I Just Love Liberal Imagination

United States
December 6, 2011 6:16pm CST
If life truly did imitate art, liberals would inhabit a perfect world. Full stop. We’ve reached utopia. This is my rant about the new Showtime series Homeland – which, by the way, I really enjoy. I think it’s a very well-acted series. I love Mandy Patinkin. He was great in Criminal Minds. Damien Lewis has been one of my favorite actors since his stellar performance in HBO’s Band of Brothers. So this is really one of my new favorite television series. But if you’ve seen it, you know as well as I do that it’s nothing more than liberal imagination run amuck, trying to paint the world as they see it – with Americans, primarily white and privileged, as the terrorists and all Muslims as innocent victims of circumstance. If you thought that Law & Order episode where the guy killed immigrants because he was influenced by reading Glenn Beck books in reverse (or some such nonsense) was wild, then you ain’t seen nothin’ yet! In Homeland, the CIA got word of a pending attack to be carried out by a POW who had flipped. Turns out, it’s true. Two American POWs flipped, one of whom is the unassuming upper middle-class white Damian Lewis. It’s not that white folks can’t be terrorists. They most certainly can. But as the show plays out, you find just how ridiculous the premise is. Sgt. Brody (Lewis) was captured and tortured but eventually loved by the show’s version of Bin Laden, Abu Nazir. Nazir feeds and clothes Brody, gives him a nice home in which to live in and to teach his son English. It’s the good life, and Brody converts to Islam and the like. Then comes what every Vietnam era antiwar protestor gets wood over – a drone attack kills innocent Iraqi children (American military = baby killers) and Brody vows revenge on America. Another terrorist of the show is a haughty white girl who decides she wants to blow America up because her father lived a life of excess in Saudi Arabia. Her Muslim accomplice, her boyfriend, is an unwitting part of her plot, a victim only following her out of love. I understand perfectly that these liberal writers and producers love putting to screen what they believe the world to be. That’s all good and well. But if this show were any more progressive in intent, Obama would screen it every Sunday at the White House. In a supposed show about the war on terror, America’s attempts to stop acts of terrorism carried out by radical mujahideen, we see that America’s soldiers all hate the war, kill babies, treat Muslims horrifically, and that Americans are the real terrorists, especially white people with loving families who witness the atrocities of America. But hey, at least it’s only a fictional TV show. I feel bad that I enjoy watching it. I root wholeheartedly for the CIA to catch and kill the terrorists every episode! But I have a feeling that this show, if picked up for another season, will just drag out the white-Americans-are-the-real-terrorists storyline until it gets as dumb as the last season of The Sopranos. Have you seen this show?
2 people like this
5 responses
• United States
7 Dec 11
I have watched this, and you are correct that it has a liberal point of view. But, I don't think that it's point is that all Muslims are good, and that war is bad. I think does point out that you CAN'T paint everyone with a broad brush, even if some on the right KNOW that you can. The point of this show is that people can have different life experiences, and that things aren't always what they seam. I see that you failed to point out that it isn't totally a liberal bashing show. If it was, Mandy would be the head of the RNC, and working for the CIA, not the DNC
1 person likes this
• United States
8 Dec 11
Mandy is the head of the Democratic party in the show, and in the CIA. They could have just made me the head of the Republican party, and in the CIA, but they didn't. The show is interesting and it does make you think. I personally don't find it all that political, I find it more realist than anything else.
1 person likes this
• United States
8 Dec 11
I find little about the show to be realistic. I only say it's political in the context that what's on the screen is what has been pushed by some on the left for decades: America's soldiers are baby killers, the CIA are all maniacs, soldiers actually hate the war, radical Muslims are really just victims of oppression and aggression, America's law enforcement is discriminatory and cruel, etc. Every one of those things has been on full display in Homeland. Is that really realistic or political opinion? But I also don't want to judge too soon as a whole. It's not out of the realm of possibility that a show like this has many twists and turns - although it has been very predictable for the past four or five episodes, with the only "twist" being Walker. They could write it as Nazir gave up his own son in order to flip Brody, playing the long con, and they could finally start painting a villain as a villain instead of attempting to humanize terrorists--Muslim or otherwise--every single episode. From the gay Saudi who just loves his family and Nazir who deals with Americans killing his family, to Brody and Walker who were sent over there by a backwards nation in America, there have been no "bad" guys in this series. Every terrorist has been painted a victim. To me, that's incredibly political. Right now, the character with the most flaws and fewest endearing qualities is the CIA officer Carrie.
