sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Boy, did Jefferson ever get a bad rap in history.  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 83/100. xfahctor (7620)   ranked 42 out of 3,984 in politics 2 years ago

This stems from a conversation I have been having in another thread on another topic entirely. though this is being written for the benefit of a prticular person, it is important corrective information that needs to be put put there.
Now, it is commonly taught that Jefferson owned slaves. There is no disputing this. It was the "thing" of the time, a time in which not many saw it as evil. what isn't commonly taught it that Jefferson, despite owning slaves early on, was not very comfortable with the practice of slavery, calling it a "moral and political depravity" As time progressed, hebecame more and more openly against it and began acting to end it. So, Lets have a look at some of Jefferson's thoughts on slavery
"Nothing is more certainly written in the book of fate than that these people [blacks] are to be free. Nor is it less certain that the two races, equally free, cannot live in the same government. Nature, habit, opinion has drawn indelible lines of distinction between them."

"Do not mistake me. I am not advocating slavery. I am not justifying the wrongs we have committed on a foreign people... On the contrary, there is nothing I would not sacrifice to a practicable plan of abolishing every vestige of this moral and political depravity."

"Nobody wishes more ardently to see an abolition, not only of the trade, but of the condition of slavery; and certainly, nobody will be more willing to encounter every sacrifice for that object."

"I can say with conscious truth that there is not a man on earth who would sacrifice more than I would to relieve us from this heavy reproach in any practicable way."

"I congratulate you, fellow citizens, on the approach of the period at which you may interpose your authority constitutionally, to withdraw the citizens of the United States from all further participation in those violations of human rights which have been so long continued on the unoffending inhabitants of Africa, and which the morality, the reputation, and the best interests of our country, have long been eager to proscribe."

"There must doubtless be an unhappy influence on the manners of our people produced by the existence of slavery among us. The whole commerce between master and slave is a perpetual exercise of the most boisterous passions, the most unremitting despotism on the one part, and degrading submissions on the other. Our children see this, and learn to imitate it; for man is an imitative animal. . . ."
He then goes on to describe what he believes will be the divine consiquences of slavery...
Indeed I tremble for my country when I reflect that God is just: that his justice cannot sleep for ever: that considering numbers, nature and natural means only, a revolution of the wheel of fortune, an exchange of situation, is among possible events: that it may become probable by supernatural interference! The Almighty has no attribute which can take side with us in such a context. But it is impossible to be temperate and to pursue this subject through the various considerations of policy, of morals, of history natural and civil.
But words alone do not an abolishonist make. So what had he done to back up his beliefs with action? Quite a bit it turns out.
as a young Lawyer, in the case of Howell v. Netherland, he argued that "“we are all born free" and that slavery was contrary to natural law. He lost the case as the courts dismissed his argument.
in 1769, as a virginia state legislator, he helped to draft a bill to allow for “manumission by deed”, a procedure in which slave owners could transfer, by deed, their “property interest” in slaves back to the slaves themselves, setting them free. The bill passed in 1782, and Jefferson who was by then the Governor of the new state –signed it into law that year.
As a member of the federal Congress in 1783-84, Jefferson drafted and submitted to that body a Report on the Government of the Western territories, which Congress enacted into law as the Ordinance of 1784. It provided that “after the year 1800 of the Christian era, there shall be neither slavery nor involuntary servitude . . . otherwise than in punishment of crimes, whereof the party shall have been duly convicted to have been personally guilty” in any part of the United States outside of the original 13 colonies. (does this sound familiar?) The slavery prohibition was deleted by Congress from the final bill... by a single vote as under the Articles of Confederation, which were then in effect, laws could be enacted only if supported by the delegations of seven States.
In his original drafts of the constitution...slavery would have been out lawed as well. The reason it didn't make it in to the final draft was merely an unfortune matter of timing. It seems his latest drafts arrived at the convention too late.
So we plainly see that Jefferson is not the whip cracking barbarin some history books have made him out to be. All that is usualy taught is that early on he owned slaves. What isn't taught is that he found it disgracefull enough to eventualy fight against it.

 

politics
sponsors
jefferson high school
Pass our free online test and receive your graduation package.
JeffersonHighSchoolOnline.com

Local Coupons
1 ridiculously huge coupon a day. Save 50-90% on your city's best!
www.Groupon.com

Super cheap Cover Ups
Cheap Cover Ups at Best-Price.com! Over 6.000 shops& 23 Mil products.
www.Cover-Ups.best-price.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  history, cover ups, jefferson, jefferson not so bad, slavery
 
1. myLot reputation of 51/100. ladybugmagic (896)   ranked 585 out of 3,984 in politics   2 years ago

I am not merely going to concede, X. I will flat out say I was wrong and will give credence to that, having not been able to wait until I got home to read this.

