Would this be a frivolous case...part 1

@vandana7 (98827)
India
February 16, 2023 10:19am CST
So our central bank governor has gone and declared that Fixed deposits when they mature will slip back to savings bank interest. UNLESS the depositor personally renews it...NO AUTO RENEWAL Now who opts for Fixed Deposits? Senior citizens. People providing for family members. Imagine me depositing 5000000 in 10 different deposits on different dates and months...and having to keep track of all those. How often do I have to go to the bank? At least 10 times? That means I use up the time of bank staff that many times...and now imagine how many people like me... So will the bank earn profits or losses....will it require more staff or not? And then I do need to travel, which means I use petrol (gas for Americans). I live in a country that IMPORTS OIL. This is absolutely illogical and irrational and anti national move....ok the last one is stretching it....sorry upfront...but he does need to review this. I do need to approach the courts on this. Just not sure if it will be dismissed as a frivolous case. Do you think it is?
5 people like this
5 responses
@ptrikha_2 (45472)
• India
16 Feb 23
Well, as of now my Savings are not keeping up. And anyways, Fixed Deposits do not help tackle inflation. Mutual Funds and SIPs prove better bet. But to some extent only. In India, Being born a Rich Farmer or a Rich Businessman is a boon. Being in middle class or classless can be a sin as these do not constitute a vote bank. Neither for the governments nor for RBI or others. And Yes removing Auto Renewal is not right. One should have a right to do this. Right for both the banks and depositors. Approaching courts to file a case which doesn't ends before 10/15 or more years?? Good joke!!. By the way if you have ready 1 or 2 Crore, you can apply for Investment visa for some country. Nothing more to say !
1 person likes this
@ptrikha_2 (45472)
• India
17 Feb 23
@vandana7 Yes a balance is always essential but things do look scary. Mere proclamations of "Fastest Growing Economy" is not going to work. Perhaps we need some miracles!
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (98827)
• India
17 Feb 23
It is auto renewal only for the term. Not for revised interest rates. That is so grrrrrrrr. Previously, this gentleman removed standing instructions. My aunt has been unable to give standing instructions for payment of her rent. Ha ha...east or west, no other place is best. LOL I am good with my country. I need to repair it...if everybody who understands what is going wrong leaves the country, it will become another Pakistan.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (98827)
• India
17 Feb 23
Mutual funds give you what...8 to 10 percent max 15 percent compounded. If you are wise enough to select the right one. Then again, mutual funds are subject to market risk. COVID times have clearly shown that risk...when markets plunged, and really plunged for a short while. Many needed the money then! Hospitalization and vaccinations and treatment...damn expensive. 6 months monthly expense in banks...ALWAYS. One third in less risky investments like Fixed Deposits, treasury bonds. 2 thirds in mutual funds and equities. That is how I would advise. The 1/3rd in FDs, etc., would include gold. That can also be manipulated you know...lower income to pay lower taxes....but higher capital gains which are exempt. PPF comes to mind too. Exempt, Exempt, Exempt category. Gold incidentally has given more than 10 percent compounded in the last 4 years (including the interest on Sovereign Gold Bonds), unlike stock markets which are hovering around 6 to 10 percent, but yes, potential is there. I am not sure SGB will not continue to give that rate...kinda, I expect the same rate of return on gold because even if the prices of gold come down internationally, as per the world bank forecast, the fact remains that Indian rupee will tumble...making gold expensive. And we all know how crazy Indians are about gold. Added to that is China's economy opening up, and China too is a big buyer of gold. So yes, I do expect the trajectory to continue ..notwithstanding the drop in gold prices internationally. Our trade deficit and BOP are scary. I expect to see dollar become equal to 100 by or in 2026. By the way you might want to look into those commercial investments...they come in units form...minimum investment I think is 25 lakhs. But it is real estate investment and you get decent rent when compared to outside, without the hassles.
1 person likes this
@DaddyEvil (137145)
• United States
16 Feb 23
No, that is not a frivolous cast. You're talking about a mountain of interest difference between those two rates times each person who has Fixed Deposits. I wonder how much that guy wants in kickbacks from the banks?
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (98827)
• India
16 Feb 23
Nah...actually that is painful..either SB interest, or if auto renewal is accepted, then old rates of interest...he has just increased a lot of work for senior citizens.
2 people like this
@ptrikha_2 (45472)
• India
16 Feb 23
@vandana7 All senior citizens of India can unite and go on a Dharna outside RBI office. May be that would help?
2 people like this
@wolfgirl569 (95190)
• Marion, Ohio
17 Feb 23
I don't think it's frivolous. You should at least be able to decide which way you want it set up
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (98827)
• India
17 Feb 23
It was bad as it is, when they did away with Standing instructions. There are many things like rent, utility bills etc., which could be paid directly by the banks without regular instructions or instruments.
1 person likes this
@JudyEv (325758)
• Rockingham, Australia
17 Feb 23
I agree. This is a ridiculous decision.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (98827)
• India
17 Feb 23
See...the interest rates have increased. If my 3 years deposit gets renewed (banks have that option), under auto renewal, they will continue with the old interest rate, which is almost half the rate it is now, forcing me to travel and renew it manually. I cannot think of anything more inconsiderate for senior citizens.
1 person likes this
@LindaOHio (156157)
• United States
17 Feb 23
Are these like our CDs (Certificates of Deposit)? Ours don't automatically renew either.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (98827)
• India
17 Feb 23
Yes. That maybe the reason our governor decided to change the present rules.
1 person likes this