Short Story: When being helpful is not really being helpful at all!

The Mullah had his wood chopped now by his father-in-law
@innertalks (23744)
Australia
October 1, 2020 8:28pm CST
The Mullah Nasruddin's father-in-law had moved in with the Mullah, and his wife, due to the death of his own wife, and because they thought that he would fare better under their roof, as he was already an old, and rather feeble headed man. At first, he tried to help, and to pull his weight around the house, but the way that he did things, without asking anyone about whether he should even do them, yet alone the way that he should go about doing them, proved to be a problem for the Mullah, and his wife, rather than any real help. In fact, he was more an annoyance, and a hindrance, to the otherwise smooth running of their house, or at least it had been relatively smooth, until this old gent arrived there. For one thing, he used to be a knife sharpener, years ago. And, so he sharpened all of the Mullah's knives in his drawers, as well as some of the tools, in his garden shed. The Mullah was used to some of them being a bit blunt, as he liked some of the knives that way, for what he used them for. The Mullah had one paring knife, that he kept blunt, as he used it to scrape the wax off of apples, before he used them. He did not want to cut into the flesh of the apple at all, while he was doing this. The blunt knife was an aide to his primary aim here. Everything has a prime use in the Mullah's house, and is left set up in that way, on purpose. He cut his finger rather badly, on one such sharpened, now razor-sharp knife, because he was not aware that this had happened to his knife. He was scraping his apple, towards himself. The razor-sharp knife now slid right across the shiny wet skin of the apple, and it sliced a bit off of the Mullah's finger too. Then, the Mullah examined the old man's toilet, one day, as the guest room that he was living in now, had its own toilet, and ensuite bathroom too. The Mullah's wife had asked him to clean it, as the old man's eyes were not so good, and he often left it rather dirty, to say the least, about it, of what we could say about the cleanliness state of that toilet. The Mullah was surprised to see that the porcelain of the bowl, had deep scratch marks in it now, inside the bowl. He told his wife about this. His wife asked her father. It turned out that the old guy was trying to clean some of the brown-coloured crystallised sediment, left in the toilet, off of the toilet, with sandpaper, from the shed! "No wonder it was now so badly scratched!", the Mullah thought to himself. Lastly, the Mullah had the daily newspaper delivered to his house, early every morning, at around 9 am. He liked to keep abreast of the news, around his locale. The father-in-law, although he knew this, as he had been told many times, still, would wander up to the local shop, and buy another paper, at 8.30 am, every morning, thinking, in his own distorted little way, that he was helping the family, by his doing this. The Mullah was beside himself: This type of helping was unhelpful to the household budget, in every way. The Mullah took his father-in-law aside, and he said to him, "I will give you some chores to do daily, as I know that you want to help us do some things here in the house to help us get by, but please, if you feel like doing any extra, please let one of us know first, before you do this extra stuff." The first job he gave him was to sharpen the axe, as that did need sharpening, (It was kept up in the woodshed, not the garden shed, and the old guy had not found it yet, in his previous sharpening spree) and then, he allowed him to splinter some wood every day, for the old wood heaters, in every room of that large old manor house. This kept the old man quite busy, so he was tired after this, and so, he was then more well behaved, for the rest of the day, at least until tomorrow, came around, then too. Afterword: When is being helpful really not being very helpful at all? When we help somebody in a different way to which they wanted to be helped, or of how they like things to be done, in their own way too! Photo Credit: The photo used in this article was sourced from the free media site, pixabay.com The Mullah had his wood chopped now by his father-in-law.
8 people like this
7 responses
@DocAndersen (54399)
• United States
3 Oct 20
ah the intent versus reality argument - well said!
3 people like this
@innertalks (23744)
• Australia
4 Oct 20
The old father in law had a good eye still for seeing a straight line even if he was already close to 90.
Yes, thanks, Scott. We can have intent, and the reality can be different. Sometimes the intent, is malicious, though, and sometimes it is done in ignorance. A good intent, is better than a bad intent, despite the reality, being as it is, would you say that though? Some people also say that we create our own reality. The Mullah was feeling sorry for his father-in-law, because he had spent the whole afternoon, in the Mullah's garden, cutting the edges of his lawn border, bordering his garden. It had been an excruciatingly hot afternoon, and the old man had cut all of the edges, just with a pair of kitchen scissors. It took him hours to do, all in the hot sun, and the old guy was already, well into his eighties now, as well. He was afraid to disturb the Mullah, in his study, with the door shut, and working on his upcoming talk, on the nature of impersonal reality. Was it different, or the same as the nature of personal reality? The old man had done a great job, though. All of the edges were straight, and perfectly done. Not a blade of grass was out of place. The Mullah had not asked his father-in-law to do anything, but to rest, on that very hot afternoon. He had helped again, but at least this time, he had done well. The Mullah took him out, and he bought him a large icecream cone, which he lapped up with a happy pleasure, and with a big smile in his face too. "His afternoon's work was worth it," was the simple thought in his head. Photo Credit: The photo used here belongs to me, the author, of this piece. The old father in law had a good eye still, for seeing a straight line, even if he was already close to 90, years young.
