sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionsblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLot

Do you know the meaning? email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 96/100. cortjo73 (1864)   ranked 23 out of 6,963 in questions & answers3 months ago

I was thinking last night about the phrase, "Take everything she says with a grain of salt."

What does that saying mean? Does it mean that everything she says (or he) lacks an ingredient? Is it related to sarcasm and maybe to cut the sourness of sarcasm you need to tame it with salt...like with margaritas? What does it mean? Did I get it right? Does anyone know?

I could probably google the origin of that phrase and find out by myself but, I find it much more fun to put it to my myLot community to see if you all can teach me!

Do you have any other sayings or phrases that you have pondered the meaning or the origin of? If so, what are some sayings that confuse you but, you might still use them? LOL!

 
 
questions & answers
sponsors
Jesus Loves You
Here is a prayer that can change your life.
www.Jesus2020.com

Los Angeles Electricians
Find Los Angeles Electricians& Electric Contractors at YellowPages.
LosAngeles.YellowPages.com

Find Tons of Quotes
Get Famous, Inspiring, Funny& More Quotes w/ the Free Quotes Toolbar.
Quotes.alot.com

Angelwhispers (4424) response was accepted on 6/17/2008.
denotes best response.
tags:  sayings, phrases, grain of salt, meaning, confusion
 
1. myLot reputation of 90/100. xtinelee (3158)   ranked 1,897 out of 6,963 in questions & answers   3 months ago

Er. It means that you shouldn't take whatever she is saying that seriously. It's actually just an analogy.


myLot reputation of 96/100. cortjo73 (1864)   ranked 23 out of 6,963 in questions & answers  3 months ago

I understand that it means not to take a person too seriously. But, why "with a grain of salt"? What specifically does a "grain of salt" have to do with not taking someone seriously? That is what I have never gotten. I have always understood that people are saying not to take a person too seriously. I just don't get how salt has anything to do with it! LOL!


myLot reputation of 92/100. longbangod (1072)   ranked 443 out of 6,963 in questions & answers  3 months ago

OKay. Got it. I for one dont really know the explanation of that phrase. At least now I know the meaning of it. Thanks for the info!

Jesus Loves You Here is a prayer that can change your life. www.Jesus2020.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 97/100. sophialin (1043)   ranked 34 out of 6,963 in questions & answers   3 months ago

hi cortjo73,i think it means you should never trust all that she said.she may be a person kind of unreliable or like to say everything exaggerated extragerated.thus be careful to what she says and not take serious to it.


myLot reputation of 96/100. cortjo73 (1864)   ranked 23 out of 6,963 in questions & answers  3 months ago

Hello sophialin. I understand that it means not to take someone so seriously but, why salt? What does salt have to do with not taking someone so seriously? What does "a grain of salt" mean specifically?


myLot reputation of 97/100. sophialin (1043)   ranked 34 out of 6,963 in questions & answers  3 months ago

i guess 'with a grain of salt' means rather retain parts for yourself not give out all.

Los Angeles Electricians Find Los Angeles Electricians & Electric Contractors at YellowPages. LosAngeles.YellowPages.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 21/100. redyellowblackdog (2662)   ranked 1,964 out of 6,963 in questions & answers   3 months ago

I don't know the offical meaning, but I can guess.

Salt is added to food to make it more palatable. So, I suspect 'a grain of salt' with something someone says means a particular statement is offensively untrue and needs something added to be tolerable. Since it is only a 'grain' of salt, the offensiveness is probably not too large.

This would mean the phrase "Take everything she says with a grain of salt" indicates that person lies a lot but the lies are mostly intended as not really big lies.

That's my guess.


myLot reputation of 96/100. cortjo73 (1864)   ranked 23 out of 6,963 in questions & answers  3 months ago

You might be onto something. I know it has always meant not to take someone too seriously but, that "grain of salt" thing has always confused me! LOL! And, I wondered if it has something to do with making something taste better going down. More digestible. LOL!

Thank you for your interpretation. I think you are probably right!

Find Tons of Quotes Get Famous, Inspiring, Funny & More Quotes w/ the Free Quotes Toolbar. Quotes.alot.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 90/100. Angelwhispers (4424)   ranked 16 out of 6,963 in questions & answers   3 months ago

I believe it to mean to take things like that with some common sense and skepticism. Okay LMAO here it is "it means that a copious measure of skepticism should be applied regarding a claim"

yup just as I thought, don't believe everything is as it appears to be. There probably is a small amount of truth in what she says, but a whole lot of embellishment.


myLot reputation of 96/100. cortjo73 (1864)   ranked 23 out of 6,963 in questions & answers  3 months ago

LOL! I still don't get why they recommend "a grain of salt". LOL! I wonder what the origin is. I read somewhere, actually a couple of times, some origins of some popular sayings. I can't remember probably any of them but, they were cool to learn about. I bet this is one of them that actually has an origin as far as why people started saying it. Not just what it means as far as the definition but, when and why people started associating "a grain of salt" with "a copious measure of skepticism...". LOL! I understand how to apply the saying. I don't understand what a "grain of salt" has to do with it! LOL!

