sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Would you report your friend?  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 96/100. ronaldinu (9358)   ranked 20 out of 12,079 in friend 3 years ago

A thought have passed through my mind, that of reporting my friend for child neglect. I recently learned that my friend has left her 8 year old son with 103C fever and his three year old child at home all alone unsupervised. It was only for an hour but for me that is certainly one thing that should not be done.

To put all the story in perspective, this woman has adopted a child but this mother has not made a bond with her child. My friend is saying that the child has some learning and communication problem. Her daughter has delayed speech. She is three years old and utters only very few words. My friend thinks that the adoption agency has tricked her. I had a head to head discussions quite a couple of times. I always tell her that she must accept her daughter as she is, that there is no health guarantee on a child of your own let alone an adopted one and she keeps saying that the adopting agency has tricked her.

On one side I feel that it is my duty to report this case of child neglect on the other hand I feel loyal to my friend. Would you report your friend?

 

friend
sponsors
California Drug Attorney
We Are Skilled in Drug Cases. Call us today for a Consultation.
NoCuffs.com/800-662-8337

Ask a Lawyer: Child Law
A Family Lawyer Will Answer Now! Child Law Answers Today: 87.
Law.JustAnswer.com/Child

Child Development Degree
Earn your Child Development Associate Certificate at home.
www.PennFoster.edu

Ohara_1983 (3480) response was accepted on 5/2/2009.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  children, child abuse, friend, adoption, child neglect
 
1. myLot reputation of 87/100. jessi0887 (2559)   ranked 1,264 out of 12,079 in friend   3 years ago

I would report her because it sounds like she is doing it because she is unhappy with the kids. I would report it.


sonamama10 (50)   ranked 11,942 out of 12,079 in friend  3 years ago

don't worrie betterluck mess time


lynne3171 (76)   ranked 12,066 out of 12,079 in friend  3 years ago

I agree with you ...


scoobyman (6)  3 years ago

I agree primarily because that 9 year old child with a fever of 103 should never be left alone. As to the 3 year old I think she wasn't ready for an adoption of a special needs child and I don't believe she was tricked because adoption agencies normally require the adoptive parent to get to know the child and spend some time bonding and I find the adoption agency was neglective in not observing her lack of attachment to the child based on her comments to you. In my opinion she don't need children.

California Drug Attorney We Are Skilled in Drug Cases. Call us today for a Consultation.  NoCuffs.com/800-662-8337
 
2. myLot reputation of 75/100. BethsMom24 (817)   3 years ago

Hey Ronaldinu, I read the discussion you started on this. I didn't add there as I think everything has already been said but I feel compelled to add now. The loyalty, if any is deserved, should be to these poor kids who are MOST CERTAINLY being neglected. It doesn't matter if it was an hour or 5 hours. That child was running a fever of 103-- which can be very dangerous. Your friend has rocks in her head and is a pi$$ poor excuse for a mother. She should have been turned in when it was realized she was not bonding with her adoptive daughter and basically pushing this poor little girl away. If someone doesn't step in NOW much worse is going to happen down the road.

Ask a Lawyer: Child Law A Family Lawyer Will Answer Now! Child Law Answers Today: 87.  Law.JustAnswer.com/Child
 
3. myLot reputation of 96/100. ANTIQUELADY (16514)   ranked 25 out of 12,079 in friend   3 years ago

yes, if they were neglecting their children i would. i would probably try to talk to her first but someone needs to see that the children are being taken care of.

Child Development Degree Earn your Child Development Associate Certificate at home.  www.PennFoster.edu
 
4. sonamama10 (50)   ranked 11,942 out of 12,079 in friend   3 years ago

yes


myLot reputation of 93/100. MsTickle (12894)   ranked 1,594 out of 12,079 in friend  3 years ago

You are new and so probably don't realise that this response is unsuitable.....please, please read the guidelines....click on this link:

http://www.mylot.com/o/guidelines.aspx


myLot reputation of 73/100. AnnieOakley1 (2645)   ranked 1,947 out of 12,079 in friend  3 years ago

One word responses are against the guidelines.

Online Psychology Degree Earn a psychology degree online. Accredited. Respected. Affordable.  www.APUS.edu/Psychology
 
5. myLot reputation of 98/100. SomeCowgirl (14319)   ranked 444 out of 12,079 in friend   3 years ago

I would report her, if she can not give the children a loving home just because of their learning difficulties, or even if it was something worse, then she should not be of custody!

