I think I'm too gentle. Does that make me ineffective?

Pondering..by graur codrin - Sometimes we ponder over whether our approach is the right approach.
India
November 25, 2011 1:09pm CST
I realized this after some reflection for a bit of time recently. While there is nothing to feel bad about this as a personal attribute or trait, there are situations in which it may be misplaced. Like for example in career and day to day dealings. While I hear praises for being considerate with colleagues at work, they may not be delivering on expecting deadlines for which I am made primarily responsible. I may be appraised by my management as not being effective. Similarly, in interpersonal dealings in society, many service vendors that I have to deal with may be gleefully enjoying my soft & liberal outlook. Do you cautiously ensure that your personal trait doesn't hinder your effectiveness? How do people perceive you as? What is your intrinsic nature? Please share. Lets discuss the pros & cons of being gentle & considerate.
3 people like this
12 responses
@ravisivan (14079)
• India
26 Nov 11
No. Sometimes we may feel that others take advantage of it. If we get over that then we may be able to function well. I am perceived as a liberal and considerate person. I follow rules for attending office but when it comes to giving benefit to employees I use to be liberal. good day.
• India
26 Nov 11
I think firm but gentle & understanding may be a good balance for dealing with people when discharging our own responsibilities. Glad you share some common personal attributes with mine.
@ravisivan (14079)
• India
26 Nov 11
Thanks for sharing common views and all your help. Are you watching test match now. India needs 9 runs to win. Do you think India will win?
• India
26 Nov 11
No I was not. I was anticipating some good things for myself too, which I have not received yet. . Hopefully, I will be rewarded for the gentleness too.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
30 Nov 11
The biggest thing for me is that I tend to be way too soft with my children. The result of this is that they try to walk all over me all the time. This isn't a good thing and I really should have realized sooner that I couldn't be both a parent and friend to my children while they are small. However, this is something that I'm working on making better as I'm spending more time with the kids.
• India
1 Dec 11
dorann: I had typed a response yesterday but the connection kept playing spoilsport & I see now that it's not posted. I was saying that we must realize very early that there is a fine balance required between control & permissiveness. Kids do need gentle handling but at the same time, some impression must get their minds that we can be firm without harming their real well being. Because it makes reconciliation with drastic change difficult for both.
@ravisivan (14079)
• India
2 Dec 11
With children we should be strict parents -- we must be keeping a distance from them and from others also so that we are not taken for granted. We must not be appearing to be strict or rude but still maintain relations and enforce regularity. good day.
12 Jan 12
To be strict is good as well is necessary.But I think it is good to be close to children. Sometimes just affection and friendship becomes necessary.After all parents are the ones they know since their early childhood.They expect love and an ideal they can follow, in their parents.Simply love them as they will always need it. Sometimes keeping distance might cause lack of connectivity from their side.They might also feel akward to discuss anything with you.They need a vent to open up.They might want to say it to you or share something with you.
• Philippines
14 Feb 12
Consequence for being gentle is that some people tend to become abusive and let things be done by you even if it's already beyond your job. Another cons is that you are being misinterpreted as an ineffective employee or person even if you are doing your best though. For me you should take things in balance you should monitor yourself if you are already being too much in both sides of the matter.
• India
15 Feb 12
That's a good view, Panther. Thanks for valuable insight!
@Bluedoll (16774)
• Canada
25 Nov 11
If we look at ourselves and we see character traits that are good ones, I see no disadvantage in that unless they are mismanaged. Not sure if that is the right word to use but what I mean if there is a deadline and you communicate this and make it understood that there are consequences then I do not see an issue. Only if the character trait prohibits the message. Shyness for example might prevent the information from being delivered but gentleness need not affect communication negatively. People that are used to only one style of management that is aggressive might not get it but that would be their confusion. Perhaps being repetitive, asking for confirmation as to what the deadline means might fix that confusion while still maintaining, creditability with gentleness and that would be showing consideration?
@Bluedoll (16774)
• Canada
26 Nov 11
This is so funny – I misread the question simply because once again as this often happens, the question was not really a question but a statement. The real questions came at the end of the description. I think you have made your mind up and are not puzzled on this trait, nor need advice, nor looking for a different perspective? You are convinced this human character trait is effective and merely seeking discussion about it. Correct? I think gentleness is a wonderful quality to be in possession of. The only problem I see with gentleness is sometimes lack of motivation, if the situation demands a more aggressive approach. Now this demand might actually come from a situation or from subordinates who feel since they do not have a task 'manager' can do just about anything they please. They do not see rules being enforced because they interrupt the softness of the gentleness to mean weakness.
1 person likes this
• India
26 Nov 11
Bluedoll: You are right, I wasn't really perplexed but wanted to study how other myLotters feel about it & wanted some discussion on the pros & cons. Thanks for pondering further and clarifying. Your sentence: They do not see rules being enforced because they interrupt the softness.... Edit: They do not see rules being enforced because they interpret the softness....
• India
26 Nov 11
I get your point that communication about what is expected of people has to be amply clear/unambiguous. You are also pointing out that gentleness should not mean being vague about specifying deliverable. Yet, in monitoring how things are progressing, someone like me will get alongside to try & understand whereas some others, the so called task masters may feign ruthlessness. I see that as a lack of involvement + lack of conviction in themselves. I see things realistically and therefore don't get unreasonable with my subordinates. Your dissection of the issue is good.
