Do twins have a closer bond than single sibling babies?

@mommyboo (13174)
United States
January 7, 2009 11:31am CST
I have heard overwhelming evidence that twins have a closer psychological (and maybe even physiological) bond than single siblings do. What do you think? Are you a twin or one of a multiple (triplet, quadruplet) set? Do you think you'd be more affected by anything that happened to your twin or triplet as opposed to another sibling? I have known a few sets of twins, more identical than fraternal, which is odd to me. I have noticed that for every way they are similar, there are just as many ways they are different. With identicals, usually it is personality - one will be much more outgoing than the other, or they will have vastly different interests and friend circles. With fraternals, sometimes it is all of the above, if they also look nothing like each other and behave nothing like each other, it stands to reason they will have very different groups of friends. On the other hand, I have heard interesting accounts of twins separated at birth and raised by different families, and these people often develop the same interests, likes and dislikes, even have similar friends, marry similar spouses and choose the same names for children. Sometimes they work in the same job fields, move to and live in the same area (unbeknownst to each other) or marry within the same FAMILY and work at the SAME company! I'm not sure what to think, there seems to be conflicting evidence. If you are one of a multiple, share your thoughts. If you just have a theory or idea, share your thoughts.
7 people like this
14 responses
@sharra1 (6340)
• Australia
8 Jan 09
Yes I think they do. I think if they are from a split egg so they are identical then they are more likely to share thoughts and feelings as well. It can depend on how close siblings are in age but twins are always a pair and other sibling are rarely closer than 3 years. In my family we were 5 years apart so my eldest brother is over 9 years older than I am and I have very little in common with either of my brothers. My two nephews are twins and they have always been close even though they are totally different.
3 people like this
@leenie50 (3992)
• United States
10 Jan 09
Sharra, My older sister is 3 years and 10months older than me and my twin, and my oldest brother is 11 months older than us. Then my brother just under us is 2 yrs. and 5 months. Then my parents managed to wait 5 years befoe they had the second 2 at 2 years apart and five years later had 2 more boys 2 yrs. apart. It's called being a Catholic using the rythm method.lol leenie
2 people like this
@sharra1 (6340)
• Australia
13 Jan 09
I think that single children always have an age gap and they can have a gender gap as well sometimes. Twins are always the same age and the ones I have have known always had a strong bond.
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
12 Jan 09
In my family I have a sister 2 1/2 years younger and a brother 11 years younger and a sister 12 years younger. I also have a brother 4 years older but he was my (step) brother and as such wasn't involved a ton in my life. Even though we all lived together, he spent as little time at home as he could plus he moved out when he was 17. I spent 3ish years with him around off and on vs almost 10 years with my other siblings. In my own current family... there is a similarity. The older kids were 13 and 14 when the little one was born. They are now 19, 17, and almost 5.
1 person likes this
@shell94 (990)
• Canada
8 Jan 09
My uncles are identical twins and they seem to share a remarkably close bond. They seem to know quite often what the other is thinking and do things in very similiar ways. Mind you they have their unique personalities as well. I agree with the statement that the personalities are often quite different with identical twins. This rings true in my family as one is more soft spoken and more shy I guess the term would be and the other one is far more outgoing and not afraid to speak his mind. They do not work at the same type of job at all, and one is married while the other remains single and seems to like his life this way. But when either of them is having an issue the other one is always right there to help the other one out however that may be.
@sharra1 (6340)
• Australia
8 Jan 09
I have heard that identical twins are like this. They are from the same egg and all the ones that have been interviewed talk about a bond that is so close they feel similar things. They are often very close emotionally. Just because they are identical does not mean they are duplicates. They are still individuals but they are so close that their twin come first before anyone else.
3 people like this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
12 Jan 09
Maybe they are bonded in some ways like spouses are, especially after a long time. It would likely be the same phenomenon right? You've spent so much time in close proximity to each other, doing the same things, doing things for each other too that you know some things about each other, can finish each other's sentences, can tell how each other is feeling without being able to explain or describe it to someone else. I also agree, Sharra, that they are each other's most important person outside of themselves, maybe even if they have families.
@leenie50 (3992)
• United States
10 Jan 09
Sharra, You are right, my twin will always come first. leenie
1 person likes this
@mikeysmom (2088)
• United States
8 Jan 09
i think it is probably true that they have a closer bond in MOST cases. i have also seen where they resent each other because they feel they have no individuality and as a result are not close. i guess it can go both ways but i would imagine for the most part it is a very close bond.
