sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Does using a dimmer switch affect the cost of electricity?  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 7 out of 632 in sharing of knowledge 5 years ago

I was told by electrician that using dimmers will not save electricity cost.
He said that dimmers are only for ambience…
I like ambience, but I would like to save electricity as well.
Is my electrician right?


light
 

sharing of knowledge
sponsors
Need New Lighting?
Only $65 For Installed Recessed Light
GreenPElectric

Variable transformers
1-1000 amps, manual, motor, portable, micro controlled& regulated
http://variac.com

Light Bulbs For Less
Huge Selection& Great Prices - All Sizes, Watts& Styles. Shop Now.
1000Bulbs.com

pyewacket (12221) response was accepted on 1/20/2008.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  electricity, light, ambience, dimmers, bulbs
 
1. myLot reputation of 61/100. iamgenius (286)   5 years ago

use zero bulb,does not cost u much


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 7 out of 632 in sharing of knowledge  5 years ago

sure I can stay in the dark, I can also live in the forest, why would I need a house?

Need New Lighting? Only $65 For Installed Recessed Light  GreenPElectric
 
2. myLot reputation of 97/100. ersmommy1 (11456)   5 years ago

CFLs are simply miniature versions of full-sized fluorescents. They screw into standard lamp sockets, and give off light that looks just like the common incandescent bulbs - not like the fluorescent lighting we associate with factories and schools.And you can save up to 20% on your electric bill.


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 7 out of 632 in sharing of knowledge  5 years ago

yes, but I am talking about dimmer SWITCH....
I have installed few and I want to know if I can save using dimmer light....


myLot reputation of 95/100. zeloguy (2397)   ranked 45 out of 632 in sharing of knowledge  5 years ago

Simple answer... as you dim a light bulb it uses less electricity but that is not the way to save electric. You would have to have a regular light bulb so dim you would not be able to see (about 30% of the output) instead of just installing compact florescent bulbs.

Variable transformers 1-1000 amps, manual, motor, portable, micro controlled & regulated  http://variac.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 95/100. LittleMel (7625)   5 years ago

I'm not sure about dimmer. We have lamps that we can switch to dimmer and dimmest, still we pay the same amount every month.
the best way to save electricity is to buy energy saving bulb. you can see the sign on the package when you go out and buy them.


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 7 out of 632 in sharing of knowledge  5 years ago

I have energy saving bulbs already...I am still trill with dimmers....I have some with remote control...

Light Bulbs For Less Huge Selection & Great Prices - All Sizes, Watts & Styles. Shop Now.  1000Bulbs.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 98/100. pyewacket (12221)   ranked 55 out of 632 in sharing of knowledge   5 years ago

I was looking around for that answer..think your electrician is right...that it's just an ambience effect..it will make the bulb last longer though the dimmer you have it--so in other words...only by having the light completely off will you save on electricity--though I did got a bit conflicting info...the first suggests that you only save on the bulb's "life" while the second source says yes, you do save electricity therefore money...guess time will tell on that new electric bill..right?

(First source)


HOW DO DIMMERS SAVE ENERGY ?
When the light is off, no energy is being used. The longer the triac is off, the lower the light output, and the greater the energy savings.

Lutron Dimmers Pay for Themselves:
Dimming
the lights Saves
electricity Makes incandescent
bulbs last longer
10% 10% 2 times longer
25% 20% 4 times longer
50% 40% 20 times longer
75% 60% > 20 times longer

Here's the link


http://www.lutron.com/pro...



(second source)


Energy-Saving Idea #3: Dim the lights. Dimmer switches are a wonderful convenience people have long enjoyed. They conserve electricity—up to 50 percent off the lighting portion of your electricity bill—and they extend the life of your bulbs up to 20 times. Dimmers can be used with existing incandescent bulbs.

http://64.233.169.104/sea...