@HosmanF (92)
• Belgium
4 Dec 11
Good evening dear mylloter friend , first of all i care to say that i consider myself to have the same carachter as yourself , i tend to be a verry polite person , my mother had gaved me a verry strict and full of polite manners , and for that when i used to be a teenager the macho guyz used to either pick often on me either take advantage of my goodnness , because besides my polite character i tend to be a rather naive person when it comes to be asking for my help , i always tend to see if i cann ease up people weights ( figure of speach ) , so because of these "flaws" manny people used to take advantage of me , untill i decided that no more , now i still continue to be gentile and polite , but only with people that truly desirve to be helped and that truly need , people who wont take advantage , even if those people are verry few i believe i am here to help those people and try to mark their lifes in a good way , so that them in return will someday help another person who will be in a bad situation and trully need someones shoulder and helping hand, so whatever people may thing of me i trully am not ashamed and will not change been this way . I wish you a trully great evening dear friend. Hosman...
• India
5 Dec 11
Hello Hosman. I think we should not be deterred by such provocation by the bullies and remain true to our basic nature. Good to know your commitment to continue to help people who are in need and to just remain who you are. Have good time friend.
• Philippines
26 Nov 11
I share your concerns because I am similar to you're methods of dealing with people. I would like to commend you on being considerate and I guess understanding on other party's capabilities. Maintain such attitude. However, it is not wrong that once in a while,you applyw force to show authority. This will remind the people around you that there's still that line that they must not cross. Being too gentle or too friendly can sometimes lead to abuse of your kindness. Drawing the line, demanding,exerting force of authority is helpful.
@ravisivan (14079)
• India
26 Nov 11
welcome to mylot. i have seen people adopting tough style also producing results. But my strategy is to be liberal. I feel 550/50 Task/people will be ideal. But difficult to adopt. good day.
• India
26 Nov 11
One comfort I have assessed by close observation is that-fortunately-people know it that I can be quite firm without affecting their morale. I wish the people to whom I am accountable do not get me wrong while assessing me. Good to get your view here.
@lilaclady (28207)
• Australia
28 Nov 11
I think I can be classed as too soft, and because of this I think sometimes people find it easy to take advantage of me a little, but being a bit of a people pleaser I feel so long as the people I care about are happy then I am happy too.
• India
28 Nov 11
That's a very positive attitude. Have you had to undergo any major issues when people around took liberties? Have you never felt that , boy, its time I changed that a bit?
@mr_pearl (5018)
• India
25 Nov 11
Hello there... I am somewhat like you... It is a good thing, and many appreciate it... But boy, we have got to be careful when it comes to important issues, where a little stubbornness is highly necessary... I am like you, soft spoken and kind to everyone. But whenever I feel that someone is taking advantage of it, I throw away my kindness cloths and put on a stubborn mask... Being kind is good, but don't let anyone take advantage of that... Good Luck!
• India
26 Nov 11
That's quite right. Being watchful about kindness and consideration being exploited is important. I think it stems from confidence and when such discretion is exercised firmly, people do get the message.
@snowy22315 (169973)
• United States
14 Mar 16
I am often gentle, but now always just remember it says in the bible, "The meek shall inherit the earth"
@jpso138 (7851)
• Philippines
26 Nov 11
Well I guess handling people is really difficult. There are different kinds of people and each of them have different attitude. If you are to considerate, it may also backfire in you since people might abuse you for such. If you are to strict, then it can also be bad. I guess the best thing to do is be a fair person. Give credit where is due and provide punishment if needed. The important thing is to respect each one of them and most likely whether you are strict people will understand. I have been handling people before, I do not know whether I am good at handling people or not. But I have always noted that no matter what, people will always abuse you if you are to considerate.
@ravisivan (14079)
• India
2 Dec 11
I suggest middle order approach. I also agree with you. we should not very strict or very lenient. good day.
@sjvg1976 (41131)
• Delhi, India
26 Nov 11
Hello Pushhyarag2000, I do make a balance i always don't remain liberal i need to be strict sometime.I understand it well that when you are labeled as gentle and generousness your subordinates don't listen to you and you start losing control on them. On daily dealings too people take you lightly if they see you liberal or soft all the time and many don't hesitate to take advantage of yours many times.
• India
26 Nov 11
The emphasis on guarding against people taking me lightly as well as deriving undue advantage is right. The only comfort is that the same cannot be generalized for everyone across the board-there are a few black sheep that misguide others-yeah, one has to be watchful & not remain a mute spectator. I am happy I'm conscious of the pitfalls and remain on guard. Thanks for sharing,
@aimhrea (181)
• Philippines
25 Nov 11
i think you've already found your answer. as you said, there are time when being such may be misplaced. i myself am a firm believer of the adage that there's a time and place for everything. also, it's when things are too much that cause problems. being gentle i think does not necessarily equate to or efficacy of a person, i have a professor that is foremost a gentle soul. people think there would be a skating rink in hell first before she would loose her temper or even raise her voice. But. she is always firm and conducts herself with such authority and intelligence that she only has to raise her brow to get the lot of us moving--and i have rebel tendencies lol.
• India
26 Nov 11
You are right. I do get firm when situation warrants. But I see no reason getting unreasonable & pretending to be tough like those who like themselves called task masters. I work closely with colleagues which makes me realize & appreciate their efforts in the normal course. When I see exceptions, I get firm & clear.