“Women take better decisions based on intuition.;men take better decisions on

@kalav56 (11464)
India
August 16, 2010 6:41am CST
“Women take better decisions based on intuition.; men take better decisions on observation”--this was a dialogue I heard yesterday in a film. Do you think so?. What are your views and observations regarding this?
6 people like this
17 responses
@dpk262006 (58679)
• Delhi, India
16 Aug 10
Hi Kala! I agree with this observation. Sometimes, it so happens that my better half takes better decisions than me, which are based on her intuition. If I have to take a decision, I will normally don't go by intuition, rather, I would apply all my experience and logics to arrive at a decision.
1 person likes this
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
16 Aug 10
It is said that women do have this intuitive skill Deepak.But I think, it helps to couple our observations too.Actually,and thta too on specific occasions, our intuition would itself be based on a set of observations recorded on the subconscious.We ourselves may not be able to pinpoint it but it may be there.
@dpk262006 (58679)
• Delhi, India
17 Aug 10
Kala- I agree with you that women do have intuitive skills and I have experienced the same. Undoubtedly, past observations stored in the subconscious mind also help.
@vandana7 (102698)
• India
16 Aug 10
Babyface, if I may ask, how often is that sometimes?
@jaiho2009 (39140)
• Philippines
16 Aug 10
hello dear, I think Yes,some women believe and listen with their intuition,as it is called women's instinct. With some situations it can be applied esp when it comes to family matters involving her family,loved ones to top the most,her kids. Men could be too observant becoz they don't possess the instinct that we woman possesses. But,women always had the best idea and decision making (oh men,comment on this)using intuition and observation. Have a good day always dear
1 person likes this
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
16 Aug 10
Hi jaiho1 Good to see you here. It is true that we do take inuitive decsions and have a peculiar feeling at times with regards to decisions. We have been blessed with too many connections in our brain[our wiring is such].
@jaiho2009 (39140)
• Philippines
16 Aug 10
@Jo, that's my daughter dear...my only daughter
@Jotomy (6322)
• India
16 Aug 10
hi jai, you are looking so beautiful.
@riyasam (16556)
• India
16 Aug 10
i am not so sure of this,i agree with the womens part,i think men donot take unneccessary headaches and leave the decision making to women..
1 person likes this
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
16 Aug 10
Hi dear! Thanks for the participation.What you say is true. Times have changed and women are also exposed to the world and get into interactions with outsiders thus honing their skills of observation.
@drannhh (15219)
• United States
16 Aug 10
I think that within each gender we have the same or at least very nearly similar capacity for action, but that because of the leanings of the different societies around the world, men and women grow toward certain tendencies, some more than others. So some men might be more intuitive than some women but other men might be better observers. It is true than in my 40-plus year marriage my late husband taught me to be a better observer and I taught him how to act more on his own intuition. But I think both men and women need to work hard to improve both their observation and their intuition and both can learn either. Where I live it is encouraged that women be more intuitive and less material and for men it is the reverse, so in order to change that stereotype we both have to swim upstream in our thinking. It takes moral courage to do this.
1 person likes this
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
17 Aug 10
There has been a change in society too in the recent past drannh and women are also given lot of exposure,they get to mingle with many and this naturally enables them to learn better survival skills.But, men and women do need to work hard to achieve a balance. I do agree with what you say. Thanks a lot for the response.
@vandana7 (102698)
• India
16 Aug 10
Me not agreeable!! I tried intuitive stuff in stock markets and I failed so no, observation is a must both ways!!! That is just a dialogue written by somebody who was unemployed a few years ago, and is perhaps less educated than you and me. Forget it!!
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
17 Aug 10
Definitely; Balance is always needed. I am racking my brains but I am unable to remember where I read that instinct or intuition is an outcome of a collection of experiences. As I had said elsewhere, we women tend to store far too many things in our memory and this helps at times.Too many insignificant things also ruin us causing clutter but it has its benefits.THat is why we are very quick thinkers.
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
17 Aug 10
Hi Vandana! Thanks for the participation. If you read my comment ot Kiran and her counter comment you would understand thta our intuition is itself a culmination of a set of subconsciously registered observation.Stock market is a study Vandana.Intuition here to is based on collective experiences, observations and knowledge.
@vandana7 (102698)
• India
17 Aug 10
I agree. But may be we are such quick thinkers in some matters that we can come up with solutions in fraction of seconds, that is why it gets labeled as intuition. :) But to be honest, I think there has to be a balance somewhere between the two!!!
@allknowing (153529)
• India
16 Aug 10
I would not like to compartmentalise this as I have seen different patterns in my family. I would rather say that everything depends on the exposure/need of the individual to play the role of either an observer or be carried away by intuition.
