The Dog Whisperer

United States
January 21, 2007 1:34pm CST
Does anyone else watch this program? I absolutely love to watch him work with an animal that no one else seems to be able to control. I also love his humerous explanations about the animals. I don't think there is another human being that can mimic a happy dog than Ceasar Milan. I wish he could come to Georgia though and teach had to potty train my dachsund. I have been doing this for years with all different breeds of dogs but this little Bella has got me stumped!!! I haven't bought his book yet but that is on my list of things to do. He certainly trains humans well!
5 people like this
36 responses
• Canada
22 Jan 07
This is a wonderful discussion. I haven't watched this program, but I am aware of who Caesar is. Some people complain that his training methods are too harsh, but I have learned while training our dogs over the years, that if you watch dogs, or puppies, in a pack situation, or a litter situation with the mother dog, that the alpha dog is sometimes quite harsh while dealing with the more subordinate members of the pack. Dogs understand dog language, and dog behavior. They are dogs, not human beings. If you try to understand their ways, and deal with them in their way, and try to emulate some of their behaviors for training purposes, you will have much better success. For example...a mother dog will grab the puppy by the neck scruff, and give it a quick shake, to stop a behavior she doesn't like. Try that, it doesn't hurt the dog, but it lets him know who is boss. That is only one example. She will also, grab the puppy by the neck scruff, and deck it, make it lie down, to subdue it. You can do that to. Grab it, and force it down quickly, on it's side. None of these things hurt, and the dog gets to know who's boss, and soon you don't have to do it at all. You simply have to establish your authority in a forcefully kind way. A trained dog is a happier dog, because he knows his boundaries. It's the same as teaching your children to grow up and function as a responsible adult in our society. Nobody, dogs or kids want to be yelled at all the time.
• Canada
22 Jan 07
Exactly right! We should try to understand them, not try to make them understand us. Human beings are so self serving and egotistical. Why should the dog try to figure us out. We can't even figure us out. LOL !
3 people like this
• United States
22 Jan 07
Dogs are no humans, that is correct. However, humans are not dogs, either! It's impossible for us to act like an "alpha dog." A dog knows how another dog feels. You don't know how much pressure to apply when pushing a pup to the ground. I'm sorry, but there ARE way more humane ways to train your dog. ESPECIALLY a puppy! That's why this topic gets me a little upset. A PUPPY does NOT need harsh training methods. If you get a puppy, there are other great methods you can use to train your dog. If you get a dog from a shelter who has a shakey past, it is even MORE IMPERITIVE that you get the help of a professional animal behavioralist, instead of just listening to a guy on TV. Every dog is different. You do not have to establish authority in a forceful way. I never yell at my dog. I give him one look or command, and he knows what's going on. I've never forced him to do anything. He does it because he's been trained to and knows he gets more freedom when he behaves. Teaching children in a forceful way does not work, it will not work on your dog either! Ceasar's methods work great for dogs who have had terrible pasts, but for love's sake...if you get a puppy, don't listen to Ceasar.
1 person likes this
• United States
22 Jan 07
You said this very well. A lot of his teachings are very familiar to what you said you did. Dogs are not humans and respond better when we communicate with them in their own language!
3 people like this
• Canada
22 Jan 07
Another thing that is very useful and works wonders when trying to train a dog, is to NEVER let it go first. Do not let it go through a doorway first, never let it walk in front of you when on leash, things like that. Again, it's about letting the dog know who goes first. The Boss.
3 people like this
• United States
22 Jan 07
A better way to train this is to make your pup sit before he gets ANYTHING that he wants. It's especially useful if it's the only trick he knows! This helps a lot with anything. He wants to be pet - sit first. Wants to go out side - sit first. Wants to be fed - sit first. It'll make your dog never jump on people, either! Also, instead of training stay, just train sit, and then a release command. So, if you want to walk out the door first, tell your dog "Sit" and then once the door is open and you're through, say "Okay" or whatever release word you want to use, and your dog will know that he has to remain sitting (or downing) until you give the release cue. It takes some practice, but I have found this invaluable, especially with little dogs who love to run out doors!
