Nursing in Public... An Opportunity for the Dense to Sound Off.... ;~D
By ParaTed2k
@ParaTed2k (22940)
Sheboygan, Wisconsin
September 28, 2009 2:05pm CST
In another post, I started a discussion about governmental infringement of our rights, using legislation making it illegal to make a nursing mother feel uncomfortable. I added a "disclaimer for the dense" because I didn't want the example to become the discussion.
In the sense of fair play and open dialogue, I'm posting THIS article to discuss the nursing in public issue itself.
What the Wisconsin law forgets is that a nursing mother's comfort or discomfort isn't any more or less important that the comfort of everyone around her. It isn't a matter of "if you don't like it, you can leave", because no one should have to leave at all.
When I was a teenager, only a few of us had cars. Some of us willingly became kind of a "taxi" service for our friends who didn't. To me it was not only being nice, but it meant more time to spend with my friends.
Because I often brought friends directly from school to work, or from work to wherever we were going for fun afterwords, it was common for friends to change clothes in my car. I had a 67 Oldsmobile Cutlass (think aircraft carrier :~D) which held 8 of us in front and back bench seats. Friends that were girls could completely change their clothes without exposing any part they didn't want to.
If that is possible, then there is absolutely NO reason a nursing mother can't take care of her baby's needs in the way only nursing can, without calling undue attention to herself. The only reason for doing things that bring attention to herself... because for whatever reason.. she wants the attention.
I am glad that mothers don't feel the need to confine themselves to public bathrooms and their cars when feeding their babies. There was a time when women's bathrooms were designed to allow mothers to feed babies in comfort, but apparently that time is long gone. I remember wondering why women's bathrooms were basically "lounges" while men's bathrooms were all about the business of urination, defication and hand washing.
Over the last couple of decades women's bathrooms have sought equality with mens's bathrooms. In most cases, a nursing mother wouldn't even be able to find a spot in the bathroom should she choose (or be told) to nurse there.
Common courtesy is a two way street. Common courtesy should mean that a mother should feel uncomfortable, dirty or anything else bad for nursing her child in public. Common courtesy would also mean that the mother wouldn't call undue attention to herself while nursing either.
Nursing is a healthy, natural act that has no real downside. On the other hand, nursing isn't a spectator sport, nor is it an excuse for a mother to make a spectacle or herself. While it is wrong for a person to overtly make the mother feel uncomfortable, it is equally wrong for the mother to make those around her feel uncomfortable.
4 people like this
4 responses
@Hatley (163772)
• Garden Grove, California
28 Sep 09
hi this reminds me of fifty years ago when my son was a baby and I was nursing him, I had just returned from the pediatric clinic and was about to nurse my baby when I was admonished to take him upstairs to the ladies room.well the ladies room in this Phoenix bus station was about one hundred degrees as the air conditioning had gone on the fritz.so I went back downstairs, sat down in the air conditioner lobby, fixed myself to nurse and shielded all from anyone';s view with his little blanket. the same nasty man came over and was going to give me a bad time again, when the elderly man seated beside me said the the nasty man, why are you harassing this young woman, she is not showing anything here and if it does not bother us it should damned well not bother you.
No I was not mAking a spectacle of myself, but I did not intend to make my wee baby suffer in one hundred degree heat either,no matter what you squeamish men think. Most mothers dont run around the room yelling oh look at my boobs,look at me,so get off your highhorse. nursing is a natural thing, not something dirty and disgusting.
2 people like this
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
29 Sep 09
btw, this is exactly the kind of attitude that causes the problem. You read an entire post SUPPORTING public nursing, but you latch on to the ONE thing that YOU considered negative.
@smacksman (6053)
•
29 Sep 09
I think your typo may have triggered the response - I think a 'not' is missing?
'... Common courtesy should mean that a mother should feel uncomfortable, dirty or anything else bad for nursing her child in public. ...'

@miamilady (4910)
• United States
28 Sep 09
I'm just wondering...because I LOVE to go off topic...When you all were in that "aircraft carrier". Did any of you feel the urge to moon other drivers as they were passing by?
Where does that fall into the topic of infringing on other peoples rights (and sensibilities).
2 people like this
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
30 Sep 09
I would put mooning in the same category as the mothers who purposely expose themselves while nursing, just for the shock value.
@laglen (19759)
• United States
28 Sep 09
I responded to your previous discussion and I will respond here. I nursed my daughter and did it where ever it was needed. But I was discreet. That is the key. I think nursing a baby is a very natural and wonderful thing, but I still don't want to see it! It falls under fat chicks (me) in a bikini and spandex on anybody!
@ChaoticBeauty (263)
• United States
28 Sep 09
Hi there...
I'm a man, so I don't have the personal experiences you guys do, but I'm with you on the issue. Here in Washington state, moms can nurse anywhere, anytime, anyhow they like, and anyone who admonishes them is out of line. There have even been instances where people have been sued for admonishing a nursing mother. There's nothing wrong with it, as you have said. It's a beautiful natural thing, and I will say the same thing to someone if I witness a mom being told off for this...it's ridiculous our society these days...the democrats had to go and ruin it all...lol...
Anyway, have a good day all...blessings...
1 person likes this



