Insult to Injury justice system...Yemen laws

@vandana7 (102281)
India
July 16, 2025 11:36pm CST
Case in brief. A married woman, enters into a business contract with a Yemeni national along with her husband. Then her husband cannot join her and she is left alone to manage the partnership. Civil war in the country increases monetary problems leading to the Yemeni national renegading on the deal. So far no issues but ...he holds the passport of the lady, for the purposes of the business and refuses to return, seeking more money and other favors, (sexual favors alleged). The lady has husband and kids back home, and so decides to sedate the guy and pick her passport, and return. Unfortunately, the guy dies. What ensues is series of court cases condemning her to death. But there is an exit route...Blink.... "Blood Money"...one wonders if the terrorists use that route, but I am straying from the case. So it says, you compensate the family monetarily and leave. Here...I have a feeling justice is not served. How I would have judged. 1. He renegaded on contract without promise of repayment in future, so it is equal to cheating....the lady deserves compensation for this.............her investment plus compensation for mental agony of being kept isolated from her family. 2. He did not return her passport, which was almost equal to kidnapping, and this lead to mental agony, and related irrational action, so MURDER CONDONED. Net net, the family needs to pay to the lady, not the other way round. THIS IS THE REASON I SAY WE SHOULD HAVE UNIFORM SET OF LAWS ACROSS THE WORLD. THAT WAY .."IGNORANCE OF LAW IS NO EXCUSE" WOULD NOT BE VALID UNLESS THEY ARE HIGHLIGHTED UPFRONT. KINDA BASE SET OF LAWS COMMON ACROSS THE BOARD, AND VARIATIONS INDICATED TO THE PROSPECTIVE VISITOR IN A BOOKLET...DULY INDICATING DIFFERENCES FROM THE LAWS OF THE COUNTRY THEY ARE BORN IN AND THE LAWS OF THE COUNTRY THEY ARE TRAVELING TO. This will ensure that they choose to be careful with what they are doing. In the present scenario, I think the lady over sedated the guy ....because A. She needed time to search the passport. B. She needed time to book a flight. The guy in question may have been too powerful for her to fear him so much. Whatever...........traveling to another country whether for job or other purposes comes with its own consequences ...some of which can be as serious as this. This is not the first time that I have heard of people handing over their passports. The former househelp of my neighbor too was trapped for almost 3 years, with a lady in the middle east, who was so abusive that she burned her face. Even though she was a Muslim widow. What not a mother suffers for her child back home. When we have microchips for dogs, why don't we have microchips of passports too? Just feeling sorry for the nurse.
https://www.livemint.com/news/nimisha-priya-case-why-the-kerala-nurse-faces-execution-in-yemen-a-complete-timeline-of-what-happened-11752638042144.html?utm_source=firefox-newtab-en-intl
5 people like this
4 responses
@LadyDuck (481777)
• Italy
17 Jul
@DaddyEvil taking a passport of a person from another country is considered kidnapping. She had to escape to save herself, so she did not commit murder, it was self defense.
2 people like this
@vandana7 (102281)
• India
17 Jul
But the laws in Yemen do not consider it to be self defense. Weird justice system. If they want help from more humane world, they oughta come out of the ancient rut. Which is why I say uniform laws. Many insane actions like stoning a woman would disappear.
1 person likes this
@DaddyEvil (156889)
• United States
17 Jul
I know if you work in China and you're from another country, sometimes they take your passport. I wouldn't be comfortable giving up my means of escape, no matter what they hired me to do.
1 person likes this
@LadyDuck (481777)
• Italy
18 Jul
@vandana7 Be sure that if he were a man, he would not risk to be killed by the local justice.
1 person likes this
@DaddyEvil (156889)
• United States
17 Jul
Taking the passport of the person from another country SHOULD constitute kidnapping and the lady was then free to take whatever measures necessary to escape the kidnapper, up to and including killing him to escape... In my opinion, of course.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (102281)
• India
17 Jul
I feel basic laws across the board should be uniform, and I too feel in this case, killing is self defense. As a matter of fact, if she used sedative, then it should not be looked at killing at all, because if the intent was to kill, she could have found some poison to do the job. Unfortunate that she was trapped and there are no laws that Yemen is asked to conform to by some International body.
1 person likes this
@DaddyEvil (156889)
• United States
17 Jul
@vandana7 I agree, it is a shame there are no uniform laws across the board like that.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (102281)
• India
17 Jul
@DaddyEvil Any region specific laws, can be given in the hands of people before issuing required visa...they gotta know the dangers upfront and availability of remedy and take informed decisions. This was pure helplessness. I think even I would do it.
1 person likes this
@JudyEv (361041)
• Rockingham, Australia
18 Jul
People can be incredibly cruel to others. However, you will never get uniform laws. The various cultures are too different.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (102281)
• India
18 Jul
What I meant was...you have a common base set of laws...framed by International Court of Justice. Then have a booklet for each nation...how our laws differ from laws in Australia, how our laws differ from laws in India, how our laws differ from laws in the US...so on and so forth. The booklet should refer to the exact section of the common base set of laws...to which the alteration relates. It then becomes incumbent on the person to read those laws, before applying for jobs or migration, even travel visa. Variations if any could result in conflicts between two nations, with varying understanding of law. In such a situation, the concerned parties could approach the International court of justice, and the law of the land maybe overridden by the law of majority. What this will ensure is international travel and business will go to nations that exhibit some set of uniformity, effectively forcing others out of their age old archaic laws, to fall in line. That is the idea anyway.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (102281)
• India
18 Jul
@JudyEv Gee...thanks...I am considerably more mature than Pony. LOL
1 person likes this
@JudyEv (361041)
• Rockingham, Australia
18 Jul
@vandana7 When you put it like that, it sounds a very sensible idea.
1 person likes this
@LindaOHio (198018)
• United States
17 Jul
I agree with most of what DE said.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (102281)
• India
18 Jul
I too feel that it is equivalent to kidnapping and therefore self defense. But their laws are weird. They are not exactly based on human feelings.
1 person likes this