Child Care Services Need Child Care Services?  yellowpages.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 85/100. alharra (347)   ranked 3,038 out of 12,079 in friend   3 years ago

YES!!!!! Those kids need to be taken care of and protected. How would you feel if this woman did this again and one of the kids got hurt or worse died? As for the info that the woman has not made a bond with her daughter-is that the kid's fault? Did it occur to you that she is simply making excuses for her bad decisions/behavior?


jonny3hats (25)   ranked 11,582 out of 12,079 in friend  3 years ago

yeah i totally agree, she is a mother and should be more responsable, even if she hadnt bonded she should have the sense to stay with them or seek medical help

Find Local Child Care Find Safe Care for Your Child. Search Local Listings Today.  www.Care.com/childcare
 
7. myLot reputation of 95/100. kareng (3747)   ranked 1,924 out of 12,079 in friend   3 years ago

It does sound like your friend has a problem with this adoption. She sounds resentful. And yes, I would never leave a sick child alone, let alone two children. What was she thinking?? I would report here. You have to think of those children and they deserve better care than that.


myLot reputation of 93/100. MsTickle (12894)   ranked 1,594 out of 12,079 in friend  3 years ago

I agree with you karen. I think this woman is definitely resentful and I think she is probably right and the agency has foistered this baby onto her under false pretences. I would be devastated if that happened to me and I think I would become rather unstable around my kids as a result. Now I'm not excusing her but I think this is what has happened...I think this person is terribly upset and depressed and has possibly lost some of her reasoning. She is a teacher too so there should be nothing to prevent her having time off to tend to her unwell children...who normally looks after the little one I wonder while this person is at work?

Personally, I think the children AND the mother are in serious trouble and definitely need help. One would need to be careful when reporting to the authorities because I don't think this woman is to be blamed. She has ended up with a child she not only does not want but one for whom she feels no love or affection. I think this is terribly sad.


myLot reputation of 95/100. kareng (3747)   ranked 1,924 out of 12,079 in friend  3 years ago

It is very sad!


myLot reputation of 73/100. AnnieOakley1 (2645)   ranked 1,947 out of 12,079 in friend  3 years ago

Ms.Tickle....
If she (the mother) believes that the adoption agency has done this horrible thing to her, given her a defective child, instead of a healthy one. Um, I know this sounds crude, but is there a warranty? I mean, she must have signed a contract for adoption, right? And, um, do you think she was guaranteed a child free of known health defects? If so, she can sue them and get a replacement. From a purely legal point of view.

But if she was not guaranteed this, in writing, then what would have happened if she had a child of her own and it developed these health problems? I mean, what would she do then? Try to kill it, like she is this one? If she was incapable of dealing with the problems, she would give it up for adoption.

If you have been given a miracle of life, you should accept and love them as they are, or give it away to someone else who can give it the love and acceptance that you cannot. It's that simple. You don't try to kill it with neglect. That is just atrocious.

You don't have to love a child to care for it properly. Give it basic fundamental needs, you know?

So, it would actually be best if Childrens Services did get involved. They would provide counselling, and likely have the child placed with someone that won't neglect it, until they can find it a permanent home that will love it. Or work with the mother to resolve the issues. They usually do everything they can to keep the family unit intact, first and foremost. Their last resort is removing the child permanently.

If this lady has an issue with the adoption, she should either take it up with them directly, or give the child up for adoption herself, since it is obvious she doesn't want it.

So, what about the 8 yr old. How is it okay for her to leave him alone, and even when he needs extra care because he is sick.

Sorry, but I still feel she is UNFIT and she IS TO BLAME, 100%. She is the adult responsible for their care and is subject to the laws governing her area to ensure the safety of BOTH of those children. JMO.


myLot reputation of 95/100. kareng (3747)   ranked 1,924 out of 12,079 in friend  3 years ago

Well said Annie!

Find Lost Family Worldwide DNA family reunification database.  www.dnareunion.org
 
8. myLot reputation of 56/100. dorothyDauphinee (429)   3 years ago

if she is leaving her children unattended i most certainly would think of the children who only have you for protection

Owed Child Support? We Help Frustrated Parents Collect The Child Support They're Due.  www.SupportCollectors.com
 
9. myLot reputation of 97/100. dragon54u (15683)   ranked 1,677 out of 12,079 in friend   3 years ago

I don't know what I would do, you're in a very bad situation. sad

Tell your friend that if she does this again someone will probably report her. Encourage her to get some family counseling before it damages her and her children further. Where is the father? Do you think she doesn't spend time with the little one and that might be why she doesn't talk much? These children sound neglected.

