sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

15-Year-Old from Germany Jailed for Skipping School. Isn't that crazy?  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 634 out of 26,920 in people 6 years ago

A 15-year-old girl from the German town of Goerlitz will be jailed for two weeks as punishment for persistently skipping classes, the education ministry for the eastern state of Saxony has said.
The ministry said the decision was made by a district court and came after the girl's parents failed to pay a fine and the girl herself refused to do community service.
I think it is crazy. I am wondering how many days in jail would spend kids from some of american public schools?

 

people
sponsors
Online High School
Get Your High School Degree Online. Don't Wait. Learn More Now!
HighSchoolDiploma.net

alternative school
Pass our free online test and receive your high school diploma now.
JeffersonHighSchoolOnline.com

Find After School Sitters
Thousands of Sitters Available. Sort by Experience, Rates,& More!
www.Care.com/babysitter

Debs_place (6749) response was accepted on 2/23/2007.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  school, jail, education, kids, punishment
 
1. myLot reputation of 87/100. michelledarcy (4379)   ranked 1,201 out of 26,920 in people   6 years ago

I think that is a silly punishment, the girl gets to be off school even longer, which is probably what she wants.
In this country if kids play truant its the parents who have to take responsibility and they can be fined and sent to prison for it. I think this is better as parents should take responsibility for their children and make sure they do the right thing.


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 634 out of 26,920 in people  6 years ago

yes, probably she doesn't want to be in school.


myLot reputation of 27/100. ajradical (179)  6 years ago

hell yeah!

I've experienced skiver kids. they're stupid, they aren't even skipping school because they don't like it.

but still she's skipping school now for sure lol, she should just be made to go to EXTRA SCHOOL!!


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 634 out of 26,920 in people  6 years ago

smart..


myLot reputation of 95/100. zeloguy (2397)   ranked 2,438 out of 26,920 in people  6 years ago

Someone in the US is 'bad' in school. They start a fight, bring a knife to school to show his buddies, acts up, etc... and what happens?

They get EXPELLED. NO MORE SCHOOL FOR YOU!!!

What the heck is that? I understand detention, but kicking someone OUT of school for not wanting to be there in the first place?

Online High School Get Your High School Degree Online. Don't Wait. Learn More Now!  HighSchoolDiploma.net
 
2. myLot reputation of 97/100. mom2chriskel (988)   ranked 4,994 out of 26,920 in people   6 years ago

Actually, I believe here it is the parents who would go to jail for not making sure the kid was at school.

Maybe the parents honestly didn't care. I can tell you the first few times my child skipped school, I may let it slide because I skipped school once or twice but enough days to get fined and my child would have been in trouble.


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 634 out of 26,920 in people  6 years ago

That's right.


zhar00001 (10)  6 years ago

Its certainly not the parents fault, and it shouldnt be such a big deal. But to go as far as "court" with this... Its simply rediculous. But if thats the law, then thats the law.


myLot reputation of 97/100. Debs_place (6749)   ranked 197 out of 26,920 in people  6 years ago

I had a friend, with a ddaughter was ddoing the same thing, she was already going to therapist.

At first, he was going to work, after he work her up for school. SHe rolled over went to sleep.

Then he worked from home, got her up, made sure she got dressed and out to the bus stop, then he went to work. Found out as soon as he left, she walked away from the bus stop.

He then drove her to school. He watched her go in the school. She walked in one door and out the other.


After htis the therapist suggested tough love, strip her room, give her a mattress, no sheets, a pillow, no pillowcase and a blanket. She was allowed out of the room for school and the bathroom.

If she went to schooland stayyed for 1 day she got sheets, she wnet to school for 2 more days, she got a chair, for 2 more days, she got a light, 2 more days she got a desk.

If she went to school for 1 solid week after that she earned 1 hour of TV time a day.

If she back slid she lost her priviledges. She knew what she had to do to get each item.

He drove her to school for 2 weeks, before she stayed in for 1 day. the next day she cut....do you get the picture.

This man did everything he could.

How could you punish him any more, believe me, he as a good father, he was so upset, everyday at wokr I heard about her antics.

DId I mention that as she walked through the school, she would get some drugs fromher friends to use on the 4 mile walk home?


myLot reputation of 97/100. Debs_place (6749)   ranked 197 out of 26,920 in people  6 years ago

I had a friend, with a ddaughter was ddoing the same thing, she was already going to therapist.

At first, he was going to work, after he work her up for school. SHe rolled over went to sleep.

Then he worked from home, got her up, made sure she got dressed and out to the bus stop, then he went to work. Found out as soon as he left, she walked away from the bus stop.

He then drove her to school. He watched her go in the school. She walked in one door and out the other.


After htis the therapist suggested tough love, strip her room, give her a mattress, no sheets, a pillow, no pillowcase and a blanket. She was allowed out of the room for school and the bathroom.

