Major Differences Between Cats & Dogs

United States
February 11, 2010 9:01am CST
Hi there! I have to ask for some advice when it comes to having cats and dogs. I've had animals my entire life, and my husband and I currently have four cats and a rabbit. I've been getting an inkling for a dog lately, although I'm a huge cat person. I'm trying to figure out both the financial and other aspects of having a dog versus a cat. Although I've had dogs before, it was back before I was married and living with my parents, so they took care of everything. Basically, I don't want to look over any details of having a dog. I know that they require more care than a cat...they must be let in, let out, trained if they haven't been already, bathed, and obviously I would need to buy a bed and toys for the dog as I only have cat stuff. I know I need either a fence in the backyard or one of those lines you can put up with a lead so they can roam. Vet care and flea treatments are givens. My question: am I missing anything? I remember working at a pet store and having to sell dog licenses, but I never remembered signing up any of our own dogs for licenses. Is that necessary for all dogs? For those of you whom have both cats and dogs, have any of you had any problems? At my parent's house we had ten cats and two dogs and they were mostly dismissal or even lovable to one another, depending on any random two animals. What are your experiences? Thanks, everyone. I want to make sure I think everything through before I take a ride down to the shelter.
8 responses
@savypat (20216)
• United States
11 Feb 10
Dog license is required in most places in the USA and with that comes shot requirements. I have both dogs and cats and I don't think there is much difference in Vet fees. Dogs must be trained, you can do this yourself, attend a class or have yur dog trained. Both are rewarding pets to have.
• Atlantic City, New Jersey
11 Feb 10
Hi savypat, I have 4 cats and two dogs (pitbulls) and I can tell you the main difference that see besides the obvious is that cats tend to be more self serviant and dogs tend to want to please their owners. Cats tend to want their owners to please them it seems...lol. As far as vet fees goes my dogs are WAY more expensive than my cats because of their upkeep on their shots (rabies etc.). My dogs are also full breed dogs, which tend to have more problems than mixed breeds, or so I am told by my vet. Both my dogs suffer from skin conditions (much like humans) and both break out in hives when stressed out. The dogs are also more maintenance because they need to be walked daily. Just letting them out in the yard really isn't doing anything for them. They need an activity like walking to exhaust their energy and give them a sense a being, while cats are content with laying around the house all day once they are mature.
• United States
11 Feb 10
savypat, thanks for the clarification on dog licenses. I wasn't sure if it was just pure breeds or all dogs that needed a license. warmweather, I've had lots of animals in my life...horses, cats, dogs, chickens, all species of rodents, many types of fish, birds, and reptiles...and wouldn't you know most of the annual health care bills went to the dogs. The dogs were the most expensive health care wise, even more so than the horses during racing season. Cats seem untouchable for the most part. I definitely have to agree with you that dogs are more expensive...at least, from my experience!
@jwfarrimond (4473)
12 Feb 10
I think that you need to think about how your cats will react to a dog coming into the house. If they are not used to living with a dog, you might have a problem with that. It's bad enough introducing a new cat to the resident cats, I'd hate to think how my lot would react to my bringing a dog into the house, they'd probably leave home en mass!
1 person likes this
• United States
13 Feb 10
That's definitely my number one priority...they have lived with dogs before (a Shihz-Poo and a Rottweiler), and whenever there were problems it was the dog's doing. My oldest cat gets kind of angry whenever we'd adopt a new kitten, I think mostly out of jealousy, but he always becomes the "mother hen" within a few days. My biggest concern would be bringing a dog into the house and realizing the hard feelings won't go away...it wouldn't be a good situation for the cats or the dog.
@maximax8 (31053)
• United Kingdom
11 Feb 10
I had cats in my family when I was a child. I find cats like to do their own thing like have fuss when they want it. They can be loving to their owner and guests. Many cats like to go out of doors. Cats can do their toilet outside or in a cat litter tray. I now have two dogs. They are both miniature poodles. They are called Secret and Magic. They go out for walks with me on their leads. They need to be brushed and combed. A dog groomer visits my home to cut their coats every six to eight weeks. She is cutting Magic's fur right now. Secret will be next. Cats and dogs both have expensive vet care. Going away on vacation someone must look after the cats or dogs. My dogs miss me when I go off traveling. My mom kindly looks after them when I go on a trip overseas. A dog needs a life long commitment and it demanding to look after. A cat is a big commitment too. I love animals so very much.
