could you recognize your parents or your child if you never knew them?

@winterose (39887)
Canada
December 12, 2009 8:01pm CST
assume that you were separated from birth from you mother or father or child from birth? For whatever reason the reason is really not important to this question at all, but you are an adult now, if you were the child who was separated from the parent and if you were the parent you child is now 20 years old. You go out somewhere perhaps to a shopping center or restaurant and there sitting at the next table is your real parent or real child. Do you think you would recognize the individual? Maybe you see the family resemblance, or maybe you just get a funny feeling about this person, you are attracted to them and you don't know why or maybe you don't feel anything at all, what do you think is it possible to recognize or feel something about something you never knew yet somehow know you know them?
1 person likes this
16 responses
@celticeagle (189838)
• Boise, Idaho
13 Dec 09
I think in some instances you can recognize parents but I am not so sure about children. I think they would recognize you before you did them. Thinking about my mom. I am relatively certain I would recognize her but then I knew her for my entire life. I would wonder if it were a situation where you had never know the person. I think it would be rare but it could happen.
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
13 Dec 09
good answer, yes there has been some documented cases about that, where their was some feeling of familiarity that they just could not shrug off
1 person likes this
@celticeagle (189838)
• Boise, Idaho
13 Dec 09
I saw a documentary about twins that were seperated and similar their life was. Very fascinating!Ofcourse I think that was more DNA than anything but still interesting.
@ElicBxn (64169)
• United States
13 Dec 09
not a chance I remember a case where 2 twin girls were adopted by different families and ended up living with in a few blocks of each other, people would often tell them how much they looked alike and they were friends - but didn't realize they could be related until they both discovered they were adopted from the same place and investigated.
2 people like this
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
13 Dec 09
yes but do you think you would somehow know, there are many cases where people just instantly knew, called it tuition or whatever but they just knew
1 person likes this
@ElicBxn (64169)
• United States
13 Dec 09
not me, I could probably be in the same restaurant with someone I know and if I hadn't seen them recently, I wouldn't recognize them I'm bad, but I don't really look that closely at people Having said that, one weekend we went to a friend's coworker's place to record the sound track for a puppet show - she recorded the script so she just had to do the puppets and not the voices, and that night I spotted her co-worker at the restaurant we were at - with her son. Another time, we went to a Trout Fishing In America concert and the next night I was flying home and recognized the gal from the next table. We got to talking and it turned out she used to live near us and knew someone I knew - small world. But I wouldn't recognize them now and wouldn't have recognized either one of them if it hadn't been about the same time. Memory? what memory? we don't need no stinking memory...
@Lakota12 (42600)
• United States
13 Dec 09
After loosing my 3 boys I looked every where to seeif I could reconize any thing in people I met that I would think they were mine! Never did see it any where as all the states I moved around in. never knew where adopted parents could move too. The oldest one I think I would have reconized if I had seen him for he looks just like his dad did at that age. Aslo found out that he could have been living around the block from where we did one year. The other 2 not sure I would have reaconized them as it took me several years to reaconize that my 2nd son favors his grandpa on my side he just isnt fat! but the face with glasses and hiar line gets to me. The 3rd on no way would I have reconized . HE was real blonde headed, wide wide shoulders and tall.
1 person likes this
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
14 Dec 09
so sorry to hear about losing your three boys though, that has got to be really really hard.
@Lakota12 (42600)
• United States
14 Dec 09
It was and took 27 years to find them again! Thier dad took them from my babysitter took tham to another state than where we lived and then put them up for adoption!
@Hatley (163772)
• Garden Grove, California
13 Dec 09
hi winterrose you know this would make a wonderful story, a novel oh my love the idea. I think if for whatever reason my son may have been separated from me until he was twenty I would know he was my son the moment I saw him. once in our neighborhood store he was at a check stand and the clerk saw me hurrying over,and she said to me, oh my this young man has to be your son,he looks so much like you. I have heard that from the time he was about ten that he looks like me instead of his dad, although his eyes are brown like his dads were and his hair is so dark brown its almost black like his dad's was. I have pale ash blonde hair. but my sons face resembles mine so I would recognize him. If I had been seperated from my mom at an early age I think again I would recognize her when I met her as we always had movements so alike it was scary. so if I watched this woman I had not seen for years and saw her doing the same things I did I think I would go oh myh that woman is my mother. but this is all supposing of course.
2 people like this
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
13 Dec 09
the idea actually came from an old movie with lana turner, it was called Madame X I think. Her husband was rich and took her child away from her and through her out. and for whatever reason, she is on trial for murder and her son is now grown and the lawyer who is defending her. He doesn't know who she is. But he says to his dad, I don't know why but I have a feeling I know this woman.
@Canellita (12029)
• United States
19 Dec 09
I suppose it would depend on how much you resembled each other and how much time you spent together. There are people who worked in the same place or lived in the same neighborhood or shared the same circle of friends who later in life found out they were related that never considered that fact but others would mention similarirties.
