Attach assets for smuggling gold, but not for rapes, acid attacks, human traffickers, etc.

@vandana7 (102392)
India
July 5, 2025 12:10am CST
I may be plain stupid. But when Enforcement Directorate (ED) in India gets right to attach assets of a person smuggling gold, why is it that people who rape or resort to acid attack, human traffic, get away without similar constraints? I have long advocated that assets of rapists, human traffickers, acid attackers, road rage folks, pedophiles be confiscated. What more, a percentage of assets of their family members too be taken away. The reason I say so is, a. As long as the assets remain with such folks, they are in position to encourage wrong elements, resort to hiring people to threaten the victim or her family or her lawyer and remove them from jobs etc., forcing them to withdraw the cases. In India such things are common. b. The family of the criminal supports him often knowing fully well that he wronged. The reason is simple...they need to keep things under wraps to retain the respect of the society for the future of their kids, and also stand to gain from the assets of the accused should the accused be eventually acquitted. c. Availability of assets and or power enables the rapists to force judges to lower punishment. d. Last and the most important factor..........I believe rape is infringement of constitution. Constitution gives rights to each and every individual to be safe and move around the country. When this right is infringed, it is a major crime, so the rights to hold property should be taken away. Given comparison with such serious crime, smuggling of gold seems almost a non crime. Yet assets of the person get attached, disabling the person to use them to cover the tracks. What can you say of lawmakers when they feel the first rape should be punished lightly and only the second rape be eligible for serious punishment? Do they really understand how difficult it is for a person to stand up and fight for her case of rape? How many hide the issue, because they don't want to go through a case forever and risk losing it when the other person is rich. So whoever decides no they are not going to put up with it, may actually be sixth or tenth victim. Does the rape still deserve to be treated as a smaller crime? When a girl gets raped, the first time, the society does not say, oh it is only the first time, let us ignore. She gets punished for lifetime, often with horrific memories, rendering her incapable of enjoying sex in marriage. How then, can lawmakers bring in lenience towards such crimes while letting economic offenses become more worthy of tying down a person?
7 people like this
6 responses
@JudyEv (362775)
• Rockingham, Australia
5 Jul
It is very unjust that perpetrators of these crimes aren't punished.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (102392)
• India
5 Jul
Conviction rate is as low as 27 percent. Rest either languish or get dismissed for want of evidence. Average 30000 reported cases, and I am sure the numbers are much higher. Just that people don't have faith in the system to deliver justice, so don't file cases.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (102392)
• India
6 Jul
@JudyEv I was speaking rape cases conviction rates and reported cases annually.
1 person likes this
@JudyEv (362775)
• Rockingham, Australia
6 Jul
@vandana7 Sometimes people here don't report petty theft as the police really aren't that interested.
1 person likes this
@id_peace (16653)
• Singapore
5 Jul
In my country, anyone who rape, kidnap, or hurt others, will be jail for a very long time whether they are male or female. If they are male, they will be caned.
1 person likes this
@id_peace (16653)
• Singapore
6 Jul
@vandana7 Castrate the offender. That was a topic that was discussed before in my country. Chemical castration but it did not pass through as it is against the human right.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (102392)
• India
6 Jul
@id_peace I think human rights people need to be quietened because they are not getting grip of the magnitude of the issues and problems. They should offer alternate solutions, so as rights or other humans are not infringed. Personally, I don't think castration helps. It causes other hormonal disturbances, which lead to increase in anger. That in turn can make the rapist vengeful. None of the solutions we have so far, can really help the victim, such big is the trauma. The way I suggest can at least prevent more damage to her or him, and their families. Human rights activists cannot intervene in this.
1 person likes this
@psanasangma (7924)
• India
5 Jul
Believe me, by seeing and reading this news always frightened me and even to travel. Can't trust anyone! The victims always suffer and the rapist always get away in many ways. I also couldn't imagine victims being the witness herself and carrying all the evidence is dangerous for her so as to her family.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (102392)
• India
5 Jul
The whole thing is so lopsided. Why can't they use lie detectors and truth serums in addition to the evidences?
1 person likes this
• India
10 Jul
@vandana7 I wonder they may even try to manipulate the machines
@jstory07 (145776)
• Roseburg, Oregon
5 Jul
Rape is just as bad as any other crime and should be punished.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (102392)
• India
5 Jul
The law treats it so lightly. I feel so sorry for the girls. On the one hand there is the issue of dowry, which is tough to accumulate, so they have to study and work, and if they do, then risk of getting raped increases.
@wolfgirl569 (122249)
• Marion, Ohio
5 Jul
Money rules in most places sadly
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (102392)
• India
5 Jul
It is difficult to ask young daughters to take up jobs or even study.
1 person likes this
@LindaOHio (200592)
• United States
5 Jul
Why does someone have to rape twice to be severely punished? This is nuts.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (102392)
• India
5 Jul
That is the law out here. LOL The first time not serious punishment, the second time serious. But what about the many cases prior to the first case that reached the court? When politicos feel, they are boys, they sometimes make mistakes, what can you expect?
1 person likes this