Just how justified is Trump in talking about the "China Virus"?

Tweet

Donald Trump loves to blame someone else when things go wrong - nothing has gone more wrong that the Covid-19 pandemic, and he thinks he has an easy target in China as its source. He has even given the impression that he believes that China deliberately exported the virus to the United States with the sole purpose of upsetting his re-election campaign! I am not sure that he has actually ever said that in so many words, but it is clear that some of his supporters have taken that line. He and Mike Pence have in any case made great play of the fact that he - apparently - took immediate action back in January in banning all flights from China and thus saved "millions of lives". He has recently defended his use of the term "China virus" rather than "corona virus" on the grounds that "Corona" sounds like a place in Italy, which is clearly not the same as China! However, there could be an interesting and ironic error being made here. Let's leave aside the fact that the word "coronavirus" has nothing at all to do with its geographic origin (it refers to the physical appearance of this class of viruses), and think for a minute about Italy. We are fairly sure that the virus reached the UK as a result of ski tourists returning to the UK from the Italian Alps, and not directly from the Wuhan region of China where it it originated. North Italy was the worst affected region of Europe during the early weeks of the pandemic. The notion that thousands of infected Chinese people were swarming into the United States in those early days does sound more than a little far-fetched - do Chinese nationals from an impoverished region of the country really do that much international travel? However, Italians are far more likely to fly to the United States. There is a huge population of Italian Americans living along the eastern seaboard, and that is precisely where the worst outbreaks occurred in the early days - notably in New York State. You are more likely to find Chinese nationals on the other side of the continent, where many of their ancestors migrated to from across the Pacific. Back in January, Trump did indeed restrict air travel from China - although Americans returning from China did not face the same restrictions. However, flights from Europe - including Italy - continued unabated for some time. So the "China virus" may indeed have originated in China, but is it not just as true that it is also the "Italy virus" by virtue of the fact that that country was probably the source of most of the infections that actually reached the United States?