Multiple Personalities
By May Day
@HaruLoid (1592)
Philippines
June 2, 2024 3:36am CST
The episode that I'm watching in Law and Order shows the accused to be suffering from a Multiple Personality Disorder.
The Judge finds the accused to be competent to testify under oath in trial. I wonder why?
I don't think the accused could be competent enough to testify considering that she has Multiple Personalities, and her memory depends on which personality was present during a said event.
That's one complicated trial to do.
4 people like this
2 responses
@pumpkinjam (8876)
• United Kingdom
5 Jun 24
I know a lot about multiple personality disorders. My husband has one called dissociative identity disorder (DID). He would be perfectly competent to stand trial, as would one of my two friends with the same condition. Another friend may not. These disorders, like any other condition, vary from person to person. Depending on the type of disorder, the woman may remember what happened. My husband has symbiotic DID, which basically means both his personalities (or alts) are aware of each other, although this is thought to be unusual.
There is a film called 'Split', which is an extremely dramatised version of someone with DID. It's loosely based on a true event in which a person committed a crime but couldn't be convicted of it. They had no recollection of it because it was another alt that actually committed it. It can be complicated when it comes to that type of thing (but there was also a similar case with conjoined twins where they couldn't be jailed for something one of them did because it would take away the freedom of the innocent twin).
In the case you mentioned, I would expect a psychiatrist or similar would have been involved to assess competency and to ensure they were talking to the correct alt. While there are some MPDs where personalities can be totally different, I have described the most common type as being extremes of normal e.g. most of us change (knowingly or not) to fit certain situations. DID is similar to this. It's also not usually scary.
1 person likes this
@HaruLoid (1592)
• Philippines
6 Jun 24
I'm sorry that your husband and some of your friends have DID. I find your husband quite rare. Most of the documentaries or shows that I watched always portray someone with DID as somewhat unaware of the other alts. I find it a good thing that your husband is aware of his alts. This made me wonder on how he is able to deal or communicate with them.
I was able to watch the movies Split and Sybil. I didn't know that Split was actually based in a true story.
Truly, there will be difficulties on how to communicate a person with DID when it comes to trial. The lawyers, judge and psychiatrist have to make sure that they are talking to the right person. I find it also unfair for the original if ever he or she ends up in jail because of what his or her alts commit.
In case of conjoined twins, that ones a bit hard to believe. I don't think one twin can't be aware on what the other twin was planning on doing - committing a crime. They usually are pretty much aware of each others' actions. The other twin could have stopped the accused twin from committing the crime, but then again, anything can happen. I might have a hard time imagining it.
1 person likes this
@pumpkinjam (8876)
• United Kingdom
6 Jun 24
@HaruLoid my husband's specific type is rare in that his alts are both 'awake' at the same time, although a different one takes control. Most people with DID are aware they have it and have awareness of other alts, they just tend to act independently while others are 'asleep'. While any form of DID was thought to be rare, there is now one school of thought that it is far more common - but, like many conditions, it can easily go unnoticed if it causes no issues.
A lot of the films and TV shows are really bad at depicting the reality of DID. My husband said that watching Sybil made him scared to seek help so he'd spent years hiding his condition.
With trials, this is why a psychiatrist needs to be involved. It's also why the true case on which Split was based ended with the person not being convicted - the alt on trial was innocent. DID can be treated (although some people choose not to because of side effects and other reasons) but, as it's always caused by trauma, it's usually better to treat that first if possible.
1 person likes this
@Marilynda1225 (91011)
• United States
2 Jun 24
I'm reading a book right now and the victim has multiple personalities. It's a mystery book so it should be interesting to see how it turns out.
1 person likes this
@HaruLoid (1592)
• Philippines
4 Jun 24
That's interesting. May I know what book that is. Books are more detailed in exhibiting these kinds of things compared to what we can just see in TV.