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
16 Aug 10
If you read my comment to the previous response you would find that I have also written the same thing becasue it varies from person to person.In this particular film it was a sweeping remark in the context. Do you know Tamil?
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
16 Aug 10
It is true. When people are forced to mingle with many[in contrast to olden days where women were designated a role only at home]the attitude also changes. Finally, everything goes back to one'e exposure and aptitude to observe and take decisions.
@allknowing (153529)
• India
16 Aug 10
No kala. I do not know Tamil. I did not read your comments. When there distinct roles as in the past perhaps one could put men and women in different compartments. Not any more. Both men and women are exposed to activities which were hitherto gender based. And with this exposure it is ultimately the individual that gets classified.
@narayan2006 (2954)
• India
16 Aug 10
I too think in the similar line. It is believed that women possess strong intuitive power and their decisions are frequently more based on intuition rather on objective analysis.It is said that power of intuition are mostly linked to one's heart rather to one's mind. It seems that women are more led by their heart than by their mind in taking decision. It might be a special gift of nature to women who seems to have the capacity to foresee the future consequences of their actions more correctly and decide accordingly. Thanks.
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
17 Aug 10
Actually I tend to think that this 'intuition' in women is itself a manifestation of their collective observations at various points of time.So, they do it fast.THey store umpteeen data in their memory ,you see,significant or insignificant
• India
17 Aug 10
I really don’t know Kala and am quite confused myself as to how I reply to this. Firstly see, women have been confined to their homes and immediate family and friends for centuries now while men have roamed the world and interacted with strangers at every level. Personally I feel such lifestyles over a prolonged period have their impact on the thought processes of men and women. I don’t know whether you’ll agree on not, but I feel that when we (women) are amongst family and friends and have to do the same things day in day out, we somehow let our guard down…we are no longer that cautious, that observant. We grow up amongst pre-determined situations with pre-determined responses and even before we think, we tend to come to conclusions. However, for men its an entirely different scenario. Having dealt with strangers and hostile situations for ages, they have naturally become more observant, circumspect and wise in most of their decisions. This is not to generalize everybody, but this is what I feel.
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
17 Aug 10
I feel different about this sudipta.I agree that men are more observant in many aspects but regarding this intuition and decisions made on intuitive thinking I feel it is due to a colelction of some experiences recorded in our subconscious. As I was writing in the course of the discussion, we tend to store plenty of trivia [sometimes to our peril]in our memory and this comes in useful at times. But, at the same time I also feel that if the situation needs some cold logic we may fail because occasionally [I don't know how to explain it and I don't know if you have felt it]some impulses, signals, get recorded [this is with people and our interactions].So, some decisions may prove wrong if we had attributed too much to nothing, making a mountain of a molehill.
• United States
17 Aug 10
I think it is Bullsh!t. Not All women just do things without thinking. And Not All men look and reason out things before they do things. How you decide to do things is different for everyone.Last time I checked I was female and I Always think what I should do Before I do it. And once I decide to say No , that means the answer will remain No. With that said i do believe in Intuition. Not "woman's intuition" It is unisex. Either gender can and does have it. If you listen to it That can help you decide. But to assume that All women use Only intuition is Bullsh!t.
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
17 Aug 10
Hi ! It is not that women use only intuition. We cannot categorise like that and I feel that this intuituion is itself a collection of experiences and observations recorded in our subconscious.THanks for the response.
1 person likes this
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
17 Aug 10
Of course there is no doubt about it.We are all thinking human beings and both cases are always there.
1 person likes this
• United States
17 Aug 10
I think it is sexist to think Only women use intuition. Men use it too.
1 person likes this
@vijayanths (7877)
• India
16 Aug 10
Hi, Kala, Better decisions can be made only from careful analysis and research. Of course women seem to have better intuition powers. But I will not make a decision by a mere intuition. Surprisingly the more I research and decide higher are my failures But I never give up my researches before making decisions.
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
16 Aug 10
I totally agree with you Vijaynths.Any decision must be taken after serious thought, and research.Failures and successes are not in our hands. Thsi dialogue was in the film yesterday "Parthiban Kanavu'.
@vandana7 (102698)
• India
16 Aug 10
Hi vijayanths, I think intuition, coupled with observation is the key. Neither of the two can be effective without the other.
@dawnald (85137)
• Shingle Springs, California
20 Aug 10
I use both, but I am way more logical than most people, including many men. I think it just depends on the person.
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
21 Aug 10
Very true.It varies from person to person..And whether it is a man or woman, soemtimes it is also a matter of training to be logical.
