sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   news   photos

Do you consider Sign Language as a Language??  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 95/100. pheonixstar1982 (1307)   ranked 39 out of 14,563 in questions & answers 1 year ago

When people ask how many languages i know, i always say two: English and Sign Language. But the question is how many people consider Sign Language as a second language? If you do not why? Is it because you believe a language has to be spoken?

 

questions & answers
sponsors
Washington Nationals Tickets
Buy Washington Nationals tickets here at 100% guaranteed prices.
www.frontrowseatsllc.com

Official Digi-Key Site
Search Our Huge Selection of Quality Electronic Components Here.
www.DigiKey.com

Teach Baby Language
Unlock your child's potential for speech and language.
www.BabysFirstFiveYears.com

texasheartland (1194) response was accepted on 10/16/2008.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  sign language, language, communication, asl, second language
 
1. myLot reputation of 73/100. irishidid (3168)   ranked 3,957 out of 14,563 in questions & answers   1 year ago

I do consider it a second language, but I have deaf and hard of hearing family members. I don't know that everyone would think it would be though.


myLot reputation of 95/100. pheonixstar1982 (1307)   ranked 39 out of 14,563 in questions & answers  1 year ago

I have a brother who is non-verbal and we use sign language for him. I consider it a second language because a language does not just apply to words being spoken.


myLot reputation of 73/100. irishidid (3168)   ranked 3,957 out of 14,563 in questions & answers  1 year ago

Exactly. I remember when my daughter was in developmental preschool and they would use signing to help those kids. My daughter is verbal but often used sign language when she was younger because she felt more comfortable than speaking.
Communication by sign is important to more than just the deaf.


myLot reputation of 95/100. pheonixstar1982 (1307)   ranked 39 out of 14,563 in questions & answers  1 year ago

Yeah, a lot of parents are also teaching there babies sign language for a more effective way of communicating until they learn to speak. I think that is awesome.

Washington Nationals Tickets Buy Washington Nationals tickets here at 100% guaranteed prices.  www.frontrowseatsllc.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 96/100. moonlitmagikchild (7384)   ranked 24 out of 14,563 in questions & answers   1 year ago

i never really thought about it and your right it is.. so there should be an option on surveys and applications to choose it then..


myLot reputation of 95/100. pheonixstar1982 (1307)   ranked 39 out of 14,563 in questions & answers  1 year ago

It should be listed.

Official Digi-Key Site Search Our Huge Selection of Quality Electronic Components Here.  www.DigiKey.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 45/100. WhatsHerName (1726)   1 year ago

Thought I don't know sign language, I wish I did and I consider it a language. I think it would be great if it were our second language. So many times I wish we all knew it so we could talk to each other from a distance. I hate it when people yell at each other from across a room. I sure could use it where I work.


myLot reputation of 95/100. pheonixstar1982 (1307)   ranked 39 out of 14,563 in questions & answers  1 year ago

Everyone in my family uses sign language because i have a brother that is non-verbal. The draw back about using it across a room is that people have a tendency to think you are talking about them.


myLot reputation of 45/100. WhatsHerName (1726)  1 year ago

Well then, they need to learn it too.

Teach Baby Language Unlock your child's potential for speech and language.  www.BabysFirstFiveYears.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 82/100. Simplyme31 (160)   ranked 2,431 out of 14,563 in questions & answers   1 year ago

I would say that I do believe that it is because language is ones form of communication and to me it is speaking with actions instead of sound therefore sign language to me is an actual language.


myLot reputation of 95/100. pheonixstar1982 (1307)   ranked 39 out of 14,563 in questions & answers  1 year ago

I agree but i have talked about it with a friend who said that i could not consider it as a second language based solely because nothing verbal was spoken and i was using American Sign Language. They said if i was signing in another language that he would consider it a second language.

Sacramento Storage Units Find Sacramento Storage Facilities - Residential, Commercial, Mini.  yellowpages.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 94/100. migsmartinez (1096)   ranked 495 out of 14,563 in questions & answers   1 year ago

Definitely. I think a language is a structured means of communication. Since a lot of people use Sign Language as a means of communication and because there is structure to it, I consider it a language. I don't think a language has to be spoken.


myLot reputation of 95/100. pheonixstar1982 (1307)   ranked 39 out of 14,563 in questions & answers  1 year ago

I totally agree.

sign language interpreting jobs (Hiring) Apply Here Found: 100's local jobs in your area. $10- $75+ /hr + Benefits.  www.bestjobfinder.net
 
6. myLot reputation of 93/100. texasheartland (1194)   1 year ago

I consider ASL a language. Technically, you are speaking. Just with your hands. Just because you are not using your voice doesn't mean you're not making words. If you write the words, you're are still using a language. Hands are not that much different. Just used for different situations.

And I find it admirable you know ASL. I have tried, but failed because I couldn't remember everything.


myLot reputation of 95/100. pheonixstar1982 (1307)   ranked 39 out of 14,563 in questions & answers  1 year ago

I must confess that there are some words i don't remember and have to look up because i don't use them regularly.

used audi cabriolet manual gearbox Used Cabriolet Research, Reviews & Latest Prices. Free Info.  www.Audi.Edmunds.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 99/100. Shellyann36 (688)   ranked 4,676 out of 14,563 in questions & answers   1 year ago

I do consider it a second language. I have an ex-sister-in-law that is deaf and I worked previously in the mental health field and sign language was necessary. I say yes to it being a second language!

