sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

End our current health care system email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 46/100. thegreatdebater (1032)   ranked 511 out of 6,346 in politics8 months ago

The United States has made many mistakes in our countries history, one of our worse may be our continuation of a failed health care system. This is a system that provides free health care coverage for the poor, the powerful, and the olderly. But, makes the rest of us fend for ourselfs. The rest of us are left to pay the outrageous salaries for doctors, health care executives, pharmaceutical CEO's, and for research and developement of new drugs (that most of use working stiffs can't afford). This is also very harmful to our economy, most other countries pay for their health care, so their corporations don't subsidize their countries health care like US corporations do. Two companies (GM and GE) pay over a billion dollars a year in health care, most of their foreign competition doesn't pay a dime, thus putting them at a disadvantage. Can you please explain to me why you want to keep this system intacted?

 
 
politics
sponsors
Tell Congress: Get Health Reform Right
Speak out to ensure that health reform creates VALUE for patients.
HealthCareREPAIR.org

DC Area Attractions
Find museums, national monuments, historic homes, wineries and more.
www.fxva.com

health care employment md
Search 1000's of Listings& Find The Right Healthcare Job In DC Area.
www.washingtonpost.com/jobs

xfahctor (5223) response was accepted on 7/16/2009.
denotes best response.
tags:  health care, socialized medicine, don't just complain, help make a change
 
1. myLot reputation of 77/100. xfahctor (5223)   ranked 68 out of 6,346 in politics   8 months ago

It does need an overhaul, a big one. However, to simply pounce on it in a simple reactive way would be a disaster of near biblical praportions. A number of questions that must FIRST be answered are:
1.) How will it be paid for and who gets the bill?
2.) How do we ensure the quality and availability remains?
3.) How do we do it with out turning such a system in to to a beurocracy like everything else the federal government runs?
And those only scratch the general surface of questions, it doesn't even touch the thousands of specifics in each of those 4 questions. The big hurtle is that our federal government is already neck deep in far more than it is suposed to be and as a result, it doesn't do any one thing particularly effective, inexpensive, efficiantly or rapidly, except maybe to get in the way of our lives and liberty.
You might be suprised to know I am not nessesarily against some sort of government alternative to health coverage, that is, a government sponsored insurance plan for those who wish to opt in. But I want:
a.) for such a plan to NOT be manditory,
b.) to ONLY deal with paying the bills and oversight of the billing proccess to those who choose it, NOT the healthcare itself
c.) To strip the government back to it's original intent and eliminate a lot of the nonsense to pay for it and make it more efficiant before it runs ANYTHING else
d.) To have a clear and effective way to pay for it
e.) To impliment such a system in a constitutionaly sound manner.


myLot reputation of 77/100. xfahctor (5223)   ranked 68 out of 6,346 in politics  8 months ago

oops, forgot original question 4
4.) How do we do it in a constitutionaly sound manner and not effect the liberties of the people and the rights of the states?

Tell Congress: Get Health Reform Right Speak out to ensure that health reform creates VALUE for patients. HealthCareREPAIR.org
 
2. KLVentures (92)   ranked 201 out of 6,346 in politics   8 months ago

We need to be very careful when looking at reforming the health care system in this country. There are some advantages with the current system that I do not believe have been properly expressed to the public.

First of all, we do have the best care in the world available here in the U.S.A.. We may not be able to afford it but it is available here. As an example, my wife had to have brain surgery a year ago due to the presence of an AVM. She had her surgery at Mass General Hospital in Boston. Luckily, we had decent insurance and were able to afford the procedure. While down there, we met several other people that were at the hospital from other countries with socialized medicine. They were at Mass General to receive treatment because the surgeries they needed were not available in their country or the wait was too long.

Second, the tax burden for a socialized health care program will be extremely burdensome on the tax payer. The amount of tax increase will require for Americans to dramatically alter their lifestyles. The estimates on this cost vary widely, but I think it would be safe to say that the average taxpayer would lose an additional 10% of their income to fund such a program.

