Help! my dog continues to poop on my carpet no matter what i do!

@Zelda414 (149)
United States
December 5, 2008 2:34pm CST
I have this beautiful, sweet and loving half chihuahua with half pomeranian female dog named chiquita who will go potty in the bathroom on the newspaper and poop but the second i leave the house or dont pay attention to what she is doing she will come and poop in our spare room or in the livingroom no matter what i do, ive tried spanking her, grounding her, you name it. i love her but i dont like her right now and i need help please some advice would be very much appreciate it.
1 person likes this
6 responses
• Argentina
6 Dec 08
This will sound bad, so don't take it the wrong way because many dog owners make the same mistakes: It's not the dogie's fault, it's yours. You say she only does this when you're not looking after her. This means Chiquita poops, walks away, sees a fly on the wall and she already forgot she pooped. Then you come back, you see the mess, you spank her, ground her and whatnot. But she's failing to associate the punishment with the actual event. You see, not only you're failing at fixing the behavior, you're actually making her scared of you because she doesn't know what's going on or why she's being punished. Even if you caught her in the act, don't ever, ever punish her physically. You see, instead of figuring out she's not supposed to do her stuff in that place, she's thinking she shouldn't do it in front of you. What you get in return is what's happening to you, she only does it when you're not around. So here comes the good part. It can be fixed but it needs dedication, patience and cleaning products for your carpet. First things first: If you find the poop, just take a deep breath, clean it and move on with your daily life. Now, if you get her in the beginning of the act, just tell her "No" in a firm tone, don't yell at her because it's not needed, it just needs to be firm. She'll probably startle and stop the act. Now take her where she's supposed to do it, wait until she's done and praise her. WAIT for it, this is where you'll need a lot of patience. Snacks or even her own dog food are great for this, try keeping some in your pocket. Remember, don't interrupt her while she's going at the right place, once she's done praise her by saying "good dog" or whatever words you like to use, then give her a little snack. Soon enough, she'll associate going potty at that place with a prize. Her brain will tell her that going in the bathroom gives her a cookie, going somewhere else doesn't. Then she'll make an habit of it and you wont have any more problems. No need for corporal punishments or getting angry at the dogie. It will take some time depending on Chiquita's age, if she's a puppy it'll be easier. If she's older it'll take some more time because she already has the habit of behaving a certain way and changing a behavior is harder than simply teaching one. But you'll be able to fix your problem with this system. I hope this helps you with your problem, if it does, I hope to hear from you. Remember: Patience and positive encouragement! Rich
1 person likes this
@Zelda414 (149)
• United States
6 Dec 08
Richard, thank you for the advice & i will inform you of some things. First off no i am not offended by your response, second i have this dog since she was 2 mths old, she is now 5mths. i have tried ignoring her n just putting her in the bathroom, i have tried putting her in the bathroom n telling her here, this is where you go pee & poop, i have tried different ways, when i punish her i dont hurt her at all because i can tell, ive tried the newspaper for the noise cuz supposably that helps, i have tried showing her n telling her no n putting her in the bathroom n telling her here in different tones, lets see oh yea this is something that i just dont get about the whole thing, i will be doing things n sometimes she goes where she is suppose to n other times right to the livingroom.........ive tried praising her with n without treats, ive tried many ways but unfortunately i really feel she is doing it on purpose..............i think when im busy ill put her in the bathroom n when i leave she will go in the bathroom until i fix my porch for her to go outside cuz i dunno n until i clean the carpet well.
@Zelda414 (149)
• United States
6 Dec 08
one more thing i have had many animals including dogs, cats, iguana, snake, ferret, sugar glider, parakeet, chinchilla n fish............she is the smallest dog i have ever had n she is the only one who has given me problems with potty training. i love her n would never hurt, her feelings maybe yea but i really do love im just irratated with this mess other wise she is an awesome dog.
• Argentina
6 Dec 08
Oh, I never assumed you were actually harming her, when I say "physical punishment" I refer to things like the newspaper roll you mention. Yes, that might work on the short run, but eventually you might find you're just triggering a different kind of unwanted behavior. For instance: the dog tearing apart every single newspaper or magazine apart. Now, since she's five months old, she's very young. She's at the perfect age for training, especially for something like this, but, she'll need you to be consistent with the method, otherwise you'll just confuse her. For what you're telling me, it seems you've tried different approaches to the issue and I think that might be playing against you on this one. The key thing while training a dog is to remember that you can be far more stubborn than he/she is. Yes, it does require a lot of patience, but it pays off in the long run. Trust me, I've used this system with about ten dogs(Not all of them mine of course), right now I'm dealing with my own five months old and it's working. There's no such thing as a magic fix when it comes to a dog's behavior, it just takes effort. I can probably link you to some training video exercises if you want, just send me a PM. They are not mine and they are free, but they might put your hopes up if you're actually seeing someone doing this stuff instead of reading the ramblings of a dude in a forum. Rich
• United States
6 Dec 08
You're going to need to have this dog under constant supervision, or in a secure place where she cannot get into trouble when you are unable to watch her. Don't worry, she will eventually grow out of needing constant supervision, but for now, she's got to have it. The general idea is to not give her the opportunity to slip. Praise like crazy when she does it right, and ignore when she does it wrong, unless you actually catch her in the act. If you do catch her, interrupt, pick her up and move her to the correct place, then praise when she finishes. A simple "no" is a sufficient interuption. Also, whenever she slips, be sure to clean up with an enzymatic product such as Nature's Miracle. Big box pets stores will have these available. They break down the components in the pet waste so that the dog cannot smell it anymore. Any place she's pottied before will attract her back until the scent is removed. Go over any old places with this as well.