@innertalks (23744)
• Australia
4 Oct 20
@Shiva49 We all have our own particular skills, and even the cat enjoys their catnapping, so there is nothing wrong with that. The Mullah has been known to have a 30-minute kipper down himself in the early afternoon too, as he has a fold-away mattress in his study, that he will lie down on, at times, when his head is too full of his realisations.
@Shiva49 (28394)
• Singapore
4 Oct 20
@innertalks I wish I had such skills and motivation at his age but I need to get over the napping habit in the afternoon!
1 person likes this
@dgobucks226 (37621)
3 Oct 20
Over time most people get comfortable doing things and having items a certain way. In trying to hard to make himself useful the father-in-law made things worse. In my view it's similar to invading one's personal space. Most people don't like that, it makes them uncomfortable. That's exactly what the father-in-law did to the Mullah.
2 people like this
@innertalks (23744)
• Australia
3 Oct 20
The Mullahs birds enjoying their grass seed
Yes, it is certainly comparable to invading someone's space, when we do things unbidden, in their space. At other times, people do mean well, as this next example shows, but they still do things in the wrong way, because they have no knowledge of the right way to do things here, which requires specialist knowledge to do them. In these circumstances, they should not just rush in, but ask for advice first, about what they should be doing to help, and not to hinder, the person, doing the task. The Mullah went for a walk with his father-in-law, and he spotted some grass growing in a field, which he knew that his birds liked that particular type of grass, with that type of grass-seed in it. So, he started picking some to take home with him, so he might give them to his birds, when he got home again. The father-in-law, also wanting to help, and seeing the Mullah picking some blades of grass, started to pick some grass too. The trouble was that he picked the wrong type of grass, those ones that have sticky, spiky seeds, and which would have killed the Mullah's birds, if fed to them. The Mullah tried to explain that he had to pick only a certain variety of grass, but the father-in-law, being also hard of hearing, as well as hard of understanding, had no idea of what the Mullah was meaning. The Mullah took the father-in-law's picked grass, and he threw it into the bin. "These type will kill my birds," he more plainly said, and perhaps the old man now finally understood him. The Mullah had to be a bit directly blunt with the old man, to make sure that he really got the real meaning this time, as otherwise, he might gather some of the wrong grass seeds, while on his own one day, and give these to the Mullah's birds himself, and so inadvertently kill them. Photo Credit: The photo used here belongs to me, the author, of this piece The Mullah's birds enjoying their grass seed, in their cage.
@Shiva49 (28394)
• Singapore
3 Oct 20
@innertalks With friends like these who needs enemies? comes to mind. The Mullah is left o watch his back as even good intentions are handed in a poisoned chalice.
1 person likes this
@innertalks (23744)
• Australia
3 Oct 20
@Shiva49 Good intentions do not cut it sometimes. The Mullah made a cup of coffee for the old man, soon after he had first arrived. As an expert coffee maker, and having been trained as a barista too, he made his speciality, a special mix that had once won him first prize for both its taste and its presentation in a local show. He thought that the old guy would love it too. He hated it. The Mullan learnt an important lesson here. He was not making the coffee for himself. He should have asked the old guy how he liked his coffee made, first.
@kareng (80243)
• United States
4 Oct 20
Great little story and that goes along with the old saying that "if you want something done right, then do it yourself."
2 people like this
@innertalks (23744)
• Australia
4 Oct 20
Yes, that's often a very true saying, but sometimes people interfere with their help, without even asking us if they can do so, as what happened here, in my story. Then we often have to undo things, and still do them ourselves too.
@RasmaSandra (98106)
• Daytona Beach, Florida
2 Oct 20
Sometimes people want to help so bad that they help too much and sometimes they think they are helping but they are not because they do not really know how to help
2 people like this
@innertalks (23744)
• Australia
2 Oct 20
Yes, that is a good point. Like the old story, of the good samaritan gent, helping the little old lady across a busy road, to the other side, when she was just standing there, looking at the cars, and motor-bikes riding past, filling in time, for something to do. She did not want to cross over the road, at all!
@RasmaSandra (98106)
• Daytona Beach, Florida
2 Oct 20
@innertalks I know that one and it is a great example
2 people like this
@innertalks (23744)
• Australia
2 Oct 20
@RasmaSandra Yes, it is oft-repeated, and known all over the world I think too.
@paigea (36143)
• Canada
2 Oct 20
It can be hard to know how to be helpful. What one person finds helpful, another does not.
2 people like this
@paigea (36143)
• Canada
2 Oct 20
@innertalks You are an amazing helper.
3 people like this
@innertalks (23744)
• Australia
2 Oct 20
Yes, I always ask the other person if I am helping them in their way, or if I am doing what they wanted me to be doing. I used to do gardening for a lot of old ladies, who lived around my area. I never did anything my way, but always in their way, for after-all, it was their house, and their garden. I only made a few suggestions, from time to time, but the rest of the time, I just quietly worked for them, not against them.