But, thank you for your help! And, thank you for taking the time to look it up!


myLot reputation of 90/100. Angelwhispers (4424)   ranked 16 out of 6,963 in questions & answers  3 months ago

LMAO sorry ... I would think somehow the grain of salt is metaphorically associated with the small amount of truth the "grain".


myLot reputation of 90/100. Angelwhispers (4424)   ranked 16 out of 6,963 in questions & answers  3 months ago

Okay here is a bit more that I found.
With a grain of salt
Meaning: With a healthy dose of skepticism, suspicion, and caution.
Example: Dave has been known to stretch the truth a bit. Take what he says with a grain of salt.
Origin: Salt is now an inexpensive and readily available commodity. But it was once very valuable due to its high demand as a food preservative and relative scarcity.
Salt was thought to have healing properties and to be an antidote to poisons. To take (eat or drink) something "with a grain of salt" was to practice preventive medicine. One would do this if they were suspicious that the food might be poisonous or may cause illness.
Thanks to Ron Akers
The phrase and meaning is thousands of years old, the Latin equivalent phrase is "cu*m grano salis".
Thanks to Barry Harridge and Richard Laurent


myLot reputation of 96/100. cortjo73 (1864)   ranked 23 out of 6,963 in questions & answers  3 months ago

Wow! I bet the folks who originated it back then would be shocked to know how dangerous salt can be when you use too much of it! LOL!

That is funny to know the people thought that you could neutralize poison in food with salt! LOL!

Thank you for this info! It is cool to learn its origin!


myLot reputation of 90/100. Angelwhispers (4424)   ranked 16 out of 6,963 in questions & answers  4 weeks ago

Hey Cortjo thank you so much for the BR:))))


myLot reputation of 96/100. cortjo73 (1864)   ranked 23 out of 6,963 in questions & answers  4 weeks ago

My pleasure! Thank you for the great response!

Yeg Flight Deals Save Coin on YEG flights. Hurry, Space is Limited. Book Now. www.iFly.com/edmonton-flights
 
5. myLot reputation of 87/100. Ravenladyj (13737)   ranked 79 out of 6,963 in questions & answers   3 months ago

I dont know where the saying originated but I do know what it means....It means to not take what said person is saying as truth since they have a tendency to embelish or even straight up lie..


myLot reputation of 96/100. cortjo73 (1864)   ranked 23 out of 6,963 in questions & answers  3 months ago

Thank you RavenladyJ. I do understand how to apply it and what it means as a whole. What I don't understand is what a "grain of salt" has to do with it! LOL! It is one of those sayings that I can use as I understand how to but, I am trying to figure out why "a grain of salt". LOL! One of those silly sayings that, if we search hard enough, we can find why people started associating "a grain of salt" with lies. LOL!

Thank you for your help!

phrase Find Local Electricians & Electric Contractors at YellowPages. Contractors.YellowPages.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 68/100. hiccup (3720)   ranked 1,013 out of 6,963 in questions & answers   3 months ago

Un-paletable food was take "with a grain of Salt" this made it more easy to swallow.

So is some things that are told to you, "with a grain of salt, "it would be more easy to swallow what is/was said.

Was use as far back as in English 1647.

Latin is "cu-m grano salis" for the same thing,

Mabe it all came about from LOT's wife(bible), who was turned into salt for looking back, TAKE IT WITH A GRAIN OF SALT.


myLot reputation of 96/100. cortjo73 (1864)   ranked 23 out of 6,963 in questions & answers  3 months ago

Wow! Check you out! I knew someone would know it! Thank you! I wondered how it came about, as well as why a grain of salt. That is really interesting! And, how cool to know that a saying so old in years, decades and centuries, is still used in modern day language!

Thank you for your help! I understood what it meant and how to use it, in the most basic terms. But, I never understood what it meant broken down as far as, why "a grain of salt"? Thank you again for your help!


myLot reputation of 68/100. hiccup (3720)   ranked 1,013 out of 6,963 in questions & answers  3 months ago

Grain can be one or grain can be many, as in a "Wheat BAG OF GRAIN", So "A GRAIN OF SALT". Many.


myLot reputation of 96/100. cortjo73 (1864)   ranked 23 out of 6,963 in questions & answers  3 months ago

Ok! Even better! Thank you again! You have been very helpful!

 
7. myLot reputation of 88/100. kriskhedkar (362)   ranked 1,895 out of 6,963 in questions & answers   3 months ago

the meaning of the idom take something with pinch with salt means you do not completely. SO the meaning of this sentence she has a tendency to exagereate. You can find teh meaning of the phrases on http://idioms.thefreedictionary.com


myLot reputation of 96/100. cortjo73 (1864)   ranked 23 out of 6,963 in questions & answers  3 months ago

Thank you! That is helpful! Isn't it funny how there is deeper meaning in some of the things/sayings that we take for granted?

