sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

What happens to a soul of an ubaptized child that dies...  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 84/100. Khayam (205)   ranked 131 out of 6,502 in religion 4 years ago

Acording to the Roman Catholic catechisms - although there is no basis in the Scripture that could support them - the soul of the dead child, uncleansed from the original sin, goes to limbo (from the Latin word "border" a fringe of hell where they spend eternity in a state of natural hapiness. In Saint John's Gospel it is written that "Unless a man be born again of water and the Spirit, he cannot enter into the kingdom of God". Saint Augustine mentions that the unbaptized babies go straight to Hell. "The are vessels of contumely and the wrath of God is upon them".


What do you think it happens to the soul of an unbaptized child that dies?

P.S. I won't be home for the weekend, but I can't wait to read your comments. Take care.

 

religion
sponsors
Child Development Degree
Earn your Child Development Associate Certificate at home.
www.PennFoster.edu

Online Psychology Degree
Earn a Psychology Degree Online at American Public University. Enroll.
www.apus.edu/psychology

Ask a Lawyer Online Now
18 Lawyers Are Online. A Lawyer Will Answer You Now.
Law.JustAnswer.com

Starflames (127) response was accepted on 11/24/2008.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  baptism, child, faith, heaven, limbo
 
1. myLot reputation of 99/100. lilaclady (22746)   4 years ago

I am not a religious person so I believe there is no difference, I have no faith as to what is written in all these books of different religions, who knows who wrote them...I believe there is something after this life but i think we will go to the same place, the very fact that some of these ordinary men who are doing the blessings of the soul are doing dispicable things should make people realize they have no rights to be giving blessings anyway, they are just ordinary people...cry


myLot reputation of 73/100. Starflames (127)   ranked 1,607 out of 6,502 in religion  4 years ago

I feel that some of what you said has some merit, especially the second part of your last sentence.

Regards...

Child Development Degree Earn your Child Development Associate Certificate at home.  www.PennFoster.edu
 
2. myLot reputation of 75/100. BethsMom24 (817)   4 years ago

I have spoken to several scholars on this issue. Some say you must be baptised in order to be acceptable to God and others say as long as you have confessed your sins to God and accepted Christ as your Savior you are acceptable to God. I am not sure you must have a "ceremony" to be acceptable to God. If you think about it many women have miscarriges; they were still babies and never left the womb before they past. Would God truly put these souls in hell or the outskirts of hell? I don't think so. Many children die during child birth- same thing as above. I do not think God will condemn any child for to him NOTHING is more precious.


myLot reputation of 73/100. Starflames (127)   ranked 1,607 out of 6,502 in religion  4 years ago

Not to worry, EVERY child under the age of accountability will eventually have enterance into God's Kingdom.

Christ said that baptism is part of fulfilling ALL righteousness (Matt.3:15).

It also appears that it is a part of the "remission of sin" and the pathway of recieving the Holy Spirit. See Acts 2:38.

And of course, having the Holy Spirit, will eventually lead you into ALL truth. See John 16:13.

Online Psychology Degree Earn a Psychology Degree Online at American Public University. Enroll.  www.apus.edu/psychology
 
3. myLot reputation of 60/100. Indrajit_25 (554)   4 years ago

In my opniion, the soul of the unbaptized child goes straight to heaven because the child is the most innocent, it is an angel.


myLot reputation of 90/100. jordan04n (370)   ranked 4,550 out of 6,502 in religion  4 years ago

Sorry...not an angel. All angels were made in the beginning.


myLot reputation of 73/100. Starflames (127)   ranked 1,607 out of 6,502 in religion  4 years ago

I think Indrajit meant an "Angelic like innocence", and not that the child is actually an Angelic being...

Ask a Lawyer Online Now 18 Lawyers Are Online. A Lawyer Will Answer You Now.  Law.JustAnswer.com
 
4. tennissandgirl (99)   ranked 724 out of 6,502 in religion   4 years ago

LDS/Mormon's believe that one must reach the age of accountability before they are baptized. Anyone that does not reach the age of accountability automatically makes it to Heaven. We believe the age of accountability is eight which is when the average child should know the difference between wrong and right. Unbaptized babies will go to heaven because they no of no evil having just come from heaven! Hope you had a great weekend!!

Owed Child Support? We Help Frustrated Parents Collect The Child Support They're Due.  www.SupportCollectors.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 73/100. Starflames (127)   ranked 1,607 out of 6,502 in religion   4 years ago

First of all, children WERE NEVER baptized, as an example for us, anywhere in the Bible. So it was not necessary and still isn't.

