Is street begging allowed in your country?
@ogbenishyna44 (739)
4 responses
@DaddyEvil (157610)
• United States
14 Aug
Yes, it's allowed in the US but some cities here don't like it and ship beggars to other cities/states. Just like the homeless here, there are soup kitchens/housing in the bigger cities that will feed beggars so they aren't bothering other citizens.
1 person likes this
@ogbenishyna44 (739)
•
17 Aug
what? They ship beggars to other cities? You mean inner cities within the state?
1 person likes this
@DaddyEvil (157610)
• United States
17 Aug
@ogbenishyna44 Big cities here have homeless shelters and soup kitchens to feed them... Most people that don't live in big cities ignore homeless people and won't give them anything. Our taxes pay for those homeless shelters.
1 person likes this
@ogbenishyna44 (739)
•
4h
@DaddyEvil Its good to know some people care about them.
1 person likes this


@sjvg1976 (42499)
• Delhi, India
17 Aug
@ogbenishyna44 They may if there were not lots of beggars on the same place.
1 person likes this
@ogbenishyna44 (739)
•
17 Aug
Oh! Im sure they get lots of money near the temple.
1 person likes this

@rsa101 (39897)
• Philippines
14 Aug
Here in the Philippines, street begging is quite visible, especially in busy urban areas like Manila, Cebu, and Davao. You might see children weaving between cars at stoplights, holding out their hands or selling sampaguita garlands, or elderly men and women sitting quietly along sidewalks with a small cup in front of them. In rural towns, it’s less common, but during fiestas or big gatherings, you might encounter people asking for small donations.
Technically, the **Anti-Mendicancy Law of 1978** makes begging in public places illegal, both for those who ask and those who give. It was meant to address organized begging syndicates and encourage rehabilitation programs. In practice, though, enforcement is inconsistent—many local authorities turn a blind eye, especially when it’s clear someone is in genuine need. Poverty, unemployment, and lack of social safety nets keep the problem alive. While some people give generously out of compassion, others prefer to donate to shelters or feeding programs, hoping to help without encouraging the cycle. It’s a complex issue, where the line between kindness and enabling is never easy to draw.
1 person likes this
@ogbenishyna44 (739)
•
15 Aug
Its good there are many donations in your country.
1 person likes this
@porwest (105542)
• United States
14 Aug
It is mostly allowed, but it really does depend on local laws. Some municipalities have laws against what it essentially "panhandling." As for my personal policy, I never give money to beggars. To be honest, I wish it weren't legal. Most beggars are a nuisance.
1 person likes this

@porwest (105542)
• United States
21 Aug
@ogbenishyna44 He does. Some cities are being overrun.
1 person likes this

