Why do people give money instead of a gift when attending a birthday party at a restaurant?
By Lena Kovadlo
@lovebuglena (52220)
Staten Island, New York
October 4, 2018 2:15pm CST
I don't know how it is in other cultures but in the "Russian" circle (here in NYC) when we get together for birthday parties at restaurants we usually give a gift of $100 per person. If there are two people that makes it $200. I have no idea who came up with that number. Why does it have to be at least $100 a person?
It is very rare that someone will come with a gift rather than cash or a check. I have no idea why that is. What is wrong with getting an actual gift rather than stuffing money or a check into an envelope?
I actually think that getting a gift is a great idea. It's more thoughtful and personal that way and it allows you to actually spend less money as well. If two people are going, the gift you get does not have to equal to $200. It just has to be a nice thoughtful gift and hopefully one the birthday person will actually like. I doubt the person will research the price of the gift when they receive it. Though you never know...
I am going to a birthday party soon and that is exactly what I am thinking of doing. And I see nothing wrong with that. And because I feel like I cannot afford to give $200, I'd rather spend less and give a gift than give money but less than $200.
5 people like this
4 responses
@BabeSays (8795)
• Mauritius
4 Oct 18
$100? I don't think Americans gives that much of money to anyone on birthday. Probably about a $25 or $50 I think.
@lovebuglena (52220)
• Staten Island, New York
6 Oct 18
Really? If we gave that much people would think we are being cheap. At least in our circle.
@lovebuglena (52220)
• Staten Island, New York
7 Oct 18
@BabeSays Where is Mauritius located? I never heard of such a name.
@BabeSays (8795)
• Mauritius
7 Oct 18
@lovebuglena Well I'm from Mauritius and none of my relatives ever even me a penny so I presonally believe that $25 or $50 is quite good.

@lovebuglena (52220)
• Staten Island, New York
6 Oct 18
I know. But not everyone can afford to pay that much. Then what? Do you always not go? Or do you go and give less?
1 person likes this
@NJChicaa (127187)
• United States
6 Oct 18
@lovebuglena do what you feel comfortable with as long as you think the recipient will understand
@lovebuglena (52220)
• Staten Island, New York
7 Oct 18
@NJChicaa I got my niece a nice gift from Swarovski. The gift was not cheap by any means, but I spent less than $200, which means I saved some money. And she actually likes the gift. That's a win-win for me.
1 person likes this


@skysnap (20152)
•
7 Oct 18
@lovebuglena yeah true. gift something that can be used.
1 person likes this
@lovebuglena (52220)
• Staten Island, New York
6 Oct 18
In that way yes. But money can be wasted on useless stuff. In that case, a gift is better.
1 person likes this

@lovebuglena (52220)
• Staten Island, New York
6 Oct 18
I think that's the right thing to do.
1 person likes this
@lovebuglena (52220)
• Staten Island, New York
8 Oct 18
@nela13 That's smart I think.
1 person likes this
@nela13 (59365)
• Portugal
6 Oct 18
@lovebuglena $100 is too much, nobody here gives it as a birthday present.






