Would you change your kid/s family name when you marry again?

By Jane
@jaiho2009 (39142)
Philippines
April 13, 2011 4:13am CST
This question caught my attention from other mylotter's asking me if i will let my kids us the family name of my future husband (if i will marry again...no plan yet) WOMEN: Would you let your second husband adopt your kid/s from first marriage and use his family name. Would you let your kids use your second husband's family name? Or will you let your kids decide for it. MEN: Would you adopt legally your wife's kid/s from first marriage? Would you let your wife's kids (from first marriage) to use your family name? My answer is,NO...let my kids use their father's name,i won't changed their family name. If ever i will marry again...my husband to be should respect my decision. How about you dear mylotters..? Share your views and opinion. Have a great day everyone Jai- now firm and not confused
9 people like this
36 responses
• Philippines
13 Apr 11
hi j! well, you do know i haven't been married yet and so far no kids that i know of. hehe but supposing... if i happened to have been married before and had kids, and then plan to marry again... in regards to adoption and using family names, i would consult everyone who is concerned and decide as a family. this means the decision has to be formed between the kids, the second husband and myself. i believe that regardless of assuming the family name or not, being a true family lies not in the name but in the love that binds. i would assume the second husband's name after the marriage, no question about that but as for my kids (if i have) i would let them decide if they are of the age that can voice out an opinion, on whether they want to retain their biological father's name or assume the name of the new father who is willing to adopt them. no matter what the age of the kids, i would respect their decision. if the kids happen to be too young to decide, then i'd let the matter sit and take it up at a more appropriate time when they reached a certain age that they could decide for themselves. on a similar note, i had an ex-bf who happened to have an adopted kid. if we had been married, i would have been willing to adopt his kid as our own. i'm glad you are no longer confused. hehe is this question somewhat a reflection of a real situation closer to home? hehe
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
13 Apr 11
hello myles, No comment...but then again...i want to hear bells ringing
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
13 Apr 11
@bhaby, don't worry..you will be the flowerpost
• Philippines
13 Apr 11
@ myles and jaiho, December bride is also fine or whatever month as long as i will be a flower girl
@shibham (16977)
• India
13 Apr 11
Hi didi.. Why you have hidden the name of that mylotter? But i know. I am still confused for it regarding my novel. But yes, i shall put my name after that kid and if he has any problem after become younger, then he has the complete right provided by me to change his name. I have no problem. Anyway, atleast 13 becomes lucky again.
2 people like this
@shibham (16977)
• India
13 Apr 11
No you did not miss it. here is the link.. http://www.mylot.com/w/discussions/2511449.aspx
1 person likes this
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
13 Apr 11
ohh..thanks for the link... i can't find her in your profile page...that's why i asks and your long absence makes me forget as well
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
13 Apr 11
dear bhai, did i missed number 12? i am sure i haven't seen lady 12
@joodzki6 (596)
• Philippines
14 Apr 11
I don't think so. That is not right. Though, you separated with husband, it is still not right to take away his right as a father to your kids, that's reality and you can't take that away from him or from anybody else. Do not include the kids to your problem as husband and wife. Let the children feel the love from their real father. Thank you.
2 people like this
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
14 Apr 11
hello joodzki, If you happen to read my topic back...my answer is NO. I would NEVER change my kids family name. Some woman change their kids name once they marry again...i am not sure about their reason that is why i posted this topic to know their reasons for changing their kids name. You are right,let the kids alone be out of the picture when the wife and husband had problem...the kids remain to have the rights to use their biological father's name. And the biological father has the right to his children... thanks for your response and have a great day
• United States
14 Apr 11
It all matters on the situation. My cousin's father left when she was young. Handed over his legal rights and left/ When her mother remarried 5 years later she asked to change her name and not only was it done but my new uncle adopted her as well. That was 30 years ago and all has been good. My cousins second husband recently adopted her daughter from a previous abusive marriage (he will be in jail until she is well into her 30's for another crime and lost custody) and they are happy. For myself it would matter how old and if they wanted to. Mine have a good father and I do not think if anything happen between us that he would ever not see them. SO I would think not. For us anyway.
2 people like this
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
14 Apr 11
hello OL, Your cousin's case is a different one and i can see all the valid reason for doing that. If i might be in the same shoes with your cousin,i will not have a second thought of changing my kids name. So,it's a case to case basis. At least i find an answer here that is reasonable enough to changed a family name. thanks for your response and have a great day
@Renhard (3471)
• Jamaica
13 Apr 11
I have no problem adopting my wife's children but I see it as just disrespectful if you change their name from their rightful father. I would never ever think to myself to actually change their name. Eve if they wanted it to change I still wouldnt agree with it. Though I would want me and my wife to have kids of our own though and not just adopted. I would want my blood in the family as well. Well that is how I see things through my eyes. Others might see what I am saying as different but that is just me. I guess I just love being fair. And that is the way how life is suppose to be, just fair and no deviation otherwise.