@paula27661 (15811)
• Australia
17 Aug 10
I think that a lot of women base their decision on careful observation too but females are known for being more intuitive than men although there are exceptions to every rule. My husband has made many important decisions from ‘the heart’ as he describes it and they have been the right ones. He relies on intuition while considering every possible outcome so it is a combination of psyche and intellect. As for me, I rely on my sixth sense most of the time but I don’t always listen to it and that is where I have been known to go wrong!
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
17 Aug 10
I too felt the same way Paula that intuition is itself a culmination of a set of observations and feelings recorded in our subconscious. It is always great to hear from you. How is your daughter?
@kiran8 (15348)
• Mangalore, India
16 Aug 10
Thats very true kala, intuition sometimes works better than any practical logic.i have had many such experiences where I have had this feeling that things may not work but went ahead because of pressure or advise from others and my gut feeling was always right.It is based on so many things that it is difficult to explain it...what are your feelings kala ? what do you say on the subject?
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
16 Aug 10
Hullo Kiran! our intuition would itself be based on a set of observations recorded on the subconscious.We ourselves may not be able to pinpoint it but it may be there.This is what I feel Kiran and this is why we get this gut feeling. We may sometimes ignore it to our peril but it is there. !
@kiran8 (15348)
• Mangalore, India
16 Aug 10
Exactly kala, it is a sum total of our sub concious having noted some finer details that may have skipped our mind or may not have properly registered at the time, and also our own experiences or others experiences which all come together to give us a kind of warning ! ...
@Jotomy (6322)
• India
16 Aug 10
Hi kala, true women always try to take decision on the ideas or impression. But men are different from it, they will not see all these and then come to conclusion they will believe only when they observe it. Have a nice day.
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
16 Aug 10
Hi Jo! It is great to see you here in my discussion.How are you? What you say is true. We get impressions and I feel this is based on some prior observations that have sunk into the subconscious.
@Jotomy (6322)
• India
17 Aug 10
yes kala i am fine. thanks.
• India
16 Aug 10
Since women are more instinctive than men. Their instincts guide them. Therefore, they take better decision based on intuition rather than observation.
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
16 Aug 10
hanks Achiles for the participation. THe dialogue was that women tend to make mistakes later while men do it better on observation subsequently though they may lack the intuitive powers of women.It was a distinct comparison based on the context of the film.THat is why I thought it would make aan interesting discussion.
@rameshchow (4426)
• India
16 Aug 10
I believe in film writers thoughts, become they are well experienced and searched before going to put a dialogue in the movie, so when we saw in that direction, you are right, but i am still so young, i don't know how explain with real world examples, can you care to enlighten me about this?
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
16 Aug 10
Well; film writers do put a lot of thought in their dialogues at times but this was extremely contextual and in this day and age I won't say that it would be totally relevant Ramesh.It isa TAMIL film where the hero looks at one girl, falls inlove with her, gets into an arranged marriage with her look-alike. He does not even approach the girl whom he is initially attracted to and finding out her likes through his friends ingenious methods, gets gifts for her and piles dream after dream in his imagined life with her because she shares many similar tastes . He goes to see soem girl arranged by his fahter and on seeing her look-alike mistakenly assumes thta she is his dream girl and gets married. They are just on their way to their new house when the dream girl passes him on the road. He is totally disappointed and in act shattered. But the second girl leads a patient life with him , bearing his churlishness. By a strange twist of fate, the dream girl sets residence in their opposite flat and befriends the wife.She loves the way the wife leads a life 'all devoted to husband'.But, in the end, when his friends realise his confusion and attraction for the dream girl, they inadvertently intervene and let the cat out of the bag.The wife is now shattered and leaves him.But in the end, the husband says that he is now truly in love with his patient wife and he delivers the dialogue--the wife was patient, was willing to give the marriage a try when he was behaving badly, was waiting with the intuitive hope of winning his love over.But when the man's mind had changed based on her baehaviour, she had lost hope, mistakenly believed that he had no feelings for her and was willing to go.She initially took a right decision to give the marriage a try; but when he took a right decision based on his observation, she made the wrong choice of leaving him.So he says he is going to wait for her after which the situation ends happily for the couple .The wife now knows the truth and they are united.THis is the celluloid example here.
• Philippines
16 Aug 10
Women are much more instinctive than men. Most women base their decision on intuition and I seem to want to believe that the best decision women make is based on intuition which men cannot do often. Men proceed by observation by which they make more plausible decision. However, intuition is not exclusive to women nor is observation exclusive to men.
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
16 Aug 10
That is always the case. We would have all people in allcategories. In the film yesterday, the dialogue was that while women take intuitive decisions the first time their subsequent decisions are not that good.[this was with reference to a particular context]and the man said thta it was the other way round for men. I too don't think it can be categorised to that extent.