Jesus said that as far as "little" children were concerned, that "of such IS the Kingdom of Heaven! PLEASE SEE: Matthew 19:14.

On the other hand, grown-ups, those who clearly understand right from wrong, are clearly encouraged to "repent and get baptized" for the remission of sin.

So unless "A MAN" be born again thru baptism, he cannot enter the Kingdom of Heaven.

Now to answer your question as to what happens to THE SOUL of an unbaptized child when it dies: ABSOLUTELY NOTHING, IT JUST SIMPLY DIES!

A child has the same fate as any of us when we die- We simply die and cease to exist UNTIL the promised resurrection and judgment.

Please remember that NONE OF US have "inherent" immortality! God- and HE ALONE is immortal! PLEASE SEE: 1 Timothy 6:16.

Jesus brought immortality "to light" through the gospel, but it IS NOT something that we are born with (PLEASE SEE: 2 Timothy 1:10 & Jude 1:21). Eternal Life is a gift from God, thru CHRIST- but it must be earned! PLEASE SEE: Romans 6:23 & Matthew 19:16-17.

If we ALREADY had an inherent immortality, then Christ died in vain being that WE wouldn't need "his gift" of eternal life to live forever- for we'd never really die at all!

So "the soul" of a child- or more proper, THE CHILD, just dies and waits patiently and unconsciously in the grave until the promised resurrection and judgment.


myLot reputation of 74/100. thedogshrink (686)   ranked 943 out of 6,502 in religion  4 years ago

Actually, the Bible teaches that the soul goes to be with the Lord, immediately upon death -- that is, the souls of the saved. The Judgment is when we are all resurrected, our physical bodies are resurrected, as Jesus was the third day after dying on the cross. So far, He is the only One Who has been resurrected, but all will be at the Judgment, "some to eternal Life, and some to Death (which is not to say they cease to exist, but to punishment)".

As for babies, they go to be with the Lord when they die. It is not spelled out explicitly in Scripture, but the references lead most Christians to believe there is an age of accountability for children, at which point they know right from wrong, and at such time they must accept Jesus to be saved. That age is not the same for everyone, and we cannot know it for sure. Only God knows when a child knows right from wrong.

King David, who was a prophet, said that he would see his son in Heaven -- the son that died at birth, and so we understand from that and other passages that babies go to Heaven. Generally, Heaven is considered to be the reward after the Judgment, and before that time, we go, without our physical bodies, to be with the Lord. Jesus said to the one thief on the cross: "This day shall you be with me in Paradise".

Nowhere is it written that baptism is required for salvation: again, look at the thief on the cross who could not be baptized since he was dying when he was saved.
Studying the Scriptures you will find that baptism is the first (usually the first) act of obedience to the Lord, after salvation, NOT a requirement of salvation.wub


myLot reputation of 73/100. Starflames (127)   ranked 1,607 out of 6,502 in religion  4 years ago

Very interesting comments INDEED tds!

I have a few questions for you...

1) Where in the bible does it SPECIFICALLY say that a saved soul goes IMMEDIATELY to heaven at death? PLEASE be specific with the bible verses AND NOT necessarily with your own personal view or private interpretation of them. I'm interested in specific bible verses ONLY. Beause if you hold this view- then the implication is that we are judged and rewarded at the very moment of death and that we have inherent immortality as one of our characteristics as humans. In other words, WE can't die!

2) If saved souls are ALREADY CONSCIOUSLY in heaven with God, THEN why is there a need for a future resurrection AND JUDGEMENT as the bible declares, if we are ALREADY judged and rewarded at the very moment of death? To judge WHAT... an inert and lifless body? What would be the purpose? Why would an inanimate body be needed if the UNDYING conscious soul can function so much freely without the restrictions of the body AND IS ALREADY IN HEAVEN?

3) Will the RESURRECTED "disensouled", inert, and lifless CLAY body which has no capacity or ability to think, reason, or undersatnd ANYTHING on its own, STAND ALONE in front of God to be judged on judgement day? And if that's the case, what's the purpose of judging something that can't see, hear, talk, feel, comprehend and lacks everything else that's associated with being alive and having intelligence?

4) Or will the conscious soul be brought down from heaven and INSERTED back into its own body so that it can understand the judgement, sentence or reward that is about to be given it? If this is the case, then once again, please show specific bible verses that back this up.

