Does God answer prayers depending on the emotions presented

@suspenseful (40193)
Canada
October 7, 2008 9:44pm CST
I do not cry that often and I am not what you call emotional and because of that I wonder if that is why my prayers do not seem sincere. I do not want to do as the heathen do to cut myself or do harm to myself to get HIM to answer and this is just a request out of curiosity. I found out I have something medically wrong with me, and after a brief crying spell and much prayer, I settled down and resumed life as usual. I remember that when I first heard I could not get pregnant and the consequent worry about the results of this - one which is what is happening now, I cried a lot, prayed a lot, and then got calmer. So I wonder whether if I had been more emotional, went without food for a couple of days, wore figuratively sackcloth and ashes, whether God would have considered my prayer sincere. In other words, did mine not going into a decline or great depression, make God not believe my prayer and request was sincere? So is it the loudest and weepiest who gets their prayers answered or the calmer and more stoic one or does it really matter? Or are tears the means to show sincerity?
9 people like this
36 responses
@glords (2614)
• United States
8 Oct 08
I believe that God knows your heart. He does not base his mercy on weather or not you are capable of being dramatic. Sometimes it seems that your prayers are not answered because God's ways our different then ours. Perhaps his will is different than yours. What he wants for you is different than what you want for yourself. Perhaps you would like an easy life. Perhaps God has planned one that is more difficult. Perhaps he is strengthening you for the next life. Perhaps you will have a great calling in the next life and you must endure trials here in order to prepare yourself. Whatever God has in store for you, you should not regret. Know that he loves you. He knows your heart, and he is walking beside you throughout this life and the next. God be with you. May you find peace and understanding.
4 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
8 Oct 08
I always thought the ones who made a big show were the ones who got their prayers answered. Now I have a husband who is an unbeliever, and no matter how much I pray, my husband has not wanted to go to church. On top of that, my husband had a stroke but he still does not want to go to church. Now I just learned that I more likely have br*st cancer on top of being borderline diabetic, the latter I suspected I was for some time. So is God doing this to get my husband to repent? My life is difficult already. So what is next me getting a heart attack and what if that does not work? I had a difficult life, was always struggling with money, went through not being able to get pregnant and carry a baby to term since I got married, I mean unless they make it illegal to go to church and arrest all the Christians and execute them what else can happen?
3 people like this
@kyodao (36)
• United States
8 Oct 08
I totally agree. In addition, God already knows the choices you will make in your life. Sometimes he doesn't answer your prayer because he knows that you cannot handle it or it's not what you need at that time. Everything God does is right on time and works for the good. So relax and continue to pray and know that God will ALWAYS show up when he needs to. He LOVES you and wants the best for you. Our judgement sometimes isn't always the best. Remember - we only know the past and present. But God knows the past, present and future. Trust him.
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
9 Oct 08
I am trying to get through this. I am still praying for my husband. Right now things are on hold as I am waiting to go to the hospital for the biopsy and I am doing what I can to reduce the tumor, if that is that, by natural means, eating the proper food, and having more faith in God that HE will heal me without the surgeon's knife. I am trying to be less complacent as that was my trouble and also to worry less. It seemed I never could reach a happy medium.
@LittleMel (8742)
• Canada
8 Oct 08
well I am emotional and easily hold grudge when crossed so I usually ask for justice and I can hold grudge for a very long time until justice is done. After justice is done I sometimes forget what happened although I still don't forgive. But I am not emotional enough to live without food or wear silly clothes hahah no way that won't happen to me too much going on in my life I have other people to think about. I believe, however, that if I haven't done anything wrong to the other person who wronged me, I always get my justice. Sometimes it's within seconds, sometimes years - but I always do, as long as I have never wronged whoever it was that wronged me. It works like karma, and all I have to do is stay true to everybody because if I don't then it would backfire on me. So based on what I experience I can say that prayers are answered if they are either in line with God's plan for the future or if it is justice. Although I only pray if I am hurt or worried that something bad will happen to my loved ones, being emotional person of course emotions will be present during the time I pray, but no matter how much emotions or sincerity present I know that if it isn't justice and not His plan, I might as well not pray because it wouldn't happen anyway.
3 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
9 Oct 08
I believe in God and that HE can heal us and answer our prayers if we do believe. So that is what I am doing praying and believing.
