i am not a tin of tuna
By Elizabeth
@Poppylicious (11134)
United Kingdom
September 28, 2018 1:34am CST
History suggests that as human beings we seem to have an insatiable need to slot each other into categories, give each other a label, and thus treat each other accordingly.
The contemporary world is no different, yet - perhaps perversely - labels are being given out willy-nilly.
Your two year old is having tantrums? Must be ADHD. Quick, get him diagnosed! Give him a label which will follow him through school and give him a valuable excuse for playing up. He's naughty because he's been told he can be naughty; he has a label.
Your four year old is fixated on trains? Well, she's definitely autistic then. Quick, get her diagnosed! Give her a label which will follow her through school, which will make her eccentricities evermore noticeable to the other children in her classes, and quite possibly hinder her development into a fully functioning member of society.
Your eight year old is falling behind at school? Dyslexia! Quick, get a diagnosis! Give them a label which gives them an excuse to never do their work.
These are just three of the labels we give children which can cause damage. In many instances I suspect that these are often mis- and over- diagnosed. How has society changed so much that so many children are being given labels?
I tend to think that the biggest reason is a lack of routine, a lack of firm boundaries. It is not a coincidence that most children diagnosed with ADHD come from a more working class background, perhaps where both parents are working more hours than the day has, too tired to provide the emotional attention their child needs.
Everybody has quirks and all of us are on the spectrum somewhere, even if it's slap bang in the middle. Those with relatively high functioning Autism or Asperger's were the odd kids we went to school with. The loners, the eccentrics and the passionate. The ones who were a bit too geeky. They were the strange professor in his dilapidated house in the middle of your street, and the elderly couple who had followed the same routine for fifty years. Because routine is important. Most of us are made anxious by change and the unexpected, but it may be a hundred times worse for an autistic person.
The modern world is amazing. It's explosive and bright, wonderful and HUGE. We have the entire world at our fingertips, never more than a click away. It's such an exciting time to be alive. But this, coupled with a lack of routine {how many families sit around the table every night to eat dinner together and talk about their day?}, an educational system which cares more about money and intellectual capabilities, and studies revealing that children aren't given the opportunity to enjoy books and reading as much, creates a society of entitled people who are only able to function with a label which excuses them from some aspect of their character and personality.
My favourite quote ever, from an autistic teenager I worked with a couple of years ago? My autism is playing up! No, love, it's not.
It's really not.
7 people like this
8 responses
@dave121495 (1294)
• Philippines
28 Sep 18
We need only to diagnose this kind of disorders only when they do it very excessively or maybe not the usual, that is why its called a disorder. Just for example depression, the feeling of being down is very excessive that is why many areas is also affected like poor concentration, lack of appetite and weight loss, if you probably observe or study the person for a day or maybe a week you could see the difference between what is normal and what is abnormal. But I think your point is that we should accept it even they are like that. We need to love them from what they are but we need something to do with that kind of problem.
3 people like this
@Poppylicious (11134)
• United Kingdom
28 Sep 18
Yes, I don't think these issues {I'm wary to call them disorders} are non-existent. Of course they exist. I do think that some parents and professionals are too quick to get a diagnosis, and I don't think this always helps.
1 person likes this
@petatonicsca (7070)
• Japan
28 Sep 18
Yes, and I think the compartmentization has only gotten worse in the past twenty years. It happens not only with people, but with jobs. Do you know any general practitioner doctors these days? Every job is getting more and more specialized, to the detriment of all the people who have been labeled as not being smart enough to get into those jobs.
2 people like this
@Poppylicious (11134)
• United Kingdom
28 Sep 18
I look back at my schooldays {in the eighties and very early nineties} and can pinpoint all my schoolmates who would have been labelled as 'something'. Facebook suggests they they integrated well into society and became successful, but they did that without labels, without their own personal classroom support and without a diagnosis.

@LadyDuck (502886)
• Italy
29 Sep 18
@Poppylicious I hope that this happens one day. Humans are not numbers and we can all be one different from another and this without being "weird".
1 person likes this
@Poppylicious (11134)
• United Kingdom
28 Sep 18
Perhaps one day some future generation will accept that everybody is different and strip away the labels that make people feel either entitled or victimised.
1 person likes this

@xFiacre (14804)
• Ireland
28 Sep 18
@poppylicious Amen. I’m not autistic or anything like it but I am definitely odd - I talk to my toilet. My brother hides behind his ADHD (self diagnosed) and in the housing estate where I work parents are crying out for a diagnosis - it’s become a badge of honour and if you don’t have a label you’re not worth very much. Interesting fact is that the psychologist who operates in this area exhibits all the signs of autism. How did the world ever get by before Autism and ADHD were invented.
2 people like this
@Poppylicious (11134)
• United Kingdom
28 Sep 18
Some of our sixteen year olds are diagnosed at a young age, and yes, they do exhibit signs, but they often arrive having never NOT had support in education. I do think {speaking as a slightly exaggerated TA with a teaching qualification and twenty years experience of working in the education system in four different roles} that they receive too much support in mainstream primary and secondary. And it's the wrong kind of support. As a result they either rely too heavily on us in FE, or they shun us completely. They dont want their EHCPs anymore, but they're told they won't have access to any support at all if they decline, which is complete rubbish. All that will happen is that college will lose anything from 2k to 40k in poundage. Some of them come with oodles of money, but they don't really need anybody with them in the classroom. It makes some of my lessons incredibly boredom inducing.
@moffittjc (128856)
• Gainesville, Florida
9 Oct 18
I think the other factor that is often overlooked is our diet. I read somewhere once that half the children who are diagnosed with ADHD did not actually have ADHD, but their behaviors were because of their high-fat, high-sugar diet. Researchers at a university simply changed the diet of these children to a healthier one, and just like that the kids started acting "normal" again within a short time.
1 person likes this

@moffittjc (128856)
• Gainesville, Florida
10 Oct 18
@Poppylicious That is very true. Many families from low socio-economic backgrounds live very unhealthy lifestyles, either because they don't know any better, or because they can't afford to eat healthier foods. It's not like they do it on purpose, many just don't know any better, or understand the consequences of eating an unhealthy diet.
1 person likes this
@Poppylicious (11134)
• United Kingdom
10 Oct 18
@moffittjc And sadly their children pass on this behaviour to their children. The circle of life.
1 person likes this
@Poppylicious (11134)
• United Kingdom
10 Oct 18
And this makes perfect sense when you look at the socio-economic background of many of these children. Sadly.
1 person likes this

@JudyEv (382658)
• Rockingham, Australia
3 Oct 18
A very insightful post and I'm sure what you say is very true. I know some adults who get exactly what they want because if they aren't indulged their anxiety, depression, panic attack will be triggered. I'm not saying that's the case with everyone but with some it is.
1 person likes this

@JudyEv (382658)
• Rockingham, Australia
4 Oct 18
@Poppylicious You are so right.
1 person likes this
@JESSY3236 (22287)
• United States
28 Sep 18
Yeah we label too much. My fiance has ADD, but he refuses to admit he has it. I think my uncle is on the spectrum. He thinks I'm on the spectrum.
1 person likes this
@Poppylicious (11134)
• United Kingdom
28 Sep 18
I think I am undiagnosed ADD, or sometimes possibly Asperger's. I think that before we started diagnosing these as an actual thing, people just adjusted and learnt to cope and adapt. Now we stick a label on them and they don't need to fit in, other people need to fit them in. If that makes sense!
1 person likes this








