What do you think?

United States
September 20, 2011 12:16pm CST
I have a friend that I go to church with. They have been hit with hard times, just like a lot of people in the last several years. I have tried to help them out in the past, nothing big, just some things here and there. Yesterday I got a text with I found out later was a mass text to a bunch of people stating that this friend's 21 year old daughter needed over $200 for a warrant or she would be going to jail. At first I thought it was like a chain text but I replied anyway stating that I couldn't help. My daughter got the same text since she's friends with the 21 year old girl. My daughter asked me if I had it and I said of course I did but I wasn't gonna loan it to them. Would you have given them the money?
3 people like this
7 responses
@Shar19 (8231)
• United States
20 Sep 11
I could see helping someone out for food and household items if they were in really stuff times. That's just being human and wanting to help people survive. However, to help someone out because their kid is in trouble with the law is just crazy to me. I can't believe that the parents had the nerve to send out a mass email to everyone. Makes me wonder if they are the type of parents that always cry "not my baby, she/he didn't do anything wrong". Give me a break. So no, I wouldn't help them out in that situation. You do the crime you pay the fine.
1 person likes this
• United States
20 Sep 11
You know what Shar, she is pretty much the type of person that says "not my baby" because she doesn't even require this girl to get a job even though she's 21 years old. There is so much history I can't say here, but I like you think this was an unreasonable request. Thanks for your comment.
1 person likes this
@Shar19 (8231)
• United States
1 Oct 11
Wow, a parent that doesn't make their kid get a job? Now that is crazy. No wonder she walks all over them. Sounds like the family does have a lot of messed up issues.
@tech2d (338)
• United States
21 Sep 11
No I would not have given them the money. I'm not going to help anyone break the law. I understand about helping other people though. My ex-wife and her husband came to me and asked that I let my youngest son stay with me as they lost their home. I said ok. Next came the dog, which I was not to fond of as I have no pets and according to my lease, cannot have pets. My only request in this was I did not want her husband at my house or know where it is because they are having so many problems, I did not want them at my house. What does she do? Bring her husband to my house. I am now upset. I will continue to help my son, but not two grown adults who make more money than I and cannot manage their money. I feel like I am being used. So no....I would NOT have given the money for bail.
1 person likes this
• United States
21 Sep 11
Wow, that's a lot and I hope you are not being used. It's good you continue to help out because of your son, but I guess there is a line that should be drawn. Bail money is for sure that line for me. Good luck!
@JoyfulOne (6232)
• United States
20 Sep 11
No, I probably wouldn't have given them anything, and I think you did the right thing. You don't mention what the girl did that she has a warrant, but if there's a warrant involved, it's probably nothing small and something that she needs to learn a lesson on. Too often parents bail their kids out of everything, and they don't learn the lesson to stand on their own. Depending on what she did, a night in jail might teach her something about her actions having consequences. It's one thing to lend a cup of sugar, or hand out something food, or emergency gas, emergency baby-sitting, you know...that kind of thing. In my humble opinion, I think it's kind of nervy to send out a multiple text like that. I realize the mom might be at wit's end (and probably embarrassed), but a personal phone call would have explained more, and somebody maybe might have helped her some. If there's a threat of jail involved, then maybe the girl might realize the seriousness of whatever she did and toe the line afterwards.
1 person likes this
• United States
20 Sep 11
You're right. I thought it was very nervy to ask such a thing but I wrote it off as being desperate. I still don't know what she did for this warrant, so I wasn't gonna pay this fine. It was just too much money anyway.
1 person likes this
@GardenGerty (157615)
• United States
20 Sep 11
I am pretty sure I would say the same as all the others. I have helped people with necessities and would continue to. On the other hand, just because their is a warrant does not mean the girl is guilty. I get the impression though that she tends to get in trouble and has not learned to be responsible.
• United States
21 Sep 11
Well the girl isn't very responsible because she's 21 and not in school or working. She doesn't even seem like she wants to work. Her mom works and supports her.
@Hatley (163781)
• Garden Grove, California
21 Sep 11
stacysmomstl hi there are places they can go to get the 200 dollars so why bother other people with that. I cannot think of the name but they adverise all over the place and they will talk to the parents and lend them the money, but of course it must be paid back. no I wo uld not loan 200 dollars to a person who m ust have broke the law as she caused her own grief. I would suggest a bail bondsman and let them take care of their own errant daughter at 21 she should know better than to get in trouble and get a warrant like that. she wo uld get no sympathy from me at all.as the old tv series where the guy is always saying if you cannot do the time, then do not do the vrimel; that goes for me too.
• United States
21 Sep 11
I think I will try to look up some places where they can borrow it. It think they were in a desperate spot, but like I told my daughter, that ain't my problem. I never thought about the bail bondsman. That's a good idea. I might suggest that if they haven't conned someone into giving them the money yet. I just didn't like to be included on the "mass text". I thought my friend could just call me direct and tell me the situation. And I still don't know what the warrant is for. So you are right, no way no how am I gonna loan that money.
@SIMPLYD (90722)
• Philippines
21 Sep 11
On the first place, i would ask first what happened that the 21 year old got a warrant. If i come to know that it's because of her wrongdoing, then i wouldn't loan them even a part of the $200. I think, sometimes we have to draw the line in helping. In this case, it is just but right that the 21 year old face the charge and learn a lesson from it.
• United States
21 Sep 11
See that's the thing. I can't get an answer for that. I guess I'll find out Sunday at church. However, when I text back and asked what happened, I got nothing. That's why I think it wasn't really a warrant issue, the probably needed the money for a bill or food or something. If that's so, it upsets me too because why couldn't my friend just tell the truth. I don't know, the whole thing is very strange and I just don't like it at all.
@SIMPLYD (90722)
• Philippines
22 Sep 11
I think if my friend will be like that, saying lies just to save her face, then i would stop helping her.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
21 Sep 11
I honestly am the kind of person that will help another person whenever and where ever I can. However, I also think that there has got to be a place where you draw the line. I don't know what the warrant is about, but if her parents won't put up the money themselves, then I really don't think that I would be able to do it either. I would bail my own children out of jail if it would ever come to that, but I really don't think that I could bail someone else's child out of jail.