Anyone for National Service?  |
|
We still have National Service here in Greece from the age of eighteen. I'm interested to hear if other countries still have national service, if you went through it, what it was like. Maybe you went through it in the past, or a male relative did.
So how was it, what was involved, was it good for you, enjoy it or hate it. Give your views on national service please - it should make interesting reading.
| |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
1. diamania (1770) | 1 month ago | We do have it but it is not active at the moment. Meaning that the entire army consists of professionals at the moment. In case there is a demand for more soldiers they can always activate it. I wouldn't get approved for the job though, I guess they would put me behind a computer doing administrative tasks or something, there's now way they can send me to the battle front, I can't even handle a toy gun let alone a machine gun.
| |
| |
|
|
|
|
Senior Affordable Auto Insurance Affordable Auto Insurance for Seniors. Discount Rates at The Hartford. AARP.TheHartford.com | add comment |
|
|
|
|
thea09 (4348) | 1 month ago | Hi fjaril, so basically you know as much about national service as I do but I do know now that Sweeden doesn't have it, mind you you probably don't need it as you don't have oil, and I don't mean olive oil for once. Can't see anyone invading over gloop rights, or DAIM bars come to that. So basically you went to school, lived at home and have the first marriage out of the window.
Of course the navy would have been good for you, all that fresh air and the chance to taste foreign foods. Amazingly my Greek friends who were in the navy are the only Greeks I know willing to even look at foreign food, and it's a good career now out here, we even have a naval university. Then again Greeks and boats do rather go togther as we probably invented them and it was the only way of getting to the town from the fishing village until they invented the road about 50 years ago, other wise it was over the mountain on foot.
| |
|
|
fjaril (4321) | 1 month ago | You are quite the witty lady with tongue in cheek so much and still able to speak so clearly and cleverly! Do you have a Master's in that??
I could, of course, contradict a few points you have made, but then I am no match for you. So I don't.. because I don't have information in my head like you seem to have,, I am not at all sure I can take you on, you see,,and if I told you that one of my passions has been boats, especially mine and I only.. just... a few ... years ago.. sold her.. my last one..
aagh.
| |
|
|
thea09 (4348) | 1 month ago | Well you probably know far more about boats than me Fjaril, so you could win that one. Unless the boat you sold was a fishing boat as I've been in a few of those. I'm also well up on those big tourist boats which people pay exorbitant amounts of money to sit on. Somehow though I don't see you as being Captain of a tourist boat. But what were you doing with a boat on a mountain?
| |
|
|
fjaril (4321) | 1 month ago | thea dearest, I know this will come as such a shock to you and, for that, I am so sorry. But we have had roads through and from and to the mountains here since the beginning of time and thus, and thus, it is very simple to turn the keys in one's ignition and drive down the mountain to the particular harbour where said boat would be lulling in wait of the master.. for yet another marvelous journey in the sun and wind on the blue sea.. aaah
John Masefield said it so well and I loved this poem the first time I ever read it...
I must go down to the seas again, to the lonely sea and the sky, And all I ask is a tall ship and a star to steer her by, And the wheel's kick and the wind's song and the white sail's shaking, And a gray mist on the sea's face, and a grey dawn breaking.
I must go down to the seas again, for the call of the running tide Is a wild call and a clear call that may not be denied; And all I ask is a windy day with the white clouds flying, And the flung spray and the blown spume, and the sea-gulls crying.
I must go down to the seas again, to the vagrant gypsy life, To the gull's way and the whale's way, where the wind's like a whetted knife; And all I ask is a merry yarn from a laughing fellow-rover, And quiet sleep and a sweet dream when the long trick's over.
yeah!!
