Wrong suggested tips
By Lena Kovadlo
@lovebuglena (53157)
Staten Island, New York
July 11, 2026 10:29pm CST
Though tips are supposedly optional in the United States, if you do leave a tip, it should be based on the subtotal amount, not the total. You should not tip on tax.
Often when the receipt shows suggested tip amounts, they are based on the total and not the subtotal. Enough times people will just take one of those suggested tips and fill it in to the tip line on the receipt. If you do that and don’t do the math first, you’ll often end up leaving a tip on the total, which of course includes tax.
I was at a restaurant today and that is exactly what happened. I saw the suggested tip amounts on the bill and I was ready to put one of them in to the tip line of the receipt. After taking one of those percentages and doing the math, it turned out the suggested tip was calculated from the total and not the subtotal. Knowing this, I redid the math for the subtotal and left the correct amount.
I don’t understand why receipts automatically show suggested tips for the total when you’re not supposed to leave a tip on the tax part.
6 people like this
4 responses
@lovebuglena (53157)
• Staten Island, New York
12 Jul
Yes, some countries if you try to leave a tip, they’ll even be unhappy about it.
2 people like this
@lovebuglena (53157)
• Staten Island, New York
12 Jul
Why would you leave a tip on government tax?
2 people like this
@lovebuglena (53157)
• Staten Island, New York
12 Jul
People that leave a tip on the total, probably don’t even realize they’re tipping on the total; especially if the receipt already has the suggested tips in there.
2 people like this
@porwest (113642)
• United States
12 Jul
Why would you leave a tip on government tax?
@lovebuglena I guess I just have always tipped on the total. Maybe it's just easier, and it doesn't change the tip that much.
1 person likes this

@lovebuglena (53157)
• Staten Island, New York
12 Jul
We tip for the service. I get that. But tipping should not be based on how expensive something is, which is how it’s in the USA because we tip a % of the subtotal. So if you get a big steak, your tip will be higher than if you would get a bowl of salad. They still bring you one plate; service is the same. Yet you have to leave a higher tip because the steak is more expensive. That is not right.
2 people like this





