Pre-paid credit cards, has anyone used one? What's good and not so good about

@writersedge (22563)
United States
July 30, 2008 7:08am CST
them? I work at a call-in sales center. People see a TV commercial, newspaper ad, or radio ad. They call into us. In order to buy anything from us, they must have a credit or debit card. Many people say they don't have one. One of the instructions is to tell them to get a pre-paid card, sometimes, depends. Anyway, I went to Rite Aid to check out pre-paid credit cards. Seems like some of the card companies want a lot of money to buy the card (some as much as $14.95) and some want a lot to keep them going ($4.95 a month-more or less). So that could be $20 just to get started to use a card. Has anyone used them? Are they better or not as good as a regular credit card? Can you overdraw on them? The rates seem like a lot, but credit card companies seem to charge even more so maybe it actually saves you? Do you reload them the same place you buy them from and does it cost you a lot every time you reload? Are some companies cheaper than others? Have they come in handy for you? I don't like telling people to go do something I haven't done. I'm interested in getting one and I think in the long run it would be better than a regular credit card, but I'm not so sure. What do you think?
3 people like this
5 responses
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
30 Jul 08
They would be all right for someone with bad credit and someone who is trying to rebuild credit. It also might be all right for someone with good credit who does not want to carry a lot of cash with them, but it would be the fees to buy one would get me off and the stigma that if I do get one, they will think it is because I got bad credit. If you want to establish credit, the best bay besides putting enough money in the bank so the bank knows you are a good risk, is to buy something on the 30 to 90 day plan and pay it off previous. With the regular credit card you do not have to pay an annual fee unless you get the one with the benefits, but why not use a debit card? I doubt these pre-paid credit cards give points or airmles.
3 people like this
@writersedge (22563)
• United States
30 Jul 08
So you like the debit card better than a pre-paid card. Interesting, you think there is a stigma to them. I don't think of people having bad credit. I think of people not wanting to get into debt or if their card is stolen having all kinds of crazy charges on it. Prepay means the money is there, unlike regular credit cards. My husband is with you. He likes debit cards. Many people that call in say they have only savings accounts, of course they could just be trying to get a sales person off their backs, but they call me, I don't call them. All I know is that cash doesn't work on the phone and many people who call in are against credit cards and some are even against debit cards. Many fear them getting stolen or in the case of elderly people, someone seeing them using them and beating them for the card or knocking them over to steal them. But with a call, you can report them missing and stop payments. But you can't do that if you're in the hospital unconscious. I guess there are all different ways of looking at things. I hate debit cards. When they first came out, those ATM machines did all kinds of stuff including jam my check and not give me any money. So for three days I didn't have a cent. Also if I pressed a wrong number and didn't notice, I got locked out. So I told them they could keep their debit card. Unemployment gave sent me one, I would only use it at an atm and I could only take out $20 at a time. So I have $18 in the card that I will never be able to get out of there, but I paid taxes on it. When you get 1/2 the pay you would have made per week and every week, you can't take out the last bit of it under $20, you catch a serious attitude, esp. when you have to ask your husband for money to keep going and the amount you need per week is usually under $20 that you're short that you could have had if it wasn't for that brainless policy!
2 people like this
@ElicBxn (64169)
• United States
30 Jul 08
For someone who has no credit left, a pre-paid allows them to help rebuild their credit. You can't overdraw them, at least, you couldn't when they started. They aren't better or worse than a regular card, just different.
2 people like this
@writersedge (22563)
• United States
30 Jul 08
Good, you can't overdraw them, that's better than a bank account and maybe a debit card. Fee wise or money wise, it seems like they could be better or worse depending on the fees for each card. American Express seemed to have only $5. or $6 for the initial charge for the card and then $2 per month, but suspended if you kept using the card for a certain period of time. Whereas was it Visa or Master card that had $14.95 charge to start pluse $4.95 per month to keep it going. Seems like my regular credit cards are more than that. Thanks, no credit or at end of credit, helps people out. So they may be a good idea for some people.
2 people like this
@mcc371 (918)
• United States
31 Jul 08
That was very sweet to choose mine as the best response. Thank you!
1 person likes this
@writersedge (22563)
• United States
1 Aug 08
You're welcome. You explored every aspect of credit, debit and prepaid cards that I was wondering about. You deserve it.
1 person likes this
@carolbee (16230)
• United States
30 Aug 08
I have not used a pre-paid credit card and probably never will. I know nothing about them until you started this discussion. It sounds like it would be a good idea for those who tend to spend too much on their monthly credit cards. Depending on the balance of the regular credit card and the interest, it's cheaper to pay the $4.95 each month. I can see where it would be helpful if someone was on a tight budget and wanted to buy groceries, etc. on this card.
1 person likes this
@writersedge (22563)
• United States
31 Aug 08
All very true. Where I live, fewer places are taking checks. Often signs say cash or credit card;no checks. Thanks and take care.
1 person likes this
@saundyl (9783)
• Canada
10 Feb 09
I have a prepaid much music card - it has my name on it it was only about 40 dollars to get and they have reasonable rates. I've checked out others and they seem terribly unreasonable or expensive just to have when you dont want a "real" card. There's no interest on mine there's a 1.50 load fee and i think a 9 dollar yearly renewal fee...not expensive. of course theres limits like a debit card on how much you can load or spend in a day but to me thats not unreasonable. I like using mine for online purchases. I have noticed however a few places (like for final fantasy) wont accept prepaid ones even if you have the funds on it. I'll be trying to book a flight sometime with it as well to see.
1 person likes this
@writersedge (22563)
• United States
11 Feb 09
Thank you, it's always good to have someone tell from personal experience what something is like. Take care, and hope to see you around more.