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
8 Oct 08
I am not emotional but I do hold grudges and I have a good memory and could put things and incidents together. I can remember those who helped me in the past, but I also can remember those who hurt me and started the ball rolling towards the decisions that they made that caused me to feel I had to make the wrong decisions. That is why I am very careful to not to do anything that would cause another person to sin as it were. So I always pray to God for wisdom, but sometimes it does not seem to come like last Sunday, it was just a little cool, so I decided to put on my nylons, but most of the ladies around were still in their bare legs and sandals and the trouble was that my nylons were black and the other ladies except two were either bare legged or the nylons were natural and looked barelegged. So I guess I have to pray extra hard to not make booboos.
2 people like this
@pawnee (187)
8 Oct 08
I do not believe in god and feel that prayer does nothing but help you manage the task ahead, much like meditation i think its just a focal point.. But so what, we all need one right? I just try to believe in myself.
2 people like this
@marzoeki (138)
• Indonesia
8 Oct 08
i'm also never get cried when do a pray,, emotion sometimes come followed our mood when we do a pray.. but i think it's another kind of effect caused by our believed,, we trust so much with God,, we are confident that God will hear what we said,, then emotion sometimes appear then... God will always answer when we do a pray,, but sometimes it's instant,,and sometimes not,, sometimes God give us another answer,, because God know which is better for us.. ^^
3 people like this
@felher08 (195)
• Philippines
8 Oct 08
Long or short prayer to God doesn't matter. For sure, God answers all prayers for those who pray sincerely, in faith and wholeheartedly. God knows what is in your heart when you pray. No need to express emotions outwardly. However, God's answers to your prayer are always positive, if you think it positively. You may seem to say that your prayers were not answered, if you think it negatively. What is important in your prayer is faith and your prayers are answered.
3 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
9 Oct 08
It all depends on what you consider want or need. Surely healing is considered a need if that also means that you will be able to help someone else. If I were to die or get worse, what will happen to my husband? And of course, I do not want to have the tumor grow, but rather to shrink because the consequent cost in clothes and supported garments would mean that things that we need to do around the house could not be done. I do not pray for things that I can do myself, except for making the right decisions, and to manage my budget and not waste my money as if I wasted my money, I would not get what I wanted but there are somethings like health and unforseen circumstances I cannot do myself. I need God's intervention.
1 person likes this
@felher08 (195)
• Philippines
9 Oct 08
I just want to share my personal experience in prayer. Faith is important thing that I asked in prayer and give thanks for it for it is God's gift. I do not focus my mind to myself and my own want, but rather what I see in other's needs. I always ask for forgiveness and ask for strength in doing good to others.
1 person likes this
• India
8 Oct 08
it depends on your needs and how you respond to it.. express your heart truly to god which wikll surely bring answers
3 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
8 Oct 08
I do that. I ask God to answer my prayer and I am willing to wait, but sometimes I wonder if I wait until it is impossible with man whether HE will take a failure of mine a reason for not answering it with a yes. It is frustrating though since I do not know how long to wait.
2 people like this
• India
8 Oct 08
I believe in god and i think that universe is all running with god grace the more we trust the good prospects we have
3 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
8 Oct 08
That sounds good. I have to get more trust in God and not rely on my emotions.
2 people like this
@owlwings (43915)
• Cambridge, England
10 Oct 08
From what you say, it seems that your prayer was answered. Even if you didn't realise that you were praying for calmness and acceptance, that is what you arrived at. Now, you may say that that wasn't what you prayed for, so how could it be an answer? Don't forget, though, that nobody has ever seriously claimed that God gives us everything we want but that he does know our needs - and supplies them! In fact, many people will tell you that God knows our needs before we even do ourselves (so why pray, you may ask?) The answer is that we need to pray in order to keep ourselves in a right relationship with Him, to bring to mind our need for His love and grace - 'wor[th]ship' is to something's value or worth as 'friendship' is to having friends. I am sure that your prayer was sincere but how many times have you heard a child ask for something that they want - 'to be left alone', a toy or candy, yet to have been completely satisfied and and happy on being given what they really need - love, cuddles or food! Sometimes it may seem that you get almost the exact opposite of what you 'asked' for but think a little deeper (and with gratitude) and you may understand that, in fact, you have been given something of much greater value.
2 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
10 Oct 08
It all depends on what you classify as a want. I mean if a majority of women get pregnant at the right time, I am not asking for something like a toy doll or a cadillac or a large six story house or a cruise to the Bahamas, or my husband to die so I can marry Prince Charming. And if one classifies getting pregnant after married, which I prayed for years, as a want instead of a need, then the only need we can pray for is to have just enough food to feed us for the day with no hope for any tomorrow and for just enough clothes for that day and also shelter for that day and that is what the poor people in AFrica and Asia have to live for. They have nothing and they have to work the next day just to live. I mean is not God better than that? Also is not with God all things are possible? Should we limit God by our own opinions?