I know it's more than a couple of questions- but that is exactly the kinds of questions which arise when one advocates that we humans are actually "undying immortal souls".

Tell me, what does, 1 Timothy 6:16, mean to you, when it says that "God ALONE is immortal"? Because this is a verse that needs no ones interpretation. It speaks for itself! And yet, is in direct opposite of what you advocate. So explain this to us in light of your view and the other questions I've postd above.

As far as the "age of accountability" goes, I totally agree with you, God, and He alone, knows what that age specifically is for each and everyone of us. I've never disagreed with that.

And you're also right when you say that it isn't explicitly spelled out in scripture that babies go to heaven immediately at death. As a matter of fact, it isn't spelled out that ANYONE goes to heaven immediately upon death! And there's a reason for that. Because NO ONE does! Everyone remains unconsciously dead in their graves UNTIL the promised resurrection. However, The bible EXPILICITLY SAYS that God ALONE is immortal!

So that means that We ALL DIE! It doesn't mean your body does and NOT YOU- the soul! That would equate you with God making you a spirit and immortal too, and therefore not needing the gift of God, ETERNAL LIFE, to live forever! But rather what this means is that "YOU"- THE SOUL (THE WHOLE MAN), which is both soul and body, your WHOLE essence, DIES!

Remember what we are and how we were made. God formed us- or shaped us out of the dust of the earth and breathed into our nostrils the breath of life and man- this clay silhouette, BECAME A LIVING SOUL! Please see Genesis 2:7. So we don't have a soul- WE ARE souls! Without Gods breath of life we'd be dead- or dead souls!

King David DID NOT SAY that he would see his son IN HEAVEN. This is merely your assumption. And that belief would contradict what Christ himself said, "That NO ONE has ever ascended into heaven"! Christ said these words LONG AFTER the death of David's son, so that is proof enough that the child isn't and didn't go to heaven. Please see John 3:13.

What King David was merely implying is that his son couldn't come to him (being dead), but that he would go to him, as in joining him- but in death! And David has done exactly that. The bible says that David IS DEAD, BURIED, AND HAS NOT GONE INTO HEAVEN. Please see Acts 2:29, 34.

The thief on the cross DID NOT go to heaven on the day of the cross as you imply. Three days AFTER the cross, christ said he had NOT YET asceneded to the Father in Heaven. Please see: John 20:17. So how could the thief have gone to heaven with Christ on that very day? Besides that, if king David is not yet in Heaven, then no one is.

And lastly, I never said that baptism was "a requirement" for salvation, even though it's something that could certainly be favoribly argued for. Go back and read the original posters comments, where he quotes John 3:5, "Unless a man be born again of water and spirit, he cannot enter into the kingdom of God";

I knew the implication here is baptism, but the posters context is in regards to a child. So if you look carefully at my response to this particular line, you'll see that I placed my emphasis on "A MAN", to make the distinction from a child, indicating that a "MAN" is someone already having attained the age of accountability, rather than implying that baptism is required for salvation.

Anyways, if you care to answer some of these questions, please feel free to do so.

Regards...



myLot reputation of 66/100. remrick (132)   ranked 1,454 out of 6,502 in religion  4 years ago

I have to agree with thedogshrink... I can't answer starflames questions though... I'm too sleepy for that... I'd love to hear what thedogshrink has to say... cheers! :)


myLot reputation of 73/100. Starflames (127)   ranked 1,607 out of 6,502 in religion  4 years ago

Hi Rem,

Well it's okay... get yourself a good and restful sleep and perhaps at some other time, you can share your views.

I too am getting a little tired, but I really am wanting to make an effort in getting to the magic number of 500 posts. I can't wait to be able to copy and paste! LOL... But I still have a very,very long way to go.

God Bless...


myLot reputation of 66/100. remrick (132)   ranked 1,454 out of 6,502 in religion  4 years ago

well, the passage you're referring to in matthew 19 says that the kingdom of heaven belongs to SUCH AS THESE... Jesus probably meant that the kingdom belonged to those who had a childlike faith... he didn't exactly say that it belonged to the children, but to such as these... so it doesn't necessarily support the view that children go to heaven after they die... it's still debatable... but then, that's just my interpretation... cheers! :)


myLot reputation of 66/100. remrick (132)   ranked 1,454 out of 6,502 in religion  4 years ago

haha! i wanna get to 500 posts so i can copy and paste too! hahaha! goodluck to the both of us then... ;p

I'll be signing off in a while... you should take a break, too... :)


myLot reputation of 73/100. Starflames (127)   ranked 1,607 out of 6,502 in religion  4 years ago

Oh, I am... and good luck with that magical 500! hehe....