I do believe that we can make improvements to the way we pay for health care in this country, but we need to be very careful in the way that we decide to do this.


myLot reputation of 81/100. irisheyes (2931)   ranked 232 out of 6,346 in politics  8 months ago

"First of all, we do have the best care in the world available here in the U.S.A.. We may not be able to afford it but it is available here"....This is the crux of the problem. What good is healthcare that the host country's citizens cannot afford? Jefferson Hospital in Philadelphia prides itself on having the best neurosurgery on the face of the earth. If you visit, they will give you a spiel about how the members of Arabian ruling familiies fly in there on a regular basis. Frankly, I'm more concerned with the care they are offering to the underinsured South Philly workingman or woman. When I accompanied a sick friend to Jeff and heard their little pep talk, all I could think of was those hyjacked US airplanes on 911. On that day, they hyjacked our airplanes and now their money seems to be hyjacking our best hospitals while many of our own citizens do without and our government does nothing.


myLot reputation of 46/100. thegreatdebater (1032)   ranked 511 out of 6,346 in politics  8 months ago

KLV, you are 100% correct in your statement that we have the best health care in the world: If you can afford it. There are two different people in this country: Those that can aford it (or work for a company that helps pay for your insurance), and those that can't (or people that work for a company that don't care about their employees, or bought into the Bush health insurance plan HSA's). I am not 100% for national health care, but I think that we need to do something to stop the huge profits of hositals, and drug companies. While the people of the United States is subsidizing R & D for the drug companies they are sell their drugs in foreign countries for up to half the price we pay here. Why should we allow this?

You make a very good point about the amount of money for a national plan, but I don't think you will like what I am about to tell you. Look at your W2 from last year. Now look at how much money you made, and look at how much money you spent on health insurance, now include any co-pays. I bet you are real close to that magical 10% mark. I can tell you that national health care is going to cost about 10%, which is the average amount of mony people pay in health care throughout the country. Kind of strange isn't it.

DC Area Attractions Find museums, national monuments, historic homes, wineries and more. www.fxva.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 74/100. cjforeverknight (340)   ranked 2,529 out of 6,346 in politics   8 months ago

I heard that Australia & the UK pays for the health care of the citizens. Also I heard from a friend of mine that Australia when you pay for your auto tag you pay for your auto insurance at the same time. It sounds to me like these countries care about the citizens.


myLot reputation of 59/100. MysticTomatoes (795)   ranked 2,140 out of 6,346 in politics  8 months ago

They care about their citizens with some of the highest tax rates in the western world. England pays about 35-40% in taxes on just about everything including their income. With this "free" healthcare comes higher taxes and that's something that 90% of Americans can't afford. Take what you make now. Slash that by half. Can you afford to live on half of what you make? I know I can't. Our salaries keep shrinking and taxes keep rising.


myLot reputation of 46/100. thegreatdebater (1032)   ranked 511 out of 6,346 in politics  8 months ago

Mystic, if England has such high taxes, then why does anyone live there? New York and California have some of the high taxes in the country, yet their population is much larger than the majority of the country. Taxes are huge in places like France, yet they go on vacation often, and their debt is much lower than ours. People have been throwing numbers around for year as to how much it would cost to move to national health care, and most are wrong.


myLot reputation of 59/100. MysticTomatoes (795)   ranked 2,140 out of 6,346 in politics  8 months ago

THe fact is that AMericans are fat and lazy. The problem is that our incomes don't match the incomes of others around the world. England does have high taxes, but their cost of living is low enough and their incomes are high enough to where they can afford it. Ameicans can't.

