sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

Is There Anyone Who Hasn't Read The Harry Potter Series Besides Me? email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 98/100. gtargirl (1249)   ranked 31 out of 10,237 in reading3 years ago

Okay now, no attacking the innocent reader, but I read the first book only because my son's fourth grade teacher was reading it in class. I never had an interest to read the rest of the series. Neither did my son. Don't get me wrong, JK Rowling is a great writer (she knows the formula). Nonetheless, I felt the story had been done before. At the least I thought she was ripping of J.R.R. Tolkien but then again, many writers are influenced by other writers. Anyway, didn't mean to get on my soapbox. Am I alone? Has anyone else not read JK Rowling's books? I wonder what her crime series will be like?

 
 
reading
sponsors
Kumon
Read reviews for this business wit directions, offers and more
Washingtondc.Citysearch.com

Hp Deskjet F4100 Drivers
Update your Hp Deskjet F4100 with official drivers. Free download.
www-Repair.com/hpdeskjetf4100

Hp Deskjet 5550 Xp Drivers
Update your Hp Deskjet 5550 Xp w/ Official Drivers. Free download.
HpDeskjet5550Xp.Driver-Fix.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  harry potter, books, reading, jk rowling, harry
 
1. myLot reputation of 95/100. LilyoftheThorns (3746)   ranked 50 out of 10,237 in reading   3 years ago

YOU HAVEN'T READ HARRY POTTER! OHMYGOSH! lol. I'm kidding! I don't think it's awful that you haven't read them. People read what interests them, there are books I don't want to read. And I know they aren't as famous as Harry Potter, but who cares? It's the same situation. You shouldn't be expected to read a book you don't like just because it's famous.

I do read Harry Potter, but I was a lot more excited about reading it when they first came out. As mroe books came out, I still read them...but I could wait to read them. I haven't started the last book yet, I'll start it when I'm finished reading my current book.

I'm really interested in seeing how her crime books turn out too. Any news on that?


myLot reputation of 98/100. gtargirl (1249)   ranked 31 out of 10,237 in reading  3 years ago

I haven't heard any news on her latest venture. Is she writing for children still, or moving into the big people story line? I wonder. I'm sure she'll do well. Have a wonderful Friday evening.


myLot reputation of 85/100. oneandonemakesix (24038)   ranked 212 out of 10,237 in reading  3 years ago

I to have heard she is moving onto crime books and I will definitely pick up a book if I like the first chapter.

I love legal thrillers, and true crime stories, and Christian fiction, so I will be anxious to see how anything else seh writes turns out.

Mooch


myLot reputation of 95/100. LilyoftheThorns (3746)   ranked 50 out of 10,237 in reading  3 years ago

Yeah that's how I feel. I LOVE MIchaell Connelly books. And if she's planning on writing her crime stories anything like his they are going to be a big hit!

Kumon Read reviews for this business wit directions, offers and more Washingtondc.Citysearch.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 87/100. StrawberryKisses (1661)   ranked 8,356 out of 10,237 in reading   3 years ago

LOL I have never read the Harry Potter books either LOL I didn't even know they existed until the movies started coming out LOL They aren't the kind of books I like to read.


myLot reputation of 98/100. gtargirl (1249)   ranked 31 out of 10,237 in reading  3 years ago

Aha, I knew it. I am not alone. LOL. I actually do love fantasy but she catered too much to the child and all that stuff. Maybe I'm a little darker than that. I love my swasbuckling and wizardry done by tall, dark and handsome or pretty elf boys. Sorry, just had to put that in there. Thanks for your input and have a nice Friday evening.