2 people like this
• United States
22 Jan 07
These are all good ideas. Thank you both for responding.
• United States
22 Jan 07
These are all good points. Thank you for the information.
@sandie61 (2359)
• United States
22 Jan 07
I`ve never heard of this show. I would like to see it though. can you tell me what station, time and day its on? thanks.
@sandie61 (2359)
• United States
22 Jan 07
thanks. I will look for it.
1 person likes this
• United States
22 Jan 07
It is on National Geograpic here and not sure if it is Tuesday or Wednesday night, but one of those. You can also see previous shows at other times on that same channel. I think you will like it.
@stailgate (2363)
• United States
22 Jan 07
I do watch this show and you are right, he is amazing!!! There are some dogs that they show at the start and I am just thinking, why don't they just get rid of that dog!! and then at the end, it is so well behaved, and it is just a total turn around. It really is amazing how he has that gift!!
2 people like this
• United States
22 Jan 07
He is amazing.
@crazynurse (7482)
• United States
22 Jan 07
I haven't seen the show. I am really not sure how I have missed it. We are dog lovers in our home. However, we have a wire-fox terrier who is giving us a fit. He was great as a puppy, until the fourth of july. He was in the process of coming in the door from outdoors and a neighbor's bottle rocket went off. He got spoofed and ran under a bed. He would not come out and growled and attempted to attack if we went near the door of the bedroom. It was many hours before he came out. Now, anytime he is loose in teh house (out of his old training cage) he runs to that bed, goes under and growls and attmpets to bite! We have to keep him in his old training cage and only let him out in the den with us when the doors to the den are all closed. It is so terrible. I have asked the vet for help and he just shrugs his shoulders. I will certainly start watching this show...as it sounds like it will be very beneficial! Thanks for posting about it. On what network is it aired ?
2 people like this
@uath13 (8192)
• United States
22 Jan 07
I have to respect the guy. He takes what trainers have been saying for years and puts it out there in an understandable and entertaining method. When I tried to explain my training techniques to my wife it was near impossible for me to get the point across. She watched his show and came back " SO THATS WHAT YOU'VE BEEN DOING". I have to say I have some of the most well behaved hounds around ( see my profile for pics ). Here's a good spot to tell what happened this weekend with my largest, Voden. It was time for his yearly heartworm check. We headed to the local vets office where frankly he dwarfs anything else in there. When we arrived we went in and sat for a bit. He sat perfectly beside me until I got up. We went around and introduced ourselves to the other dogs and owners. Most of the dogs just did the usual snif and howdy, one puppy seemed to take a liking to Voden. None of them showed any fear toward him even though most of them could have easily fit in his mouth. We went into the exam room, the only place where we have any problem at all ( he hates standing on the slick metal table, no traction ). The doctor came in, drew blood, did the tests & gave him 3 shots. Voden didn't even flinch. The doc was impressed, most dogs strugle or snap at him. On the way out we stoped at the counter. While there takin care of the bill another person brought in their boxer. This was a hyper uncontrolled dog. Immediatly the other dogs got defensive and snarling. The little puppy from earlier came and hid beside Voden. The Boxers owner saw Voden sitting there calmly and said she wished hers was so well behaved. About this time her dog decided to jump at Voden. Voden without hardly showing any interest did this neat little shoulder thrust technique of his. He slightly leans on another dog then suddenly thrusts out his shoulder. The boxer slid and stumbled about 3 feet across the floor, then laid there quietly on his side having been put in his place. The boxer remained there until his owner took him outside. Afterwords I got several questions about how I'd gotten him so well behaved. As we left we met the now much calmer boxer and his owner outside and everything was ok. We talked for a bit and I suggested she watch some of Ceasars Shows for pointers( She odviously wasn't the dominant one ). I commonly get into such conversations and often make that recomendation. I've got plenty more stories but I think that one was long winded enough.