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 7 out of 632 in sharing of knowledge  5 years ago

I was on line for over 2 hours and I get all confusing information too.
In one source they say it saves bulbs in other that it saves electricity...
My switch claim to save money. Because I did not see saving,I start to question.
This is my system. I feel like I am saving only on bulbs....

http://www.3bmsmartswitch.ca/index.htm

Energy Saving Light Bulbs 20,000 Hour Bulbs, Compact Fluorescent, Halogen, Full Spectrum, CFL's.  www.bulborama.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 95/100. OreoCookie3 (22476)   5 years ago

That is a new one on me. I always thought there would be less electricity if the light wasn't as bright. I like ambiance too, but I did think less electricity was used. Think we should start buying those expensive light bulbs that are supposed to save us money.


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 7 out of 632 in sharing of knowledge  5 years ago

It is new for me too...most of my bulbs are energy saving bulbs...but...wouldn't be nice to save more with dimmers?...

Tulips.com Fresh Cut Flowers & Bulbs Direct from the Farm! Guaranteed!  www.tulips.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 100/100. arkaf61 (5809)   ranked 330 out of 632 in sharing of knowledge   5 years ago

Hmm I never really thought about the dimmer in terms of saving electricity. I do have dimmers and I use them mostly for ambience. THe light is still on, even dimmed so I wouldn't think it would save in electricity.SO I"m guessing your electrician is right :)
On the other hand I also use energy saving light bulbs, going by what I read about them, they do help since they spend less electricity.


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 7 out of 632 in sharing of knowledge  5 years ago

Yes, bulbs are saving for sure...dimmers are not...(if my electrician was right)

Ultra Bright Flashlights Brilliant ultra-bright police flashlights.  www.blacklightsusa.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 98/100. mipen2006 (2935)   ranked 372 out of 632 in sharing of knowledge   5 years ago

I don't know, but I would have thought the lower the light, the less power required. To me that's logic.


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 7 out of 632 in sharing of knowledge  5 years ago

It was my logic too, but it is not working this way...

New: Bulbs And up to -57% Compare prices now and pay up to 57% less on high quality Bulbs And!  www.Bulbs-And.news72.com
 
8. myLot reputation of 60/100. ltmoon (848)   5 years ago

Your electrician is mostly right. In spite of all the tripe someone C&Ped into their response, dimmers do not really save you much money and actually shorten the life of the bulbs. A dimmed bulb draws a little less energy, but not in direct relation to the lower brightness.

so...Dim your lights and enjoy the ambiance!

The way to really reduce energy use and save money is to switch to the new curly-Q florescent bulbs. Without even changing your other lighting habits, switching all your bulbs will cut the lighting portion of your electric bill by 70-80% depending on the bulbs you use.


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 7 out of 632 in sharing of knowledge  5 years ago

Yes, I like ambiance....maybe I can have few Q bulbs for saving in my bathroom...

led light Find led light Online. Free Shipping $50 on 100,000 Items!  Target.com/FreeShipping
 
9. myLot reputation of 60/100. ltmoon (848)   5 years ago

P.S. You can't use a dimmer on a florescent bulb!!!


myLot reputation of 77/100. Mondoh (118)  5 years ago

Yes U can, will say so on the package...
New stuff, Home Depot, Loew's, online..
AC

Ambience Looking For Ambience? Find It Nearby With Local.com!  Local.com
 
10. myLot reputation of 95/100. gabs8513 (23375)   ranked 51 out of 632 in sharing of knowledge   5 years ago

I have to be honest I always thought that it saved electricity but I am not sure
I thought it did because if the Lights are dim they should not use as much electricity
Now I am not sure and I don't know


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 7 out of 632 in sharing of knowledge  5 years ago

I like to have dimmer lights all over the house, but it cost a lot...


myLot reputation of 91/100. mbcousins (104)   ranked 107 out of 632 in sharing of knowledge  5 years ago