If she went to schooland stayyed for 1 day she got sheets, she wnet to school for 2 more days, she got a chair, for 2 more days, she got a light, 2 more days she got a desk.

If she went to school for 1 solid week after that she earned 1 hour of TV time a day.

If she back slid she lost her priviledges. She knew what she had to do to get each item.

He drove her to school for 2 weeks, before she stayed in for 1 day. the next day she cut....do you get the picture.

This man did everything he could.

How could you punish him any more, believe me, he as a good father, he was so upset, everyday at wokr I heard about her antics.

DId I mention that as she walked through the school, she would get some drugs fromher friends to use on the 4 mile walk home?

alternative school Pass our free online test and receive your high school diploma now.  JeffersonHighSchoolOnline.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 98/100. rainbow (3926)   ranked 506 out of 26,920 in people   6 years ago

I think this is going a little far, she is still a child and teenagers are noticably stubborn, do they really think this will get her back in school? Think of all the bad things she could learn in a young offenders place, she'll come out with new skills, new friends, new ideas and possibly less intention than ever of going to school.


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 634 out of 26,920 in people  6 years ago

This is what I was thinking....nothing good for this girl


myLot reputation of 98/100. rainbow (3926)   ranked 506 out of 26,920 in people  6 years ago

In England they have discussed the parents going to prison but I'm not sure if it's enforced yet, luckily my boys are not old enough to skip school yet...


appleapple (30)  6 years ago

I agree with you.For a kid,is it helpful for her to put her in prison?
of course not.
If that's useful and helpful,many kids in China will be put into prison.Now in the countryside,many kids can't go to school because their parents have no money.therefore,how should the Chinesed government do ?

Find After School Sitters Thousands of Sitters Available. Sort by Experience, Rates, & More!  www.Care.com/babysitter
 
4. myLot reputation of 70/100. mbarryton (1427)   ranked 5,231 out of 26,920 in people   6 years ago

ive never heard of the child ever going to jail over something like that. thats totally crazy. however i do know that a parent in the US well get sent there if they kids lay outta school to much because i was pretty close once :(


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 634 out of 26,920 in people  6 years ago

this is first time I heard about someone going to jail for missing school.

Earn an EdD & Credentials Doctor of Education (EdD) Programs for Busy Educators! 100% Online.  EducationDegreeSource.com/Free_Info
 
5. myLot reputation of 94/100. Dolcerina (2026)   ranked 1,361 out of 26,920 in people   6 years ago

Yes it is crazy. I do not understand it, because a child (in my country) must attend school until the age 14. If the parents does not give her the possibility to attend school, the guardian service or institute or office (sorry I can not translate it) take away the child from the parents.
I think that is another kind of law. So the parents may not get penalty first of all.... The guardian must have done something.


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 634 out of 26,920 in people  6 years ago

I think in Germany is mandatory to finish high school.


myLot reputation of 94/100. Dolcerina (2026)   ranked 1,361 out of 26,920 in people  6 years ago

Oh my God! I believed it happened in a special "close-german" city in your country.
I am sorry but it is a stupidness, do not belive this! LOL It can not happen in Europe!


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 634 out of 26,920 in people  6 years ago

We don't have "closed German city" in america.
Görlitz is a small an lovely city in Germany whose origins go back to 1017. It is located approximately 200 km south of Berlin, it lies at the border with Poland and very close to Prague.


myLot reputation of 94/100. Dolcerina (2026)   ranked 1,361 out of 26,920 in people  6 years ago

I know the german city it is correctly Görlitz. (There is a factory which I transported from.) But I do not understand how can you belive this stupidness. I wonder where have you heard it...


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 634 out of 26,920 in people  6 years ago

It was all over Internet. Look in Dresden news.


myLot reputation of 94/100. Dolcerina (2026)   ranked 1,361 out of 26,920 in people  6 years ago

this article is from a southern african news site! Do not belive everything you hear or read from the media. I can belive it if I read it on a german site.
Anyway congratulation, you received lots of comments for this news. This how media works too.


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 634 out of 26,920 in people  6 years ago

First:
I don't read South African news.
Second:
I do read Reuters and Scotsman news and they have really good reputation.
call London: Tel: 0207 961 0200 and talk directly to media people.
Last:
Stop this insult.

Groupon 50-90% Off Deals The perfect fix for a groggy morning: a 50-90% off deal in your inbox!  www.Groupon.com/Sign-Up
 
6. myLot reputation of 94/100. jbrooks0127 (1867)   ranked 3,026 out of 26,920 in people   6 years ago

While i agree this is way over the top you do have to admit it would get thier attention. I would think there must be a better way to do that however.

If that occured in the United States can you imagine the public uproar it would cause. We think IRAQ was bad we woouldn't hear about it until this was reasolved.

I am not sure that is good. Way to many children raise themselves these days. This could get real bad here.


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 634 out of 26,920 in people  6 years ago

agree...however if someone is good student, wouldn't matter..