2 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
9 Dec 09
It is just that some women and men do not have to pray for things that they need and sometimes what one does not get, gives one the wrong impression of them. For instance I started a discussion on the difference between being childless and being childfree. The suffix on the ends of the word child gives a different meaning and since there has been so much emphasis on the latter, it is assumed that if you cannot have children you do not want them. Now I am an adopted mother and I found there was another assumption that women who adopt do not know as much as about when a baby cries out of hunger or how to hold an infant in the correct way. Also before we adopted, there was the assumption that we who do not have children are only interested in the material things. And I was a bad girl when in my late teens, had a boyfriend, got pregnant out of wedlock, gave the baby up for adoption and there is an assumption that we have to prove that we are good enough for marriage. So a women who kept herself pure can be a sloppy housekeeper, can marry right after high school and does not have to proof that she has a talent but with us, we have to be neat housekeepers, wonderful cooks, or whatever (like I have a gift of bonding to children and knowing when a baby's cry means hunger or tired even though my friend who has had children and is now a grandmother does not). And I do not ask for material things. Look I want a piano, it would be good for my singing, I want a larger house, I want a better computer that will not run slow in the evening, but I do not pray for them. What i prayed for was for me to get pregnant after marriage and have the baby born healthy and raise him or her in the LORD. I did not want to prove that I was worthy of such a gift. And there are women who are sloppy housekeepers, lazy, give their husbands burnt offerings every day and they still get pregnant.
@Lakota12 (42600)
• United States
8 Oct 08
If you go by what you beleive prayers are never answered in the way you want them to be answered!
2 people like this
@Lakota12 (42600)
• United States
10 Oct 08
Thats why I dont pray for me!
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
28 Dec 09
I pray for babies not to be afraid of me. I have no conception if they make strange with women who have children or if they just make strange with women who cannot have children, so I do not want to take any chances. I also started to pray for my not being blamed anymore for not bearing children after marriage. I am beginning to suspect that the husband does have something to do with it. If the husband is bossy and treats the wife as a child sometime, that God will not grant them children because HE wants the children to respect their mother. I practically told my husband that he had better not get mad at me. I have not asked my friends, but some day I will to see if the few that finally got pregnant found it was when their husband started to treat them as an adult and not bug them all the time.
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
9 Oct 08
That does sound confusing. I have to believe that God will answer my prayer in a positive way. HE knows that I love children but HE also knows that I may not handle having to care for a severely handicapped child (afraid of the child dying while in my care and if he does, I will get so depressed and be catonic) I do know HE is unwilling to test us more than we can take. And I know that HE will never turn me into a child hater. So if God does not answer your prayers the way I want, well the thought of that would be horrible if the answer turns one the wrong way.
• United States
8 Oct 08
I do not think that "window dressing" has any effort on how God sees the sincerity of your prayers. He can see into you heart and knows what you feel. You do not have to put on a "show" for Him.
2 people like this
• United States
9 Oct 08
As I tried to convey in my response my God does not need a show of emotion to show my sincerity He can see what is in my heart.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
8 Dec 09
That is a good idea. God does know that I am not that much into emotions. Oh I do flare up but that does not last long. And even though I am intense, i do not show it.
@stephcjh (38473)
• United States
8 Oct 08
I don't think God really judges us by if we cry or not. Slot of people do not cry or show a whole lot of emotion, especially men. I think God answers all prayers as he sees fit. Sometimes I thank him for not answering some of them because he has better things in mind for me later on that I was never aware of.
3 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
8 Oct 08
But they are men and men are not expected to cry. I am a woman and I am not into crying that much and when I finish praying, I feel calm. Does that calmness after wards show a "I really don't care if this prayer is answered or not," and God takes it as indifference?
1 person likes this
@checapricorn (16061)
• United States
10 Oct 08
[i]Hi suspenseful, I guess GOD will not base His answers through our emotions, it is by our faith and at the same time if granting our prayers is good for us...that is why sometimes, some prayers remained unanswered and for some it takes time before it will be granted! HE knows that is best for us and personally, I haven't tried crying when I will ask for something, sometimes, I will cry because I thank HIm for blessings I received![/i]
2 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
9 Dec 09
I always thought that the more emotion and crying you made in your prayer, the more God would hear it. It is so confusing.
