sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

Obama, Biden and the National Guard: Right Idea, Wrong Direction... email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 60/100. ParaTed2k (4586)   ranked 402 out of 6,348 in politics1 year ago

Backing Obama's "Blueprint for Change", Sen. Biden called for a stronger voice at the federal level for the National Guard. I think that its great that the Democrats want to address problems the Guard has faced, almost being the Red-Headed Step Child of the US Armed Forces.

Until the 90s, the National Guard was considered a state asset that could be federalized if needed. Prs. Clinton changed that with his version of the "drawdown". After he was done, 50% of our Army's Infantry and 75% of our Army's Artillery was National Guard. In other words, it was given a major role in our nation's defense. The plan was dubbed "Whole Army".

The Commanding General of the Alaska Army National Guard said that Gov. Palin really had nothing to do with the command and control of the National Guard. Sadly, that is true... but it wasn't always.

What Obama's plan will do is complete the federalization of the Army and Air National Guards... something that was never supposed to happen, and shouldn't now.

The National Guards of each state should be put completely under the command and control of their states, where it belongs. Training and Equipping can still be done at the federal level because each NG unit still would have a role in our national defense.

The problem is, The National Guard units taken from the state aren't treated as equals once they are federalized, even though they do the exact same job their Active and Reserve counterparts do. Yes, the Obama plan could serve to equalize the NG in the eyes of the Regular Army brass, but at what cost?

The cost would be what we have witnessed since the 90s... that is, from the outside looking in, there is no difference between the Army Reserves and the Army National Guard.

The entire concept of the NG is that we are state assets, with responsibilities to the people of the state and the state itself. The federal government's gain will be (and has been) the states' loss.

It is just another example of the Federal Government trying to strengthen itself and weaken the states.

 
 
politics
sponsors
National Guard Rings
Buy your U.S.N.G. Ring direct from the factory and Save up to 50% OFF.
www.dunham-mfg.com

National Guard Scholarships
Get Post Military Career w/100% Tuition Assistance, Online Courses.
www.Education4Military.com

cheap nationals stuff
Washington Nationals Apparel Sale - Prices Slashed Up to 60% Off.
FanaticsOutlet.com/nationals

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  national guard, obama, biden, army, air force
 
1. myLot reputation of 22/100. kennyrose (4048)   ranked 2,972 out of 6,348 in politics   1 year ago

Seems to me the democrat run house has left the lights on but no body has been home,why would any of even begin to think the democrat's are going to address anything,two years they have run the house and we all see clearly our house is in one hell of a big mess.
I read that Gov Sarah Palin distracted the Alaska national guard across the state due to a a bad fire when she was a mayor in Alaska.
Seems that I read a mayor takes control in cases of storms,fires and big events that happens in their state,thank God we don't have to sent the democrat house the dam place would surely burn down.

National Guard Rings Buy your U.S.N.G. Ring direct from the factory and Save up to 50% OFF. www.dunham-mfg.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 71/100. evanslf (388)   ranked 135 out of 6,348 in politics   1 year ago

I agree. The national guard should remain with the states, we don't want even more centralisation at the federal level.

National Guard Scholarships Get Post Military Career w/100% Tuition Assistance, Online Courses. www.Education4Military.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 77/100. ladyluna (2495)   ranked 178 out of 6,348 in politics   1 year ago

Excellent topic, ParaTed!

I couldn't agree more! These no longer veiled attempts to strip the States of their regional autonomy blatantly contradict the edicts of our Founding Father's Federalist view of our nation.

Geesh, giving consideration to the purvasive departmental power grabs, the Department of Education, the Dept. of Labor, the EPA, the FDA, etc... and the expansion of the powers of the interstate commerce laws, the State's had very little regional autonomy left at all. The most obvious perview of regional autonomy was the State's regulated militia, or its National Guard. If the NG's are fully centralized then there is no defending body to stand up to a corrupted federal government. Hmmm, doesn't this represent a glaring defiance of the U.S. Constitution, specifically the Second Amendment???

If I may be so bold, this is more than a little scary. And, it ought make every American more than a little nervous!!!

cheap nationals stuff Washington Nationals Apparel Sale - Prices Slashed Up to 60% Off. FanaticsOutlet.com/nationals
 
4. myLot reputation of 73/100. newtondak (2125)   ranked 279 out of 6,348 in politics   1 year ago

I totally agree - the National Guard should be left under the supervision/regulation of the state in which they reside and their first responsibility should be to that state. While it is important that our Armed Forces be adequately staffed, it is also important that we have forces that are stationed locally and are immediately available.

12 Hrs or Less US Passports When Trust & Time Count, we offer Solutions 24/7, Wash/DC-866-727-7362 www.PassportDocs.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 90/100. flowerchilde (6827)   ranked 56 out of 6,348 in politics   1 year ago

I felt a definite chill when I read this.. shocked
Thanks for posting it!

Washington Jeep Dealer Learn About New Deals at Your Local Washington Jeep Dealer www.JeepDealer.com
 
sponsors
12 Hrs or Less US Passports
When Trust& Time Count, we offer Solutions 24/7, Wash/DC-866-727-7362
www.PassportDocs.com

Washington Jeep Dealer
Learn About New Deals at Your Local Washington Jeep Dealer
www.JeepDealer.com

WA Appraiser School
Get Your Appraisal License Today. DETC Nationally Accredited.
www.RealEstateLicense.com

similar discussions
Gangs In America
Do you think there is anything that can be done about gangs in America?
cnn reports: is marial law coming soon to the u.s.?
CNN u-tube video is martial law being set up as we speak,you be the judge. (CLICK LINK BELOW...
Veterans Memorial Wall~Enter Here~
A veteran,whether active duty,retired,national guard,or reserves~Is someone who at one point in...
Obama thinking about calling out the national guard
In light of the violance along the border Obama is thinking about putting national guard troops on...
All you National Guard people...
thank you for doing what you do. I just had to say this after going through the ice storms here in...
sponsors
12 Hrs or Less US Passports
When Trust & Time Count, we offer Solutions 24/7, Wash/DC-866-727-7362
www.PassportDocs.com
Washington Jeep Dealer
Learn About New Deals at Your Local Washington Jeep Dealer
www.JeepDealer.com
WA Appraiser School
Get Your Appraisal License Today. DETC Nationally Accredited.
www.RealEstateLicense.com
Washington DC Tours
Customized Student Tours in the United States. Contact Us Now.
www.EducationalTours.com
Obama-Biden Website
Barack Obama Needs Your Help to Change Washington. Sign Up Today!
www.BarackObama.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.