Which do you prefer?

United States
March 23, 2007 6:30am CST
Which Charmed do you prefer? Charmed with Pru? Or Charmed with Paige? Let me know.
4 people like this
22 responses
@andrika (386)
• Indonesia
24 Mar 07
i watch charm when there still prue in it. why did she have to leave?
• United States
24 Mar 07
She didn't have to leave. She choose to leave. They didn't make her. She wanted to go and do bigger things.
@kwenge (2493)
• Kenya
9 Oct 07
I prefer Pru, because in the first place she is the one who made me glued to the program because of how she used to do things and also her beauty really striked. I was really terrified when she left the show but now am getting along and its becoming better.
• Malaysia
10 May 07
hmm..i think i prefer charmed with paige. no particular reason, maybe it's because i've forgotten what it's like when pru was in it hehe..but both are good, charmed was one of my favourite series ever :D
@010878 (303)
• Indonesia
9 May 07
I think I like it better with Paige because she's funny and sometimes goofy and unlike Prue she doesn't have quite strong confidence in herself. And she's so white and pale like a china doll. She's definitely my fave Halliwell
• United States
21 Apr 07
I think I prefer the Charmed with Paige. I think Paige has more fight in her than Prue. Paige actually lives through more episodes than Prue and gets married as well.
14 Apr 07
I prefered Charmed with Paige, it's a far more relaxed version of Charmed in which Piper was the predominant sister. Plus there were elements in the Paige related episodes which actually made me laugh, where as when it came to Prue's leadership and appearances the series was incredibly strict and seldom made me laugh.
@jinggay46 (263)
• Philippines
7 Apr 07
hmm.. that's quite hard to decide because i like watching charmed. but come to think of it, watching charmed with paige is much more exciting.
• Belgium
7 Apr 07
normally the serie would have go on with prue and not paige!! If shannen hadn't left off course... I really don't like paige that much...the serie isn't just the same whitout prue!!!!
@m_5ugar (1013)
• Malaysia
3 Apr 07
prefer prue, because she is the older sister and she can protect piper and phoebe from the devil
• Philippines
2 Apr 07
Charmed with PRUE of course. The show shows more of their sisterhood than Charmed with Paige.
@melody1011 (1664)
• India
31 Mar 07
The ones with paige were definetely better. With Prue around and being the big sister, most of the risks were taken by her. But i did not want her to die., However when paige was taken on, there seemed to be more balance of power even though piper was not the oldest. So yeah, i prefer the episodes with paige.
• United States
28 Mar 07
I love all the charmed shows but I have to say that I like the character of Paige much better that I did Pru. I think it has more to do with the actress that played Pru. She was a wonderful character but I just don't care for that actress. Never have.
@pangeacat (619)
• United States
27 Mar 07
Personally, I prefer Pru. But, I understand that they could no longer work with Shannon Dougherty and decided not to just hire someone who kind of looked like her to continue the same character. Unfortunately, for me ~ the show went downhill when they killed off Pru.
• United States
26 Mar 07
charmed with paige. I thought Pru was kind of bossy. I really like Paige's personality.
• United States
26 Mar 07
my fav. was with both of them. each one bring diffenrt powers and skills to hte sisters
@Suze05 (480)
• United States
24 Mar 07
I don't know.. I can never decide. I loved Pru and I loved the episodes with her..but Paige has more powers, and with Pru gone that made Piper the oldest sister and made her in charge..and the most powerful. I think bringing Paige in gave the show more options with her being half whitelighter. The show would have been sooo much different without her.. so many things never would have been able to happen. Having Paige and her ability to orb and stuff saved them so many times...they didn't have that with Pru. So I guess I like the Paige ones a little better but I'm sad Pru had to die. :O))
@azilanohj (286)
• Philippines
24 Mar 07
Charmed with Pru. i have fun watching it before but now i have no time or maybe i get disappointed when they let her out in the show. and also there's something wrong in the show because as i remember, when the sister went to the future Pru is still alive and pheobe has two children. i don't know how will they gonna do that now.
• Philippines
23 Mar 07
I prefer Paige, she's a redhead which is cool and she does more things than Pru could.
• United States
23 Mar 07
Well, I just like Charmed. I have to say I like the ones with Paige better. Maybe because they are the newer episodes. I like Paige's look a little better than Pru. I don't get to watch all of them though.
@gegegelay (934)
• Philippines
23 Mar 07
Having Prue in the first few seasons really made Charmed a big hit. But when she left, many were curious why she had to leave. At first I thought she was pregant or something and she was getting married. But, I think the reason was because she really wanted to leave. I don't really know the issue about it, it just sucks that she had to leave. The three had connection with each other. I saw their compatibility as sisters as if they were really sisters in real life. When Paige entered the picture, the series still made it big and it somehow returned to its normal status, even much better I think, because of Paige's powers and the improvement of the story. But I still don't see the connection between the three of them. I still see Paige as their close relative, like a cousin for instance. I don't know.. Prue, Piper and Phoebe had a really special bond with one another.