Trying to find a Christmas cookie to make for the cookie swap
By NJ Chicaa
@NJChicaa (125544)
United States
December 9, 2025 1:56pm CST
As I wrote yesterday my good friend invited me to a cookie swap on Saturday that she is hosting in memory of her late friend. She said there are competitions and, well, you know how I love to be a showoff when it comes to cooking and baking. I am 100% not competitive but I *am* a showoff.
Last night I looked through the All About Cookies and How to Bake Everything baking books. I didn't see anything that I wanted to make. Today I went through Food Network's list of 100 Christmas cookie recipes. I saw an iced lemon sugar cookie one that looked interesting but my friend said someone else is doing lemon butter cookies. I went through the Serious Eats web site and found a chocolate sandwich cookie with chocolate buttercream that is a possibility. I also saw an interesting recipe for chocolate cookie "cups" that you fill with chocolate ganache and top with a couple of mini marshmallows to look like a cup of hot chocolate. So far that is the leading contender.
Today I'll look through the Bravetart and Baking for the Holidays baking books and make my final decision. I need to make sure I have the ingredients, equipment, and time to make everything since I need to make SIX DOZEN of whatever I decide on.
Last night I looked through the All About Cookies and How to Bake Everything baking books. I didn't see anything that I wanted to make. Today I went through Food Network's list of 100 Christmas cookie recipes. I saw an iced lemon sugar cookie one that looked interesting but my friend said someone else is doing lemon butter cookies. I went through the Serious Eats web site and found a chocolate sandwich cookie with chocolate buttercream that is a possibility. I also saw an interesting recipe for chocolate cookie "cups" that you fill with chocolate ganache and top with a couple of mini marshmallows to look like a cup of hot chocolate. So far that is the leading contender.
Today I'll look through the Bravetart and Baking for the Holidays baking books and make my final decision. I need to make sure I have the ingredients, equipment, and time to make everything since I need to make SIX DOZEN of whatever I decide on.10 people like this
9 responses
@BarBaraPrz (50888)
• St. Catharines, Ontario
9 Dec
I wonder if one could substitute orange for lemon...
3 people like this
@AmbiePam (107848)
• United States
9 Dec
@BarBaraPrz That’s an intriguing thought.
2 people like this
@RasmaSandra (91681)
• Daytona Beach, Florida
9 Dec
Here's something totally different
2 people like this
@LindaOHio (207968)
• United States
10 Dec
I would have voted for the lemon; but the cups sound good too.
1 person likes this
@snowy22315 (199842)
• United States
9 Dec
I think the filled cookie cups look so great, I have seen things like that online. Almost everybody likes chocolate.
1 person likes this
@MarieCoyle (52059)
•
10 Dec
Yum, the lemon ones would be my pick, but chocolate is always good. I am sure whatever you make will be phenomenal!
1 person likes this