Why was the case Howell v. Netherland dismissed?

And why is Jefferson not being taught about in some schools somewhere?

I will stand, though, by what I said in overall reference to the constitution and government with the quote by Thoreau.

"I cannot for an instant recognize that political organization as my government which is the slave's government also."




myLot reputation of 83/100. xfahctor (7620)   ranked 42 out of 3,984 in politics  2 years ago

I didn't post this to make you concede...it was just something that I got interested in and you just so happened to give me a reason to post it here.
The case wasn't dismissed, what I meant was that the judge summarily dissmissed Jefferson's Arguments, I guess he wasn't as abolishonist as jefferson was.
As for Thoreau, I have some thoughts but don't have time right now to adress them. I will instead just say in general that to blame the constitution for evil government is misdirected. It is merely a document. It would be like blaming a record contract for someone who was listening to the artist on that contract commiting suicide.


myLot reputation of 51/100. ladybugmagic (896)   ranked 585 out of 3,984 in politics  2 years ago

There is a huge difference between a recording artist and the government of the United States. It's a good analogy, but it's apples and oranges.

jefferson high school Pass our free online test and receive your graduation package.  JeffersonHighSchoolOnline.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 75/100. irishidid (3461)   ranked 838 out of 3,984 in politics   2 years ago

Excellent piece, X. There is so much not taught about our history and so much that has been left out, twisted, and flat out denied.


myLot reputation of 51/100. ladybugmagic (896)   ranked 585 out of 3,984 in politics  2 years ago

That is for sure - a lot of homosexuality in well known historical characters has been concealed, and, in some countries, they won't even teach about the holocaust.

This is why I am wondering what made people remove teaching about Jefferson in some schools? I know there are other threads, but I haven't looked at them yet.


myLot reputation of 75/100. irishidid (3461)   ranked 838 out of 3,984 in politics  2 years ago

True. Look up the Irish holocaust and slavery. That's another one that has been swept under the rug or made to look like it never happened.


myLot reputation of 51/100. ladybugmagic (896)   ranked 585 out of 3,984 in politics  2 years ago

Is this what you are talking about?

http://www.irishholocaust.org/home


myLot reputation of 75/100. irishidid (3461)   ranked 838 out of 3,984 in politics  2 years ago

Yes, good find. There are also a number of deniers just as there are deniers of the Jewish Holocaust and other things.


myLot reputation of 51/100. ladybugmagic (896)   ranked 585 out of 3,984 in politics  2 years ago

What hurts more? That it happened, or that people denied it happened? In some cases the denial is because of shame. In other's, it is because people think it was deserved.

The whole thing makes me sick.


myLot reputation of 75/100. irishidid (3461)   ranked 838 out of 3,984 in politics  2 years ago

As tough as it is to think about it is certainly something that should be corrected in the history books and a better understand of where the Irish are coming from.


myLot reputation of 83/100. xfahctor (7620)   ranked 42 out of 3,984 in politics  2 years ago

Being both Irish and pagan...I can attest to all of this. It's why I really don't celebrate St. Patrick's day....other than as a good excuse to drink...lol.

Local Coupons 1 ridiculously huge coupon a day. Save 50-90% on your city's best!  www.Groupon.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 86/100. laglen (7665)   ranked 90 out of 3,984 in politics   2 years ago

X - Thank you for posting this piece on one of my favorite historical figures. I think that the beginning of our country should be concentrated on more in the schools. The bark about and I agree on the importance of each culture and back ground, but I consider this to be a huge part of America's culture and back ground. To understand where we are and why we are, we must look at where we come from.

Looking at the above post, I believe, just backs up what I say. The holocausts are very important to learn so that they are not repeated. Slavery is important for the same reason. "Americanizing" of the "Indians", again, to not be repeated and to understand the development of society.

I agree that Jefferson is mis taught in schools. I have learned more now than what I learned in schools. It pains me to hear that they will take so much out of our history books.

Educate and inform the whole mass of the people... They are the only sure reliance for the preservation of our liberty.
Thomas Jefferson


myLot reputation of 83/100. xfahctor (7620)   ranked 42 out of 3,984 in politics  2 years ago

He is probably one of my favorite historical figures in the U.S. not only did he acomplish alot, his words are often full of timeless wisdom. It was almost as if he was already warning us of the times we see now way, back then.