@Zelda414 (149)
• United States
6 Dec 08
Thank you very much as soon as i get some extra money i will look for those kinds of products i had a feeling i would need to do something like that to help eliminate the odor that is keeping her attracted because she keeps going in the same spot. i am 5 mths pregnant could part of her reactions be due to that? thank you so much for your advice.
@deebomb (15304)
• United States
5 Dec 08
You say that your puppy only goes to the bathroom When you leave her or your not paying attention to her. I would say that she is punishing you for leaving her and when you have other things to do. I have had my kitty do this. She went to the bathroom in my daughter-in law's bath room because her son teased her. They were living with me at the time. Now that they are gone she hasn't done it since. I have seen other dogs do the same thing. You might start keeping her in the bathroom or doggie cage when you have to leave to prevent her from pooing around the house.
@Zelda414 (149)
• United States
5 Dec 08
i just started doing that, leaving her in the bathroom when i leave but i guess i am going to have to do the same thine while im doing chores around the house too because i dunno what else i can do, thank you
1 person likes this
@deebomb (15304)
• United States
5 Dec 08
I read that your pregnant and in a wheel chair. After the baby comes she could be a real problem. She could get very jealous. Something you need to think about.
1 person likes this
@Zelda414 (149)
• United States
6 Dec 08
yes this is something i have thought about so i have played baby cries etc for her off the computer n babies around her but so far she seems fine.
@Amberina (1541)
• United States
6 Dec 08
My daughter has a small dog and what she did when she had to leave it for a couple of hours was put it in a big dog carrier with a blanket and some toys then put it in a room that was nice an quiet maybe a radio playing softly. When she came home she would go directly to it's cage and put a leash on it and take it outside to go potty. If it messed on the floor when she was home she would clean it up and then go put the dog in the kennel for awhile then take it outside. She would also take it outside immediately after it was done eating or drinking she would limit it's water and food twice a day it would get to eat and drink, she put the bowls up in between times. When the dog would be good she would reward him with treats and when it was bad she would never spank it she would spray it with water from a water bottle. Good luck most little dogs never get completely house trained but you can help them not to go on the floor if you put them in a kennel for awhile while your gone and take them outside to go about every couple of hours.
5 Dec 08
With no more information, I'd guess (and it really IS a guess - I could be very wrong) that your dog is craving attention or very nervous. If it's for attention, she has to learn that she can't have you attending to her all the time. When you turn away or leave, she gets annoyed and goes off to do something wrong, so that you pay attention to her. In this case, the best thing to do is ignore the poop (and keep the door closed!). Instead, give her attention when she does something good - reinforce the positive, not the negative. If she's anxious, that's a different matter. She may feel lonely. Are you out for extended periods of time, leaving her alone? Does she have things to do while you're gone? Experts reccommend that dogs not be left for more than 4 hours maximum. I'm more a cat person, personally, so I may be way off the mark. It'd be worth having a trawl through article sites and dog info sites to see if there's some professional advice around. Try Googling something like 'house training your puppy' or something.
1 person likes this
@Zelda414 (149)
• United States
5 Dec 08
I appreciate your quick response, to be honest i am home most of the time because i am pregnant and wheelchair bound so i dont go out except usually 2 maybe 3 times a week with my caregiver to run errands but its very rare that i am out for 4 hrs or more and she has toys to play with that she loves. she is very spoiled to say the least, she sleeps with me and i give her as much attention as possible, but i was cleaning the dishes and she did it, she pooped on my carpet ive tried ignoring it n enforcing the positive for a couple wks and nope not a change it irritates me because she will poop in the bathroom on her newspaper an literally minutes later she is pooping on my carpet.........she went to poop one time in my room n i caught her in the act before she was able n put her in the bathroom well she stayed there all day before she finally pooped...........i dont get her she gets tons of attention from me and my hubby an for her to do this is so irriatating and im pregnant i dont need to deal with that n the baby i cant thats too much on top of it im going to college online. i dunno im lost she is 5mths ive had her since she was 2mths n her brother is trained like you wouldnt believe n the only thing different i did between the two is spoiled her n not him because i wasnt keeping him.
• India
6 Dec 08
Yeah its really nice dog i think very much attracted to your home. so name it something related to home