3 people like this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
12 Jan 09
I guess this is why people need to know their kids, if you know your kids' personalities, then you can figure out whether they need more individual encouragement or more together encouragement. I know that sounds funny but some kids just need siblings, other kids would be much happier as only children. I was an only for a long time... and I probably would have been fine being an only. I have siblings now and I love them but I think I'd have been okay either way. Certainly I would never go back after knowing what it's like being part of a big busy family. However, there are some kids who by luck of the draw have a personality that causes them to resent any siblings - likely because it takes the attention of their parents away from THEM. They also in turn may resent their parents' friends or the fact that their own friends may have other friends.
7 Jan 09
I knew a set of idential twins a while back who at age 40 lived together, worked for the same company, were part of the same theatrical club and basically did everything together - from eating the same meals to dressing in very similar fashions. I mean that they would eat lunch together in the canteen every day and both would have the same meal. If for some reason they couldn't share their lunch hour, then whoever had lunch first would phone the other twin to let them know what they had eaten. As far as relationships went - from what I could work out, they had made a pact years before that they wouldn't get involved with any man because they would both be interested in the same man and that wouldn't work! Why not just share as they did with everything else? (you gotta just as yourself) :¬) They 2 ladies had the same hairstyle, wore their make up the same, everything was the same! They did nothing on their own! Then one day, one of them got made redundant. The other then took voluntary redundancy as soon as she could and they both headed off into the big bad world. Their plan was to find jobs at the same company. I lost track of them, but do still wonder if they every managed to find 2 jobs at the same company. It was quite freaky! Violetdreams
2 people like this
10 Jan 09
Hi Leenie Redundant - laid off from work. I guess redundant is one of those terms that is different in every country. I know the word they use in South Africa is different to the British equivalent (redundant), but for the life of me can't remember what the SA equivalent is - if I could, I bet you, you'd be familiar with it in the US. Did that clear up your question?
1 person likes this
@leenie50 (3992)
• United States
10 Jan 09
Violet, What do you mean they got redundant? leenie I also know an identical set of twins who live next door to each other and own a bar together and dress the same, hair and all. I think they are a couple years older than me. They have done everything together their whole lives. Incredible.
1 person likes this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
11 Jan 09
That sounds freaky - like co-dependency (which I think is very freaky lol). BTW, we usually say 'laid off' although I figured out what you meant. Since I don't have a twin I'm not sure how I would feel. I don't think I'd want to be identical to somebody - unless I had a plan in mind to screw with somebody by pretending to be someone I was not lol.
@bamakelly (5191)
• United States
8 Jan 09
I have heard of the phenomenon of twins or multiples growing up together and having that special bond together like finishing each others sentences and knowing what the other is thinking. Some twins grow up separately and meet up a little later in life to find that they wear there hair the same way and have the same styles in clothes and husbands!
2 people like this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
12 Jan 09
It's interesting, isn't it?
@inuceres (341)
• Philippines
8 Jan 09
i think that is true... i have a twin brother but they don't not really the same they are fraternal,...unlike those identical twins that you never what they are differences confusing
2 people like this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
11 Jan 09
Are they closer to each other than either one of them are to you?
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
11 Jan 09
Hi mommyboo, I was watching a documentary about twins and was showing the bond that develops in the womb. It continues later on in life. However this does not mean that the twins whether identical or not do not have separate characters, like and dislikes. (c) ronaldinu 2009 - the more people I meet-the more I love my dog
1 person likes this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
14 Jan 09
Yes, despite the fact that nature can sometimes create an identical physical person, it has yet to create an identical personality/psychological person lol. I don't think that is possible. Especially not in this society.
@dawnald (85135)
• Shingle Springs, California
7 Jan 09
My twins are 8, boy and girl. The girl is precocious and her brother has autism. They do seem to have a special relationship. She's almost like the big sister and takes him under her wing. Because of the autism, he has problems with language and social skills, while she is good with those things. She's also a lot more extroverted than he is. He's tall, she's short. He's a good eater, she's a picky eater. Boy, girl. Left handed, right handed. But we'll see when they get older how much they have in common and how much they don't!
2 people like this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
10 Jan 09
LOL! Do you feel they are closer somehow than if they were siblings born say... less than 2 years apart? This is neat, I didn't know this about you. Of course it's not like I go about asking my friends if they have twins either without a reason.
1 person likes this
• Romania
8 Jan 09
yep i believe so.