• United States
22 Jan 07
While I respect the previous persons opinion I have to agree with you. Ceasar shows us that a dog has to live like a dog and not like a human. If we want our animals to be well behaved and others to enjoy being around them there has to be control. I feel it is the same as raising a child. You have rules and ways of enforcing those to benefit the child and so also with the animal. I think the older methods are more reliable with dogs and children. If it has worked for many years why would you try to change it. To crate my puppy and let her lay in her one urine for even a little bit is not something I am willing to do so I will continue to look to Ceasar for answers to my dog problems. Thank you for a great story! I will go on your site and look at your dog pictures.
1 person likes this
• United States
22 Jan 07
What a beautiful animal. You can tell by his stance he is well trained. Good job for you!
1 person likes this
@uath13 (8192)
• United States
22 Jan 07
Oh and as for the last person response about Ceasar being too harsh, What do they suggest? a newspaper? Spraying the dog with water? You have to consider that they have to condense everything into a short segment of the show. He expects the owner to contine the work and returns later for an update. Quatelmon sounds like one of those trainers who can only get the dog to respond with treats. Do this , have a biscut, do that have a biscut. Most people go to those type and the dogs flunk out. There's never anything harsh on his show.
2 people like this
@missybal (4490)
• United States
22 Jan 07
Have you tried every time your dog goes in the house you leave rub their nose in it (only #1 of course) and then you take them outside leave them on a chain and leave them out there for a good long time. That's how I trained my puppy. Anyways I love that show and study it well in order to know how to train my dogs myself. Right now I don't have one because I only live in an apartment and don't have the room at the moment to get a new dog.
2 people like this
• United States
22 Jan 07
Yep, I have done this with her. She is just a stubborn little thing. She is getting a little better. I guess I will just have to keep working with her. I try to take her out at least every hour or two but sometimes get busy and that is when she tinkles in the house. Thanks for the advice. I also love this show and I keep watching hoping someone will have this problem so I can she what he says to do.
1 person likes this
@kishchun (497)
• Oman
22 Jan 07
i love dogs, but don't have one right now because i live in a flat now, and not in a bungalow. the problem is, yes, you guessed it right, i don't know how to potty train a dog! hm... do let me know on which channel this show is on, the time and the name of the show, please! i should definitely enjoy watching this show, though am not sure if we have this aired in this part of the world. hope it is.
2 people like this
• United States
22 Jan 07
It is on National Geographic channel here and at different times but if you have it, you should be able to catch it at about 8:00 in the evening.
1 person likes this
@cripfemme (7698)
• United States
22 Jan 07
I watch it, too. And I love it myself. I usually watch it while writing at some rediculous morning hour like 2 AM.
• United States
22 Jan 07
Are you a writer? I don't stay up quite that late but he is on at several different times. I too enjoy his shows.
1 person likes this
@hellboi (661)
• Philippines
22 Jan 07
i've always been eager to watch this show but unfortunately the skeds are not in tune w/ my free time. all i do is browse through the natgeo website and read, makes me more eager to watch though
2 people like this
• United States
22 Jan 07
I hope you will get a chance to watch it. You will really enjoy it.
1 person likes this
22 Jan 07
I have heard of this program from a friend of mine in the States. It sounds like something that would help me with Kai. He is our welfare pooch with a few hangups. It's really too bad we don't get this program here in Scotland. I'll have to see if my friend can tape it for me.
2 people like this
• United States
22 Jan 07
Yes do that if you can. He is particularly fond of pets who have been adopted with previous hangups. He also has a site I think on the internet and a new book out, so maybe you can find the book. You would really enjoy the shows though.
1 person likes this
• United States
22 Jan 07
He is quite awesome to watch. Though I don't think it's always as easy as they make it look on tv... there is plenty of tape on the cutting room floor I am sure. Not to minimized his ability, because it is amazing. Just so many people say... wow, he does that in 5 mins..... I think a little of that is for tv. I'm going to have to go out and get his book now too.... sounds quite interesting.
2 people like this
• United States
22 Jan 07
You are right it is not always so easy. In fact on some of his shows he tells the owners that it may take several weeks or months for them to completely finish a task but consistency is the key then he goes back several weeks later for a follow-up to see how the dog and owner are doing. I am going to have to get the book too.
• United States
22 Jan 07
I love watching that show and I think that people that bash his way of working with animals really don't understand it. They claim he is too primitive with his behavior modifications, and I think whatever works, works.