• United States
11 Feb 10
The independence of cats versus the dependency of dogs is definitely the number one difference in my eyes. Grooming is the one thing I thought about first when thinking about getting a dog...they simply don't groom themselves very well. I do remember taking the dogs to the vet more often than the cats during the first eighteen years of my life while living with my parents--despite the fact we had ten to fourteen cats at any given time (both barn cats and indoor) and only up to two dogs. With the cats the largest thing we had to deal with was fleas and surgery on an ear cyst. With dogs, we had cyst problems, worms, joint health issues, and had to eventually put both dogs on medications. In my experience the dogs had much more health care costs involved.
• Philippines
13 Feb 10
cats tend to be independent.they would eat and sleep the day away.dogs are more social.they want to be where their owner is.dogs require exercise;cats don't.dogs require human interaction.some cats aren't really social.they will only come to owners when they are hungry.
@jeannames (303)
• Turkey
13 Feb 10
I don' t like cat. Because cat is ungrateful. Lacks feelings of fidelity. you fed cat and then can go out.
@13tyates (1606)
• United States
11 Feb 10
Cats and dogs have very different personalities! Just like cats needing shots so will dogs. Some places require papers on the dog. Of course you will need a fence to keep it in a certain area. You need to take the dog on walks almost every day! Having a dog can be rewarding but like you I find myself being a cat person!
1 person likes this
• United States
11 Feb 10
I am full-heartedly a cat person as well. I told my husband just the other day, though...between him, our four cats, and our rabbit, I still have too much energy for all of them combined. Personally I'm always very hyper and energetic and I tend to wear everyone, including all of our animals, out. I told him I'd been thinking of a dog because of the walks and attention required...just to help keep me occupied.
@jwfarrimond (4473)
12 Feb 10
I think that you need to think about how your cats will react to a dog coming into the house. If they are not used to living with a dog, you might have a problem with that. It's bad enough introducing a new cat to the resident cats, I'd hate to think how my lot would react to my bringing a dog into the house, they'd probably leave home en mass!
• Canada
13 Feb 10
I am just going by my experience but here goes. I grew up with a VERY large and lovable Irish Wolfhound lab mix. My mother was a stay at home mom and all 4 of us in the family took part in the dogs discipline. The major factors that you have to consider when having a dog is time that you have to spend with him/her. If you and whoever you are living with are out of the house for 6-10 hours a day then a dog would not be a good companion choice. Dogs are almost like having children in that in order to be raised properlly need alot of your time, love and training. Cats are independant and can suit themselves for long periods of time where as dogs can't. Large breeds especially need lots of walking and even the ability to get to an open field or beach a few times a month to let them run free. If you get a puppy, someone will have to be home with him often enough to potty train him properly. This is usually not such a difficult step. Chewing however is a different matter and puppies will chew anything and everything so make sure to supply toys for him to chew and to be consistent in punishing him with a firm no, time out in a kennel etc if he is chewing your shoes or furniture and always replace the shoe or item with his chew toy so that he gets what he is aloud to chew and not aloud to chew. Make sure that you chose a food that is healthy, it may be on the more expensive side, but make sure you are not feeding him low cost crap that alot of the pet stores dole out. If you get a medium to long hair dog make sure that you brush him often because it will be more comfortable for him and easier on your furniture lol. A puppy needs puppy food only for the first part of his life, I can't remember how long until you transition him to adult food so ask a vet. Also you should mildly introduce the cats to the dog at first because they will be anxious especially around a puppy and it needs to be a gradual introduction in order for them to establish a healthy relationship with each other. The cats are going to be ok in the basement or in a room of your chosing for a few days and you can alternate with the dog, giving them short times to meet and sniff each other out. You might hear some people suggest that you should brush your dogs teeth but we never did that with our dog and he did not have any dental problems. Some dogs will though. Be prepared for large vet bills if something does go wrong. The bigger the dog, the bigger the bill actually. And most of all, be prepared to commit. I don't know what kind of pet owner you are but you sound conciencious and that you love your pets so I wouldn't think that you would be one of those people that get a puppy and once it's grown out of it's "cuteness" so to speak are done with it. Most dogs can live up to 20 years so realize like cats actually that a dog will be a lifetime commitment. Lastly, adopt from a shelter, humane society, a place that NEEDS good owners to rescue animals. Stay away from pet stores. Good luck to you. I hope that you find a beautiful dog that will have a long and happy life with you. Cheers!