How do you really feel about mother in law? Do tell...

@ilyzium (1197)
Canada
November 11, 2009 3:38pm CST
My mother in law I think is a very nice lady, however she has to be one of the most meddlesome people I have ever come across. Don't get me wrong though, I do have the utmost respect for her and she produced my wonderful husband and instilled in him all these important values. However, she likes to meddle in everything. When we were first married my mother in law would go through my cupboards and rearrange everything because she didn't like the way I'd arranged things. Also, whenever she comes to visit she'll go through my freezer like she has a right to....No you don't! She also did that to her other daughter in law too btw. Although we don't have kids yet, so she always has to interfere with her other son's parenting abilities. The latest straw is that she's asked her other son if he could build a smaller house on his property for her to move into permanently! He was only speechless and changed to subject. My husband would actually like to move into a larger home but I'm refusing because I know if we did my mother in law would insist on moving in! No thanks...What have your experiences been?
1 person likes this
14 responses
• Australia
11 Nov 09
My mother -in-law is too good,she welcome the guest as like any thing .she is wonderful lady,she never used a harsh words.Her food preparation are very unique .Very one of our home are fan of her including me :-)
1 person likes this
@ilyzium (1197)
• Canada
11 Nov 09
Wow your mother in law sounds perfect! I'm just wondering though how your mothers in law are when they come to visit you?
@dodo19 (47133)
• Beaconsfield, Quebec
11 Nov 09
My mother-in-law is a really amazing woman, mother and grandmother. She is really fun to be around, and I'm just so thankful that I know her. I think that it's pretty much safe to say that she has adopted me. I'm glad that she has, as we are very close, and although my own mother is still alive and such, I'm really not close to my mother. We just simply don't have a good relationship, my mother and I. I'm glad that I have my mother-in-law.
1 person likes this
@ilyzium (1197)
• Canada
11 Nov 09
I think that's really nice that you and your mother in law has this special close relationship between you. You two are lucky to have one another I think. Too bad about your relationship with your Mom. Well I do love my mother in law, she just drives me crazy when she visits is all.
@carolbee (16230)
• United States
13 Nov 09
Ok you have every right to be irritated by your mother-in-law's behavior. I don't believe it is anyone's right to go through cupboards or closets to see what is kept in the house. If she wants to know it would be easier for her to ask what you keep in your freezer. My mother-in-law passed away a little over two years ago. Not only was she a wonderful lady, we were friends also. I loved her dearly. She was meddling into our business when we first married but changed her ways. She was always there for me when I needed babysitting or just wanted to chat and get some advice. I miss her and know she is resting in peace.
@carolbee (16230)
• United States
13 Nov 09
I am a mom, mother-in-law and grandma. I have never searched any of our daughter's homes to see what they have in any rooms. I feel like it's not my business. I wouldn't want them searching my house although I have nothing to hide. I try not to meddle in our daughter's business unless I get angry and then look out..lol If all 3 are happy, content and successful I can't ask for anything more. I did my job and they need room to grow and age without my bossing. By the way, they are all 3 adults now. I do miss my mother-in-law and think of her so often. She was a wonderful woman.
@ilyzium (1197)
• Canada
13 Nov 09
Hello carolbee, Yes I agree I do have every right to be offended by it. Funny thing about it is that my husband and even his other brother were telling me that his mother knows everything and to listen to the voice of experience? OMG I thought I was going to have to strangle someone!! :(I kept telling them that I need to make my own mistakes and that I don't need unwarranted advice, and when I do I'll ask for it!! I think it's nice though that you had a good relationship with your own mother in law. It's good for you too that she eventually stopped meddling in your relationship, because that as we all know does not always happen. Have a good day. :)
@ilyzium (1197)
• Canada
22 Nov 09
I have to say that you sound like the perfect, ideal mother in law we'd all like to have. You're there for your kids, but do not smother them or snoop into their business. I hope they all appreciate you!
• United States
12 Nov 09
I like my mother in law. We've had our ups and downs but I still like her. She made me mad when my husband was in the military. He developed asthma and they were going to discharge him and send him home. She got mad about it and said he didn't need to come home. It wasn't anything to do with my husband...it was all the military's doings. My husband had no choice. He wanted to stay but they wouldn't let him because he developed phycial induced asthma while he was there and he still to this day has asthma and every once in a while will have to use his inhaler and then lay down for a little while because it makes him feel bad. His mom fought with me about it when I told her he had no choice and then his grandma got in on it and they both were being mean to me. We weren't married at the time (only dating) and I told him he needed to take care of his mom and grandma or I was going to be gone when he got back home. They were fighting with my over something stupid and I wasn't going to let them keep bashing me for something the military was doing. It wasn't like I was making him come back home but you would have thought that they way they were talking and treating me. My husband took care of everything and you wouldn't think that my mother in law and I had ever had any problems. I guess she knows her son will take up for his wife (now as of 6 years) and she's super nice to me and to her grandson (our son). So I really like my mother in law and we get along fine now.