1 person likes this
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
20 Dec 09
you have never spent any time with them at all you don't know them. That is the point of this discussion. You might resemble them maybe you don't this discussion is more about feeling and intuition
@snafushe (791)
• Canada
14 Dec 09
Yes I think so, because both my mom and dad have lots of resemblances to me. My mom says I look exactly like what she looked like when she young, and we have the same nose, mouth, and teeth. Me and my dad have the same eyes and other resemblances. Both sides of my family have very distinct resemblances, and when you look at a family photo you can tell right away everyone is related.
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
14 Dec 09
that is great hon
@snafushe (791)
• Canada
14 Dec 09
I actually have three sisters! All older then me, so take your pick. Though I'm pretty sure one of them is married with kids and the other one is in a very devoted relationship.
• India
13 Dec 09
Since this is a hypothetical question so obviously you understand that I have no such experience but from all practical experience, I guess I would not recognize my parents or my own child if I did not see them before and suddenly come across them as an adult or as an old person. Believe me , my son is now 10yrs and I cant even recollect properly how exactly he looked in his infancy…their faces change so much and so fast that its really not possible to identify that same baby as my own years later. And with regards to parents, well it’s the same…both my dad and mom looked quite different in their youth than they do now. Its but natural that people will change and if we are not on regular connection then no, I would not recognize them.
1 person likes this
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
14 Dec 09
thank you so much for your answer my friend
• India
13 Dec 09
I do not think, it is possible to recognize your parents or your children if I have, never seen them. Maybe if I try very hard then I may be able to recognize them with somebodys help, other wise it is not possible. I have heard of brothers and sisters marrying, and later on finding out that they are long last brothers and sisters.
1 person likes this
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
14 Dec 09
it is possible most people would not be able to though and yes you are right brothers and sisters have married have not known they were related.
@mobhomeir (7558)
• Philippines
13 Dec 09
Hello winterose I could reply you this topic but I can't say fully because we have our own version of saying it...a sort of a term we used in our own dialect...this is a nice topic to discuss with but sad to say, I could not really share what I had in me because I am afraid I could not be understood by the majority... mobhomeir..
1 person likes this
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
14 Dec 09
okay hon, I understand
@VANILLAREY (1470)
• India
13 Dec 09
Ya that would be easy with my sixth sense and my DNA recongnizing eyes.
1 person likes this
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
14 Dec 09
yes some people have a sixth sense that is why I posted this discussion, thanks so much for your answer.
@veromar (1453)
• Argentina
13 Dec 09
This is a very interesting premise, winterose. I would assume that those who believe in reincarnation would have a much different view than others. I know you have started your discussion with the context of familial separations, and I think it could go even deeper than that. Here's an instance for you....When I was in college I was at work one day (I was a sound engineer at a recording studio that tourists could come in and sing along to a track that I recorded for them as a souvenir)....in walks this woman. We took one look at each other and started crying. I'm no flake or anything. Both of us. Bawling like babies. It was weird....one of those other-wordly experiences that just happened. I KNEW her. She knew me. We were complete strangers and both bawling like babies. We were both perplexed by it. The strength of the emotions that we were encountering. So, we did a "past life regression" and discovered that we were "tribal brothers".. Cherokee to be precise....brothers. It explained the connection. It explained the emotion. And we KNEW when we saw each other....
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
13 Dec 09
wow that is amazing
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
14 Dec 09
I believe that I would be drawn to the person that I was related to in a certain sense. I may not know right away why I was drawn to that person, but there would be something about them that would make me feel a sort of connection to them. This is much the same as it is when you run into someone that you've known in your past that you haven't seen in a long time. You know that you know the person from somewhere but you just can't place them for a while.
1 person likes this
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
14 Dec 09
yep that is what I think it would be like as well.
@Anneleia (54)
• Philippines
13 Dec 09
I guess there will be an spark or something that will recognize a parent for their child. I mean,if a parent didnt know that's his child but he feels comfortable or at ease with that person especially if he knows that his child is with that same age, that would be a good start to know if that is his child and vice versa.
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
13 Dec 09
so you think you would some how have that spark for your child or your parent?
• United States
13 Dec 09
I definitely think I would be able to recognize my parents if I had never met them. There's a lot of resemblance between my parents and I physically and also the way we act. For example I have never seen anyone roll their eyes the way people in my family do. Also the way my parents talk would definitely catch my attention, and other small things like the way they would twiddle there thumbs or their sarcasm. All in all I think i'd be able to recognize them instantaneously.
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
14 Dec 09
yep those are signs for sure.
• Canada
13 Dec 09
With my vision, I odn't think so. It took me a lot of years of living with my mother or sister before I could see how we all looked alike. On the other hand, I've seen people who look exactly like someone I know, yet they are not at all related to that person. Personally, I don't think I could.
1 person likes this
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
13 Dec 09
vision is one way but you might just get a funny feeling you know this person, you know what I mean?
• Sweden
13 Dec 09
I guess that there is a huge possibility that you will feel something strange but obviously you cannot recognize what that feeling is. Blood instinct as they say... but because of the fact that you dont know each other and that you just meet from somewhere, it is hard to recognize the feelings that you have.
1 person likes this
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
13 Dec 09
yeah that is true, but if that person gets the same feeling well then you might just start talking