• United States
8 Oct 08
I did not get to finish and it went through...just because someone weeps that does not make them more sincere. God knows your heart. That is all that matters.
2 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
9 Oct 08
I am sincere. I just want God to know it.
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
8 Dec 09
That makes me feel better. I have heard of people really getting into crying and screaming and they felt that God answered their prayers, while me I do not go into that much crying. But at least, God hears me. I hope I just do not start to act as if it is just making a statement instead of really praying. That is the danger of not being emotional. You have to get over the temptation of praying by rote.
• United States
9 Oct 08
Other people may question your heart because they are human, and you are human. But God is the King of all. He does not have to question anything because He knows everything. He knows your heart.
1 person likes this
@dragon54u (31636)
• United States
11 Oct 08
No, I don't think you have to be emotional. God know what is in your heart and knows when you are sincere. He answers prayers (or not) in such a way to best benefit you, even though we sometimes think He doesn't.
2 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
9 Dec 09
Well unless the doctor told me "I am sorry A- but you will not survive a pregnancy, you will die in the first or second month because your womb is too small" or something like that. I could not believe it was a physical thing that kept me from getting pregnant after marriage. And there is help. Now if the doctor had said first "you have too many cysts in your ovaries that are smothering the eggs," so that even though my fallopian tubes were gone, they could not even transport them into my uterus = but no doctor told me that, so I wonder if it was because I was a bad girl, if it was because my husband assumed that I did not have the intelligence of a flee and was bossy, if it was because I did not clean the dish properly. Sort of hate having to prove I was worthy ofgetting pregnant and of course, it is like being on a diet, sometimes I cheat and it goes back to the same thing again. How can no getting pregnant benefit me when we are not wealthy, would have never made enough money to go on a world wide cruise, or get a mansion, etc. unless there was a 100 percent chance that I would not survive a pregnancy but I never heard it from the doctor and I am not a child hater.
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
29 Dec 09
We were the third choice in the bunch and I would have loved biological as well as adopted children. The reason I could have my own was that I got vd and I did want to get checked out at a clinic way before I got married - I was in my mid 20s at the tme - but the lady I was staying with told me not to go because that would mean I would be branded as a bad woman. In fact it was hard for me to go to a doctor even for an annual checkup then and by the time, I had to go because of pains, it was too late. It was not the case of God deciding that I would make a better adoptive parent, it was the case of man deciding that I should not get pregnant. So part was my fault but I am sure that whomever decided for me will get it at the end and I will be justified.
@dragon54u (31636)
• United States
9 Dec 09
I think that perhaps the children that you adopted had need of you, specifically, and that's why you did not have biological children. God does not punish like that, He teaches. Remember He is a loving father and lets things happen or not happen for a good reason. Don't continue to blame yourself because God is not punishing you. You were needed by others and gave them two wonderful parents that love them.
1 person likes this
@iskayz (5420)
• Philippines
8 Oct 08
Hi! God listens to every word we say. He knows every heartache and suffering we're going through and we don't need to remind Him of that. He knows what we're thinking and he knows what we need. God doesn't answer prayers based on how emotional we are when we're praying but I believe He grants us what He knows would be good for us. He knows everything. You just got to have a lot of faith in Him. Ciao!
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
9 Oct 08
I am not that emotional. It is just that I am afraid that because I am not moved to tears that often, that perhaps HE does not believe that depressed attitude that I have means that I am not sincere. I do not want to think that God will always say no, because I have seem the result of that in the stance of women who have just given up and say "oh well, what I want or need will never happen." And I am fighting like crazy not to turn into one of those women.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
8 Dec 09
That sounds like a good idea. I just pray naturally. I do get upset sometimes, and when I get upset, sometimes I feel afterwards that God is saying from heaven, "say A= really meant it this time. She is really crying," when I said that prayer hundreds of times and felt that there was no answer. But I cannot turn my tears off on and on when I feel like it. It does not work.
@iskayz (5420)
• Philippines
10 Oct 08
We don't have to cry often when we pray. It actually depends on our emotion while we are praying. There are people who are so emotional at times of problems. You know yourself and you are not an emotional person. It doesn't mean that if you don't cry your prayers aren't sincere. If you are feeling afraid, that's a sign that you are somewhat lacking faith. Just believe in your prayers and don't think about whether God will answer your prayers or not. Just pray. Ciao!