• United States
22 Nov 09
Yeah, I was proud of my husband too for standing up for me to his mother. Thanks for the best response!
@ilyzium (1197)
• Canada
22 Nov 09
Oh your welcome. Have a great day, well what's left of it. ;)
@ilyzium (1197)
• Canada
13 Nov 09
You certainly went through a lot with your mother in law when you were dating. Wow I wouldn't have taken it very well if (his mother) would have tried to meddle that way and accuse me of being instrumental in him being discharged? I think you have a great guy though that he stood up for you and wouldn't let them blame you for it. Some men are such "woosie's" when it comes to dealing with their own mothers. I'm glad that you have a good relationship with your mother in law now, and her with your grandchild too.
@adhyz82 (36249)
• Indonesia
12 Nov 09
iam unmarried person. but if iam married with someone,my princip is my wife`s mother is my mother too, and my wife (someday) must think like that, my mother is her mother too , not only mother in law. so if the princip is begin from this view, i hope it can reduce many conflict between me and my wife`s mother or my wife and my mother. thanks
@ilyzium (1197)
• Canada
13 Nov 09
Yes I hope that you won't have any conflicts over the mother in law either, when you get married. I think a lot of the time it stems from the fact that the mother in law feels like she's giving up control and wants to be the ONLY woman in her son's life. When problems arise it's important for the son to have a talk with his mother, otherwise there will be much resentment and tears. I've been through it all before.
@ilyzium (1197)
• Canada
22 Nov 09
Well I guess you'll see one day when you get married. Too soon to tell.
@adhyz82 (36249)
• Indonesia
13 Nov 09
i think my mom is wisely, very wisely and can diferentiate whats the pmy roblems , she can talk and whats my problems that she give me trust to me to solve by myself. i hope my mother`s in law is wise mom too.
12 Nov 09
hi, i think i am a stupid person, i chose to live with my mother in law, she is a widow, only has ONE son who is my hubby..... honestly, i cannot stand her, she talks loudly, hot temper, dishonest, drives me crazy each day. i cried alot because of her, my husband doesnt want to move out, cos she is getting old now, no one will look after her, sometimes i just want to walk away, but i dont want to leave my husband because of her, i hope someone can give me advise....thanks
@ilyzium (1197)
• Canada
12 Nov 09
Oh I can really relate to what you are going through. Is there no one else in the family that can look after her? Is there someone else in the family that can talk to her about her behavior? Does your husband know how upset she makes you? I think that your husband needs to have a long talk with his mother, and tell him that her behavior is unacceptable, that it hurts you and that she has to behave herself if you'll be living under her roof, or that you'll move out! Why couldn't you two move out, live somewhere else and just have your husband come to visit to check up on her? Some of those mean people wind up living a long time. I think your mother in law needs to be scared that she's going to lose her son by moving out, maybe then she might change her behavior? Has he tried that approach? I suspect not. You're his wife, more important than the mother I think. See I worry about having my mother in law move in with us because she's meddling, though it hasn't happened yet. Good luck with how it goes and keep me posted!
@ilyzium (1197)
• Canada
22 Nov 09
I am so sorry to hear what you have to put with with, it's really not fair at all to you. Is there no one that can talk to your husband, to reason with him and knock some sense into his brains?
13 Nov 09
hi, thanks for ur reply, my husband loves her mom so much, whatever she says :is right !! he believes in her ,she is smart, she will not scold me in front of him, at first i did complain to my husband, but ended up to arguement, he rather to stay with his mom forever. even he knows i am very upset with his mom, he will not comfort me, he will not say anything, he is so sure : I will be OK. i really hate her, esp the way she makes up stories, she is a 100% liar, the worst woman i have ever seen in this world.
@mikeysmom (2088)
• United States
12 Nov 09
thankfully mine never lived close to us so i only saw her once in awhile. she never meddled like yours but she was very quirky and did a lousy job of mothering my husband because of her quirkiness. he has little or no life skills and that is something we need to be taught. he told me she never really did much for him and he was left to fend for himself and there was not alot of affection and such which every child needs to feel secure in life. she pays no attention at all to my son which really irks me and she has moved even further away in the past 2 years. no great loss for any of us really. she was never really there for my husband and he sees how i am with my son and realizes what a lousy mother she really was.
