sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

3 Wheel Prams - Are they really safe?  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 87/100. Gemmygirl1 (2628)   ranked 94 out of 3,703 in had children 5 years ago

I have been thinking about this for a while now, i never bought one coz i thought they were just ugly. I know they are popular with many people especially people who are very active.
My question is, are these 3 wheeled prams really as safe as the manufacturers claim they are?
I only ask because in the past 5 months, there have been 2 deaths here in South Australia alone.
The first was a woman who was talking with her 5 month old son when they pram tipped over & slid in to the river - her son drowned.
The second was less than a month ago, a grandmother was walking her 10 month old granddaughter when, just like the first one, the pram tipped over & slid in to the river (they were on level concrete footpaths so that wasn't the cause)- they got the baby out but she died later in hospital due to lack of oxygen to the brain (i believe).
Does anyone out there in myLot land have one of these 3 wheeler prams & what are your thoughts on them? How safe are they really?
I'd like to hear from people who have one of these prams or from someone who knows someone who uses one - just to get an idea on whether they should be banned coz the fact they tipped over so easily tells me they're far from safe.


3 Wheeled Prams
 

had children
sponsors
OSHA Safety Compliance
Industry Leader: 56 Years Providing Training, Software, Guides& More
www.JJKeller.com

OSHA and Workplace Safety
Let Our On-site Consultants Establish Best Safety Practices
www.JJKellerServices.com

Baby Shower Gifts
Playtex® Drop-Ins® Nurser Gift Set Perfect Starter Kit for Mom-to-be.
PlaytexBaby.com/7Essentials

maddysmommy (10969) response was accepted on 5/1/2007.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  safety, 3 wheel prams, prams, babies, baby safety
 
1. myLot reputation of 94/100. sedel1027 (12989)   ranked 5 out of 3,703 in had children   5 years ago

Here in the US the only people I have ever seen using these are people who are exercising (jogging with their babies in storllers0> I tried to do some research on deaths here and didn't find any. I think if they were really dangerous they would not be on the market. I don't know how they are priced by you, but here all of the strollers with three wheels are really expensive.


myLot reputation of 87/100. Gemmygirl1 (2628)   ranked 94 out of 3,703 in had children  5 years ago

They're expensive here too - the first drowning by the tipping 3 wheeler was being pushed by a model i think so she was out doing her exercising - she stopped to answer her phone & the pram just tipped over.
They're trying to have them taken off the market, think about it this way - have you ever known a 4 wheeled pram to tip over sideways without help?
Thanks for your thoughts on this though!

OSHA Safety Compliance Industry Leader: 56 Years Providing Training, Software, Guides & More  www.JJKeller.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 99/100. ElusiveButterfly (9602)   ranked 530 out of 3,703 in had children   5 years ago

Well, from the stories you have listed here I would not ever purchase one of these for my grandbabies. I remember the old carriages that enclosed the baby. They could lay down in the carriage. The top flipped up to protect the baby from the elements and you could attach a mesh screen to keep the bugs out. The baby was comfortable and there was room to put a diaper bag, etc. There was a foot brake on the wheel to stop the wheels from turning. I wish they would bring the older carriages back.

OSHA and Workplace Safety Let Our On-site Consultants Establish Best Safety Practices  www.JJKellerServices.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 94/100. maddysmommy (10969)   ranked 1 out of 3,703 in had children   5 years ago

My son had one when he was a baby and it was a gift from my inlaws. I found them pretty good to use, easy to maneuver when out and about (sometimes difficult when in a mall or store as they are a little big). It's also heavy to lift when putting it into the boot or on a bus, so I also had a stroller on hand too. I would not have bought one for myself though because they are expensive.

My son hasn't had any problems with "tipping" over or falling out of the seat. We always made sure the seat belt was around him and secure. I think they were more suited for out-door type areas, rugged roads and being in Samoa (with bad roads/footpaths), it was well suited. A few of my friends had them (because it was the "in" thing to buy) and even though they looked good, they mostly complained about it being too big and heavy.

I found ours to be safe and I only used it to take him for walks and when we went shopping.


myLot reputation of 87/100. Gemmygirl1 (2628)   ranked 94 out of 3,703 in had children  5 years ago

Oh no, you misunderstood :)
The babies didn't fall out of the seat, they were strapped in, the stroller tipped over with the babies secured in the seat & the whole pram with baby slid in to the river.
They were out & about on jogging paths - the parent of the first death was a model of some kind & he jogged along that path regularly.
So, yeah, it wasn't the lack of restraints, it was that the prams just tipped too easily & took the babies with them when they slid.
It's very sad.


myLot reputation of 94/100. maddysmommy (10969)   ranked 1 out of 3,703 in had children  5 years ago

Oh I'm sorry! that is very sad!

