sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Relationship Semantics   email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 79/100. kavita23 (2188) 6 years ago

Ok, im asking this question just because I need an unbiased opinion on
something. My girl and I fight a lot and much of the time it's
a misunderstanding or miscommunication. Regardless of our problems,
and regardless of hurt feelings (I care about her, so im not
dismissing her feelings, just trying to get an opinion unrelated to
emotion)

If I said "go to hell"

she heard that as literally "drop dead" or "i wish you were dead" or
"i wish you harm physically"

Does her interpretation seem reasonable? Ok, im a guy... just
looking for an opinion maybe from some women. I know it was mean...
I know it wasn't nice...

Why would I ask this question? Well, we fight about semantics like
this all of the time. Take for granted, please, that its not
important what the cause/result of our fight is, I just want an
opinion as to if it makes any sense whatsoever to understand "go to
hell" literally as "drop dead" (like "i wish you were dead"). BTW,
we're both from the US if that makes a cultural difference

 

sponsors
Why Men Lose Attraction
10 Dangerous Mistakes Women Make That Men Find Totally Unattractive
CatchHimAndKeepHim.com

40+ Women Looking For Men
Meet& Date Affluent Older Singles. Everyone is Serious& Screened!
www.MatureDatingOnly.com

Counseling, Therapy
Depression, stress, addiction, life coaching, adults& adolescents
www.april30th.org

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  relationships, love, relationship, argument, anger
 
1. myLot reputation of 74/100. lauriefnp (4173)   6 years ago

I can understand your frustration in this relationship, because you and your girlfriend obviously have differences in how you communicate. You may not mean anything malicious or hurtful when you make a comment, whatever it is- that's just the way you are. If someone said "go to hell" to you, it may not have an impact or any meaning to you. But you have to understand that some people take things more seriously and literally than others, and your girlfriend seems to be one of them. Neither one of you is right or wrong. I suspect that she might tend to read a lot into conversations and maybe she is someone who analyzes everything that is said. If that is so, and you are the opposite, then you may have a real problem due to different personalities and communication styles. The fact that you fight often is a sign of that, I would think.

Personally, I would resent my boyfriend telling me to "go to hell", no matter how I interpreted it. That is a condescending remark, and it would give me the impression that my opinions were not important to you and that I was being dismissed. Try talking and communicating with her about this, in a mature and respectful manner.


myLot reputation of 97/100. rmuxagirl (6855)  6 years ago

I agree. Under no circumstances is it alright for my b/f to tell me to "go to hell." I would be upset and may not talk to him for a while. It's disrespectful to me to say that and like Laurie said, it's very condescending and I would feel like I was being dismissed. Which is probably how your girlfriend is feeling. No matter how she took it still gives off the impression that you're not important to the person who said it.

It is hard to work through communication problems, I'm going through somewhat the same thing with mine man.

Why Men Lose Attraction 10 Dangerous Mistakes Women Make That Men Find Totally Unattractive  CatchHimAndKeepHim.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 98/100. jewel76 (1709)   6 years ago

Your girlfriend might be more sensible than others, and those words hurt her more than they would another person. Before saying those words, try talking. Yelling or calling each other names will never work out, even thought the fights resolve, they will always come back. Me and my husband have never had a serious fight since we are together (4 1/2 yrs)because we communicate well. We don't scream at each other or call each other names. When i see he gets too agitaded and that fight might emerge if i answer back, i wait a bit, let him cool off, and then talk about it. I must admit, i have a very smooth temper and a lot of my friends ask how the hell i do it to remain calm and not fight. I don't really know, maybe because my parents always used to fight (scream, call each other names) and ended up divorcing, so i tell myself by avoiding the fights we will be safe? I don't know, but one thing's for sure, talking will always be better than saying mean things and yelling. At least, if you let her cool off, when you talk to her about it after, you'll have time to think about what you'll tell her, and not scream things you didn't mean. Good luck!


myLot reputation of 98/100. sweetgirl_k1 (3428)  6 years ago

I totally agree!!


myLot reputation of 40/100. yogesh66 (859)  6 years ago

if one were to look at history ,there are so many referense to "hell on earth"......of course we can list a zillion oppressions(religiously, politically, etc.) and may work focus on this "living through hell"
so, when i say "go to hell", can i not be saying "stay here"

or even better," stay here because i want to buy you something pretty"?

40+ Women Looking For Men Meet & Date Affluent Older Singles. Everyone is Serious & Screened !  www.MatureDatingOnly.com
 
3. dhayang2 (24)   6 years ago

just as simple,if you want your relationships last,just be patient,remember: always respect and love your partner to have a lasting relationship!

Counseling, Therapy Depression, stress, addiction, life coaching, adults & adolescents  www.april30th.org
 
4. myLot reputation of 42/100. lucsct (266)   6 years ago

I do agree that "go to hell" was a bit harsh (and I don't even believe in hell!). While I can understand her being upset, I don't really think it should be to the point where she thinks you actually want her to be harmed in some way.

When I say or hear the phrase "go to hell" it registers in my mind simply as "get out of my face" "don't talk to me" "leave me alone." It never goes beyond that.

I'm a woman, by the way.