Google it.

health care employment md Search 1000's of Listings & Find The Right Healthcare Job In DC Area. www.washingtonpost.com/jobs
 
4. myLot reputation of 81/100. irisheyes (2931)   ranked 232 out of 6,346 in politics   8 months ago

I could not agree with you more. A few years ago there was a coalition formed between business and labor to take a look at the health care system. It was the first time ever that big business (Walmart etc) and labor sat down on the same side of the table. The coalition was headed by Andy Stern who was a former Philadelphia labor leader. They quickly came to the conclusion that the US health care system was broken to the point that it could not be fixed and needed to be scapped and rebuilt. I haven't heard anything about this lately but I would certainly like to see President Obama meet with some of the members of that coalition.

You hit the nail on the head when you brought up the fact that health care is a major reason we are losing jobs. It always amazes me that people can't see this and continue to harp on wages being lower elsewhere. In fact they made a big issue out of auto workers making the equivalent of 60K per year and totally glossed over the fact that at least 1/3 of that 60K package was in health care benefits. Automakers are one of the few industries that gave adequate health care and it probably helped to get them in the mess they are in.

One of my pet peeves is the situation with the hospitals in the big cities like Philadelphia where I have lived. There are more colleges and universities here than anywhere else in the country. Thousands of those graduates stay for at least awhile and work in the city. They are healthy, young people away from their family doctors and school infirmaries but they almost all work jobs with health benefits. What happens when they need an antibiotic, sprain a wrist, need a few stitches? They head for the nearest hospital ER which in Philly means a state of the art teaching hospital that automatically charges their health care plan two grand the minute they walk in the door. And who pays for those visits? Me and you and everybody paying ridiculously high health care premiums. There's got to be a better way.

Used Honda Civic Sedan at Yahoo! Certified Used Cars in Washington, DC. Shop for a Honda Used Car. www.honda.com/yahoo
 
5. myLot reputation of 78/100. sierras236 (495)   ranked 286 out of 6,346 in politics   8 months ago

I do not want government run health care period. The government has already has a proven track record of screwing things up. You want them to screw up your health care as well? Case in point, Medicare and Medicaid. The government would take all of our options away. In addition, none of our medical records would be safe anymore. HIPPA would essentially go out the window.

Sure our current system has flaws. I am not downplaying them. Every health care system you look at has flaws, UK, Canada, and Europe. Health care carries a high cost. We do have the best system in the world because it is not government controlled. The government cannot tell us what treatment is best for the individual. Can you imagine some government worker who has no medical knowledge whatsoever making your critical medical decisions? Because that is exactly what will happen.

What is the true cost if the government takes over? Think about it. Higher taxes because they need to fund it. They would hold the power of life and death in their hands. They can refuse critical treatment because it costs too much. The elderly would essentially get thrown aside because they are too costly to treat. Every one would be forced into a cookie cutter diagnosis where these symptoms are this disease regardless if the person has the disease or not.

There are options that people may not be aware of to offset the higher costs. Hospitals are generally willing to work with you to help you pay. Fundraisers are quite common. Prescription drug companies currently offer help in obtaining medications. We do have options. The government will essentially take all of those options away.


myLot reputation of 46/100. thegreatdebater (1032)   ranked 511 out of 6,346 in politics  8 months ago

Sierras, are you saying that our health care system doesn't have flaws? Our health care system is by far the most expensive in the world yet, we still have one of the highest infant death rates in the world. If our system is so go, they why does third world countries do a better job then we do at this? Right now you have a corporation deciding what is best for your medical needs, and I can point out time and time again where people were denied treatment by an insurance company, and that insurance was sued, and lost. The lie that elderly would be thrown aside is wrong, and you show me where the goverment has ever been sued for not providing treatment through medicare? Medicare wouldn't change one bit, it would stay the same, so you can throw that argument in the right wing BS bin. Do you know why hospicals, and drug companies are willing to work with you? Look at the earning for the drug companies, and look at margins, they guys are making between 30 and 5000% mark up on their drugs. These drug companies are selling drugs to countries like Canada, and England for up to a quarter of what we pay here. Please, explain to me why we here in the United States should subsidize the rest of the world?


myLot reputation of 78/100. sierras236 (495)   ranked 286 out of 6,346 in politics  8 months ago

First, I hate when people give me the wrong information when all they need to do is a simple search on google to get their facts straight. The U.S. is actually ranked #180 in infant mortality rates. www.cia.gov/library/publi... your first argument is completely off-base. Another correction, the corporation decides the medical care that they will pay for. They do not dictate to the doctors their diagnosis. This does not mean that I cannot go to another doctor for a second opinion (even though I may pay out of pocket). To be fair, cost is a determining factor in whether people seek the appropriate care or not.

