So what do you think of JLo and Steven Tyler

Philippines
January 21, 2011 7:45am CST
Are you an Idol fan? Have you seen the premiere episodes of AI 10? How'd you like the new judges so far? They're no Simon and Paula but these two have something to offer different. What do you think of them? Personally I think the show is less fun without Simon and his quips especially with the not-so-talented people who audition for the show. It's just different. I miss him and his bad attitude. And I guess I've grown accustomed to Kara (and Ellen) too. But now they're also gone. AI seems different. But Im keeping my hopes up that the two new judges will deliver. Let's go AI!
1 person likes this
7 responses
@franne32 (694)
• Philippines
21 Jan 11
Yeah, Simon is entertaining but we can't judge their way of judging until the middle of the season.
1 person likes this
@inkyuboz (1392)
• Mandaluyong City, Philippines
21 Jan 11
Yeah, it feels a little different without Simon "The Scowl" Cowell, but the addition of these two new judges is a welcome change. Mr. Tyler has a very commanding persona, maybe because of his rockstar roots, but he's also very genuine and amiable when he likes a contestant. I still haven't warmed up to J.Lo yet but all in all she's alright. I still don't like Randy Jackson, I hope he's the one who went away and they retained Simon or Ellen.
@Hatley (163781)
• Garden Grove, California
22 Jan 11
hi kaycharmedMD I just saw one episode but I have always admired JLo and StevenTyler seems to have good stage prescence. I miss the sarcasm of Simon and the fun as he gave the awful singers who did not realize they were completely todn deaf a nice sarcastic word or two or six or ten. and he was honest as these people ' were so bad it made you wonder why they even tried. People in the 'television audience are not fools and they could tell a really great singer from a tone deaf squeaky non singer. So the good ones got the applause the lousy ones did not.
@ybong007 (6643)
• Philippines
22 Jan 11
I missed AI, I have not been able to watch full episodes after david cook's winning. I think without Simon the show seems boring lets just hope that the new judges will be able to do a good job. Besides, it's really the talent that people are after and not the judges.
@lady1993 (27225)
• Philippines
22 Jan 11
I'm definitely an Idol fan- I just love shows that showcase talents- and auditions too. I love the new judges, maybe even better than the past ones. Although I still miss Kara and Simon. I hope the show gets better.
@doggydimon (1369)
• Philippines
22 Jan 11
Actually, we were watching American Idol the other day. All of us not a fan of that show. But somehow, we got stuck to watching it because of the new judges and the new contestants. We just keep laughing and laughing both with the contestants and the judges.
@entengo (70)
• United States
21 Jan 11
There good and the show looks a lot better without them