@happylife1 (13403)
• Karachi, Pakistan
2 Oct 20
@innertalks Nice and full of lesson naration
2 people like this
@Nakitakona (59987)
• Philippines
2 Oct 20
I have experienced it. I would like to be helpful but my helpful job done isn't helpful at all. It worsens or turns bad. For I learn a little of doing it. Thus, a little learning is a dangerous thing.
2 people like this
@innertalks (23744)
• Australia
2 Oct 20
Yes, attempting something with only a little learning can indeed be dangerous, for our self, and for those who will have to endure the results of our actions too. That's why the Government legislates that only qualified people can be electricians, doctors, chiropractors etc etc etc.
2 people like this
@innertalks (23744)
• Australia
2 Oct 20
@Nakitakona Yes, that's right, but in some countries, like here in Australia, they are catching up with more and more of these non-experts. Martial arts was legislated, osteopaths, second-hand dealers, even massage practitioners, you need a licence here now. I am not sure what is left that you can do without being qualified anymore here. Maybe, a chess tutor; you can still do that without proof of your skills and abilities at chess.
@Nakitakona (59987)
• Philippines
2 Oct 20
@innertalks That's right but there are still do the things they're not expert to do.
2 people like this
@Shiva49 (28394)
• Singapore
2 Oct 20
Yes, one need to adjust and know the reality before chipping in. Some, trying to help, turn out like a bull in a china shop, doing more damage in the process and others having to put out the endless fire. I have found women are more useful in the house while men can be a burden. The Mullah is kind and considerate despite getting harried all the time, not knowing where the troubles are hiding ready to sprout any time. I salute the Mullah who is tested at the highest level by God and seems to come out with flying colors all the time. Lesser humans would have been driven up the wall much earlier.
1 person likes this
@innertalks (23744)
• Australia
2 Oct 20
Yes, the Mullah certainly rises to the occasion, and mostly follows his heart, rather than any hurting, in his mind. God always helps the helper, who helps in the right spirit of love, and so helping really helps, rather than hinders, because love shows you if you are helping in the right way, or not, if you keep your heart open to those being helped. Yes, women, seem to be able to connect to others better than men can too, and this connecting keeps them aware to see if their help is really helping the other person they are trying to help, or not.
@innertalks (23744)
• Australia
2 Oct 20
@Shiva49 Perhaps he tries harder with someone that he now has to live with, maybe he is testing himself, to see how he can control his reactions, and still access his heart, maybe, also his love for his wife, and the fact that this is her father, further tempers his responses too. It's a funny word "temper"; we can learn to temper our temper, and it means to control it, or to keep it measured down a bit. The Mullah realises that most people do try to help others but in their own way. But, they often do not seem to have the awareness to think past their own way/methods of helping others to the possible consequences of their actions. Here is another example from the Mullah's almost full journal of happenings that have happened to him when he is with his father-in-law. The Mullah was on his way to his community hall, to give his weekly talk there. He had decided to take his father-in-law with him, because the old man had been sitting around, looking pretty bored with himself, all day. They went out to the Mullah's garage. The Mullah tried to lift the roller door up, but something seemed to be holding it down, from its going up. He looked down the other end of the door, and the father-in-law was there, holding the door down. He was only a short man, and his idea was good. (for himself) He did not want the door to go up to the top of its roll, as he couldn't then reach it, to help bring it down again, once the Mullah's car was outside of the garage. The problem was though, if this is done, the door is still top-heavy, if it is not rolled up to its top full position, and then it is in danger of falling down again, unexpectedly so, as the car shakes it a bit as it goes underneath it, and a disaster will follow. The car will be hit with the falling door! The Mullah used a bit of extra strength, and so he pushed it past the pulling down hands of the father-in-law, so that the door then was rolled up, all of the way to the top of its roll. The father-in-law was not even going to be the one to pull it down again on the other side, though, before they drove off anyway, as the Mullah had to do this, as he had the key to lock it, and the father-in-law was already inside the car, by then, and it would take him too long to get out and in again, if he had of been the one that had done this too. At least, he was trying to help me here again, the Mullah smiled to himself, as they drove off together. "That's another good tale for my talks about human relationships, I have here, which I will give out to the good people of this village, next week, in my talk next week, after I have had the chance to write it up tonight," he thought to himself, as he powered the powerful sports Jaguar car up, and sped off quickly into the distance. The old father-in-law was slow in most of the things that he did now, but he did like the Mullah to go fast in this car, so the Mullah, at least, always obliged him in his doing this for him too, whenever the old man was in his car, with him. At most other times, he would only drive slowly, for he knew the power of the car, and he knew that he didn't have to prove its speed, or its power, to anyone else, as he drove it along, by himself, happily singing along, as he drove.
@Shiva49 (28394)
• Singapore
2 Oct 20
@innertalks Yes, the interconnection of the hearts is palpable in the way the Mullah is able to tide over some tough situations. I have come close to throwing in the towel a few times seeing how intransigent others can be when they never budge an inch. The patience of the Mullah, inspired by love for another human, shines in the way he tackles his father-in-law.
1 person likes this