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
fjaril (4321) | 1 month ago | aaaah.. a virtual hug, dear thea.. I know the feeling well. Once you have felt it, you never ever forget it and it is a rather sort of longing that feels like it was from another life and you have lost it somehow.. It isn't the same but a take a stena line ferry over to Denmark every year, for a break and the feel.. not the same, but it feels good.. to sit on deck with my face to the sun and let the blue of the sea and that of the sky take me to a content place inside me. Do you have such a place also?
| |
|
|
|
United Kingdom Passport Service in US Urgent Experts Handling, On time solutions. Call us for instructions. www.passportdocs.com | add comment |
|
|
|
3. ANTIQUELADY (11248) | 1 month ago | Would u please explain what it is. If we have it, it must be called something else.
| |
| |
|
|
thea09 (4348) | 1 month ago | Sorry Aunty, I didn't realise it went by different names. It is when usually 18 year old males have to sign up for a year in the army without any choice. Hopefully they never see real fighting. We used to have it in the UK but it has been stopped now for many years and it would certainly have brought some structure and discipline into the disaffected boys lives.
| |
|
|
ANTIQUELADY (11248) | 1 month ago | tHAT'S O.K., THEA, QUIT APOLOGIZING TO ME ABOUT EVERYTHING. That is not neccessary., lol. I thought maybe that was what u meant but wanted to be sure. IT'S called the draft here. I don't believe right now guys have to sign up. It use to be where it was mandatory when they turned 18.
| |
|
|
|
ANTIQUELADY (11248) | 1 month ago | I think u are right. National guard is a good thing but it is strictly volunteer service. Hope u have a good day.
| |
|
|
|
Free SelectQuote Life Insurance Quotes Reliable life insurance policy quotes from major carriers www.selectquote.com | add comment |
|
|
|
4. Hatley (20658) | 1 month ago | thea oh yes here in the united States we have the National Guard where young men can sign up and get college credits while serving in peace time, and they are being trained as reservists to go to war if they are called. I do not think we have the thing where they must sign up when they are eighteen anymore, but during the war years all the young men had to sign up when they reached ate 18. My son always managed to miss being drafted as he was always just a few years over the limit then now for the last few years there is no mandatory signing up. But what got me was this horrid war in iraq where so many of our California young men had to go and so many never returned. they never talk about that part of that stupid search for weapons of mass destruction. weapons that never were found, but all the young lives lost can never be retrieved.
| |
| |
|
|
thea09 (4348) | 1 month ago | Hi Hatley, so the National Guard is voluntary not mandatory, I think that's for quite a few years while their education is paid for. I think signing up was compulsory for most in war years. I don't think anyone seriously thought the Iraq was had anything to do with weapons of mass destruction Hatley but the news certainly showed many patriotic Americans supporting the whole thing.
| |
|
|
|
Insurance Coverage For business, auto, home & life. Call us for affordable insurance. mantsch.localplacement.com | add comment |
|
|
|
5. dawnald (9596) | 1 month ago | Military service? Ours is all volunteer, though there has been a draft at times in the past. I never served. My Dad was in the army long, long ago, but no other immediate family members were.
| |
| |
|
|
thea09 (4348) | 1 month ago | Hi Dawn, I can't say we're in the minority yet over here, though we still are the only ones so far that have it, there must be more countries. Here even Greeks who were born abroad are expected to do it if they move here, and a son of a friend is about to join and he came here especially to do it as lived abroad. I think they must be brought up with a strong sense of needing to do it at some point, or maybe they just all like playing with guns.
| |
|
|
dawnald (9596) | 1 month ago | Germany does it. Richard's cousin was telling us all about it.
| |
|
|
|
Josh Vickers Insurance Affordable auto, home & life insurance coverage. Call today. vickers.localplacement.com | add comment |
|
|
|
6. ZephyrSun (3496) | 1 month ago | Is that like some sort of military thing? I know that men in the US have to do something about the draft at the age of 18 but, beyond that I have no idea.
| |
| |
|
|
|
ZephyrSun (3496) | 1 month ago | Actually it's called the selective service and when drafted the male can be thrown into any branch of our military.
| |
|
|
|
autonation Year End Sale Secret Holiday Deals. Pay Below Dealer's Price on Your autonation. CarBuyingDiscounts.com | add comment |
|
|
|
7. debrakcarey (1351) | 1 month ago | Our military is voluntary. But there are perks offered as incentive, like paying for your education. Of course now, with two wars going on, not all the young men get to take advantage of the education. Sad.