Baby Shower Gifts Playtex® Drop-Ins® Nurser Gift Set Perfect Starter Kit for Mom-to-be.  PlaytexBaby.com/7Essentials
 
4. myLot reputation of 98/100. fawcey (425)   ranked 1,067 out of 3,703 in had children   5 years ago

I read about this also, I couldn't believe it when it happened the second time! I never considered one either cos I too thought they were ugly, but now I think maybe they also aren't as sturdy as the four wheelers, and if there is a safety problem then it should be properly checked out before any other accidents or deaths happen.

OSHA Information Get Materials & Solutions for OSHA Safety Regulations & Compliance.  www.business.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 92/100. 4cuteboys (2889)   ranked 639 out of 3,703 in had children   5 years ago

I had one for awhile, it was okay, I never worried about it tipping, it was very sturdy. It also had brakes for the wheels, and a hand brake at the top for emergencies. I got rid of it though because I wasn't jogging with it, and I too thought it was big and ugly. It was nice when I had to push it over grass and stuff. The big wheels made it easier. I've never heard of that happening, that's pretty scary.

Ergonomics Training Customized, On-Site Training by Certified Professional Ergonomists  www.humantech.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 99/100. Woodpigeon (2596)   ranked 71 out of 3,703 in had children   5 years ago

I see people using them all the time and didn't know there was any question of safety with them.

The ones that definately aren't safe are those little lightweight umbrella type buggies. We were given one of those and it used to tip over backwards.

I like the standard 4 wheeled prams with a canopy and under carriage storage. They might be a bit bulky and unweildy, but they are sturdy and we never had any accidents with them.


myLot reputation of 97/100. Calais (7020)   ranked 205 out of 3,703 in had children  5 years ago

I have only heard of bad things about these. The two that you mentioned also. I would definantly not but one, and they remind me of the Trike Bikes which are dangerous anyway. But everyone is different, so I suppose its personal preference.

Find Local Child Care Find Safe Care for Your Child. Search Local Listings Today.  www.Care.com/childcare
 
7. myLot reputation of 82/100. deedles88 (277)   ranked 1,063 out of 3,703 in had children   5 years ago

Ive had both. We keep a 4 wheeler in the car for when we are out shopping and I keept a 3 wheeler at home for when I go out for walks with my 'mums group'. I think they are great, some are big and bulky and ugly. But in the end they all have to pass the same safety tests, and there has probably been 4 wheeler deaths that havent been mentioned. Its up to you thought, but I do like the 3 wheeler, its easier for me to control.

IPC Certification & OSHA Trainer/Operator,Soldering,Forklift, Safety,10-30Hr Outreach Programs  www.veriontraining.com
 
sponsors
OSHA Information
Get Materials& Solutions for OSHA Safety Regulations& Compliance.
www.business.com

Ergonomics Training
Customized, On-Site Training by Certified Professional Ergonomists
www.humantech.com

Find Local Child Care
Find Safe Care for Your Child. Search Local Listings Today.
www.Care.com/childcare

similar discussions
It's hard to live in Indonesia..??
why..? one of the reason because there are so many inconvenient & discomfort when we go...
Are your cellphone batteries safe?
Verizon Wireless has recalled 50,000 cell phone batteries, some of which may be counterfeit, after...
She slipped while walking to class!
A friend of mine sent me a text this morning real early asking what I would do. She was heading...
Don't you hate it when people drive and talk/text on the phone?
I hate it when people do that. I never text or talk on my phone. I wait, or if people keep on...
There should be seat belts on busses! What do you all think?
How can it possibly be considered safe to put all those children in one vehicle with no seat belts....
do you put an extra door lock for your safety and security at home?
good day dear fellow mylotters, now a days, securing for your safety is a must. aside from the...
How do we keep our children safe?
We tell our children all the time that strangers are dangerous and to never go with them. We...
texting while driving
Hello my fellow people. Wanted to just share and get an opinion of everyone regarding texting a...
What do you think about online chat?
Online chat has been around us for quite some time now. From the traditionally well known ICQ and...
Do you wear seat belt when you are in the car? Helmet when on motorcycle?
Malaysia has made it obligatory for all passengers to wear seat belts when in the car. If it was...
sponsors
OSHA Information
Get Materials & Solutions for OSHA Safety Regulations & Compliance.
www.business.com
Ergonomics Training
Customized, On-Site Training by Certified Professional Ergonomists
www.humantech.com
Find Local Child Care
Find Safe Care for Your Child. Search Local Listings Today.
www.Care.com/childcare
IPC Certification & OSHA
Trainer/Operator,Soldering,Forklift, Safety,10-30Hr Outreach Programs
www.veriontraining.com
Find the Car You Want
Choose a Car from Millions of Listings - New, Used or Certified.
AutoTrader.com
OSHA Safety Training: Web
Online workplace OSHA training that employees enjoy. TV-quality video.
www.mastery.com
Stylish Baby Sleep Sacks
US Company, stylish designs, high quality, 100% cotton, $4.95 shipping
www.BabyinaBag.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.