An 1809's medico's view on piano-playing

Tweet

I’m reading a book about the early days of the nursing post/hospital at Ravensthorpe, a small, isolated country in the south-east of Western Australia. The Phillips River was nearby and the local paper was called the Phillips River Times. In the 19th January, 1809 edition, an article was posted entitled ‘Piano and the Nerves’. It appeared first in a medical paper. In his opinion, the chloroses and neuroses from which so many young girls suffer, may be largely attributed to the abuse of the piano. I quote ‘He believed it was necessary to abandon the deadly habit of compelling young girls to labour on the keyboard before they were 15 or 16 years of age. Even at this age the exercise should be permitted only to those who are really talented and possessed of a robust temperament. The study of the violin produces even more disastrous results than those attributed to the piano.’ End of quote. I can actually understand his reasoning. The photo is of our piano