2 people like this
• United States
13 Apr 11
We all have our reasons and yours are valid my friend. Somehow I feel that changing the name means almost as if they did not have an existence in their biological family tree. Hi Renhard
1 person likes this
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
14 Apr 11
hello Renhard, Your reason id valid enough. You respect the kids father,and you also wish to be respected,that the good point in here. I am sure the kids father will have same mind as your's,he's happy that you never changed his kids name after your name. That's one good reason why i don't want my kids family name to be changed. Respect to the father and also to my in-laws who are always been good and supportive to me and my kids. thanks for your response and have a good day
• United States
13 Apr 11
Hi jaiho Personally I would not change the name of my child(ren) for any reason outside of course if their biological father had some sort of background dangerous and or murder spree related incidents. But really I would not because my concern for my child is to make sure they understand the roots of his/her own family roots. I know their are some who may opt to do this and I can certainly can respect it but as for me I feel that it something I could do.
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
14 Apr 11
hello hwg, Precisely,it would be easier for the kids to trace their roots and also less explanation. Unlike when we change their names,there would be some confusion and explanation needed (not to mention other people who will asks...though we don't owe any explanation to them eh) We have our personal reason,they have their reason to change... Thanks for your response and have a great day
@Renhard (3471)
• Jamaica
13 Apr 11
Oh yes and that too. I guess I wasnt thinking about that one. The only way I would change it is if it was for some sort of protection for them. But otherwise to change it for name sake i would see as just disrespectful.
1 person likes this
• United States
14 Apr 11
It depends . If the kids had a great connection with their natural father , I would let them keep hisa name. But if their dad has cut them off, he doesn't see them . He acts like he doesn't care and my fiance treats them like his own. They have a great connection , then They would change their names.
1 person likes this
• United States
14 Apr 11
You too. I must add , if my kids were over the age of 13 , it would be up to them , not me. If you are old enough to have a bar/bat mitzvah, then you are old enough to decide.
1 person likes this
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
14 Apr 11
hello sarah, Your reason is a good example why some mothers changed their kids name and use the step-dad's name. Like the other mylotters here who also give another good reason why her aunt change the kids name after the step-dad... i am sure there is always a good reason why some mothers changed their kids names. I do respect each reason,for i might changed my kids name also if i had a very good reason for doing so. thanks for your response and have a great weekend ahead
1 person likes this
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
14 Apr 11
yes,when kids are old enough to decide for themselves,that would be another consideration too...we can not stop them,but give advice. see you around friend
1 person likes this
@dpk262006 (58675)
• Delhi, India
19 Apr 11
Hi Jai! It is a hypothetical situation for me. If it happens, I would not change the original names of the adopted kids but I could add my surname (if am remarrying with a woman with kids) to kids' original names.
1 person likes this
@dpk262006 (58675)
• Delhi, India
19 Apr 11
This way they can keep their old and new identities. Say a kid's name was Ramesh Sharma (Sharma is the surname here) and now he needs to add another surname say Malhotra, so his name will be written as Ramesh Sharma Malhotra and after sometimes people will start knowing him by his new name.
1 person likes this
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
19 Apr 11
a better idea... but i don't think this can be done legally.. because,there will be confusion who's name to be added in the "father's name section" i usually use my maiden name so my old friends can recognize me easier... but with legal documents and signatures...i have to use my husband family name...
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
19 Apr 11
hello dpk, Wait dear,you will not going to change the kids family name,but you will add your name (uhmnn...) i never heard such situation...aint that more complicated and confusing? But,good to know that you are willing to adopt the kids (if ever)
@Sreekala (34312)
• India
13 Apr 11
Dear sister, I can’t think about a second marriage. I know I can’t predict my future and the destiny but I am sure I won’t marry again. I am happy with my kids. I just can’t think any other person rule on my kids. To be very frank, sometimes I am annoyed if their father scolds them rudely. I won’t say anything infront of kids because I know it may ruin them so I will tell him, you were so rude, privately. So here the questions are not applicable for me.
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
13 Apr 11
hello dear sis I just thought of this topic when dear Shiby asks upon responding to his topic lady no.13. I don't have any plan too...but even if given a chance,i won't consider changing my kids family name for few reasons. Good to see you once again dear sis...hope no more boredom
1 person likes this
• Mexico
13 Apr 11
Hi jaiho: If I were in you case, I let the kids decide if the want my family name in teh future but that's their decision. But in my opion they should have their real father name unless he'd be a terrible father. He is one of the most important person on a kids life so that's the way things should be. ALVARO
2 people like this
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
14 Apr 11
hello Alvaro, You got it my friend. The kids father is the most important person in their lives,so retaining the kids fathers name will keep the bond and respect between. But if the kid/s prefer or decide to change their family name after the step-dad...there must a good reason why the kid/s have to do it. Then,i will also respect my kid/s decision. thanks for your response and for always sharing your opinion have a great day
@thesids (22180)
• Bhubaneswar, India
13 Apr 11
Hi jai didi Not quite sure. First because I will Not have a second marriage. Why should I? But let me assume, as your question needs this assumption - Then, it depends on the legal issues of so many things. If the kids are less than the legal age, maybe, I and my second wife will think and talk to decide. If they are grown ups, the kids will decide. Not us. The legal angles have to be considered because there might be some inheritance, or even other issues that I am unable to think of right now.
