Be a judge ... issue no. 2

@vandana7 (99013)
India
June 5, 2022 4:51am CST
Ok... the scenario is every other day we hear about rapes and gang rapes. The issue has become as common as the detergent advertisement. So yesterday a minor was gang raped, and there were minors among the rapists. International bodies like Amnesty need to understand that a juvenile in the west comes up in a different scenario when compared to a juvenile in my country. The law and order takes quite some time to really punish, and punishments are laughable. Given such a scenario, don't you think a boy even if he is just 11 or 12, if he is capable of raping, then he needs to be tried for rape, notwithstanding his age. And that parents need to be punished too with some financial fine for not having brought up the kid well. At the risk of sounding communist .. I feel each one of us has duty towards the country and society. Which takes precedence depends upon the situation. But these duties are sacrosanct and above the duties towards family. Failure to do those duties is to be treated as anti national act. So we should respect the rights granted by constitution to fellow citizen, minor or not. If those rights are infringed due to some act of mine, I should expect punishment equivalent to that I give to a terrorist. The punishment needs to be defined upfront so as to work as a deterrent. Why is a rapist equal to a terrorist? He disrespected the clauses in the constitution through which the victim derived her rights to live safely in this country. The rapist should be penalized monetarily, and if he cannot afford to pay that much his next generations or siblings would pay. This amount should keep on increasing at inflation rate. Limitation act should not apply to such puinshment.
6 people like this
7 responses
@LindaOHio (157676)
• United States
5 Jun 22
I tend to agree with you. A minor raping another minor is missing something in his upbringing and may have some mental challenges mixed in. A "child" starting out his life this way shows that there are some serious problems.
3 people like this
@vandana7 (99013)
• India
5 Jun 22
Parents should be watchful and check their children's friends and books and cell phones randomly to know what is happening in the life of their child.
2 people like this
6 Jun 22
I agree too. A minor who can rape has serious girl-hate issues. Scary.
3 people like this
@LindaOHio (157676)
• United States
6 Jun 22
@vandana7 Exactly. Parents either are too busy or just don't care.
1 person likes this
@LadyDuck (459629)
• Switzerland
5 Jun 22
I agree with you, non only the minor must be punished but also his parents, as they have been unable to teach to their son to respect the women. They must indemnify the victim financially.
2 people like this
@vandana7 (99013)
• India
5 Jun 22
Yes, parents as well as the rapist should be punished financially, and this should be in addition to the prison sentence for the rapist.
2 people like this
@LadyDuck (459629)
• Switzerland
6 Jun 22
@vandana7 I fully agree with you and the governments MUST do something to punish those who try to abuse women.
1 person likes this
@xander6464 (40915)
• Wapello, Iowa
6 Jun 22
Is he facing any prison time?
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (99013)
• India
7 Jun 22
@xander6464 Oops..sewing machine ...sigh. The arguments presented by the legislators was....he is a kid, he can be goaded to do things...by adults around or what the victim was uttering. Just because he is a minor. So not his fault. He needs to be given a chance to restart his life. So sewing machine to work as a tailor. The guy used a long iron rod and shoved it inside the uterus of the victim. Pulled part of uterus out...the girl survived all that... to tell the horrific stuff. But legislators did not do much. Instead, the girl's brother was given a government job to quieten things up. Where was Amnesty International when such injustice happened? They only stand up for small children being punished...but this guy was 17 years few months old! Almost an adult..how did he qualify as a minor and a kid?
1 person likes this
@xander6464 (40915)
• Wapello, Iowa
7 Jun 22
@vandana7 That's kind of a novel approach to crime. Making it like a game show.
1 person likes this
@xander6464 (40915)
• Wapello, Iowa
7 Jun 22
@vandana7 That is sad but pretty typical. The world always seems to have more sympathy for the rapist than the victim.
1 person likes this
@wolfgirl569 (95959)
• Marion, Ohio
5 Jun 22
It sounds likea fair way to get the family more involved in helping prevent the problem.
2 people like this
@vandana7 (99013)
• India
5 Jun 22
Family should be involved. Somewhere we go wrong in thinking it is only about love. It is also about the country having provided resources amenities etc., to ensure the survival of the country for the next generation. We can't just use the resources, and forget about corresponding obligation.
2 people like this
@arunima25 (85690)
• Bangalore, India
6 Jun 22
I agree with you. It's a shame that such incidents keep rising in the civilized society. And rapists are as bad as terrorist or even worse
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (99013)
• India
7 Jun 22
Aruna Shanbhoug's case... Nirbhaya's case... Unnao case... these are striking cases where justice system failed miserably.
1 person likes this
@arunima25 (85690)
• Bangalore, India
7 Jun 22
@vandana7 They did. While the culprits in Nirbhaya case were pinished, it was a long wait. Justice delayed is justice denied. And the one juvenile escaped the wrath of punishment because he was shy of few months to be trialed as an adult
6 Jun 22
I think your stand on it is pretty reasonable. It's not as if like asking their balls to be chopped off for raping.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (99013)
• India
6 Jun 22
Why our government does not come up with at least this much bothers me.
6 Jun 22
@vandana7 Hmmmm.
1 person likes this
@CuriousGab (3251)
• India
7 Jun 22
One of the 6 accused of nirbhaya case was also minor. He was sent to reformation home for 3 yrs and then relased. It was such a heinous rape and murder ,how can he do that with a mentality of a child? It obvious that the mental state of such kids is not like child and they should be given proper punishment considering the severity of crime. Once released they might commit more crimes
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (99013)
• India
7 Jun 22
You bet. More crimes, better execution ..will not repeat same mistakes. Has taken training in the reformatory home...has developed contacts too...so that he will get help and give help to bad people. Wow...just wow...and legislators did nothing to bring down the cases. I feel the same way about acid attacks.
1 person likes this