Whatever you do, please try to get her to seek help with her feelings. Those children deserve a better life than they have with her and if she can resolve her feelings it will be better for all of them.

40+ Find a Friend Compatibility Matching from the Inside Out. Meet Affluent Singles !  www.MatureDatingOnly.com
 
10. Patrika952 (85)   ranked 3,224 out of 12,079 in friend   3 years ago

Report her! A disability does not mean neglecting medical care, a fever of 103 needs attention...well I just saw you said 103C, Im not sure what that mean in F though. But if she is neglecting her children than they deserve better treatment. She adopted, therefore she has a responsibility to provide care.


myLot reputation of 88/100. skysuccess (5593)   ranked 3,963 out of 12,079 in friend  3 years ago

Sorry my friend, please compare her previous post against this one before you declare blatantly.

Ref:
http://www.mylot.com/w/discussions/1910862.aspx

It is totally warped and misguiding. Furthermore, the account is quite tainted. No offense here, ronaldinu. I believe truth must be told.


myLot reputation of 92/100. nanajanet (2933)   ranked 1,672 out of 12,079 in friend  3 years ago

skysuccess, what do you mean? I am confused.


Patrika952 (85)   ranked 3,224 out of 12,079 in friend  3 years ago

I am confused as well. I seem to be missing the point that you are trying to make.


myLot reputation of 73/100. AnnieOakley1 (2645)   ranked 1,947 out of 12,079 in friend  3 years ago

Skysuccess...
You have only posted a link the the first discussion that stated that the children were left alone. This one asks if you would report the mother for it.

confusedSo, where do you get;
- tainted?
- misguiding?
- warped?

I think the words that you used may very well apply to you, not ronaldinu.

You have not posted any other 'truth'. We are all interested in the truth, of course. If you want to refute ronaldinu's claims, prove it!

Free Children Software CD Over 50 fun, educational activities & games on incredible CD - Free  FreeSoftwareCD.net
 
sponsors
Online Psychology Degree
Earn a psychology degree online. Accredited. Respected. Affordable.
www.APUS.edu/Psychology

Child Care Services
Need Child Care Services?
yellowpages.com

Find Local Child Care
Find Safe Care for Your Child. Search Local Listings Today.
www.Care.com/childcare

similar discussions
Why does everyone want to parent our children????
I tell you, I consider myself a very good, responsible, loving parent/grandmother...Why do the...
Children's reading development
AS I mentioned before, my daughter is 6 and her whole school year is supposedly below standard in...
What is the rediculous rule(s) at your childs school?
The students are not allowed to miss any school time.. it they show up to class after the bell, it...
Bad mom teaching unethical behavior
That bad mom is me, by the way. Dearra has had a bad headache since Monday night. It's finals...
First child
My first child will be here in 3 weeks and I'm excited. Does anybody got any good advise for a...
When Kids Attack, Will you get angry??
Today we have some of our relatives who came over for a visit. As like always I prepared food and...
Having Kids
I know for sure that I want to have children. I just love the Idea of raising someone and passing...
Would you allow your child to fly alone on an airplane?
My middle child is now 5 years old. His grandparents live in Massachusetts and us in Florida, they...
How many children do you want to have?
When I was young I always dreamed to have 10 children. It may seem outrageous but I always wanted...
my kids ask for a birthday party,how to say no?
I dont luke a aprty cause i am gonna be the one who have to prepare it, and to finish all the mess...
sponsors
Online Psychology Degree
Earn a psychology degree online. Accredited. Respected. Affordable.
www.APUS.edu/Psychology
Child Care Services
Need Child Care Services?
yellowpages.com
Find Local Child Care
Find Safe Care for Your Child. Search Local Listings Today.
www.Care.com/childcare
Find Lost Family
Worldwide DNA family reunification database.
www.dnareunion.org
Owed Child Support?
We Help Frustrated Parents Collect The Child Support They're Due.
www.SupportCollectors.com
40+ Find a Friend
Compatibility Matching from the Inside Out. Meet Affluent Singles !
www.MatureDatingOnly.com
Free Children Software CD
Over 50 fun, educational activities & games on incredible CD - Free
FreeSoftwareCD.net
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.