1 person likes this
@slickcut (8141)
• United States
8 Oct 08
God is an all hearing God..He does not request you to sit in sack cloth & ashes...He looks upon the heart,he knows your thoughts..Are we being just a tad bit dramatic today? It sounds as though you are terribly upset with God...Don't be ,i can understand your distress but just put your faith to work...Hold on suspenseful ! God is watching over you during this trying time.Relax,be calm & have faith...My prayers are with you...
2 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
10 Oct 08
Thank you. I was getting rather desperate and felt that God did not answer my prayer because I did not do anything crazy to get it answered. So I guess trust is enough, but I still wonder why one prayer has not been answered. It makes me rather upset sometimes and now with this other thing coming on.
@1corner (744)
• Canada
8 Oct 08
Hi suspenseful, You've got quite a few supportive responses here. Let me add this... Will be praying your requests along with mine during my quiet time. Cheer up! God responds to faith, not fear and worry.
2 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
10 Oct 08
Thank you. I welcome your prayers. I cannot fight this on my own, and I am hoping that the prognosis is favorable and that my prayers are answered positively and that no one hinders my prayers.
@elemental69 (1561)
• Ireland
8 Oct 08
Your prayers have been heard.... It just seems that they havent. They will be answered when you least expect them to be. All will be well, you'll see. xx
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
9 Oct 08
I guess I just have to have more patience. That is one thing that I am sadly lacking as well as a lack of trust or believing that I am not good enough for God to answer them. It does seem I lack these things. Also I wonder if God will answer my prayer if I pray when the television is on. I can hear it even when I go to bed. My husband watches it later on.
@bombshell (11256)
• Germany
8 Oct 08
no! the tears dont show the sincerity depends on the person.yes i gues if you truly believe the miracle and the powers of God you will feel and ralized that your prayers has been anwers.also depends how your pray like if it is heartily prayer or its just a tip of our tongue.
2 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
10 Oct 08
I do believe that God answers my prayers. It may be that HE has not answered it yet and maybe is waiting until I know that man cannot answer it. It is a prayer of desperation, but maybe I should act desperate but go into a decline, refuse to leave the house, or something like that.
@Arkie69 (2156)
• United States
8 Oct 08
I don't mean to belittle anyone but a lot of our prayers are not answered for the simple reason we are not what we should be or do not have the right attitude. God works on a barter system. He will freely give to us if we are willing to freely give to something to Him. The word "Willing" there is very important because God doesn't always require we actually give Him anything but we must be willing to if He requires it. The strongest prayer you will ever pray is within your thoughts. Our thoughts are a direct reflection of what we actually are inside. We can lie to God with our words but not with our thoughts. We must be totally honest with God in all matters. The first thing we need to do is give God our permission to help us. Without our permission God isn't free to work with us. We need to have God tell us what He wants from us.
2 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
10 Oct 08
I am honest and I asked God for help. It is just with my wanting to get pregnant, I felt that when we adopted and the boys were grown enough, my husband got rid of the baby things, and I felt that the only way was for me to spend all the money I had to get more stuff if a baby comes and that my husband would not help me and I only made about $100 a month. So I felt that God was going to help, but it would have to be all HIS doing and I could not do even a bit to help myself. Now I am still praying for to get pregnant and have a baby but it would have to be a complete miracle that some how the parts inside me would have to be restored and I am not like Sarah and Elizabeth where everything was there already, etc. And now with this worry about br*st cancer, I can now do a little to help myself, but it came on so quickly that I can only do so little to help. So I am stuck and I hurts.
@Anitamo (50)
• Bahamas
8 Oct 08
After reading your view I believe probably thats what happening to me. I am not the emotional type. When I was younger my mom wanted me to see a shink because when people die i was not sympathetic niether empathetic. Today I can not connect with people on that level. So after reading your views probably thats why God dont answer my prayers. I believe that sometimes we ask for things that are important to us, but he believes that we really dont need it I guess.
2 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
10 Oct 08
I figured that much, that had I really did something desperate that God would answer me. The trouble is I did something desperate because I believed that God did not believe that I really wanted to get married, so I went to look for love in the wrong places. I decided when I got married, I could also do an act of desperation and kidnap someone else's baby, kill the mother, rob a bank to get the money to go to a fertility clinic (I am a writer and I watch Tv and these illegal acts may be ways that women have gotten pregnant,) but I decided that those were wrong and I was going to pray, but we could not afford to go to the States and get the treatment anyway. So should I have taken out a knife, found a pregnant woman and just before slitting her throat or gone to the hospital and taken a baby, and then suddenly I would have discovered I was pregnant? Giving an example about desperation can lead to. I made one mistake in my life, no two, and I do not want to make another to get God to notice my desperation.