And, I will check the link out. Thank you for that as well!

 
8. myLot reputation of 87/100. Alnitak (143)   ranked 1,983 out of 6,963 in questions & answers   3 months ago

> Do you have any other sayings or phrases that you have pondered the meaning or the origin of?
> If so, what are some sayings that confuse you but, you might still use them?

Since I'm Italian I've got lot of foreign idioms I don't get:P
One was "The Apple of my Eye". I've found out the meaning a few days ago and it was really nice.

I remember too an English one: when they're having a drinking toast they say to each other "Mud in your eyes". Does anyone knows where it comes from?


myLot reputation of 96/100. cortjo73 (1864)   ranked 23 out of 6,963 in questions & answers  3 months ago

I can't remember any others ones right now.

And, I think I remember reading the origin "apple of my eye" but, I can't remember it. I would love it if you could remind me.

And, what is the origin of "Mud in your eyes" because, if I ever knew that one, I can't remember it?

If I can think of any others, I will ask you!


myLot reputation of 87/100. Alnitak (143)   ranked 1,983 out of 6,963 in questions & answers  3 months ago

"The apple" was the way they were calling the pupil because they were thinking it was solid and spherical (that now we know is not, because it's a hole) so since when you love someone you look at him very much, his image could be seen reflected in your pupil like if he was inside the "apple".

I wonder if Gwyneth Paltrow named her daughter thinking about this pupil thing... LOL!

About "Mud in your eyes", I'm not sure about this, but I've read that was an idiom used by peasants to wish a good season because the more they would get mud in their eyes working in the fields, the more they would have been rewarded with good harvest.

Another explanation says that it was used by soldiers because when they got MITY that meant that a grenade exploded next to them and this meant that they survived, so it's used to wish a long life.

 
9. myLot reputation of 87/100. Anhedonia (1779)   ranked 740 out of 6,963 in questions & answers   3 months ago

I have got a book which someone gave me for Christmas, and if i can find the book, I will look it up and come back! Just a second now. . ..

AARGH! Where is it??? Waaaaa. Well for now, I'll just say everything goes better with salt. lol


myLot reputation of 96/100. cortjo73 (1864)   ranked 23 out of 6,963 in questions & answers  3 months ago

LOL! You are right! Everything does go better with salt! LOL! In fact, I think that probably way too much for my own good! LOL!


myLot reputation of 87/100. Anhedonia (1779)   ranked 740 out of 6,963 in questions & answers  3 months ago

ROFL. . .that book was so cool and I don't know where the heck I put it. It had all kinds of expressions and their origin.


myLot reputation of 96/100. cortjo73 (1864)   ranked 23 out of 6,963 in questions & answers  3 months ago

LOL! Don't you hate it when you misplace something? Like it sprouted feet and walked away and every time you get close, it just runs for cover and hides somewhere new! LOL!

You need a book shelf! LOL!

 
10. abdulmajeed (75)   ranked 2,490 out of 6,963 in questions & answers   3 months ago

"Take everything she says with a grain of salt." It means in my sense that what she says take it seriously. Don't take it easy or mischevously.


myLot reputation of 96/100. cortjo73 (1864)   ranked 23 out of 6,963 in questions & answers  3 months ago

Thank you for your interpretation. Most people seem to think that it means that she lies so, to not really believe her when she speaks. LOL!

Thank you for your help!

 
sponsors
Yeg Flight Deals
Save Coin on YEG flights. Hurry, Space is Limited. Book Now.
www.iFly.com/edmonton-flights

phrase
Find Local Electricians& Electric Contractors at YellowPages.
Contractors.YellowPages.com

similar discussions
Sayings that annoy you
In everyday dealings with people whether at work or stores etc., people seem to have saying that...
What is the funniest things your child did or said
My daughter is 20 months and she like to smell things. She goes up to her daddys feet everynight...
You'll be damned if you do and damned if you don't!!!
We all know some of the well known proverbs like "You have to take the good with the bad", "You...
eduation is eyes
education is wealth which can not be destory. the person one who have money one day it will...
Sayings that do not Translate.
So my best friend leaves the shop today on her way to work. We had been having a cup of coffee and...
favorite saying or quote.
there are so many sayings and quotes.. some are funny and make me laugh and some have very nice...
bar none?
what does that really mean?? there are so many phrases we use and i dont even know what some of...
Examples of the Prophet Muhammad’s Sayings
*-{God does not judge you according to your appearance and your wealth, but He looks at your hearts...
Favourite Sayings
What is everybody's top 10 favourite sayings?Mine are....... 1. If it's not broken, don't...
what is the motto of yours??
everyone has a motto in life,or some meaningful words, so tell me which motto do you like?? ...
sponsors
Yeg Flight Deals
Save Coin on YEG flights. Hurry, Space is Limited. Book Now.
www.iFly.com/edmonton-flights
phrase
Find Local Electricians & Electric Contractors at YellowPages.
Contractors.YellowPages.com