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
13 Apr 11
dear sids I even think about it "inheritance"...not my primary reason. But i believed that my kids needs to maintain that name (biological father) for many reasons. Respect to my in-laws (they are very good people) and keeping a good relationship with my in-laws and my ex-hus relatives who never changed and been good to me always. Now,with inheritance,it won't be a problem...there are legal matters to settle that. it's actually settled ... Anyway,i really appreciate your views ...you made me smile with your intro " First because I will Not have a second marriage. Why should I?" happy Wednesday dear bhai
1 person likes this
14 Apr 11
for me if the kids wanted to change their name then i dont think i would mind. i hate my ex as he treated me really badly and verbally, mentally and physically abused me and isnt worthy of having kids.
1 person likes this
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
14 Apr 11
hello titchy, This is one good reason if you consider changing your kid's name. If the father is not caring about his kids,then better change the kids name if your second husband is willing to adopt the kids. But if the kids are big enough to understand things,you must talk with this matter to them also. If the kids agrees...then go on. i am sorry to hear that you've been into such abuses...i wish you all the luck on your next relationship thanks for sharing your story and have a great day
14 Apr 11
its not that he is a bad dad, i just hate him and i dont think he is right to be a dad as i have witnessed things and noone believes me.
1 person likes this
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
15 Apr 11
you have all the rights to decide what's best for your kids my friend...and i believed that mother's knows best
• United States
13 Apr 11
It all depends on lots of things, For one how good your kids get a long with their step father. You should sit them down and ask them what they think of it, unless they are way too small. Its a tough discussion, Get his opinion too and see what he wants to do. I think it be easier to keep the kids names the same, but if this guy is really really great especially with the kids and is gonna be a positive role model for there lives and be there for them and you see this as a long term thing then Yeah I can see why you would want to change names.
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
13 Apr 11
hello ial, Well,i have all the good reason to keep my kids family name. My in-laws are one of a few good in-laws and so with their immediate relatives. With due respect i will keep their name for my kids. I am not sure about the other's opinion. You are right,you pointed out good reason in here. This esp when the kids are smaller,and can not decide for themselves. i do appreciate your views here and thanks for participating have a great day always
1 person likes this
• United States
13 Apr 11
I am on my second (and last) marriage. My kids have a different name than I do because I took my current husbands last name. I have 2 boys and 1 girl. I would not change my kids last name for a few reasons. 1. Their father is still in their lives, and besides our troubles and divorce, he loves them very much. Frankly the thought never crossed my mind. 2. My boys are the only boys to carry on that name. My ex has only sisters and no one else, in a long line of "name" has that last name anymore. That would be sad. 3. I was adopted by my mothers 2nd husband and I have 6 sisters. None of us are carrying on the name. Now the downside. 1. I have a different last name than my kids. Hard at school sometimes but in this day and age it is getting to be more common. At one school I had to show that I was the biological parent. But most just accept, and I think it happens alot now. 2. I will always get mail for Mrs."kids last name" just because people assume it is. Really is doesn't bother me, I have kids with my ex-husband and that isn't a bad thing. What was bad was everything else. But he is a semi-decent father compared to what some have and his family is really good to my kids. Sometimes it is hard to have a different last name but now we are used to it for the most part.
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
14 Apr 11
hello synderblog, It's not a big deal having different surname with our kids these days,it's already common and people who are open minded don't need any explanation. But of course,there are still few people who are not open with this kind of situation and seems to be judgmental (don't bother). You have the best reason for not changing your 2 sons family name. It is very important since their father is the only one who carries their family name,so,it is a must that you shouldn't change your son's names. It's fine with girl's since ,once they married,their family name will changed too. Thanks for your response and have a great day
@SViswan (12051)
• India
19 Apr 11
Honestly, I'll have to cross that bridge when (and IF) I come to it. It all depends on WHY I am re-marrying...does it have anything to do with abuse (directed at me or the kids)....and the equation between my new husband and my children. IN fact, if they are very young, I would wait till they are older and mature enough to decide if they want to take on my new husband's name or stick to their biological father's surname. I think it's for them to choose and not me. I got a chance to choose their first names...but the surname I think should be their choice. And whatever the decision,I feel as adults we should be able to respect it. As Shakespeare said, what's in a name? The person and the relationship is more important than a name, isn't it? Btw, my kids do not have any surname....just an initial (which happens to be the first letter of their father's name AND also the first letter of MY surname which is my father's name:)) There has been a lot of confusion based on that point...especially since I have not changed my surname after marriage (it is a lot of hassle that my husband didn't want to go through).
