Will you be irritated when a friend laughs at you when you fell down the stairs?

@manong05 (5027)
Philippines
October 20, 2009 9:35pm CST
I think this is something cultural. I find many westerners who find the idea unpleasant and not an ideal situation to laugh. In the Philippines many do it to express our concern. We laugh and at the same time offer our hand for assistance. It will be a different matter though if the who laughs is a person you don't know. Is this a cultural thing? Will you laugh in a situation like this?
4 people like this
19 responses
@dekada80 (388)
• Philippines
21 Oct 09
Maybe it depends on how close this friend to me is, but normally, filipinos smiles on minor accidents such as getting trip, falling on a chair or stair, if that's the case showing a smile or laugh at that person means just like telling him/her "common, you can take it...", just to boost his/her morale, but then offering him your hand at the same time.
1 person likes this
@manong05 (5027)
• Philippines
21 Oct 09
yes boosting the morale, that is. Not in any way an insult. cheers!
• Philippines
21 Oct 09
yes, i think this is something cultural. we have been used to that when u see a friend falling from a chair or falling down the stairs. that is our first reaction but we always come to the rescue, run after him down the stairs to help him. but when i fell down the stairs, people who were with me going down were terrified seeing me fast rolling down. my high heels got caught in the edge of the stairs and i came falling down. people who witnessed the incident were strangers; they didn't laugh but helped. when i got back to the office, i was telling them of the incident. we all laughed at what happened to me, narrating to them my embarrassment. i was purposely going to the doctor's clinic at that time and the fall from the stairs overtook my first agenda with the doctor. i made fun of myself as i narrated what happened. i told my office mates of the frightened look of the witnesses. i jokingly told my office mates that i could have told the witnesses who were frightened and asked what happened: this is how i go down the stairs. leave me alone! hahaha... honestly, filipinos can still laugh at their own misfortunes to lighten up things.
@manong05 (5027)
• Philippines
21 Oct 09
Yes, this is one great trait that we Filipinos have in common. We can always see humor in everything even in misfortunes. The sad thing is there are those who go the the west and take this trait with them and often they get themselves into trouble with the natives. It is a big deal for them to laugh or even smile in a situation like this. I have had sad experiences with this during my travels. Hahahaha. Experiences that are indelibly etched in my memories. enjoy life!LOL now I am actually laughing. cheers!
@manong05 (5027)
• Philippines
21 Oct 09
you're right janeycat, I think a person will definitely cry when hurt but afterwards may end up laughing. hahaha cheers!
• China
21 Oct 09
i'd like to say that it depends.if i feel down with no hurt,i will laugh loudly and treat it as a joke.but if it does hurt me a lot, maybe i will cry loudly,lol~~i don't think it matters something like embarrassment.
• United States
21 Oct 09
I think this is insealed in us from birth, kinda like the way we was made.. Kinda like the embarsing girl giggle when she farts... My little girl says I don't like when people laugh at me when I fall down because it hurts me, I only like to laugh at others when they fall.. WOW.. This one was hard to explain to her, that if you don't like it someone else may not either, I said just laugh with them, it is what I do.. I try to find all of life as Funny and Fun!!
• United States
23 Oct 09
DO I ever agree with you... Laughter is Awesome and what makes it more Wonderful is when it is Shared!!! ...
@manong05 (5027)
• Philippines
23 Oct 09
It will be a good sight if both will end up laughing. cheers!
@kkanaka (886)
• Singapore
22 Oct 09
If I see somebody falling from the stairs maybe I will be shocked and will run to help him/her but if it really looks very funny, I might not be able to hold back a giggle... but still I will run to help....
@manong05 (5027)
• Philippines
29 Oct 09
same here kknaka, most of the responses share your sentiments too. I'm sure we are all sensitive enough and know when to giggle and when not to. LOL
@mymelodake (1338)
• Philippines
29 Oct 09
To be honest, for me, it would depend on how he fell. If there's an injury involved then, I wouldn't especially if I witness it first-hand. I mean, probably we would laugh about it later, but not at that moment. I would probably laugh a bit as long as nothing bad has happened, but not at the person. At his clumsiness maybe, or how he fell. Also, I think this is more of the person and not the culture. My mom takes everything seriously and would never laugh at a similar situation, however funny it would seem to me. In my case though, I am usually a humorous person, and I easily find humor in everyday things. I think I just have that tendency. I remember a classmate of mine telling me how he watched the Return of the King twice in a row. Six hours in the cinema, and he came out with a fever, and I just laughed out loud. He wasn't offended though, and he laughed right along with me.