Cheers...



myLot reputation of 84/100. Khayam (205)   ranked 131 out of 6,502 in religion  4 years ago

The conditions of baptism:

Faith (Mark 18:18, Acts 8:37)
Penance (Acts 2:83, Matthew 3:8)
Personal Request (Acts 8:36)
I doubt a newborn could "fulfil" these, despite Tit 3:5.
Even more, as 1Peter 3:21 highlights, the baptism is the confession of a pure soul not a spiritual remission of the sins.

Mormon Religious Faith Reach Spiritual Fulfillment through Christ & the Mormon faith  www.mormon.org
 
6. iZoran (77)   ranked 1,414 out of 6,502 in religion   4 years ago

Unfortunately I do not have a Bible at hand to refence, but my memory tells me that children have an automatic right to heaven, this being stated by Christ himself. Wish I could reference it for you.


myLot reputation of 73/100. Starflames (127)   ranked 1,607 out of 6,502 in religion  4 years ago

Perhaps you mean, Matt.18:1-6 and/or Matt.19:13-14.

Heaven and Hell Know some surprising truths about the mystery of life after death.  library.ucg.org/heavenhell
 
7. myLot reputation of 90/100. jordan04n (370)   ranked 4,550 out of 6,502 in religion   4 years ago

Baptizing does not get a soul into heaven. A child that passes before the age of accountability is not responsible for his own soul so that child goes to heaven. Believing in the Lord Jesus Christ and you shall be saved gets a soul into heaven. A child is not held accountability til he has the ability to understand. This is Biblical. God loves all his children and wants them to accept him Yet, they must understand what they are accepting, Do you not think beyond the Roman catechisms?


myLot reputation of 73/100. Starflames (127)   ranked 1,607 out of 6,502 in religion  4 years ago

Baptizing ALONE will not get anyone into Gods Kingdom... but I think that it is a part of fulfilling righteousness for any whose reached the age of accountability. Please see Matt.3:15 and Acts 2:38.

Bautizos - Baptisms Recuerdos, Centros de Mesa, Decoraciones, Accesorios y Mas ...  www.LACrafts.com
 
8. fishsky (19)   ranked 4,609 out of 6,502 in religion   4 years ago

WO...I think it too cruel to a child. As is said in Chinese culture,everyone is born kind.This is my own private opinion


myLot reputation of 73/100. Starflames (127)   ranked 1,607 out of 6,502 in religion  4 years ago

I agree, everyone is born a baby! Can't get any kinder than that.

Super cheap Baptism Gift Buy cheap Baptism Gift & save now! Best-Price.com - the shop expert.  www.Baptism-Gift.best-price.com
 
9. myLot reputation of 92/100. overwings (3631)   4 years ago

Till a couple or so years ago all the souls of those babies were in the limbo. Now the limbo has been abolished so it's been decided they all went directly to heaven. The borders of the after death Geography have changed a few times along history. Like new countries appearing and dissapearing.


myLot reputation of 73/100. Starflames (127)   ranked 1,607 out of 6,502 in religion  4 years ago

Hmmm... I'd really be interested in seeing biblical evidence supporting these views.

the Baptism of Jesus A Bible study on the relationship between Jesus’ Baptism and the Cross  www.bjnewlife.org
 
10. myLot reputation of 96/100. katrhina23 (1097)   ranked 3,305 out of 6,502 in religion   4 years ago

I hope they go to heaven and be with the Lord. They are innocent and it wasnt their fault why they werent baptized.


mintymint (36)   ranked 3,710 out of 6,502 in religion  4 years ago

I am sensitiv person and im alwready a bit sad about that but that life. I know that they are ok and that they are happy with dear Good. My father died i was in pain and i once saw him in my dream asking me what do i want him to do for me, what wish do i have? Nice dream. Im catolic and i belive in Good so like i sad that boys or girls are just fine. WE HAVE TO BELIVE, THAT THE POINT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
IF YOU BELIVE IN GOOD, CAN YOU QUESTION THIS???????
O ITS SO SAD


myLot reputation of 83/100. ClassyCat (874)   ranked 1,341 out of 6,502 in religion  4 years ago

There is nothing anywhere in the Bible that teaches
infant or any other baptism, apart from an experience
of repentance, and confessing one's sin to God.