It's been my observation that this can be a good thing, but government beauracracy gets in the way...not to mention wars getting in the way. I do think that young men need the structure at that early age. Teaches them to be responsible and accountable. If it works like it should...the best laid plans, you know, don't always turn out as they should.
Pres. Obama has suggested a mandatory plan for madatory community service. Don't know how well this would go over as it seems from my research that it would be used to indoctrinate young people with the governments agenda...and not used for teaching ethics or accountability and responsibility. I would rather see it stay voluntary and actually be a positive force for good. Perhaps if the government was trustworthy, I'd be all for it. You know me, the eternal cynic...anything the government does gets bogged down in paperwork and red tape...and propoganda.
How does it actually work other places? Is it a force for good or just a 'program' that makes things worse and wastes money and lives?
| |
| |
|
|
thea09 (4348) | 1 month ago | Well it was abandoned in the UK hence the growth in yob culture I believe, there's certainly plenty there that could have done with the discipline, but not all of course. I don't see it being abandoned here as we are a small country and don't tend to go around waging wars, but with a long history of occupation, the Turks, the Germans, then of course not actual occupations but unpleasant types in charge like the odd dictator, Greece needs to keep up a strong defence and it does have the positive effect of turning out real men. Men here know it is expected of them to do their national service and even those who have lived abroad come back and do it willingly as the age limit for entrants doesn't stop at 18. One of my friends has a son at the naval university and was in China last year with the navy and does not need to join the military because of that. I think mandatory community service is a bit of a soft option but obviously as the US is usually at war somewhere it is better than compulsory military service. I believe there is a very large proportion of men in prisons there who may have been swayed better by national service than crime if it had been an option.
| |
|
|
|
Young Frankenstein the Musical Don't miss the musical this holiday season! Tickets start at $37 here. Kennedy-Center.org | add comment |
|
|
|
|
thea09 (4348) | 1 month ago | Coudn't agree with you more there Alice, they should make it compulsory for ten year olds there, or their parents. I think that's part of the reason Greek young men seem so much more mature, they don't go invading the streets after a football match, they just lift themselves out of their seats a little and let out a quiet cheer. Any noise and their mamas would be coming along to box their ears, even if they are 42. I really don't know why the UK doesn't bring it back to get the problem element off the streets and some discipline inside them.
| |
|
|
mysdianait (11985) | 1 month ago | I've only just got here and I was about to say exactly the same thing as you Alice. Youths were different heretoo up until national service ended and it would do socety (and them) a power of good if it were to be restored IMO.
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Best Whole Life Insurance Compare Best Whole Life Insurance Quotes from Top Providers & Agents. InsureMe.com | add comment |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
WA Appraisal School Get Your Appraisal License Today. DETC Nationally Accredited. www.RealEstateLicense.com | add comment |
|
|
|
10. vandana7 (1442) | 1 month ago | Hi thea, we dont have it per se. We have something called National Cadet Corps., or NCC. But it is not mandatory. People can join it if they want. Well, I did join it, and they were to teach us horse riding. At that time, my father went abroad, and his sister was my guardian. She didnt agree to send me for horse riding, and that was the end of my dreams. I love horses.:( I think they are lovely and graceful creatures.
| |
| |
|
|
|
|
Washington Nationals Sale Washington Nationals Apparel Sale - Prices Slashed Up to 60% Off. FanaticsOutlet.com/nationals | add comment |
|
|
|
| | Insurance Coverage For business, auto, home& life. Call us for affordable insurance. mantsch.localplacement.com
| Josh Vickers Insurance Affordable auto, home& life insurance coverage. Call today. vickers.localplacement.com
| autonation Year End Sale Secret Holiday Deals. Pay Below Dealer's Price on Your autonation. CarBuyingDiscounts.com
|
|
|
|
|