Top Relationship Advice Expert Relationship Advice. 5 Free Tools & Relationship Advice.  www.havetherelationshipyouwant.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 93/100. SViswan (5864)   6 years ago

Well, if it bothers your partner so much, you better stop and use some other phrase or sentence to make her understand what you mean. Being a woman I can understand your partner's stand and having a husband who doesn't see why I shouldn't take everything he says (especially stuff like 'Go to hell'), I understand your stand. But frankly, it does affect most women (if not all). You know that's how she takes it...so try out something else. I wish my husband would do that and I'd be the happiest person in the world (with all our fights included)

Relationship Anger? Attend Classes In So. Ca. before it is too late!  http://www.angercoach.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 97/100. limosonia1 (1231)   6 years ago

I give you guys credit. Women are probably the hardest people to deal with and I am one of them. One my husband and I fight I also do that. I guess we are so use to reading between the lines. Were as men are more straight forward and don't really mean anything more than what they said. We tend to add more to things than what you really ment. In the end we realize you didn't actually mean that. If you truly love the person you are with. Communication is very important when you aren't fighting and letting yourself calm down while fighting is the best. We don't fight fair. Remember that and what ever comes out of your mouth my truly get you in trouble even if you didn't mean it that way. Also remember things forever. Good luck

Local Coupons 1 ridiculously huge coupon a day. Save 50-90% on your city's best!  www.Groupon.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 56/100. jo0911 (114)   6 years ago

Communication is one of the main ingredients of longer lasting relationships... maybe you should talk directly to your girl about these problems. Open communication is recommend...

Extraordinary New Novel Will young Adolf Hitler's love affair change the course of History?  www.YoungAdolf.com
 
8. myLot reputation of 83/100. natuser28 (772)   6 years ago

You two sound like your to immature for each other. Judging by this post, you are to young to be in a relationship. You two should be just dating. You, as a matter of fact should be dating lots of girls and don't worry about connecting with girl. Gain more experience, confidence and girls will fock to you.

Counseling-Therapist-LCSW Convenient Appointments with 20 yrs exp LCSW, Couples Individual, EAP  kijak.net
 
9. myLot reputation of 67/100. ecpunzalan (387)   6 years ago

well if you are in an argument, whether you mean it or not it will come so negative that it will start a new fight. why not chose a different phrase or something that will not be taken literaly. girls are emotional, she probably know that you dont mean "drop dead" but if you can say bad things to her she would think what else can he do to me? what else would he say next? it hurts... that you have to understand...


fights
Just Break Up? Free Video Reveals How To Win Back Your Ex-Girlfriend & Devoted To You  ExRecoverySystem.com
 
10. myLot reputation of 87/100. prawiner (338)   6 years ago

You have to control your emotions, practice yoga or meditate so that you can control your mind and anger. You will behave the way have been, so try to change the behavior, be patient, be kind to people.

Online Dating Service Tons of pics of singles waiting for you online. Find your love now.  LavaPlace.com
 
sponsors
Top Relationship Advice
Expert Relationship Advice. 5 Free Tools& Relationship Advice.
www.havetherelationshipyouwant.com

Relationship Anger?
Attend Classes In So. Ca. before it is too late!
http://www.angercoach.com

Local Coupons
1 ridiculously huge coupon a day. Save 50-90% on your city's best!
www.Groupon.com

similar discussions
Would you advise a friend to be in a new relationship after a break-up?
To be able to forget a relationship that've gone wrong? I had a friend who had broke up with her...
Do you believe that first love never dies?
It has been ages ago since I had my first love. But through the years, I still feel something for...
Some say that the best way to leave someone you love is to find another.
The mind tells you that you are wrong for each other but the heart says you are still in love. Is...
Where are the single good guys?
It's valentines again, this season tends to make the most sensible person into a lunatic especially...
Is it possible for a korean to marry a Filipino?
KOreans are everywhere now in the Philippines. And I do know some Filipino girls are in a...
Is a relationship between a young guy and wolder woman bad? and why?
Do you think a cougar relationship in which the woman is 10 years older than the guy is wrong?...
the prince charming syndrome
Ok so after watching episde after episode of daytime talk shows im wondering if women are...
To the single ladies! :))
I've come across a friend issue about her love life. That how come almost all of you set of friends...
when is it ok for a man to hit a woman
what are examples of situations for it to be ok for a man to hit a woman
is falling inlove to a younger guy is good or bad?
Cougars are now accepted in the world however, being a cougar takes a lot of responsibilities. Is...
sponsors
Top Relationship Advice
Expert Relationship Advice. 5 Free Tools & Relationship Advice.
www.havetherelationshipyouwant.com
Relationship Anger?
Attend Classes In So. Ca. before it is too late!
http://www.angercoach.com
Local Coupons
1 ridiculously huge coupon a day. Save 50-90% on your city's best!
www.Groupon.com
Extraordinary New Novel
Will young Adolf Hitler's love affair change the course of History?
www.YoungAdolf.com
Counseling-Therapist-LCSW
Convenient Appointments with 20 yrs exp LCSW, Couples Individual, EAP
kijak.net
Just Break Up?
Free Video Reveals How To Win Back Your Ex-Girlfriend & Devoted To You
ExRecoverySystem.com
Online Dating Service
Tons of pics of singles waiting for you online. Find your love now.
LavaPlace.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.