Goldman Sachs: House Spending Cuts Will Hurt Economic Growth

@gladys46 (1205)
United States
March 1, 2011 10:39am CST
ABC News' Jonathan Karl reports: A "leaked" confidential new report prepared by Goldman Sachs for its clients says spending cuts passed by the House of Reps. would be a drag on the economy, cutting economic growth by about two (2) percent of GDP. Here's the Report: . Proposals to cut federal spending, the possibility of a government shutdown, and the escallated debate over state employee compensation has increased interest in the effect of fiscal policy on growth, after last year's fiscal package briefly neutralized the expected drag from federal fiscal policy. . Federal spending cuts deserve the most attention. They are the most likely of these issues to occur, and could have the largest magnitude. The assumption we incorparated into our recently revised budget estimates -- discretionary spending cuts of $25bn and $50bn below the CBO baseline for FY2011 and FY2012 respectively --would shave nearly one percentage point off the annualized rate of real GDP growth in Q2, but would fade quickly with a negligible effect on growth by year-end. . The related risk of a temporary federal government shutdown could also lead to a fiscal drag on growth, but this appears to be a lower probability scenario. We estimate that each week that the federal government is shut down would reduce federal spending by around $8bn, and could reduce real GDP growth by as much as 0.8 pp at an annualized rate in the quarter it occurred, but would provide a lift to growth in the following quarter as federal activity returned to the previous level. . The policies that several state governments are debating related to state employee compensation and organization appear to have -- at least in the short term -- little potential macroeconomic effect. We assume that state governments will cut spending or raise taxes no more than necessary to balance their budgets. This amount will be determined by the level of tax receipts available to pay for spending, not political negotiations. Fiscal drag is quickly reemerging as a focus, only a couple of months after an agreement to extend tax cuts and unemployment benefits appeared to have neutralized most of the drag from federal fiscal policy for most of 2011. We see federal spending cuts as the most important near-term risk. The possibility of a government shutdown is a significant but less likely factor, while the debate over state employee compensation seems unlikely to have a meaningful near-term macroeconomic effect .... ____ This "leaaked" report, reportedly written by Goldman's economist Alec Phillips goes on to suggest that even those more modest spending cuts will cut economic growth rates by one percent of GDP. This is reportedly a GOLDMAN SACHS' economist ... consider the source!! But, is this what republican leaders are meaning to do, cause the economic growth to sputter thereby blaming President Obama in 2012? This article by reporter Johanthan Karl may be read further @ ABC News, dated 2/23/11
1 person likes this
3 responses
@sam3m1 (190)
• United States
1 Mar 11
i think it's pretty clear that the gop's plan for 2012 is eliminate the unions to prevent them from helping the democrats. secondly, by making moves to slow the economy even more, they hope to convince the great american public that under obama the economy tanked, so we should elect republicans. how despicable can a group of politicians be? slow the economy, cost millions of us jobs, homes, health care just to guarantee election so they can reward their wealthy supporters. it's a great country, no?
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
1 Mar 11
It's pretty clear that the unions are nothing but a money laundering scheme. Obama puts billions in the union leaders' pockets, they in turn take much of that and put it in the war chests of democrats. Nice little scam they got going there... and of course, the left is too complicate to care.
@artistry (4152)
• United States
1 Mar 11
Well sam3m1, you have got it totally right. That is the plan, when Mitch Mc Connell said "one term" they will do whatever it takes to get Obama out of the White House. They are despicable to the core and anyone who supports them and thinks that the GOP has their best interests at heart is surely under a delusion. Most will wind up on the other side of the fence wondering where the yellow went. The GOP wants their greedy way and want most of the country to suffer. They don't care. Thank you. Cheers.
1 person likes this
@gladys46 (1205)
• United States
1 Mar 11
ParaTed, can you prove that President Obama "puts billions in the union leaders' pockets" ?? That's a might tall acusation!! Seems to me that unions are the only folks who actually care about America's working people ... seems they have effectively made certain that working people have a say in their working conditions and their own abilities to work for a living wage. Just think about it, Scott Walker is said to be operating against the Labor Laws by not allowing worker representatives to negotiate vis a vis collective bargaining. Who is he (Walker) to circumvent labor laws with impunity??
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
1 Mar 11
On the short term, maybe, but the debt and deficits have to be covered someday, this trillion dollar deficit spending can't be maintained. It is killing our nation, but don't let that bother you.
@gladys46 (1205)
• United States
1 Mar 11
ParaTed, I'll ask you once more ... whatever happened to the good old GOP spin about "deficits DON'T MATTER" ???? Is it that deficits don't matter when "conservatives" are in charge of the WH and the House?? Please, don't ... don't say again that dems had control of the House for what ... 2 1/2 yrs under GW, after all the horrific economic damages were already done, after all the systemic de-regulations were on-going and all hell was just waiting to brake loose, after people like Clarence Thomas, etc. were stacked on the nation's highest court?? What??
1 person likes this
@Taskr36 (13963)
• United States
1 Mar 11
Why are you holding Ted responsible for some crap that you THINK some GOP people said? Is he a spokesman for the GOP? Is he even a Republican? Are you too lazy to deal with what HE has said and done so you're just attacking him over crap other people MIGHT have said?
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
2 Mar 11
Actually, Gladys you have to keep that in the context of the time and circumstance. Cheney was reacting to charges from the left that a $400 billion dollar deficit in a single budget was outrageous. Cheney was defending the spending. The thing is, it wasn't just the left that considered that an outrageous deficit. Fiscal conservatives protested the spending also. Fiscal conservatives are still outraged by the runaway spending, but for some reason the lefties who feigned so much outrage over $400 billion celebrate multi trillion dollar deficit spending. Yes, Prs. Bush proved he was no real conservative when it came to spending, but no president before Obama ever even thought of a budget of over a trillion in deficit spending. So don't talk to me about waste if you aren't willing to hold your guy to the same standard. And Taskr has a point, I can't be a spokesman for the GOP, since not only am I not a member, I denounced the RNC years ago.
@artistry (4152)
• United States
1 Mar 11
....Hi there gladys, If anyone would like to research it, I haven't but I have heard that during the Great Depression those in charge decided to cut back on spending and when they did it made the whole thing worse so that was the story. Which is why the administration after deliberting has decided we need to spend to get out of this. The deficit is a long term problem, but short term we have to stand the economy up, get jobs moving before we think about cutting back on spending. But if you assess the situation the GOP has put together a plan to deliberately stall job growth so that they can blame it on President Obama for having not increased jobs. It is so very clear, Scott Walker in Wisconsin with his union busting tactics, Ohio's Kasich, Florida, they are all together in their evil efforts to destroy and conquer. Let's see what happens. I remember the parable about digging a ditch for your enemy and falling in it yourself. Carry on folks, we shall see who has the last laugh. Take it easy.