The elderly will get left behind because they typically cost more to treat. The bottom line is money.

What happens when the government stops treatments that cost too much, like chemo?
Or there is no enough beds to fit everyone?

www.dailymail.co.uk/newsarticle-1172552/Girls-heart-operation-cancelled-THREE-times-shortage-hospital-beds.html?ITO=1490

The government is one huge business. They can't even run themselves. Until you can prove that the government is competent to run health care, I can not support Universal Health care.

Another solid argument is one of privacy. HIPPA was established to keep our medical records between us and the doctor. This law will disappear rather rapidly. The government will now have complete access to your medical records. They have already proven they can't handle secrets very well with the release of CIA memos. (Another topic). Plus, several stories have emerged where hackers have broken into top secret systems. Do you really think our information will be completely and 100% secure?

Are you really ready for your taxes to go up?

The power of the people is dying. You can see it every time the government passes a new law. It will only be a matter of time before we are completely invaded and all of our freedoms lost. It is already happening.

I suggest doing thorough research into government run health care systems before thinking they are the answer to the problem. They have their own flaws.

I have stated before that our current system needs changing but I have zero confidence in the government to do it.




myLot reputation of 78/100. sierras236 (495)   ranked 286 out of 6,346 in politics  8 months ago

Just fixing the links.
The first one is: www.nationmaster.com/grap...


myLot reputation of 78/100. sierras236 (495)   ranked 286 out of 6,346 in politics  8 months ago

http://www.dailymail.co.u... this doesn't work, search for Girl's heart operation cancelled three times.

Health Care Staffing Company We specialize in international recruitment of healthcare professionals for the U. S. hstar.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 59/100. MysticTomatoes (795)   ranked 2,140 out of 6,346 in politics   8 months ago

First of all, NOTHING is free. Even 0bama's "free national healthcare plan" is NOT free. If or when this passes, the lower and middle class will see a tax hike of nearly 50 to 70% of their income to pay for this "Free" healthcare system. And it'll fail. Americans are too effin lazy and too effin diseased for anything to take. We've got fat people running up billions and billions of dollars of insurane money because they can't put down the Twinkie. We've got "frequent fliers" as my husband says (He's a nurse) who come to the ED for the sniffles, a hang nail or they don't feel "right" and wind up costing the tax payers millions of dollars every year on useless tests and bogus illnesses and surgeries.

Doctors are terrified to practice medicine anymore for fear of getting sued. My husband works right now as a CRNA (Certified registered nurse anesthetist) and works in the OR with docs. He's hearing it all the time about how people are getting sued left and right. My husband is in 2 lawsuits right now as a person being sued because he was in the room when an "accident" happened. It's outrageous, and yet NO ONE wants to do anything about it.

No one wants to step forward and throw the welfare wh0res off welfare and public aid for their 9 kids by 7 different fathers. No one wants to throw the hypocondriac on public aid out in the street when she comes in for the 8th time in a week complaining of a headache. No one wants to start fining fat people for coming in and using up billions of dollars in money when they need a bypass or a new heart by the time they are 40 because they won't put down the Twinkies and fried chicken.

You've got to fix the TRUE cause of the system before you can go fixing what's on the surface. The underlying cause of the health system now is abuse. Plain and simple. No one wants to go after that. They all want to stick it to people like me who have been in the hospital oh, twice, and one of those times was when I gave birth to our daughter. They don't want to go after the hypocondriac who has been inpatient 10 times in a month. They want to instead pass the buck along to people like me who don't deserve it.