School Looking For School? Find It Nearby With Local.com!  Local.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 81/100. Idlewild (4769)   ranked 1,774 out of 26,920 in people   6 years ago

Actually it makes sense to me--she wasn't jailed for just not going to school; she kept missing school, she was ordered to do community service and refused; her parents were fined and didn't pay. So it's not just the skipping of school. But maybe they should put the parents in jail instead.


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 634 out of 26,920 in people  6 years ago

she should take community service...

Get College Degree Quick Advance Your Career with Online College Degree. Financial Aid OK!  AcceleratedDegree.com/College
 
8. SarahLynn (63)   6 years ago

Well i can honestly say i was thrown in juvinile hall for truency for 2 1/2 weeks but we still had school classes there...Maybe she is just bored with school and the lessons..That was my problem anyway...Anyway i know alittle about through personal experiance..


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 634 out of 26,920 in people  6 years ago

school is not always funn...


SarahLynn (63)  6 years ago

i didn't say i didn't have fun...I said i was bored with all the teachings

New: Jail up to 57% less Find Jail deals at bargain prices: Compare offers and save up to 57%!  www.news72.com/Jail
 
9. myLot reputation of 76/100. Goranimal (266)   6 years ago

Thats not crazy at all, if we did that here in the usa
we wouldn't be plagued with teen morons.
And i'd love to see at least one of the parents in the cell right next to her. If your that pitiful of a parent that you cant control your child to go to school then the parent needs to be right along side them.


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 634 out of 26,920 in people  6 years ago

I agree with "teen morans" in USA...


xiohexia7 (37)  6 years ago

i also agree with the "teen morons" comment, personally all stupid ppl should either grow some brains, or get drafted into the military.


myLot reputation of 99/100. cutepenguin (4879)  6 years ago

umm...if you draft all of the stupid people into the military, doesn't that mean that you'd be giving the stupid people guns?

Find Top Schools Compare Top Online Schools & Find the Best Match for You!  www.ClassesUSA.com
 
10. myLot reputation of 81/100. ryanwelsh (151)   ranked 17,341 out of 26,920 in people   6 years ago

I do not think this is a silly punishment because if the kid does not get punished she will continue doing it. Justice has to be served without exeptions as everyone used to go or still goes to school so the girl should not be any differant.


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 634 out of 26,920 in people  6 years ago

yes, silly punishment

Art Design Classes Interested In Graphic Design? Get Professional Art Training Online Now.  graphicdesignbasics.com
 
sponsors
Earn an EdD& Credentials
Doctor of Education (EdD) Programs for Busy Educators! 100% Online.
EducationDegreeSource.com/Free_Info

Groupon 50-90% Off Deals
The perfect fix for a groggy morning: a 50-90% off deal in your inbox!
www.Groupon.com/Sign-Up

School
Looking For School? Find It Nearby With Local.com!
Local.com

similar discussions
Lessons my Teachers Never Taught me in School
Do you have some lessons in life that your teachers never taught you in school? I believe all of us...
Laptops in class
I went to a high school where students were allowed to have laptops in class but Facebook had been...
Have new school bus or have local school?
Thanks to the "one child policy" in China, now there are fewer children than 20 years ago. So many...
Is the number of years you spend in school determine how much you KNOW?
Let's say you're having a conversation with someone from a different country who was educated...
what are the do's and don'ts of poetry interpretation??
Our school joined a certain regional contest and one of the events was poetry interpretation. Our...
Ipad or Not to Ipad, That is the Question.
Where i live there is a debate whether schools should buy ipads for their students. Of course, the...
Its GOOD to acknowledge when your child does well in school.!!!!..
My grandson's school took students from the school for a outing yesterday...They went to a mall...
I want to study in UP DILIMAN
I just want to have the best college education for me, the best college life I can ever imagine. I...
Is your child a devil at home, but an angel at school?
Just wondering if anyone else's kids are like this. All three of my daughters excel or excelled at...
do you really think that eduacation is the only way to be successful?
nowadays almost everyone go to school, do you really think that education is the only way to...
sponsors
Earn an EdD & Credentials
Doctor of Education (EdD) Programs for Busy Educators! 100% Online.
EducationDegreeSource.com/Free_Info
Groupon 50-90% Off Deals
The perfect fix for a groggy morning: a 50-90% off deal in your inbox!
www.Groupon.com/Sign-Up
School
Looking For School? Find It Nearby With Local.com!
Local.com
Get College Degree Quick
Advance Your Career with Online College Degree. Financial Aid OK!
AcceleratedDegree.com/College
New: Jail up to 57% less
Find Jail deals at bargain prices: Compare offers and save up to 57%!
www.news72.com/Jail
Find Top Schools
Compare Top Online Schools & Find the Best Match for You!
www.ClassesUSA.com
Art Design Classes
Interested In Graphic Design? Get Professional Art Training Online Now.
graphicdesignbasics.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.