opening for a money making venture, to attract visitors to the area. In the 1800's when many dogs had no licenced owners, and graveyards were a good place to collect titbits from sympathetic visitors, they were often where strays would be found. So truth or myth, it worked well, from that time on, and still brings revenue from tourists today....entrepreneurship was rife, even as far back as the 19th.century,it seems!
9 people like this
8 responses
@Poppylicious (11133)
16 Jan 16
When I was younger I loved this story, then I heard that it wasn't even true and felt very sad. *sniffle* It's a cute story, but definitely not true, although quite possibly based loosely on something the dog did. Maybe. :)
1 person likes this
@bookbar (1609)
• Sudbury, England
17 Jan 16
@Poppylicious Just like Santa Claus....it's a feelgood story, so where's the harm...nowadays we could use a few more of those
1 person likes this
@bookbar (1609)
• Sudbury, England
18 Jan 16
@Poppylicious Nope...we were only talking about this the other day...maybe they should bring it back...or get a new,'News manager', who is a little more enlightened...
17 Jan 16
@bookbar Do they still end regional news with a feelgood story?! Anything that warms the cockles has to be a good thing. :)
1 person likes this
@jaboUK (64361)
• United Kingdom
16 Jan 16
Oh sheesh - you've shattered my illusions!
1 person likes this
@jaboUK (64361)
• United Kingdom
16 Jan 16
@bookbar I wonder where the money comes from for 'research' like this.
1 person likes this
@bookbar (1609)
• Sudbury, England
16 Jan 16
@jaboUK ....Ain't that life? I am always amazed that college professors and the like, find the time and money, to research such harmless trivia, in a cash strapped world, hardly earth shattering
1 person likes this
@bookbar (1609)
• Sudbury, England
17 Jan 16
@jaboUK US the taxpayers... we appear to be an endless resource...if you run short just find another tax to blast us with!
1 person likes this
@LadyDuck (460454)
• Switzerland
16 Jan 16
Even if this is not a true story, I have seen dogs lying on the grave of their masters and not in ancient times, one just last year.
1 person likes this
@hostessman (11871)
• Tucson, Arizona
15 Jan 16
@bookbar since it has been around for such a long time they need to just accept that it is true..
1 person likes this
@bookbar (1609)
• Sudbury, England
16 Jan 16
@hostessman....Or not,but makes for a great human interest story, and Bobby, still sits in pride of place, luring unsuspecting tourists to rub his nose for luck
@MALUSE (69390)
• Germany
15 Jan 16
The 14 years sound suspicious, don't they? The dog must have become extremely old if you add the years it lived together with its master.
1 person likes this
@bookbar (1609)
• Sudbury, England
15 Jan 16
@MALUSE ...Possibly 2 or more, just perpetuating the myth and the Scottish pounds flowing, one might think...
@AnneEJ (4917)
• Dollard-Des-Ormeaux, Quebec
15 Jan 16
I remember hearing that story, and we probably never will know if it was true or not.
1 person likes this
@bookbar (1609)
• Sudbury, England
16 Jan 16
@AnneEJ Whichever...it's harmless human interest, and a good 'tail'
1 person likes this
@AnneEJ (4917)
• Dollard-Des-Ormeaux, Quebec
16 Jan 16
@bookbar You are right
@KristenH (33363)
• Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio
16 Jan 16
What a fascinating story on this dog.
@JudyEv (326726)
• Rockingham, Australia
17 Feb 16
I could believe that a dog would stay at a place where he last saw his owner. There is a similar story - is it Japan? - of a dog meeting a train at a certain time each day after his owner left for work then had a heart attack or something.