Thank you Mohndo....I am tuned to PolaChicago when it comes to ambience. Can't really have romantic environment w/o ambience. I'm an old hippy so I like colored lighting to so I am willing to pay the extra pennies on the few occasions I have to be romantic. Believe me, I won't go broke. I am behind the whole green push though. I believe we can help to reduce the strain on old mother earth.


myLot reputation of 97/100. polachicago (8508)   ranked 7 out of 632 in sharing of knowledge  5 years ago

Thank you, sweet respond...:)


energy1 (1)  1 year ago

I do not know the answer but I have heard that what the electician was saying was:
By using a dimmer with an incandescent bulb you do save electricity, but the electric meter does not respond to this energy saving, so you do not save money.
The triac in the dimmer switches the sine wave of AC voltage, so the bulb only uses a fraction of that wave; the dimmer the setting, the more of the wave is turned off and the more energy is saved. That means the bulb is dimmer and cooler, saving power. But the meter measures the AC sine wave and not fractions of waves.

So the power company saves real power, they don't have to generate that power that you saved. But they still charge you as if you didn't dim the bulb.

2. Dimming incandescent bulbs increases life of the bulb, especially dimmers that work as an linear switch. Bulbs burn out due to thermal shock, so the more gentlly they turn on, the less themal shock they encounter.

3. There are dimmers for flourescents, but given the above issue, why bother and risk shorter bulb life.

Super cheap For Led Light Over 6.000 shops & 23 Mil products! Best-Price.com - the shop expert.  www.For-Led-Light.best-price.com
 
sponsors
Energy Saving Light Bulbs
20,000 Hour Bulbs, Compact Fluorescent, Halogen, Full Spectrum, CFL's.
www.bulborama.com

Tulips.com
Fresh Cut Flowers& Bulbs Direct from the Farm! Guaranteed!
www.tulips.com

Ultra Bright Flashlights
Brilliant ultra-bright police flashlights.
www.blacklightsusa.com

similar discussions
When there is power failure, what do you do to make waiting time worthwhile?
Power failures seem to be happening to us nowadays. They always last for an hour or more. We just...
Do you know what to do during a strong earthquake?
Hi guy! Here in the Philippines specifically in Visayas a strong earthquake happened causing a lot...
Is using an extension wire dangerous?
We were just studying about electricity and stuff and I read in our book that that using extension...
Unplug your appliances when not in use
A lot of us know probably are aware that leaving appliances, gadgets or anything that uses...
Do you save electricity? What are the tips for saving?
I think we should try to save electricity for the future. I am using CF lamps instead of other...
How much electricity a computer consumes?
I heard that a pc or computer just consume that much electricity which a tube light consumes, is it...
Solar Bottle Bulb (new way to save electricity)
Here's a new way save electricity and at the same time environmentally friendly. All you need is a...
making electricity from fruit
I asked yesterday why cars were considered the safest place in a thunderstorm, and was told about...
What are the steps you are taking to save the electricity bill?
Dear mylotters, Do you switch off your fridge/refrigerator for some particular hours to save...
Beginning of Stone Age in Pakistan
Beginning of Stone Age in Pakistan, Because we can see the shortage of every thing like...
sponsors
Energy Saving Light Bulbs
20,000 Hour Bulbs, Compact Fluorescent, Halogen, Full Spectrum, CFL's.
www.bulborama.com
Tulips.com
Fresh Cut Flowers & Bulbs Direct from the Farm! Guaranteed!
www.tulips.com
Ultra Bright Flashlights
Brilliant ultra-bright police flashlights.
www.blacklightsusa.com
New: Bulbs And up to -57%
Compare prices now and pay up to 57% less on high quality Bulbs And!
www.Bulbs-And.news72.com
led light
Find led light Online. Free Shipping $50 on 100,000 Items!
Target.com/FreeShipping
Ambience
Looking For Ambience? Find It Nearby With Local.com!
Local.com
Super cheap For Led Light
Over 6.000 shops & 23 Mil products! Best-Price.com - the shop expert.
www.For-Led-Light.best-price.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.