• United States
7 Dec 11
Ah, I didn't point out anything about the show other than what I pointed out. So I'm not sure what you're talking about on that note. But anyway... I don't mind the interpretation; as I said, I enjoy the show. I just find it ridiculous that they went with the Americans-are-the-terrorists and baby-killers angle how they did. They could have been much more imaginative about it and not so intently political. I believe they could have introduced the terrorist characters without going to those 1960s/70s left radical talking point extremes. Thanks for the response.
@Taskr36 (13963)
• United States
13 Dec 11
It could be worse. I remember the show 24, which was already horribly redundant each season. They did a whole season making Blackwater the enemy with them helping evil African warlords invade the US and take over the White House in their bid to become the military of the US. At least in the case of Homeland the plot is believable and more original. I did notice how the Muslims were repeatedly framed as victims, but I've gotten used to that with Criminal Minds, Law and Order, and other popular shows.
1 person likes this
@bunnybon7 (50970)
• Holiday, Florida
7 Dec 11
another way of cutting down our USA!! im so sick of that. it seems like its more and more now since Obama came into office. doesnt that seem strange and suspect? i havent watched it. dont usually watch military shows. good thing we dont have HBO any more. as son would watch and be raoring mad!!
• United States
7 Dec 11
Well, it's fun to tie it in with Obama! But I doubt he has anything to do with it (bummer, dammit! lol). There are many, many cops-n-robbers shows out there with these types of story lines. This is essentially one of them. It's not really a military show per se. If someone had to explain the show quickly: CIA is bad, operating on U.S. soil, with a psychotic person leading the investigation, and the Americans are terrorists, mistakenly killing and blaming Muslims in an effort to thwart terror. It's the left's talking points put to the screen. But I can't stop watching it. Thanks for the response.
@Fortunata (1135)
• United States
7 Dec 11
Lol, how do you know Obama doesn't approve their scripts? Just joking, just joking!!! Don't want Purplepeopleeater foaming at the mouth again, lol!! I've avoided Family Guy for just that reason. Too many political jokes aimed at conservatives. It just gets tiring and tedious, not to mention just down right mean.
• United States
7 Dec 11
Family guy doesn't just make fun of republicans, they make fun of EVERYONE!!!
1 person likes this
@Taskr36 (13963)
• United States
7 Dec 11
I haven't watched the show in a long time, but I do remember them ripping into James Carville and how hideously ugly he was on one episode.
1 person likes this
• United States
7 Dec 11
Yeah, on a quick note, Family Guy is more like Ed Schultz - they're equal opportunity a-holes. But they did lose me after they started going after people's kids. Seth MacFarlane takes his stuff too far. And I don't balk because it's in poor taste, but because I no longer find it funny. Homeland is an entertaining show. I mean, heck, if I decided not to be entertained by anything with a more liberalesque storyline, then I'd have very little to choose from in entertainment. From music to movies, the entertainment industry is more slanted to the left than the news industry. So you gotta kinda ignore that stuff to an extent. Thanks for the response.
@Fatcat44 (1141)
• United States
7 Dec 11
Boy, I am glad that I did not start watching this series. I seem to keep more from cable shows.
• United States
7 Dec 11
I have talked to some people who are really, truly angry at the show. They, like I did, watched the first few episodes and found a good guy in the lead character. And that was the intent of the writers - to paint a killer as a victim whom the audience finds endearing and not ruthless. Me, I just happen to find it cheap and played out. It's not enough for me to stop watching it. I honestly still like the show. It's entertaining. But now it's in my head just how blatantly askew the plot lines are. It's more akin to Harry Potter than anything nonfiction. Thanks for the response.