sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Countries with no child safety seat laws  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 97/100. serenidity (499)   ranked 181 out of 9,015 in parenting 4 years ago

Well, I know the initial reaction is "absolutely unsafe !" but hear me out. I come from a country where children sit in the car (including infants) without a car seat. There is no law in the country for children to be restrained in a child safety seat. For one thing, although there are many cars on the road, the economy is not as autocentric as in the west. You will see an equal number of other transports on the road as well. Secondly uptill recently people never travelled long distances (and most still don't do) by car like in the US or Uk or other countries. Public transport like trains and buses have a huge network and vacations are usually planned accordingly. The last thing for consideration is the speed. The volume of traffic, condition of roads and the cars themselves, all make it impossible to drive at speeds which are usually normal in the west. On an average most people in my country would be driving at 40 miles an hour (maximum) at least in the bigger cities. Usually even lower speed than that. So even if there is an accident, it is not necessarily fatal. It may look like I am advocating non-use of a child seat, believe me I am not. But at the same time, I feel that rules are made keeping in mind the local conditions and prevelant circumstances. If some countries do not have laws for a child safety seat, maybe they don't really need one.

 

parenting
sponsors
Sears® Auto Accessories
Great Deals on Car Seat Covers at Sears®. Official Site.
www.sears.com/auto

Ask a Lawyer Online Now
24 Lawyers Are Online. Ask a Question, Get an Answer ASAP.
JustAnswer.com/Law

Honda Short Films
Learn how 'Kicking out the Ladder' inspired Honda's safety standards.
www.honda.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  car seat, child safety seat laws, countries, kids, law
 
1. myLot reputation of 93/100. Transdisc (18434)   4 years ago

Hello serenidity :)

How do you think that people in your country might react if child restraint laws were implemented? Also, are seat belts required to be used by adults?


myLot reputation of 97/100. serenidity (499)   ranked 181 out of 9,015 in parenting  4 years ago

I am sure most people who own cars won't mind as they can very well afford a car seats too. Yes, adults seating in the front and the driver have to compulsorily have the seat belt on them. Also, children are not allowed in the front seat in major cities where there is a lot of traffic. But like I said, car seats don't seem to be the need of the hour yet. The traffic makes it impossible to drive at any high speed, plus if you look at the other side of the coin, no child who can't sit would be travelling in the car unattended. There always will be someone who will hold the child and sit.


myLot reputation of 93/100. Transdisc (18434)  4 years ago

Perhaps so, but who will hold the person who is holding the child?


myLot reputation of 97/100. serenidity (499)   ranked 181 out of 9,015 in parenting  4 years ago

Like i said, the speeds are never crazy enough and fatal crashes are not so common. There is no doubt that child seats are safer than human hands, but one also has to look at the number of cars on the roads and number of children travelling too.


myLot reputation of 93/100. Transdisc (18434)  4 years ago

Statistically, I see your point, serenidity, and I hope that no children are hurt. As far as 40 mph speeds, this is plenty fast enough for fatalities. I used to work in an ER when I was younger, and I'll never forget this guy who was brought in with his face smashed in after a 25 mph collision. He didn't live.

As much as we want to hold on tight to our little ones, we're just not strong enough to do so.

Sears® Auto Accessories Great Deals on Car Seat Covers at Sears®. Official Site.  www.sears.com/auto
 
2. myLot reputation of 82/100. spalladino (11857)   ranked 494 out of 9,015 in parenting   4 years ago

You know, it wasn't all that long ago when the U.S. didn't require child safety seats either. I can remember bringing my first three kids home from the hospital and I was holding each one of them. I can also remember by son leaping around in the back seat when he was two and three years old...this was about 25 years ago. I do agree with you, the local conditions should determine child safety laws.


myLot reputation of 92/100. squirt051305 (321)   ranked 685 out of 9,015 in parenting  4 years ago

lolMy mom was telling me about that also on how she use to hold us in the car from the hospital. It was ok then but now there's alot more traffic and alot more accidents. I wouldn't trust not to have babies/children in safety seats. At the hospital where I had my son this May I had to have my car seat install by the hospital before I could take him home with me. I know the fire department also installs them if you can't make it to the days they do it in the hospital.


myLot reputation of 97/100. serenidity (499)   ranked 181 out of 9,015 in parenting  4 years ago

yes, conditions have changed, its just that in my country yet, the situation is still not the same as US. I think car seats are very convenient if you want to travel alone with a child as well, you can put the child in the car seat and drive. but in my country, people would be horrified to think of that option. They would rather hold the baby in the lap, let someobody else drive than have the baby alone in the carseat. Two wheeler accidents are more common than cars in the place i live.