@manong05 (5027)
• Philippines
29 Oct 09
I picture in my mind the looks in your friend's face coming out of the cinema with a fever. I laugh too as I read your response. Between friends, I think we find many situations humurous. We don't intend to be rude or anything like that but it is something difficult to avoid. But with people we don't know, we are a little careful.
• Philippines
29 Oct 09
LOL, I just reread my response and I feel it's kinda off. To answer your question, I don't think I will be irritated as long as I don't sense anything malicious. It's OK for me if my friend laughed and helped my out, but if I feel that he was laughing because he was happy that I fell, then that would be a different story LOL!
• United States
21 Oct 09
Probably not as I would most likely be laughing even harder then said friend.
@manong05 (5027)
• Philippines
23 Oct 09
That happens to me a lot too. enjoy!
• United States
21 Oct 09
Ha... I agree with you 100%... I laugh harder than anyone else when I fall.. Cant help myself, I think its the funniest thing....
• United States
21 Oct 09
Personally, people are people, no matter what race or culture. I find laughing at someone that falls down the steps, immature, rude, and not compassionate. But, it could have been a nervous laugh, as some people do that with bad situations. I for one, would not laugh. I would be very concerned that the person did not get hurt.
@manong05 (5027)
• Philippines
29 Oct 09
Perhaps that's the right word for it, a nervous laugh. I don't believe that people will laugh out of rudeness. Most if not all will be compassionate.
@dawnald (85135)
• Shingle Springs, California
21 Oct 09
I would laugh at myself afterward if I wasn't hurt, but I wouldn't laugh at somebody else. If somebody laughed at me, I'd be much less likely to take offense if they also offered me a hand.
@manong05 (5027)
• Philippines
29 Oct 09
Yes we often laugh at ourselves especially when there is no serious injury involved. I will restrain myself to if the one who trips is someone I don't know. It is inappropriate in a situation like that.
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
22 Oct 09
Well it depends on the fall. If it is a bad fall then laughing at the person is not at all good. But if the fall is just slight and the person did not get a bad hurt then laughing is not at all offensive and maybe even the person who fell will even laugh with me. I think if I fell on the stair and it is a bad fall and somebody laughed at me I'd be really offended of course. How bad of that person who can afford to laugh at someone whose been badly hurt. I think Filipinos are basically happy people so they always find something funny in every situation. But I think we Filipinos also know which situation brings laughter and which is not.
@manong05 (5027)
• Philippines
29 Oct 09
yes, definitely, we know when to laugh and when to refrain from laughing. When a serious injury is involved, I don't think, any of us will laugh. But in any situation we are more than willing to offer our hand of assistance.
• Philippines
21 Oct 09
hello manong, I consider that an insult, i wouldn't bother talking to that person even if he/she offers help to me. that's a sign that i wouldn't trust on that person because i know, he'll be just laughing at me in the end, when am down of course
@manong05 (5027)
• Philippines
29 Oct 09
Between friends, some people do laugh but no intention of insulting or being rude but coming from someone we don't know, it may carry a different meaning.
@joygracia (1325)
• Philippines
21 Oct 09
It depends actually if he or she laughs in a sarcasm way definitely I would feel offended and get irritated but if he or she is trying to give a laugh out if his or her joke to make things easy on me then I would not be irritated at all because I know his or her intention.
@manong05 (5027)
• Philippines
23 Oct 09
Definitely, sarcastic laughs are irritating and uncalled for in a situation like that. cheers!
@Emilycyf (61)
• China
21 Oct 09
It depends. I will fell embrassed if I fall down in a crowded place, if someone laugh, I think it's offence. Sometimes it's better to be calm as if nothing has happened, anyhow, it's just a small accdient, keep a happy mood! Of course I won't laugh at others when they are in a dillema. Still remember that I was unhappy when mum and grandmother bickered when I was a child. It's worse that at that moment our neighbor just smiled and had no action. How annoying! I really hoped he could persuade them to stop quarrels. When I grow up, I understand that he was kind and he didn't know how to mediate and how to express her feeling so he keep a smile. I think people with different characters have different response.