Jesus continually rebuked the religious leaders of His
day, for making up doctrines that were NOT according to
the teaching of His truth. Doctrine and or tradition, that
is not according to truth,keeps people in bondage.

Jesus said (concerning children and heaven) - (Matt.
19:14) "Suffer (meaning LET) the little children come unto
Me, for of such is the Kingdom of Heaven."

In (Matt.18: 3) He said:"Except you become converted and
become as little children, you shall in no wise enter the
Kingdom of heaven."

In 2nd Samuel 12:23 (Old Testament) after David's 7 day
,old son died, David said:"I will go to him one day, but
he shall not return to me."

The Bible is your roadmap and information book on how to
come to know God the Father personally, through acceptance of His son
Jesus. It also answers many questions in life. Why just
accept everything that your church teaches, without reading
the book for yourself? Religious leaders 'can' be wrong,
and when they are - they lead many down the wrong path.

Every place in the New Testament, where baptism is taught,
it is 'only' where adults are involved. Baptism does not
get one into heaven, but is a commandment to be fullfilled
by each believer. It should be a very sacred and special time.
I know it was for me.

And just believing in God isn't enough according to scripture.
It says that the devils believe and tremble, and they're not
going to be in heaven. One must receive (or accept Jesus) into
their heart/life as Saviour and Lord, and then do their best
to live as the Bible directs.

One last thing - there is also no place in the Bible that teaches
that babies or adults will be angels, or that one will sit around
on a cloud, playing a harp. I don't know where people get these
foolish ideas.

If you don't have a Bible, you can go to this link to read one,
or choose to have it read to you:
www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=

Hope I have helped you somehow. God bless.

C.C.




Is Your Baby A Cute Kid? Your Cute Baby Photos Can Be Seen By Talent Agents!  www.TheCuteKid.com
 
sponsors
Owed Child Support?
We Help Frustrated Parents Collect The Child Support They're Due.
www.SupportCollectors.com

Mormon Religious Faith
Reach Spiritual Fulfillment through Christ& the Mormon faith
www.mormon.org

Heaven and Hell
Know some surprising truths about the mystery of life after death.
library.ucg.org/heavenhell

similar discussions
Christian Practices.
Some Christians believe child baptism where as some Christians take immersion Baptism. Which is the...
Baptism
So my 5 month old daughter is going to be baptised this Sunday at my grandmas church. With our...
Can we go after baptism and confirmation at all lost?
Can we go after baptism and confirmation at all lost? Because as you get even the Holy Spirit, who...
Baptism
I am going to get baptised this weekend and I'm nervous as hell. To be brief, I was raised in a...
Do baptism and going to Church necessary for salvation?
I'm a Christian-Protestant. Specifically Pentecostal. I grew up going to Church but eventually...
baptism and salvation
is water baptism the one given by John the Baptist in galilee? is water baptism one way of entering...
If Jesus Christ Baptized with Fire, Why Do 'Christians' See Fire in Hell?
John the Baptist said, "I baptize you with water, but One who is coming after me will baptize you...
Baptism of children is ridiculous and false! Agree / Disagree?
Baptism of infants and children were otherwise inconsequential is misleading, because it is not...
At what age were you baptized?
I am a baptist. I was baptized when I was 21. when were you baptized and what was your experience?...
Did you baptizes your kids?
Are you, you gotten your kids baptizes or not at all? I know some families don't get there children...
sponsors
Owed Child Support?
We Help Frustrated Parents Collect The Child Support They're Due.
www.SupportCollectors.com
Mormon Religious Faith
Reach Spiritual Fulfillment through Christ & the Mormon faith
www.mormon.org
Heaven and Hell
Know some surprising truths about the mystery of life after death.
library.ucg.org/heavenhell
Bautizos - Baptisms
Recuerdos, Centros de Mesa, Decoraciones, Accesorios y Mas ...
www.LACrafts.com
Super cheap Baptism Gift
Buy cheap Baptism Gift & save now! Best-Price.com - the shop expert.
www.Baptism-Gift.best-price.com
the Baptism of Jesus
A Bible study on the relationship between Jesus’ Baptism and the Cross
www.bjnewlife.org
Is Your Baby A Cute Kid?
Your Cute Baby Photos Can Be Seen By Talent Agents!
www.TheCuteKid.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.