Super cheap Cover Ups Cheap Cover Ups at Best-Price.com! Over 6.000 shops & 23 Mil products.  www.Cover-Ups.best-price.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 97/100. dragon54u (15679)   ranked 28 out of 3,984 in politics   2 years ago

You'll not see that stuff in a school history book anytime soon, unfortunately. When you can manipulate the written history of a nation, you control the population. I remember reading something like that when I was in school in the 60's. We slowly had our textbooks replaced and each edition left out more and more about the goodness of our founding fathers and the real sacrifices that people made to make this a free democratic republic.

If you want to conquer a country, start by molding young minds.


myLot reputation of 83/100. xfahctor (7620)   ranked 42 out of 3,984 in politics  2 years ago

Yep, and history often starts it's journey down the toilet while it's happening. So just imagine how whitewahsed and twisted it can get after a century.

This Week: Black History This week in Black History Thriller, Tupac, Rosa Parks  thegrio.com/week-in-black-history
 
5. myLot reputation of 62/100. gewcew23 (5064)   ranked 414 out of 3,984 in politics   2 years ago

Xfahctor, you my friend deserve a Klondike bar, heck you deserve the whole box for this piece.


myLot reputation of 83/100. xfahctor (7620)   ranked 42 out of 3,984 in politics  2 years ago

lol! I'll take a jack and coke if you can do that instead..

Now: Cover Ups up to -63% Compare prices and save up to 63% on high quality Cover Ups now!  www.Cover-Ups.best-deal.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 84/100. milkmaid (375)   2 years ago

That Lincoln gets all the recognition! Glory-hound!! (and really, if you look at what freedoms he wanted slaves to have, maybe some of that sterling light fades a bit... )


myLot reputation of 83/100. xfahctor (7620)   ranked 42 out of 3,984 in politics  2 years ago

Lincoln was a tyrant who authroized military tribunals for american dissenters. Not only that, he also wanted to ship every slave back to africa when they were freed. Amazing how history washes everything isn't it.


myLot reputation of 84/100. milkmaid (375)  2 years ago

Well, that old saying "history is written by the winners" is an old saying for a reason. Imagine how different this country would be if even one of our important historical events had turned out differently. Under British control, the founding fathers we lionize would be nothing but traitors. Benjamin Franklin would be seen as some mad scientist, Washington as a power-hungry revolutionary, and Jefferson as some small-town hillbilly lawyer. Just boggles the mind.

New: Cover Ups up to -57% Compare prices now and pay up to 57% less on high quality Cover Ups!  www.Cover-Ups.news72.com
 
sponsors
This Week: Black History
This week in Black History Thriller, Tupac, Rosa Parks
thegrio.com/week-in-black-history

Now: Cover Ups up to -63%
Compare prices and save up to 63% on high quality Cover Ups now!
www.Cover-Ups.best-deal.com

New: Cover Ups up to -57%
Compare prices now and pay up to 57% less on high quality Cover Ups!
www.Cover-Ups.news72.com

similar discussions
Check out history in 1913 and what jobs and money were like
During the great depression we always hear a lot bad, maybe it wasn't so bad after seeing this link...
Does history repeats itself?
How do you see this kind of perspective? Can you tell at least one history that you think repeats...
Favorite Time In History To Study?
What is your favorite time or event in history to study in school? I always enjoyed studying...
Black History Month
February 1st marks the first day of our Black History Month. Do you try to read a book that will...
This day in History
Do you ever read this day in history things? I have an online email sent about this day in history...
A Part of Your History that You Would Like to See Before It Is Gone
Unlike past years, this year I have made a lot of travel plans. One of these trips will be to see...
America the story of US
I love to watch this on history, its very good to understand how america has been discovered...
wealth creation
I would like to be wealthy...In fact very wealthy...For wealth seems to be everything...A good...
Is it bad that I find History painfully boring?
History has never been one of my favorite subjects in school and the only topics I liked were...
Facts and reward
For a long time I thought my reflex to believe blindly that good will overcome evil is only a...
sponsors
This Week: Black History
This week in Black History Thriller, Tupac, Rosa Parks
thegrio.com/week-in-black-history
Now: Cover Ups up to -63%
Compare prices and save up to 63% on high quality Cover Ups now!
www.Cover-Ups.best-deal.com
New: Cover Ups up to -57%
Compare prices now and pay up to 57% less on high quality Cover Ups!
www.Cover-Ups.news72.com
History Books & Journals
Full-text online history books, journals, articles at Questia.
www.Questia.com/History
American History Products
Looking For History Books? Find One With Local.com!
Local.com
D-Day 1944
Richly Presented.Historical Details Come Alive.
www.sspbooks.com
Online Education Gaming
Education Gaming,Tutorials,Learning Material,Math worksheet,Jokes etc
www.tellyquiz.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.