Help needed with English grammar ... gad but my mother tongue is confusing!  |
| |
| Writing I can do. Obeying the rules of English grammar I can't do. Right now, it's this thing about plurals. I'm writing a review on T Rex helis, and have got to: "But advanced technology has seen a new generation of RC Electric Helicopters that are truly the equal of their big Nitro cousins – and it is headed by the Align T-Rex 600." It catches me out time and time again. "it is headed" - should that be "they are" or is "it is" better? See, it's a new generation, which is singular; but then they are helicopters, which are plural. Or is that 'is plural'? Gaaaaahhhhhh! Help me out here someone please! (I'm thinking a certain gentleman in sunny Worthing may be of use here) | | | | | |
| |
| | Writing a Book Publish, Market and Sell Your Book on Amazon.com and Other Channels. www.CreateSpace.com
| ISBN Textbooks Buy Textbooks Online. Search By ISBN To Get The Best Deals on Textbooks renttext.com
| Learn English Looking For Learn English? Find It Nearby With Local.com! Local.com
|
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
|
|
1. phyrre (1259)
|
3 years ago
| | I'm no grammar expert (which is sad because I'm an English major), but I do believe you have it correct here. "it is headed" should be correct because the 'it' is taking the place of the noun 'generation', am I right? You're saying that the new generation of RC helicopters is headed by that one helicopter? So, I believe it is correct. However, I do hope that someone who is a bit more knowledgeable in the area of grammar can help you. It's always been my weak spot. | | | | | | |
jazzsue58 (1695)
|
3 years ago
| | Thanks for that. It's one of those confusing things that would probably get me kicked out of Constant Content - if I could drum up the courage to submit anything in the first place! | | | |
| |
| Writing a Book Publish, Market and Sell Your Book on Amazon.com and Other Channels. www.CreateSpace.com | add comment | | |
|
|
2. stealthy (4667)
|
3 years ago
| | I agree that you have it right. It refers to generation and "is" is the proper form for that. | | | | | | |
jazzsue58 (1695)
|
3 years ago
| | Thanks. I know the Collins English guide covers it somewhere - but it was easier to come here! | | | |
| |
| ISBN Textbooks Buy Textbooks Online. Search By ISBN To Get The Best Deals on Textbooks renttext.com | add comment | | |
|
|
3. charles63 (142)
|
3 years ago
| | What I would do is substitute "it" with what "it" refers to. So the second part of the sentence would read "and the technology is headed by...". Any confusion is thus avoided. Or you could write "and the helicopters are headed by..." Both versions are grammatically correct, and the reader does not have to track back to the beginning of the sentence to figure out what "it" or "they" refers to. | | | | | | |
| |
| Learn English Looking For Learn English? Find It Nearby With Local.com! Local.com | add comment | | |
|
|
4. Darkwing (7548)
|
3 years ago
| | I would use the singular, "it is", as it pertains to one design, not a number of designs. That's the way I was taught, anyhow. It's one design of one helicopter, rather than a whole group, if you get my drift. Good luck with your review, Sue. I know you can make it. Brightest Blessings, my friend. | | | | | | |
| |
| Become Your Own Publisher Publish, Market, and Sell Your Book with BookSurge, an Amazon Group. www.BookSurge.com | add comment | | |
|
|
5. iheartblogging (488)
|
3 years ago
| | The top poster is correct-- You want to say 'it is'. Don't worry; many many many people have English as a first language mess this up and don't even care. Generation is in fact what the word 'it' is replacing, and the words 'of RC Electric Helicopters' only modify the word 'generation'. Think of it like saying 'A group of dogs'-- even though 'dogs' is plural, you start the whole phrase with the word 'a' because 'group' is singular, so it would be 'A group of dogs is...' In almost any case, if you start the phrase with the word 'a', then you will use 'is'. | | | | | | |
| |
| Untied Shoelaces.NET Great fiction for teens and older. Submit yours. $0.03/word up to $30 www.UntiedShoelacesOfTheMind.com | add comment | | |
|
|
| |
| |
| |
| |