@manong05 (5027)
• Philippines
29 Oct 09
Yes I agree with you that people have different characters and reacts differently to situations.
• United States
21 Oct 09
It think it depends on the relationship between the person that fell and the one laughing. If I'm with a friend and she falls, heck yeah I'm gonna laugh. But I'm also gonna help her up and make sure she's ok. I would fully expect my friend to laugh at me if I had fallen. If I see a stranger fall, I may snicker a little, but I try to hide it. Maybe it's a matter of not wanting to offend someone you don't know. Which is rather ironic to me. Shouldn't you be more concerned about offending the people you do know? Rather interesting.
@manong05 (5027)
• Philippines
21 Oct 09
Yes, between friends, it really doesn't matter. Just a little careful with someone we don't really know, we might get violent reactions. LOL enjoy!
21 Oct 09
It depends on whether I'm seriously injured or not. If I'm unhurt, or have just minor scrapes or bruises, then I'd have no problem with them laughing, I'd likely be laughing along with them. If any bones are broken or have other major injuries, then yes laughing would be inappropriate at the time -- however, afterwards when all is said and done, there's nothing wrong with having a laugh looking back on it.
@manong05 (5027)
• Philippines
29 Oct 09
Yes, you are right. If a serious injury is involved then laughing in any form will be inappropriate.
@Hatley (163781)
• Garden Grove, California
21 Oct 09
nanong0 5 yes indeed I would be more than irritated, I would want to know the friend's block off. There is nothing in the least funny about falling down the stairs. One could get badly injured doing that. Only an idiot who had little common sense would think that funny. I would never laugh at someone else who fell down the stairs either. it is not funny it is dangerous.
@manong05 (5027)
• Philippines
21 Oct 09
hello Hatley, thanks! I have always thought that this is something cultural. But our laughs don't actually mean an insult or lack of concern much more idiotic responses. Neither do we think that this is funny. It's actually a sign of concern. A morale boosting mechanism. Strange, isn't it. It is obvious in the 1st and 3rd comments, that this is a cultural thing. If I am in the US, I will surely not do it, I might get myself into trouble. thanks for the input. enjoy life!
@amybrezik (2118)
• United States
21 Oct 09
For me it would probably depend on the situation. If I fell and wasn't hurt, I would probably laugh with my friend. I have done it before. You can't be offended, it happens to everyone. I fell in the parking garage at my work because of heels I had on, and all I could do was laugh about it. However, if I fell down the stairs and was hurt I probably would be offended if my friend was laughing.
@manong05 (5027)
• Philippines
21 Oct 09
Yes, it really depends on the situation and though it is a normal and quick reaction, it must be done with sensitivity as well. enjoy life!
@Gongfuboy (130)
• China
21 Oct 09
Yes, you're right, it's certainly relevant to the different cultures. In China, if my friend tumbles down the stairs, I would laugh at him after I come up giving him a hand. However, if I saw other stranger falling down the stairs, I would be vocal in laugh. That sounds queer, but it's the fact. I also think other Chinese would do the same things like me. In western countries, I don't know what they will do in such case, because I never saw such things in a western country. If they act as you describe, I do believe it relate to different cultures.
@manong05 (5027)
• Philippines
21 Oct 09
Asians have many things in common. That's right Gongfuboy. Yes, never do that in western countries, they react to things differently. The bottom line is, we both show concerns, but not in the same way. cheers!
@tarsonm (27)
• United States
21 Oct 09
It depends if they asked if you were alright first before they started to laugh...because then they show that they are concerned with your well being and the fact that you are alright they feel comfortable with you for you to understand that it was funny since you were alright if you were hurt and they laughed i was taught that that is rude.
@manong05 (5027)
• Philippines
21 Oct 09
Laughing after noticing that the person is really hurt is a different matter. Yes, that is rude. cheers!
• United States
11 Nov 09
I dislike it when someone laughs at me when I trip. However I can't blame them, as often times I do the same. I always offer a hand and ask if they're okay before I laugh though, because I don't want them to get offended.