Hp Deskjet F4100 Drivers Update your Hp Deskjet F4100 with official drivers. Free download. www-Repair.com/hpdeskjetf4100
 
3. myLot reputation of 93/100. xboxboy (1813)   ranked 125 out of 10,237 in reading   3 years ago

i have not read or seen the movies. my current favorite book is 'catcher in the rye' and would love to see that turned into a movie!


myLot reputation of 98/100. gtargirl (1249)   ranked 31 out of 10,237 in reading  3 years ago

I need to start with the classics again. My TBR list has a lot of Sci-Fi/Fantasy titles on it but I would love to start reading Jane Austin and other old time favorites. Thanks, my friend, for stopping by. Have yourself a great evening.

Hp Deskjet 5550 Xp Drivers Update your Hp Deskjet 5550 Xp w/ Official Drivers. Free download. HpDeskjet5550Xp.Driver-Fix.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 33/100. urbandekay (4295)   ranked 1,712 out of 10,237 in reading   3 years ago

Well, I haven't and I would imagine most adult's have not read these children's books. I don't think it is fair to say she is ripping off Tolkien, the work of whom encompasses a wealth of Mythology and speaks to the route of English culture, as well as explicating one to the major themes of existential human experience; namely the corrupting effect of power. The Potter Books may be entertaining but that's about as far as they go.

all the best urban


myLot reputation of 98/100. gtargirl (1249)   ranked 31 out of 10,237 in reading  3 years ago

Woa, I'm thinking your intelligence far surpasses mine. I'll have to look up some of those words in my dictionary. I guess some of the ideas in Ms. Rowling's stories (like the invisible robe) had already been done by Tolkien (ring). But I did try to say, that a lot of writers are influenced by other stories and authors. It's a good thing. I do think a lot of adults have read the Potter Series, don't you agree? There's bunches of them that I know. In any case, you're right, I probably shouldn't have said "ripped off." Thanks for your input. Have a nice Friday night.


myLot reputation of 33/100. urbandekay (4295)   ranked 1,712 out of 10,237 in reading  3 years ago

Well, maybe you are right, I just presumed adults would have better things to do than read kids books. Devices that make you invisible are as old as the hills, Plato mentions the same.

all the best urban

Silver Screen Dental Read reviews for this Dentist & find more local Dentist Info. Austin.Citysearch.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 91/100. dArtagnan (652)   ranked 3,745 out of 10,237 in reading   3 years ago

Well I've never read them and as far as I'm aware about half of my friends have never read them.

I actually bought the whole set cheap from a garage sale to see what all the fuss was about. I read a chapter pages and didn't get hooked at all, so just on-sold them to my ex girlfriend lol.


myLot reputation of 98/100. gtargirl (1249)   ranked 31 out of 10,237 in reading  3 years ago

Wow! Someone actually sold them in a garage sale? And then you resold them? LOL. I'm thinking that maybe these books, especially the whole series, might probably be worth something one day. Then again, they probably should be in mint condition. Anyway, how's life in Brisbane these days? I used to live in Strathpine and went to Pine Rivers High School. Ah, those were the days. I miss fish and chips and chico rolls. Mmmmmm. Well, thanks for stopping by and have a wonderful Friday or Saturday as it might be where you are down under.:)


myLot reputation of 91/100. dArtagnan (652)   ranked 3,745 out of 10,237 in reading  3 years ago

I know Pine Rivers high! Ahh yes... good old Fish'n'Chips lol. I spend part of each year in Michigan, so I know what it's like to miss certain things like that.:)
And Brisbane is good.... just insanely hot this past week though.

Www Monografia Com Find Your Soulmate & True Love. Get Matched on Compatibility Profile. Singles-Date.com/WwwMonografiaCom
 
6. myLot reputation of 97/100. raychill (3493)   ranked 339 out of 10,237 in reading   3 years ago

I know a lot of people who haven't read Harry Potter. You have at least read one book though, so you at least started the series. I think that you're a little wrong about J.R.R. Tolkien though. I don't really get the same vibe from the two writers at all. But that's your opinion and mine.