2 people like this
• United States
22 Jan 07
So true.
• Philippines
22 Jan 07
The Dog Whisperer of Ceasar Milan is such an informative program. i happen to download the full series, where i learned even celebrities had problems taming their favorite pet. in the season, Oprah's dog, a cockier spaniel, had separation anxiety whenever she left the house and dog being inside and left behind. i also have applied Ceasar Milan's ways on how to train dogs. and it's very effective... two thumbs up for Ceasar.
• United States
22 Jan 07
I agree, two thumbs up for Ceasar.
1 person likes this
@shellyrios (1212)
• United States
22 Jan 07
Yes we watch it and have used most of the very beneficial and uselful tips for our own dog at home and feel it has helped us tremendously without having to pay for a trainer or dog school. He's awesome!
2 people like this
• United States
22 Jan 07
I agree, he is awesome and have used several of the helpful hints with my own dogs.
1 person likes this
@gabs8513 (48686)
• United Kingdom
21 Jan 07
Funny enough my Friend was just telling me about this Program tonight I have actually never seen it but I might have to look out for it as it sounds good
2 people like this
• United States
21 Jan 07
If you like dogs you will enjoy this show. He is a truely amazing person. He is also humerous even though I don't think he really is trying to be. He is just mimicing a dogs posture or action!
@MrNiceGuy (4141)
• United States
21 Jan 07
That guy is amazing. Some times its almost unbelievable. He literally spends 5 minutes with some dogs and completely cures their behavior problems. Its amazing how much he understands dogs and knows how to get them to react to his training. I don't think I've ever seen a dog that he couldn't fix, even if it took him a few weeks to do it. His little "psst" noise he makes is pretty powerful huh? Try it yourself on a dog and they immediately give you their attention.
2 people like this
• United States
21 Jan 07
I think he is pretty amazing too. It is like he has the ability to communicate with the animal. I dont' think I have seen him fail with a dog yet. Even Oprah Winfrey uses him with her dogs and several other stars so he must be good!!
1 person likes this
21 Jan 07
He is great, I'm a small woman with a soft voice. My Rotts would look at me and walk away when I told them to do something. I learned from that show how to project confidence and I tell ya when I tell my Rotts something now they can't do it fast enough! I knew what I was doing in training.... except not confident they would obey. We also have a 2yo lab that was abused and is now deaf because of it, it's often hard to dicipline him because he can't hear you. we've started doing the "bite" with the hand and he sure knows what that means! He can be a bit pushy in wanting to be the first to get love, and then he will keep pushing the other 3 dogs away, we will give him a little "bite" and he backs off and gives the other dogs their turn. The problem with our 4th dog is she is so submissive, when you walk up to her she lays down. She's still a pup so I'm hoping she'll outgrow this, it makes it difficult when trying to get her in the car (she weighs 95lbs), etc. That's the only thing I haven't seen him cover...
2 people like this
• United States
22 Jan 07
Boy you have learned a lot! Rotts can be a challenge but can be some of the best pets if the owners know how to handle them and it sounds like you have it under control. I have begun to use the walking technique. We live in the country and we felt that just letting them out and letting them run was enough, but I learned they need this walking on the leash.
1 person likes this
• United States
21 Jan 07
I watch the show all the time! The training methods he uses really do work. I've used them with training my Jack russell who really was quite the problem dog when we first got him. I also worked at a doggie daycare where we used Ceasar's methods and it was quite useful there as well. He came to Massachusetts to do a lecture but I couldn't get tickets to go see him. I haven't read the book yet either.
• United States
21 Jan 07
I do love to watch his programs. We have a Jack Russell also. They are quite active. She minds us really well but she loves to roll rocks, balls, limbs, logs whatever she can find. My husband thinks there is no other like her, although he secretly smooches on our new little dauchsund when he thinks I am not looking. I was blessed to marry someone who loves animals as much as I do.
1 person likes this
• United States
21 Jan 07
I've seen his show a few times, its interesting to watch his methods with the dogs.
2 people like this
• United States
21 Jan 07
Yes it is interesting and educational for all of us dog lovers.
1 person likes this