Learn a Foreign Language Learn in 10 days or you don't pay! Millions satisfied incl FBI & CIA.  PimsleurApproach.com
 
8. myLot reputation of 95/100. miraclefreebies (703)   ranked 217 out of 14,563 in questions & answers   1 year ago

Yes, why not?..They have a name for everything else, and besides, it's a form of communication, only without sound. I guess it can be a language as long as it can be understood. If it's not a language, then what else could it be. There's a language for every tongue out there, I don't think it would be fair to silent tongues to not have a language also. I know this may sound silly, but I think I have a point.


myLot reputation of 95/100. pheonixstar1982 (1307)   ranked 39 out of 14,563 in questions & answers  1 year ago

I agree and it was the point i was trying to make. You did it much better than i did.

express insurance washington DC You Could Save Up To 50% On Auto Insurance! Compare Online…  WashingtonD.C..INScarriers.com
 
9. myLot reputation of 89/100. sconibear (2659)   ranked 452 out of 14,563 in questions & answers   1 year ago

taken from The American Heritage Dictionary:


language

NOUN:

1.
1. Communication of thoughts and feelings through a system of arbitrary signals, such as voice sounds, gestures, or written symbols.

2. Such a system including its rules for combining its components, such as words.

3. Such a system as used by a nation, people, or other distinct community; often contrasted with dialect.



sign language

NOUN:

1. A language that uses a system of manual, facial, and other body movements as the means of communication, especially among deaf people.

2. A method of communication, as between speakers of different languages, that uses hand movements and other gestures.


so there you have it, by definition sign language is a true language.....and a very helpful one at that. thumbup

Help Develop Language In Your Baby Help your child's brain develop with the Your Baby Can Read system.  www.yourbabycanread.com
 
10. myLot reputation of 93/100. aisaellis22 (3530)   ranked 87 out of 14,563 in questions & answers   1 year ago

Sign language is a language indeed but i will never be considered as a second language nor first language. Come to think of it, wher we are a baby we communicate to our parents through sign language, so does it means that sign language is everybody's language?

Based on wikipedia, sign language uses virtually transmitted sign patterns to convey meaning.


myLot reputation of 95/100. pheonixstar1982 (1307)   ranked 39 out of 14,563 in questions & answers  1 year ago

Using sign language as a language and a baby using gestures to communicate their needs is two totally different things. One is used because one is deaf or can not speak. The other is used because development has not progressed to the speaking stage. Does that mean that you believe a language has to be spoken to be considered a second language??

Download Sis Sound Driver Update your Download Sis Sound w/ Official Drivers. Free download.  www.Driver-Fix.com/downloadsis
 
sponsors
Sacramento Storage Units
Find Sacramento Storage Facilities - Residential, Commercial, Mini.
yellowpages.com

sign language interpreting jobs (Hiring) Apply Here
Found: 100's local jobs in your area. $10- $75+/hr + Benefits.
www.bestjobfinder.net

used audi cabriolet manual gearbox
Used Cabriolet Research, Reviews& Latest Prices. Free Info.
www.Audi.Edmunds.com

similar discussions
Do you think you should teach a non-communicative disabled child sign language?
This is the question I would like your opinion on. Do you think you should teach a...
Why Not???
Here in the States, I see that the public schools are big on pushing the kids to learn a second...
Teaching babies and toddlers to sign
I've been teaching my kid to sign since she was 9 months old and she can sign quite a few things...
Learning a language...
In my days as a student I have had the chance to learn different languages including Spanish,...
do you know sign language
right now i dont know sign language, but i would love to learn it some day. its very interesting to...
Can Sign Language Help a Hearing Child Who Has a Speech Delay?
A little boy, 23 months old has a speech delay despite the fact that he is obviously intelligent...
deaf can do it ?
i am deaf, i was wonder if deaf people can enter to american idol too ? deaf dont have to sing just...
Who do you think are more harder to teach... a blind person or a deaf one?
I am a future SPED teacher but just started taking up some units in my Masters of Arts in Education...
Anyone attempting to learn ASL??
I'm trying to learn sign lanuage. I would really love to be able to sign very well, and interpret...
you know how to use a sign language?
when i was younger i sure do... curiosity leaves me to knowing the good part of sign language.......
sponsors
Sacramento Storage Units
Find Sacramento Storage Facilities - Residential, Commercial, Mini.
yellowpages.com
sign language interpreting jobs (Hiring) Apply Here
Found: 100's local jobs in your area. $10- $75+ /hr + Benefits.
www.bestjobfinder.net
used audi cabriolet manual gearbox
Used Cabriolet Research, Reviews & Latest Prices. Free Info.
www.Audi.Edmunds.com
Learn a Foreign Language
Learn in 10 days or you don't pay! Millions satisfied incl FBI & CIA.
PimsleurApproach.com
express insurance washington DC
You Could Save Up To 50% On Auto Insurance! Compare Online…
WashingtonD.C..INScarriers.com
Help Develop Language In Your Baby
Help your child's brain develop with the Your Baby Can Read system.
www.yourbabycanread.com
Download Sis Sound Driver
Update your Download Sis Sound w/ Official Drivers. Free download.
www.Driver-Fix.com/downloadsis
used 4 door anti-lock braking system
Research Used 4 Doors Find Unbiased Car Buying Research.
www.Edmunds.com
Dymaburn Weight Control Formula $17.98
Save on Popular Body Building Formula from Dymatize Nutrition.
www.vitadigest.com
baby sign language video
Baby Sign Language Dvds, Videos, Books and Cds.
SigningTime.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.