I don't think you were soapboxy at all.


myLot reputation of 98/100. gtargirl (1249)   ranked 31 out of 10,237 in reading  3 years ago

Yeah, I see now that there are those of us who haven't read the HP series. I am not alone--that's always fun to say. In any case I did think to apologize for the J.R.R. Tolkien comment. I guess what I was trying to get to was that there are a lot of similar "ideas" in both their writings. I mentioned the invisible thing (robe versus ring). Anyway I'm glad I didn't get to soapboxy. Is that a real word? LOL. Have a fun and relaxing Saturday morning.


myLot reputation of 97/100. raychill (3493)   ranked 339 out of 10,237 in reading  3 years ago

There's no need to apologize about the J.R.R. Tolkein thing, I just disagree. I'm not into the whole Lord of the Rings thing... but a lot of people find the two comparable. I just don't. I don't think their writing styles or the movie styles were similar at all.

Soapboxy can be a word if we want it too:p

Young Frankenstein in Washington D.C. See the musical Dec. 15-Jan. 10 at the Opera House. Get tickets here. Kennedy-Center.org
 
7. myLot reputation of 99/100. reinydawn (4194)   ranked 135 out of 10,237 in reading   3 years ago

Well, I'm glad to see I'm not alone. I didn't know anything about he books until after the first movie. My sister and brother - who don't read as much as I do and are tastes are about the same - are just really mystified that I have no desire to read these books. They just LOVE them!! I didn't care for the first movie, I apparently have a totally different take on what happend than what I guess everyone else thought happened... But, based on that, it's just not my kinda story. Who knows, maybe one day I'll get bored with what I've got to read - boxes of books actually - and go get the series... My oldest son (now 23) has probably read them all also.


myLot reputation of 98/100. gtargirl (1249)   ranked 31 out of 10,237 in reading  3 years ago

One day when we all run out of books to read (lol) we'll tackle Harry. Who knows, we might even enjoy them. Yes, my friend, you are not alone. Hee hee. Have a great Saturday.


myLot reputation of 99/100. reinydawn (4194)   ranked 135 out of 10,237 in reading  3 years ago

You know, that's so funny, because it's "kinda" one of my fears that I'm going to actually LIKE the books!!!!


myLot reputation of 98/100. gtargirl (1249)   ranked 31 out of 10,237 in reading  3 years ago

Oh no!! You might actually like the books? That is a frightful thought. I'm kidding. Like I said, I read the first book. From what I remember I thought it was well written and JK Rowling has a wonderful old fashion story telling kind of approach. However, something about it that just didn't make me look forward to the next installment. I'm going to wait till I'm 75, sitting on a comfy rocking chair, on my front porch overlooking the ocean to get to know Harry P. Maybe.

Kumon Read reviews for this business wit directions, offers and more Citysearch.com
 
8. myLot reputation of 98/100. marciaj (804)   ranked 199 out of 10,237 in reading   3 years ago

I have not read a single word of any of the Harry Potter books, and I have no plans to. Maybe they are good, I don't know, but nothing about them interests me. And since I have a whole shelf full of books that do interest me, the HP books are not on my list of things to read. If she is working on a crime series, that is something I may read, since I do enjoy those types of books.


myLot reputation of 98/100. gtargirl (1249)   ranked 31 out of 10,237 in reading  3 years ago

Yes, we will have to see if she makes the jump successfully. Even though I love Sci-Fi/Fantasay, a good crime story will grab me once in a while. We shall see. Thanks for stopping by and have a wonderful weekend.

WA Appraiser License Get Your Appraisal License Today. DETC Nationally Accredited. www.RealEstateLicense.com
 
9. jolly91 (2)   ranked 8,372 out of 10,237 in reading   3 years ago

I have't read it too,because I don't like that kind book.


myLot reputation of 98/100. gtargirl (1249)   ranked 31 out of 10,237 in reading  3 years ago

Hi jolly91, what kind of book do you like to read. Do you have a particular genre. It probably isn't fantasy, I'm guessing. Well, thanks for stopping by. Have a good weekend.

washington hospital occupation Full- and part-time jobs near you. Apply for your dream job today! www.JobsRadar.com
 
10. myLot reputation of 91/100. makingpots (6662)   ranked 430 out of 10,237 in reading   3 years ago

I have not read the entire series. I read the first two and started the third one. I got distracted away from finishing the third one and just haven't made it a priority to pick it back up. I thought the stories were good and enjoyed her writing but just never became a fanatic like so many people.