GE Improving Healthcare Learn How GE Technologies Are Reducing The Cost Of Health Care. www.healthymagination.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 97/100. LuvBr0wn13s (661)   ranked 1,850 out of 6,346 in politics   8 months ago

I read over some of the other responses and I really like what I am reading. I hear a lot of people bringing a lot of excellent points to the table. Now the idea would be to get these ideas and points to be heard. I think the average american can take their knowledge and experiences and draw up a plan of what they think should happen. If they can sit down with a few other intelligent americans that may not agree, but have the same goal in mind, I think we can give our elected officials a framework that they can work with. The best part of it is PEOPLE WILL BE GETTING INVOLVED in making the changes instead of just complaining about things being broken.
There are things about the current healthcare that are okay, and there are many things that could stand to be revamped. I have been educating myself about the current healthcare system for my own personal reasons, but thanks to the input here I think it is high time that I did my part and got involved.

Young Frankenstein at the Kennedy Center Don't miss the new musical at the Opera House. Get tickets here. Kennedy-Center.org
 
sponsors
Used Honda Civic Sedan at Yahoo!
Certified Used Cars in Washington, DC. Shop for a Honda Used Car.
www.honda.com/yahoo

Health Care Staffing Company
We specialize in international recruitment of healthcare professionals for the U. S.
hstar.com

GE Improving Healthcare
Learn How GE Technologies Are Reducing The Cost Of Health Care.
www.healthymagination.com

similar discussions
Health care reform
Is anyone out there for this or against it? let us know why... Personaly I am all for it. I live...
Don't give place to S t r e s s.....
Stress can cause several ill effects on your physical and mental planes. In,fact this may be the...
Health Care Bill
I had my practicum today and while waiting for class to start, my mentor teacher was talking about...
I know this will get all the claws out, but I am curious about the health bill.
I just read about premiums. Do I understand that a 65 year old will not pay more than twice that of...
new health care bill.
I just want to get many other opinions on this subject. I want to know if your for it or if your...
Who Cares?
I read an interesting article in the New York Times today here:...
38% of voters now favor the health care plan
This telephone polling took pace before last Saturday house vote on health care bill,as expected...
The start of Medical rationing
It seems that the administration has found a panel of "experts" who say that women do not need...
healthcare vs. health insurance
it's ok to have just health care program rather than have health insurance plan? what is difference...
Health care reform benefit a middle class employee?
How does the healthcare reform benefit a middle class families. What exactly is being changed? Does...
sponsors
Used Honda Civic Sedan at Yahoo!
Certified Used Cars in Washington, DC. Shop for a Honda Used Car.
www.honda.com/yahoo
Health Care Staffing Company
We specialize in international recruitment of healthcare professionals for the U. S.
hstar.com
GE Improving Healthcare
Learn How GE Technologies Are Reducing The Cost Of Health Care.
www.healthymagination.com
Young Frankenstein at the Kennedy Center
Don't miss the new musical at the Opera House. Get tickets here.
Kennedy-Center.org
Outsource Your IT and Save Money
We have more than four decades of experience in helping the medical community increase service and lower overall cost of Information Technology resources.
dpsciences.com
Limousine Services at Special Low Rates
Christmas light tours are offered by Jason Tours LLC.
www.JasonTours.com
Doctoral In Health Care
Advance Your Career. Start On Your Doctoral in Health Care Today!
www.CalUHealthcare.com
Stand with President Obama
Fight Back Against Special Interests. Sign the Petition Today!
www.DSCC.org
Humanaone Health Care…
Compare Health Insurance Quotes and Save 40% or more ….
Humana.Insurance202.com
Single Aspx Page
Get Matched with Sexy Singles in Your Area for Free! Sign-up Now.
www-Join.com/singleaspxpage
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.