Teaching music without singing or instruments
By Denise
@petatonicsca (7070)
Japan
July 19, 2020 7:59pm CST
I teach elementary music. Since March, I was teaching online, so kids could sing and play instruments at home. We will be going back (probably) mid-August, and all the studies so far are saying there should be no singing unless 12 feet apart (that would give me 2 students in my room). Also, woodwind instruments can cause aerosols. Most of them not as much as you would think, but my instrument, flute, creates more aerosols than any other instrument because when you blow it, you blow across the edge and half the air goes out (the other half goes in and vibrates because of the split). Flutes and recorders create tone by splitting the air, so naturally they send plenty of aerosols.
Japanese schools are very traditional in terms of having everyone always follow the set curriculum, which includes a lot of singing and recorder playing in upper grades. They aren't doing either. They are humming with masks on and no recorders.
The other difficult thing is that using shared percussion instruments means complete cleaning of everything between classes. I have lap glockenspiels, handbells, and a variety of rhythm instruments, but I will have to disinfect them between classes and sometimes I have zero minutes between classes.
I can teach rhythm using body percussion (clapping, tapping) and do some not-too energetic creative movement and folk dance. I can teach about composers and instruments and listening. But kids like to make music.
Do you have any good ideas other than what I have listed?
8 people like this
6 responses
@JudyEv (382412)
• Rockingham, Australia
20 Jul 20
Can you combine with a handcraft class (or not) and have the kids create their own percussion instruments so not so much disinfection is needed. Maybe seeds in plastic jars as shakers, clapping sticks. I hope others have some ideas. I wonder if there is something like the old washboards that could be utilised. Good luck.
2 people like this
@petatonicsca (7070)
• Japan
21 Jul 20
We already did that when doing virtual school last year. Many teachers are saying they are going to put together individual instrument kits with a shaker, rhythm sticks etc. My main problem is recorders and singing.
2 people like this
@petatonicsca (7070)
• Japan
21 Jul 20
Do you mean the apps or doing it with your mouth? We sing a cappella (no accompaniment) but we are not allowed to sing. One of the biggest spreaders is plosive consonants (p, t, k) according to a study done for choirs. According to that study we can sing on a hum or on "oooo" which produces the least aerosols. Beatboxing would be terrible.
1 person likes this
@petatonicsca (7070)
• Japan
21 Jul 20
@nawala123 That is exactly what we can't do. Beatbox would be even worse than singing for spreading droplets and aerosols.
1 person likes this

@GardenGerty (169535)
• United States
20 Jul 20
I like the ideas you have mentioned already. Humming in a mask--sounds like a kazoo. Could some of the students have the duty of disinfecting instruments at the end of class before they leave? They are going to delay our school until September 9 if they follow what our governor says.
1 person likes this
@petatonicsca (7070)
• Japan
21 Jul 20
If we do play percussion instruments, the students will be disinfecting them with wipes.
@petatonicsca (7070)
• Japan
21 Jul 20
I am not coming up with a whole lot of ideas either. We have 1-1 iPads and I have found some workable free apps that simulate some instruments so we will probably use that.
@Alexandoy (65302)
• Cainta, Philippines
20 Jul 20
They are humming with their masks on. That's the sign of the times.
@amitkokiladitya (171988)
• Agra, India
20 Jul 20
Wow ...using body parts and makig out music is sounds so interesting
@petatonicsca (7070)
• Japan
21 Jul 20
We've always used that for the method I use for teaching in the younger grades, but once they get older they don't get into it as much.
1 person likes this
@amitkokiladitya (171988)
• Agra, India
21 Jul 20
@petatonicsca I can understand. The big ones would definitely prefer a real instrument in hand.