It is so unlike me to not finish a book. I don't like unfinished things in my life...... so that should probably tell me something.


myLot reputation of 98/100. gtargirl (1249)   ranked 31 out of 10,237 in reading  3 years ago

I'm like you. I don't like starting books and then not finish reading them. Right now I have three books on my shelf that are half read and I feel a little incomplete. LOL. Anyhow, thanks for your input and have a pleasant weekend.

Washington Scholarships Tap Into $7 Billion In Scholarship Funds. Get Free Step-By-Step Guide. FreeEducationGuide.com
 
sponsors
Silver Screen Dental
Read reviews for this Dentist& find more local Dentist Info.
Austin.Citysearch.com

Www Monografia Com
Find Your Soulmate& True Love. Get Matched on Compatibility Profile.
Singles-Date.com/WwwMonografiaCom

Young Frankenstein in Washington D.C.
See the musical Dec. 15-Jan. 10 at the Opera House. Get tickets here.
Kennedy-Center.org

similar discussions
which one do you like:books or movies
i personally feel movies have much entertainment in them since they use graphics to visualize our...
How do you end the story without Neville?!
I just read through the cast list for the second Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows movie and...
Do You Prefer Watching Harry Potter Or Reading The Books?
I think most people would prefer watching the movies because you can actually see and hear it but I...
When is harry potter 7 releasing any Ideas?
Hey when is the 7th part of harry potter releasing...any ideas...
Harry Potter
Which Harry Potter was the best in your opinion?
twilight vs harrypotter
is twilight really better than harry potter...????watch the twilight movie, n i dont really like...
Which do you prefer? Harry Potter or Twilight?
Personally I LOVE Harry Potter, but have not even seen/read the first Twilight movie/book. Which...
After I read HAlf Blood Prince the book,HBP movie was not worth?
The book was wonderful the movie was like a summary... Most of the scenes did not even appear in...
Wizard Rock
With the ending of the Harry Potter series it seems that "wrock" bands are going on hiatus. This...
Is Lord of the Rings better than Harry Potter?
With all of the hype surrounding the new Harry Potter movie, I thought it would be interesting to...
sponsors
Silver Screen Dental
Read reviews for this Dentist & find more local Dentist Info.
Austin.Citysearch.com
Www Monografia Com
Find Your Soulmate & True Love. Get Matched on Compatibility Profile.
Singles-Date.com/WwwMonografiaCom
Young Frankenstein in Washington D.C.
See the musical Dec. 15-Jan. 10 at the Opera House. Get tickets here.
Kennedy-Center.org
Kumon
Read reviews for this business wit directions, offers and more
Citysearch.com
WA Appraiser License
Get Your Appraisal License Today. DETC Nationally Accredited.
www.RealEstateLicense.com
washington hospital occupation
Full- and part-time jobs near you. Apply for your dream job today!
www.JobsRadar.com
Washington Scholarships
Tap Into $7 Billion In Scholarship Funds. Get Free Step-By-Step Guide.
FreeEducationGuide.com
Washington NCAA Baby Shop
Washington Huskies Gear for Babies. 3-Day Shipping only $4.99.
www.KidFanatics.com
Brmc - Live CD & DVD Set
BRMC has a song on the "New Moon" album. Check out their new DVD now.
myspace.com/BRMC
The Killers - Live DVD
The Killers are feat. on the New Moon album. Get their Blu-ray DVD.
amazon.com/TheKillers
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.