@ilyzium (1197)
• Canada
12 Nov 09
Well it sounds like she was a pretty crappy mother, very selfish and only cared bout her own needs...sad really...I don't understand how some people wind up having children if they're not going to parent them? They should never have kids in the first place. Well, as the saying goes: "you can't always choose your family", or something like that.
@sublime03 (2339)
• Philippines
12 Nov 09
I have to agree that mother in laws meddle with their childrens life but there is always a line in meddling on your kids life. My mother in law and I had to argue on things for me to relay the message that I am not here to have her step on me but to prove to her that we can live with the decisions that WE make.
@ilyzium (1197)
• Canada
12 Nov 09
You're right there is always a fine line when it comes to meddling with the children's lives. Well, my hubby unfortunately is still a bit of a mama's boy so he still let's her meddle.
@doryvien (2284)
• United States
12 Nov 09
I don't have this problem because my husband's mom passed away before we got married. But even when we were not married yet his mom (bless her soul) will make comments that are polite but hurtful, and I felt that it's going to be a disaster if we stay together under one roof. As to his dad, he never meddled with our life, so I kind of like him. On the other hand, my husband always tells me that my mother is a cool mother-in-law because she acts as a parent to both of us, helps us specially when we have a financial problem, and has never made any attempt to meddle with our married life.
@ilyzium (1197)
• Canada
12 Nov 09
I don't think I've ever known anyone that has had a meddling father in law, do you? Doesn't seem to happen. Well it doesn't sound like your mother in law was that bad. How long did you all stay under one roof?
@PSmith721 (286)
• United States
12 Nov 09
I loved my mother-in-law! We used to go out and play scrabble on her patio table. She didn't have a lot to say, but she was very wise. She passed away 2 years ago, but she will always be in my heart!! It sounds like your mother-in-law is more like my exes' mom. She called DCFS on me. That was a bad time!
@ilyzium (1197)
• Canada
12 Nov 09
Oh that's really nice that you had this warm relationship with your mother in law. I'm sorry that she passed away though. Good that you're no longer with your ex then!
• Indonesia
12 Nov 09
My mother in law is one of the kindest woman I've ever met. She has been very helpful during my pregnancy and very understanding as well. Sometimes I feel she's more understanding than my own mother lol. People have warned me how annoying mom in law can be, but mine isn't like that. She's just too kind and I love her.
@ilyzium (1197)
• Canada
12 Nov 09
I think you're really lucky then to have this kind of relationship with your mother in law. How nice is that that you relate to her better than your own mother.
@adhyz82 (36249)
• Indonesia
12 Nov 09
hm, thats nice news for you citra. maybe your husband mothers have no daughter only son so, maybe she love and care you so much.
• Thailand
12 Nov 09
I don't actually have a mother in low so I can't actually discribe my words. To me a mother In-Law is defined as a good one, if she actually loves her non-related blood son/daughter like her real son. If it comes to treating them unfairly then I feel real sorry for the son/daughter as they probably will have problems through out their lives. So I suggest every mother-in-law to treat their non related children fairly and just love them, it doesn't hurt to love someone.
@ilyzium (1197)
• Canada
12 Nov 09
I guess that would be easier said than done for some people...? I actually think that I don't really have any friends that have positive relationships with their mothers in law...just thought of that, strange.
@jaz2009 (117)
• Sweden
12 Nov 09
My mother in law visits once in a month and stay with us in our apartment. She lives approximately 500 kilometers away and I think that is better, because I feel uneasy whenever she is around. She is nice but like any other mother in laws, she also wants to meddle in everything. And now that she have a grandchild with his son (my husband), she implies to follow her parenting style, which makes me upset. I don't want her to interfere with our parenting style. I don't want to tell her directly, I just told my husband to tell her in a nicer way.
@ilyzium (1197)
• Canada
13 Nov 09
Well that's why it's nice that your mother in law comes to visit and then leaves for all your sakes. ;) My mother in law sounds exactly like they way you described yours. Mine also likes to meddle in everything, thinks she knows it all, always telling you what to do and complains that "younger people never listen to older people". I've told her that we all are going to make mistakes but they're OUR mistakes and we learn by them. I do think it is up to her son though to tell her to back off. Mine never really did that so I had to tell her myself.
• United States
11 Nov 09
I never had a chance to meet my mother in law but I wish I would have she sounds like she was a beautiful woman...She raised a good son I know that.
@ilyzium (1197)
• Canada
11 Nov 09
I'm sorry that you never had a chance to meet your mother in law, especially as she raised a good son.