Short story: Alan confronts the problem of good and evil, and comes up with an explanation of sorts.
By emptychair
@innertalks (23743)
Australia
July 27, 2019 1:58am CST
Alan was walking home from the Evannwood station, about 4 pm, one afternoon.
He went past a corner shop where some kids were congregating around an ice-cream parlour there.
One kid came up to Alan, and he said hello to him, but then another kid had snuck up behind him and reached into Alan's jeans pocket, and stole his wallet from him.
Then this kid threw the wallet to another boy, in front of him, who run off with it then.
Alan thought about grabbing the first boy by the throat, and throttling him, and telling the others that he will strangle him unless the other boy gives him back his wallet again.
"Give it back or else," he would tell them.
But Alan didn't do this, even though he was annoyed, and he really wanted to do just that.
No, Alan knew that if he even just touched even just one of these minors, he would be the one charged with assaulting them.
Another reason was that Alan always carried two wallets with him, just in case something like this might happen to him. (Alan kept his second wallet in an inside pocket in his jacket, close to his chest).
The old wallet in his jeans pocket had only contained just the one $5 note, and a few coins. There was also an old bank keycard for a bank account that Alan had closed 10 years ago.
So, Alan was really not too worried about his loss.
He hurried off home before the boys could catch up to him again, peeved by the small amount that they had gotten.
Maybe, they might take his expensive Swiss watch next time.
When Alan got home though, this little incident got him to thinking.
Why does God allow both good and bad people to live together in the same world?
Why even God had allowed both good and evil even to exist both together, even within the original garden of Eden, which was supposedly a paradise.
The evil one existed there too in the role of a serpent.
As well as that, God had planted there the tree of Knowledge, of which if anyone who ate of its fruit, they would know the difference between good and evil.
Why would God plant this alluring temptation there, and then tell them not to eat of it?
So this temptation and alluring attraction was another evil in a way.
There was then at least two evil influencing agents, even in a seeming paradise.
God allows both the good and the bad to exist under himself, as he gives freedom of choice to each part of his creation.
God himself remains totally good at all times though, and by sticking to him, we can live from the good only too, and avoid all temptation, put there, not by God, but by the choice of various parts of his creation, making the choice to live separate from God in their, or another's way, rather than only in God's loving way.
Alan was satisfied with his thinking.
For after all, if we we not given free choice, we would be only just mere puppets of God. Now, we are not puppets, but can freely choose to follow God, and to live in his way, performing his will, by making our own choice to do so, out of our love for him, and which God obviously seems to want of us to do.
Photo credit: The photo used here was freely sourced from the free media site: pixabay.com
Why does God allow both good and evil to coexist together, as bedfellows, in his world?
5 people like this
4 responses
@dgobucks226 (37621)
•
28 Jul 19
God gives us the choice of free will to do good or evil in the world he has created for us. Like Eden where Adam and Eve are tested with the apple, so we are tested by the life we as humans have created for ourselves. God is letting us choose our behavior and he is an observer at this point, not dictating or interfering with our decisions. When it is time to leave our world, then is the time he will pass judgement as we await to enter his paradise.
2 people like this
@innertalks (23743)
• Australia
28 Jul 19
It is hard to get a handle on what evil really is at times, though. Sometimes, it is ignorance, and so I guess, that's why God has given us all a lot of time to learn, the difference too.
I am thinking of all of those people sacrifices, for religious reasons, by some of the Indian tribes of centuries ago, and the cannibals of New Guinea, etc etc.
Are these sins, evil, or just ignorance?
In Adam and Eve's case, I think it was from ignorance, and this is why God gave them a second chance, so to speak.
2 people like this
@dgobucks226 (37621)
•
31 Jul 19
@innertalks Yes, I agree with your perspective there. Ignorance is definitely a factor too.
1 person likes this
@innertalks (23743)
• Australia
31 Jul 19
@dgobucks226 Yes, I think so, because intention, is also a factor as well, I would say. I.E. if we decide/intend to commit an evil act intentionally, or knowingly.
@innertalks (23743)
• Australia
27 Jul 19
Yes, that is probably true, but to me, it is really just indirectly true.
If we have the eyes to see goodness, it never needs to shine brighter for us, as it is seen inwardly for what it is, not just outwardly, amongst the evil, by comparing it to that evil, in contrast to it.
1 person likes this
@Shiva49 (28394)
• Singapore
28 Jul 19
I recall one incident where one lady was robbed of her imitation jewelry by a robber riding a bicycle.
The lady was shaken but was relieved the loss was bearable.
However, the next day the robber threw back the loot with some choice words to boot!
The darker the horizon the brighter the goodness will shine.
Yes, it is our choice to follow our path and our creator is magnanimous in this regard - siva
1 person likes this
@innertalks (23743)
• Australia
28 Jul 19
Thanks, siva. That's very amusing.
Choice is based around knowledge in some aspects, but the wisdom to make the choice, or to follow it, or not, must be based on love, for it to be a good choice.
Any other type of choice just despoils the journey, and lugs you down with luggage, extra baggage, called karma, by some.
1 person likes this
@innertalks (23743)
• Australia
28 Jul 19
@Shiva49 Yes, that's the golden rule, and life can be golden for all of us if we follow that rule.
1 person likes this
@Shiva49 (28394)
• Singapore
28 Jul 19
@innertalks Yes Steve, our journey should be guided by love.
Do unto others as you would have them do unto you - is a good guide to start with - siva
1 person likes this

@josie_ (10033)
• Philippines
30 Jul 19
If God created Man, then isn't our "free will" subject to God's will? "Good" and "evil" are abstract ideas that human beings developed into a code of ethics. But nature isn't subjected to such man-made morality other than the need to survive.
1 person likes this
@innertalks (23743)
• Australia
30 Jul 19
When is free will not free, when it has been given not really freely to one.
God gave free will to his creation, even up to them destroying themselves, but it is still limited, as he has his hand on the final deciding factor, if free will tips the barrel too far for him to allow.
Is love also just an abstract idea?
Even animals show love. Has love developed as a part of survival mechanism too, then?
Love never rests on its laurels, because it has no laurels to rest on.
Love is the primordial energy force behind all else, and so it is a part of all else, inbuilt into it, for it to act on either consciously or unconsciously, and the differential between the conscious and the unconscious action moves more towards consciousness, away from mere unconscious actions, as we grow more in wisdom, knowledge, understanding, and awareness.
@innertalks (23743)
• Australia
3 Aug 19
@josie_ Yeh, it's hard to come up with answers for that, the violence of nature.
In the beginning, was the latent energy of love which spontaneously came into existence upon creation.
All else stems from this one act of love, and other lesser forces of nature are in their own way creating but not loving. Only beings with conscious awareness can tell the difference between loving and creating lovingly, and just creating karmically, or forcefully.
Energy, without love, creates a monster. Love, with energy alive consciously in its vehicle, lives the love, lovingly, not just forcefully.
@josie_ (10033)
• Philippines
2 Aug 19
@innertalks _We have come to accept empathy or "love" as a human attribute whether out of necessity or because it was already built into our DNA. But the idea that it is a "primordial energy force" that surround the universe is difficult to accept if place alongside other energy forces of nature. Examples are earthquakes and hurricanes that kill without remorse. Where is the compassion in these acts of nature?
1 person likes this