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
25 Apr 11
Thanks for the BR!
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
19 Apr 11
hello SV, What's in a name really. But some names do have great impacts.(forget politics and kingdoms) It's the relationships that matters...i agree,that is why,if ever i got the chance to marry again,i won't change my kids family name...it's all because of relationship that my kids and my in-laws had (so with their cousins and relatives on their father's side) If anyone prefer to change,they have reasons for doing so. Like how few responders in this topic sighting good reason why they prefer to change their kids family name. It's an individual choice,whether to change or not their family names. It is regardless of legalities,everyone has their freewill . thanks for your response and have a good day
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
14 Apr 11
First I think I will not be in that kind of situation. But for the sake of discussion I would say changing the name is uncalled for because it shows lack of respect to the father of the children. Maybe some women do that because they find the husband not respectable at all andnot worthy of being the father of their children but they should remember that the father is still the father no matter what.
1 person likes this
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
14 Apr 11
hello salonga, It really sounds disrespect to the biological father. But as i've read other mylotters responses,there is one who posted a very valid reason why her aunt changed her kids name and named after the step-dad. It's 30 years ago and her aunt was never wrong for doing it... So,i won't judge people who choose to change their kids name...there have good reason for doing it. Thanks for your response and have a great weekend ahead
• United States
18 Apr 11
Not all fathers deserve that respect. In the States a woman cannot change her kids names unless the father has his rights terminated either by the courts or by choice. Many kids in this situation feel the would like to have the same name as the man later in their lives who actually raised them and really was that father they respect.
2 people like this
@alottodo (3056)
• Australia
14 Apr 11
No I would not change my children's name...its their father's name and I think is not fair on the child...but then that is just my opinion!
1 person likes this
@alottodo (3056)
• Australia
15 Apr 11
Thank you...great weekend to you too.
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
14 Apr 11
hello alottodo, Everyone's opinion is open here my friend. This what make mylot a very friendly site and a helpful site for people asking or seeking advice/suggestion and opinions. Like other mylotters who responded on my topic,not everyone has the same opinion and views and i respect each one of you. It's good to share and know other ideas and opinion... I do respect your opinion,as i also don't want to change my kids name. have a great weekend ahead
@aerous (13434)
• Philippines
14 Apr 11
It is not necessary to change your kids surname once you marry again....it seems like you are totally giving up your respect to your first husband and also to your children.It was a so selfish decision to change your kids surname.
1 person likes this
@aerous (13434)
• Philippines
23 Apr 11
Your decision is at your discretion because that really the best choice you made.
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
14 Apr 11
hello aerous, My answer is NO...for whatever reason it's my decision not to changed my kids family name. But i am not judging people who let their second husband adopt their kids legally (from first marriage) and used the step-dad name. They also has valid reason to do that. Thanks for your participation here my friend and hope that you are doing fine
@Ladyslipper (1327)
• Philippines
13 May 11
I would let my child continue using his father's name. However, just in case my husband and I get separated (which I vow not to happen if I could) I don't have plans of having another relationship or getting into another marriage. I'm advocating for violence against children and as always the person who abuse and kill them are their mother's new partner or their stepfather. It's so heartbreaking. I love my children with all my heart and I'm willing to sacrifice everything for them. They are my life and happiness. Honestly, I love them more than I love my husband. I believe that it should always be the case because mostly the reason children die of abuse is because mothers know the abuse is happening and yet maybe because of their love for their partner which is crazy they don't do something to stop it and even participate sometimes in the abuse. It's so sad. :( Mothers should always be strong for their children especially the infants and toddlers. They are defenseless and voiceless. They are just dependent on adults in everything.
1 person likes this
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
14 May 11
hello lady, I understand what you feel cause i am also a mother and my kids are my life. I am separated and i always consider my kids feelings,and that's one reason why i am not into any relationship. I have to consider my kids first and foremost before myself or anyone. but i also nothing against those women who re-marry,it's their choice they just need to be careful choosing whom to lived again and should consider their kids safety and welfare. thanks for your response and have a great weekend
• Philippines
13 Apr 11
Personally, No. I will let my kids keep their father's name.
1 person likes this
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
13 Apr 11
hello astreadido, I respect your reasons...i guess we have same reasons and views in this manner thanks for dropping by and have a great day
@iCeeLuSh (187)
• Philippines
13 Apr 11
Same here I will let my kids keep their father's name. Just my two cents and just my personal opinion :)