7 Jan 09
What an interesting thought. I am not a multiple, but do have twin children. My first is a singleton - he is 5, then my twins are fraternal B/G - 3 years - so not identical obviously. We have noted that the twins seem to be total opposites in just about all ways. --- She is right handed and creative, he is left handed and more computer (logic) oriented, - She loves drawing, he never voluntarily paints, draws or anything else like that. - She is very busy, always on the move and the brain is very busy and is all over the place, He is a lot quieter and far far more ordered - he has been known to line up his food before eating it - he likes order! - She is very independent, wanting to do everything for herself, he prefers Mum to help him (even when he is able to do it for himself), and seems to prefer the security of having an Adult around, preferably Mum! When all 3 kids are together the eldest and my girl twin seem to gravitate together and actually seem to gang up on my boy twin, often leaving him out. When my eldest isn't around, then the twins play together quite happily with no problems and actually get on together really well. I think there is a definite link between them and they do look out for each other, but they are also definite individuals and while they do share some friends, they do also have their own special friends too. It will be interesting to see how they develop as they grow up. Violetdreams
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
11 Jan 09
That makes me wonder if B/G twins tend to develop more opposite characteristics as a matter of course while same fraternals may not necessarily show opposite characteristics early, they just LOOK different...
• United States
7 Jan 09
im not a twin but i do think they bond in a special way in the womb to where they are closer when they are born and grow up.. so many studies show it that there has to be something to it
2 people like this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
10 Jan 09
I get that feeling too but since I am not a twin nor do I have twins, it's harder for me to say I know for sure.
@leenie50 (3992)
• United States
10 Jan 09
Hi Boo, As a matter of fact, I am a twin. I'm Eileen and she is Elaine. We are fraternal. I was born 9 minutes before she was born. From the time we were born we were hard to separate until high school. Asyou sais, Elaine was way more out going than I was because she was so demanding and ungiving. She had to and still has to be the center of attention. whether it be familiy gatherings or her own circle of friends. Funny though, her circle of friends(women and even a couple of men)most all are the same. Elaine is just the loudest and MOST demading. they love her anyway, just as I do. It does cause a bit of conflict in our relationship. You see I moved away from home at 20 when I first married. From Florida to California. That's where I grew up and learned who I was. I realized I was also outgoing just not demanding and overbearing. I made really close friends through the years. When I left Ca. to come home I was a strong, well rounded (in more way than one)and independent woman. As hard as Elaine tries, she will never control me again. Believe me she tries. Don't get me wrong, elaine and I have an unbreakable bond, no matter what. Our bond is stronger than with our older sister and six brothers. My older sister and I get along most of the time better than Elaine and I but it's just not the same. I adore all of my brothers but again, it's not the same as the strength of the bond Elaine and I have. Elaines husband and Elaine sometimes don't like my husband well enough to spend much time with us. My husband and I spend more time laughing, over goofy things we do or really funny things, while Elaine and her husband spend more time arguing about who is right. Our life experiences make a great deal of diffence in who we've become. I moved thousands of miles away from Mom and Dad and learned to solve my own problems, no matter how difficult, because I was all I had. My first marriage was a disaster. We both have a certain amount of our Mother in us, but Elaine has my Mothers Criticism and Judgement in her. And no one knows better ther her. But again, we are still so much alike in what we say and how we say it. We are so often on the same wave length and quite often know what is on each others mind. There are so many likenesses that I can't describe. I believe it all begins in the womb. The genes rule. leenie
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
14 Jan 09
What the heck, I responded TWICE to this and wrote a really long post and it got eaten AGAIN??? I'll be sending you a private message instead, this is ridiculous!
1 person likes this
@leenie50 (3992)
• United States
15 Jan 09
That has happened to me before, several times.
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
7 Jan 09
I'm not a twin but have twin grandchildren - a boy and a girl. They are very close at 30 months even though they have the occasional fight. They still do not like to be oput of each other's sight and if my son just takles the boy to get his hair trimmed, the girl waits anxiously until he returns. She stays by the window. My son said that when they were creeping if one was out of sight they would give a wierd call and the one out of sight would come to the other one. The boy needed his sister's voice to go to sleep. so if he woke in the night they would play a recording of her voice and he would fall straight back to sleep.They are very protective of each other especially when other children are around. Blessings
2 people like this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
10 Jan 09
Thanks for sharing! I think it's neat to see how kids interact. Most twins seem to appreciate each other, ie they would be miserable as 'onlys'.
1 person likes this
• China
8 Jan 09
i am a triplet and we three are all different in physiological and psychological.my older sister is the shortest one and carry a peace temper whenever.i have a middle stature but really often become fussy with a little stuff. my younger brother seems to be always out of his right mind and do things madly and regardless others feeling.
1 person likes this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
11 Jan 09
Sounds just like you are siblings with no similarities other than your same birthday lol. Do you prefer each other's company to other people?