Ask a Lawyer Online Now 24 Lawyers Are Online. Ask a Question, Get an Answer ASAP.  JustAnswer.com/Law
 
3. myLot reputation of 100/100. jillhill (17717)   ranked 188 out of 9,015 in parenting   4 years ago

I am not avocating no seat belts either....but when I was growing up we didn't have them...and when my kids were growing up there weren't any rules about it...and surprisingly we all lived. I do understand that different cultures have different ideas......so you got to do what you got to do!


myLot reputation of 95/100. celestial052506 (1324)   ranked 667 out of 9,015 in parenting  4 years ago

I will agree with you. I can speak to my country too. There is no child safety rules applied in where I lived. Kids will ride with the adults and for the safety of the little kids they will sit on the lap of the parents and parents will cuddle them it is just the same as they have safety seat.lol since most of us are public riders, we have no seat belts except the driver. It is mandated by the Government that drivers must have seat belt. Well, the passengers will just hold on to something on the bus, to avoid being thrown when the driver suddenly stepped on the break. Yes, different cultures have different ideas and different laws. let's face that reality.thumbdown


myLot reputation of 97/100. serenidity (499)   ranked 181 out of 9,015 in parenting  4 years ago

Thats exactly the point. I am sure car seats are safe and all, but look at the countries which won't have them, an adult will be with a child always in the backseat. And I know the children would deifinitely like that more !!

Honda Short Films Learn how 'Kicking out the Ladder' inspired Honda's safety standards.  www.honda.com
 
sponsors
Insane Car Audio Discount
The lowest prices on the net from a reliable source, since 1999.
www.onlinecarstereo.com

Local Coupons
Ridiculously huge deals every day. Like doing your city at 90% off!
www.Groupon.com

Save on Car Audio
Huge Deals on Car Audio Speakers, Subwoofers, CD-Changers& More.
www.Calibex.com/Car-Audio

similar discussions
Would you allow your small kids to to this?
My father in-law treated the entire family to a weekend at the beach. On our way home, i and my two...
Do you always put your child in a car seat
I see some parents with infants and young kids riding around with them out of there car seats. do...
Travelling abroad with car seat and stroller??
Hello Everyone, My hubby, daughter and I are travelling to the States, end of May with Virgin...
Do you use a car seat carrier for your dog?
I'm just curious how many of you use a carrier car seat or some sort of harness to secure your dog...
Help! She keeps unbuckling her car seat!
My 2 year old daughter has figured out how to undo the part of her car seat that goes across her...
not using a carseat?
ok, heres the deal. i have a coworker, whose son is 4 (i think). she does not use a car seat. she...
Carseats?
Can anyone recomend a decent front-facing carseat? I want something with darker colors but that is...
Superpower: what will you do if...
If you are granted with superpower, which turn your eyes into bionic eyes which can trace money no...
What do I say to a friend w/ teens
She has a 14yo & a 16yo. The 16yo also just delivered a child this summer! And she's always venting...
It's about time, but how sad!
A device has been patented to warn drivers that an occupied child seat is in their car. The light...
sponsors
Insane Car Audio Discount
The lowest prices on the net from a reliable source, since 1999.
www.onlinecarstereo.com
Local Coupons
Ridiculously huge deals every day. Like doing your city at 90% off!
www.Groupon.com
Save on Car Audio
Huge Deals on Car Audio Speakers, Subwoofers, CD-Changers & More.
www.Calibex.com/Car-Audio
Convertible car seats
Get great deals on Convertible car seats. Shop eBay!
www.eBay.com
Local Costume Rentals
Find Local Costume Rental Shops
yellowpages.com
Top 2011 Online Grants
Grant funding may be available - Go Back to School!
www.ClassesUSA.com
Car Seats On Sale
Large Selection of Brand Name Car Seats, Fast Free Shipping!
AlbeeBaby.com/Car-Seats
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.